Saturday, January 17, 2015

Jan. 17: Mea culpa - and I apologize to David Gauvin....

Several days ago, I was angered by a news story in the NewsToday section that violated a basic principle of journalism. A news story exists only to tell us what happened, not to tell us what to think about it. But NewsToday carried a major story about the Paris shootings which opened with a highly emotive sentence designed to create hatred rather than to tell us what happened.

I wrote to the ombudsman about this, and received an excellent response. She agreed with my point, and investigated how this happened, and reminded staff that this is wrong.

Then she noted my comment that the responsible person was probably David Gauvin since he is listed as editor of the section. On this point, the editor assured me I was wrong, and that he was not involved. She also suggested, very gently, that it would be nice if I were to apologize to him. And she's right, of course.

David Gauvin, I do apologize for mentioning your name. That was sloppy jounalism on my part, and I do regret it.

In general, I was impressed by the ombudsman's handling of this. My experience of such offices is that they are usually used to cover up for the paper. But in this case there was a real investigation, action seems to have been taken; and it looks as though the ombudsman is well worth taking seriously.
__________________________________________________________________________

For Jan. 16, section A is the usual zero. Perhaps its low point is a photo on A6. It's only point is - and I'm not kidding - that downtown Moncton turns on the lights after dark. Wow! Eat that, New York.

However, the editorial page is another good one. Even the editorial is decent - if a little shallow. Alec Bruce and Norbert Cunningham are both thoughtful, reasonable, and convincing. Norbert is perhaps a little too kind to the Christian churches - though the kindness doesn't interfere with his main point. Our Christian churches have a long history of being cheerleaders for aggression and conquest. Indeed, Christianity has often blended - to this day -  with racism to become a major factor in justifying the conquests and killings of empire-building. The whole justification for the British Empire was based on the racial superiority of the English-speaking peoples and their churches. The same was true of  American expansion after 1775, and still today. God has destined America to rule the world

That's why missionaries, however good their intentions, are commonly hated among conquered people. They realize the missionaries are being used to destroy their societies.

I have nothing personally against missionaires. It was a former missionary who Christened me. He was much loved in our church. Those were hard years, and this was a district that was poor even in good  years. And, as my father once told me, people often got home from church to find a few dollars that had been tucked into their pockets as they shook hands with the minister after the service.

The minister and I didn't talk much at the christening, but we met many years later when he was in his 90s. He was the kindest, gentlest man I ever met. His name as Gamal Craik, a Welshman who worked in the coal mines from the age of six. He learned to read from the older miners who used to read The Bible aloud during their breaks, way down under the surface. In that way, he taught himself to pass the entrance exams for divinity school, and then to spend most of his life in Africa.

He most certainly was not an evil man. But such men were hated over much of the world because the colonized soon realized that these were the advance agents of societies that would destroy and impoverish them. And that's built into Christianity with its obsession on making conversions. I think the rest of the world would feel better if the Christians who have had so much impact on the societies would just behave like Christians.

On op ed, I wish Justin Ryan would say more, much more about the work he does in multiculturalism. I presume that's why he was hired. But so far, it's pretty light stuff.
______________________________________________________________________
NewsToday is a dead loss. We are on the edge of war in Ukraine, possibly on the edge of nuclear war. And we have military forces there. So far, we have not been told about how the Ukraine military has probably destroyed peace talks with its shelling of Russian   civilians in east Ukraine. We've been told almost nothing about that strange, Ukraine government that the US supports and which includes prominent Naziis and billionaire foreigners. We haven't been told about the widespread starvation or about the crash of the Ukraine economy - with western bankers scurrying to get whatever payments they can before there is nothing left to take.  There seems to be runaway corruption on both sides in this crisis we have created. And there might be a nuclear war in it. But that's not important enough for the Irving press. It's big story is on the closure of Target stores.  
____________________________________________________________________________
For Jan. 17, there is at least some news in Section A. There's a lengthy treatment of the official resport of the Bourque killings of police in Moncton - and of steps that have been taken to improve security.

There's a more disturbing report that Rotary Club is setting out on a five-year programme to end homelessness in Moncton.  There's something wrong with a society that leaves it up to volunteers to ensure that its members have homes. And there's something disgusting about a city that can raise a hundred million and more for a  hockey rink, but which leaves its homeless to starve in the cold.

The low point is on p. !7 "Price is Right stage show coming to Moncton". Yessirree we can all get tickets and even be called to "come on up" for the most distasteful display of greed and consumerism on earth. It will be at the Moncton Wesleyan Centre. (Why am I not surprised?)
_________________________________________________________________________
On the editorial page, both Norbert and Bill Belliveau talk about our provincial budget problems, and the need to cut taxes. There have been lots of columns on this. Yessirree - raise taxes, cut education, cut health...but never a mention of the role played in this by the growing wage gap, and the happy days tax rates for the rich, or the great cost of doing favours for the the rich - like giving away our forests and building a super-expensive hockey rink - not to mention wide-ranging powers we give away to big business in free trade agreements.

I have taught in public schools where average class size was 25 to 35 - as Norbert suggests. It doesn't work. Worse - New Brunswick is in the literacy toilet in comparison with almost any other part of the developed world. And some people want to cut education?  Duh, we really need a hockey rink.

As always, Norbert trots out his "experts", Donald Savoie and Richard Saillant who are, we are told, "non-partisan". Well, I don't really trust "non-partisan experts" who have never said a word to offend those who hold the real power in this province. Nor do I trust phony think-tanks that spring up with fancy names and associate themselves with otherwise respectable universities.

What is going on around the world is that the very rich have created a financial crisis - not for themselves, of course, but for everybody who isn't rich. This isn't the first time. It's been a long-term pattern for this world. They create a crisis. Then we have to pay for it in loss of services and higher taxes. They destroy jobs. Then they tell the unemployed they're lazy.

The inevitable and clearly foolish promise is that by making the rich very, very rich, we give them the money to create jobs and employment. In fact, I don't know a single instance in world history in which that has been true. We made the rich super-rich in the 1930s; but it was a war that ended the depression, not the spending of the rich. The rich have killed millions of people and taken trillions of dollars out of the Congo. But the people of the Congo have yet, after almost a hundred and fifty years, to get anything but poverty, misery and death out of it. The rich became rich out of Guatemala, Haiti, Central America in general. But the people are still worse off than ever.

When you make the rich richer, there is no spin-off. But  Norbert's "non-partisan experts" won't ever say that.

Brent Mazerolle talks about Target, has nothing to say, but says it anyway. And even Gwynne Dyer, who raises an interesting point about our growing life span, doesn't take it anywhere.
____________________________________________________________________________
There is nothing in NewsToday unless you really, really care that Montreal has a shortage of Charlie hebdo copies.

Okay. I don't know who is responsible for the abysmal choice of news in NewsToday. But I most certainly will not apologize to whoever that clown might be.
________________________________________________________________________________
The Faith page is back to being a disaster. And the churches seem to do nothing but eat.

On C13, Isabelle Agnew writes with a palpable excitement about what she has learned in university. She credits St. Thomas University for that and, as I read her letter, I was impressed that St. Thomas had done this. It's not common. I attended four universities over a ten-year period - with exposure to, I guess, over fifty professors. Of all those fifty or more, only one generated any intellectual excitement in me. For the rest, I have long since forgotten what they taught, or even who they were. Good for STU!

As usual, all the student columns are worth a read.

F6 and 7 have the usual Home of the Week with two pages of photos of a house that is huge and expensive but of no great architectural interest, and of no interior merit whatever. Why does the Irving press do this? Not one reader in a thousand could ever afford such a place. And there is nothing to be learned from it.

Certainly, the only way I could get on is by meeting a desperate widow who is wealthy, and so blind and deaf she could imagine me as attractive.


                                                           















































Friday, January 16, 2015

Jan. 16 1/2: We're in trouble...

This is not about Irving press.  It starts with the news that the Conservatives are leading in the polls with 35%. And, given where they are strong, that puts Harper close to a majority government. The Liberals are behind, the NDP way behind, that the Greens out of sight. I have often thought that the re-election of this government would be the end of Canada. I still think so.

1. This is a government of  no depth at all. There is no figure in the government who has even a hint of stature or independence. And Harper would never tolerate such a person.

2. A powerful influence in the government comes from mps who call themselves libertarians. These are people who believe there should be little to no government control over anything.- in particular, that big business should be allowed to do as it pleases. You'll see hints of this sort of thinking in Norbert's columns when he shows contempt for the "interferences" of those government employees he calls 'bureaucrats' - and he uses it as a dirty word because he doesn't understand the real meaning.

The logic behind libertarian thinking is that organizations work better without controls, and government should be a weak and as tiny as possible. And that is unspeakably simple-minded. The logic of it is that armies should not have officers to lead them. The SPCA should open all its cages, and let the animals go free. Police should get off the backs of drunk drivers.

It should also mean that corporations should not have CEOS or management of any sort - or Boards of Directors who collect huge bonusses for occasionally nodding their heads at meetings. Of course, libertarians never go that far.

The reality is that if government has no power, then we have no power. And that's what libertarians really want - a nation of slaves.

3. As well, Harper fawns over the bigots, morons, and haters in our society in order to get their votes. That's why he is "getting tough on crime" with measures that will only make things worse. That's why he's getting tough on immigration and all those 'undesirable' foreigners. (That's why he appoints to the Senate bigots and  haters like the self-centred and not very knowledgeable Senator Frum - not to mention the dishonorable member from PEI.)

4. And all of the above are in the pockets of big business. That's why they're getting tough with native peoples, now. They want native peoples to give up their rights, to give up on the chances of building their own future - and get out of the way of big business such as mining, oil, and shale gas. As a bonus, that also helps Harper with the bigot vote.

5. And, of course, Harper diverts us with useless spending - like the multimillion dollar monument to victims of communism. But there certainly will not be a monument to the many, many more over the past couple of centuries who were and still are victims of capitalism - among them, our own native peoples.

Other useless spending was the "celebration" of the war of 1812, a celebration that taught nobody anything about anything. And coming up is another one - the fiftieth anniversary of the birth of the Canadian flag. I wonder whether he'll mention that we have a flag because of a Liberal - Lester Pearson. And that the Conservatives bitterly and loudly opposed it.

6.Nor is there any reason to hope for better from the Liberals. Here is a party that, for a century, seemed to have unlimited talent - from Sir Wildrid Laurier to Pierre Trudeau. But that's all over. It's now a party of  so little talent that it has had trouble finding a leader since Pierre Trudeau. And it has certainly not found talent in Trudeau's son. It's a party that has no philosophy, no programme, no beliefs that I can think of.

7. The NDP has an intelligent leader, an effective voice in the House of Commons, and it's honest and, on balance, the most intelligent group in parliament. It's undoubtedly the best party in Ottawa.  But it went off the track fifty years ago when it blunted its ideals to get more votes by becoming more like the Liberals. Canada, to survive, has to change. It has to have government by and FOR the people. It cannot survive if it is controlled by a handful of self-serving billionaires.

We need some very tough thinking and action. And you can't do that with a a population  of sheep.

8. The Greens? Bless their hearts but, politically, they are not going to be a power until it's too late.



Then there are general issues about Canada in the world.

Canada has the longest borders in the world. It has a very small population. Harper has made all that even worse by a dreadful neglect of the armed forces so he can pretend he's balancing the budget.

Historically, then, Canada has needed be on good terms with a country that will protect us. That's why we fought the Boer War and Two world wars on the side of Britain (though Britain never wanted to defend us, and would happily have let Canada go as early as the 1870s. It had no enthusiasm of fighting our only possible enemy, the US).

But after World War Two, the British Empire was dead meat. So we had to kiss up to the US. That's why we sent military forces to Korea, Afghanistan, Libya. That's why we have them in Iraq and on the border of Ukraine right now.

If I had suggested in 1812 that we would be wiser to ally ourselves with the US, I would probably have been hanged. But by 1950, it was the patriotic thing to do. It still is.

However, we should never choose allies because we are 'friends' of the other country.  Indeed, any study of history will show that there are no such things as 'friends' between nations. In over 200 years, only one country has attacked Canada. And it has done so at least twice, It threatened to attack many more times and, to this day, trespasses in the Northwest Passage, and refuses to recognize Canadian sovereignty. That country is the US.

When Canada sent a small  army to its own prairies, largely to guard against intrusions by Americans smuggling liquor to native peoples, the US (which had a far bigger army in its west), was furious at this 'insult' to Americans. That's why Canada had to change the name of its army to "North West Mounted Police."

Let's forget the 'friends' babble. Friends do not exist in international affairs. The only country that can attack us, the only one that has attacked us in 200 years, is the US.

As well, the US seems to be a declining power. And it is declining as other are rising, and with new alliances being formed all over the world. And the change is happening very, very quickly. That has warnings for a country with a small population, a neglected military, and long borders.

But the US and Canada are the dearest of friends? Yeah. Remember how the Russians were our dearest friends in World War Two? And as soon as the war ended, they were evil? When I was a kid, Germans were huns; Japanese were nips; and they were unspeakably evil. But just a short time after the war, they were our trusted friends and they were good. In World War Two, the Ukrainians were strong supporters of Naziism, and very active in rounding up Jews. The haven't changed. And the Jew haters are still prominent in the new government. But now we're defeding them. In World War One, Belgians were routinely referred to as good and brave little people. These were the same Belgians who had just tortured and murdered and looted tens of millions of Congolese.

In the big world, all alliances are marriages of convenience. And there are no friends.

We are facing some very big issues - and facing them very, very soon. Neither the Conservatives nor the Liberals have anything close to the brains needed to face those issues. The Greens, while I agree with what they do stand for, don't stand for nearly enough - and there is no hope that they will form a government or even been an influence in one.

That leaves with the NDP. It is far the best in leadership and honesty. But, in the search for power, it has so far toned down its principles that it will have a hard job getting support for what has to be done.

I do not look  forward to 2015 with optimism.

Thursday, January 15, 2015

Jan. 16: ...And even the Irving press did good.....

First, you must read

 www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2015/01/quran-charlie-hebdo-radicalism-p-20151881632716947-html

This is far the most intelligent commentary I have found on the Paris shootings. The writer sees the shootings not as a result of the teaching of Muhammed, but as a result of the collapse of Muslim society - and the resulting distortion of what Muhammed taught.

I think he's right. Worse, I think one could made exactly the same case about the collapse of the Christian faith caused by a social crisis in the Western world. The Paris shootings, ISIL, all the rest,  have arisen from the collapse of Muslim values and a collapse of the Islamic world due to the tremendous impact of western intrusions of the past two centuries. One of the results of that is the rise of an extremism which, quite wrongly, thinks that this extremism is whatIslam was all about. That simply is not true.

The same thing has happened, I think, in the western world. Christian values have collapsed as a result of the rise of a form of capitalism that is profoundly anti-Christian - indeed, anti any religion I have ever heard of. (Go reflect on that next time you're sitting in the Irving chapel.) As a result, the healthiest Christian churches are the ones that now preach a Christian extremism which has no resemblance to what Jesus taught.

This really is an excellent and thought-provoking article.
_______________________________________________________________________

Coming up, I have lots of kind words for the Moncton Times and Transcript. But first, let me talk about the front page headline "Cost of school busing rising: report". (Busing is the TandT spelling which, I guess, would be pronounced byousing. And,, to be fair, it cuts down on wasteful use of esses.

This is a report from the Atlantic Institute of Market Studies. Most of it is a solid report. I know one of the authors, Paul Bennet, from his Montreal days when he was principal of a private school - a very expensive one for the 'right' sort of people. I remember him as being highly intelligent, a most capable school administrator, and a thoroughly decent person. And that's why I'm floundering now as I try to comment on this story.

The Atlantice Institute is not intelligent or capable or even a little bit decent. It is a 'think tank' formed by Irving and buddies to crank out their propaganda and their lies. I have no respect for the many people I have met who work for outfits like that. I was once, long ago, approached by a lawyer from a similar outfit that pimped for the oil industry in Alberta. I refused.

Now, this is mostly a good report, a sensible one,  and I know that Paul Bennett would never sell out.  Occasionally, AIMS will do an honest report to maintain some credibility. And this, I guess, will be the honest one for 2015. But, oh, I wish Paul had not lent his name to these vile people.

The report is well covered in the paper, and I have no problem agreeing with most of it. Our school bus system is wildly expensive (and not made cheaper by moving Moncton High out to the boondocks.) I strongly disagree with only one suggestion in it - that bussing be handled by private contractors. That's a typical Irving move - to think only of another way of getting more of our money. There is no reason why private contractors would be cheaper -and they almost certainly would not be.

The best part of it is to use our existing public transit system. Daily, I watch empty busses rolling through our streets. Why not allow students to use public transit by issuing subsidized passes? I went through high school using public transit every day. At that time, I don't think there was a school bus in the whole of  Montreal. And it worked fine.

Of course, there is a problem. Public transit works best for cities designed for mass transit. Moncton isn't. Most of the city looks as if it was built in the 1950s, the period when the automobile really came into favour. Those sprawling areas work great if you have a car, but are ghastly both physically and aesthetically to walk though.  (In elementary school, I walked to elementary school in about 40 minutes through a slum area that bordered the city dump.  And it was far more interesting that walking through Moncton's west end.)
Mass transit works best where there are masses of people. Solving that might require considerable re-routing of busses.
____________________________________________________________________________

The rest of the news part of Section A is it's usual, trivial self. But...wow- the editorial page and op ed ---
Well, okay. The editorial has nothing to say - but...

Alec Bruce, Norbert Cunningham. Rod Allen and Beth Lyons are superb. The first three present intelligent opinions that challenge all the hype and hysteria we've been hearing about free speech. Beth Lyons gives us a blunt and tough-minded column about the utter failure of our governments to be helpful - or even human - in their treatment of native peoples.

With the exception of the editorial, these pages are a class act - and they would be a class act in any newspaper.
         ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In NewsToday, B1 there's a report that a Spanish company wants to build a liquified natural gas export terminal at St. John. The intend to spend many billions of dollars on it. Now, think about it.

If a company spends many billions of dollars on a terminal, it obviously expects that terminal to be in operation for many years. That means a substantial increase in Canadian natural gas production for many years And it means burning the stuff for many years to come. It will be burned in another country. But that doesn't matter. The atmosphere doesn't care where we burn the stuff. It all has the same effect on climate change, and on us.

Where are the plans for what is now an emergency of global warming? How are we going to deal with it? How are we going to survive it?

The story tells us, if we look closely enough, that the oil industry and our governments don't give a damn. There is no plan. There is no future. There is only now.

On B3, Stephen Harper, the defender of free speech when it's used to anger Muslims, plans to pass new laws to restrict that speech which encourages or glorifies terrorism. Sounds good? Think hard. What Harper is saying is that you can say whatever you like - so long as Harper agrees with it. That sort of thing has been happening in Britain and the US for decades. And, of course, we have gestapo checking what we write and say. Free speech never really existed. Now it's corpse is being embalmed. Get used to it.

Also on B3 is an excellent story on the mess that the federal government has made of supplying and defining a role for our military. In all Harper's years in power, we haven't gained an inch even in replacing our aging fighter aircraft. Of course, it's hard to know what to buy when we haven't any idea what our military should be used for. Harper drastically cut spending so he can look as though he's saving money. We now have a military that is not prepared to fight anybody anywhere. But we have committed ourselves to blossoming wars in Iraq and Ukraine. And Harper has vowed to support Israel whatever it does.

In short, we are likely to kill large numbers of our own military by sending them into wars we are not prepared to fight. Then, next Nov. 11, we will hear babble about how noble these innocents were to risk their lives. And, if Harper is still prime minister, we will watch Harper again tell the veterans to go whistle for all their promised aid and benefits.

On p.4, , France, the country that just adores free speech, is passing laws to ban hate speech, anti-semitism, and glorifying terrorism. In other words, the French will be free to say whatever the government wants them to say. It all sounds reasonable. But I'll bet criticism of Islam will not count as hate speech. And I'll bet that movies about French troops being glorified for their terrorism in Indo-China and Algeria, for example, will not be banned.  Canada has anti-hate laws, too. But we are still encouraged to hate people the government wants us to hate.


By the way, I wish our news media would stop referring to criticism of Israel as anti-Semitism.

For a start, most of the Jews in Israel are not Semites. They are Ashkenaze Jews from Europe. Yes, some of those Ashkinazes have some genes that connect them with Ancient Israel. But we all have some genes that connect us with people all over the world. White people were not magically created by God as a separate group. We are all of us descended of----well, something human. But I do not know of  any evidence that God created whites, and then blacks, and then orientals, and then New Brunswickers.

Most of the Jews of Israel are of European descent, people who converted to Judaism in Europe. Hitler's racist theories were crackpot and disgusting. It's just as disgusting when we think in that same way.

Semite actually refers to a group of languages of the middle east.  Some Jews are Semites. They are the ones who, mostly, stayed in the middle east. They are called Sephardic Jews ( and they often don't care for the Ashkenazes of Europe.)

The people that we call arabs are also Semites. For example, Palestinians are Semites. So, if you criticize arabs, I could accuse you of being anti-Semitic. And I could certainly accuse the majority of Israelis of being anti-Semitic.

Words do not exist simply to make people hate or kill or fear. Words have meanings. And millions have suffered and died because we use words so thoughtlessly.
__________________________________________________________________

Oh, my. It's late.

Congratulations again to Alec Bruce, Norbert Cunningham, Rod Allen and Beth Lyons for such thoroughly professional work.

Goodnight. Wake me in Spring.


Wednesday, January 14, 2015

Jan. 14: :let's relax a bit. Let's start with the comics....

My, the comics page in the Irving press is terrible. But that, at least, is not the fault of the Irving press. Even the Blondie strip, nearing a century old, is repetitive and boring. It wasn't always that way. Back about 1920, Blondie was an air-headed flapper, and Dagwood her besotted suitor Mr. Dithers was Blondie's father. And it was all about the dizzy and dizzying years post world war 1. Then there was Krazy Kat, a brilliant strip with just a few characters and a really repetitive plot. Kat is in love with mouse. Mouse likes to throw rocks at Kat. A dog who is a policeman protects Kat. But it was funny every time. And there was Little Nemo with the best drawings I have ever seen in a comic strip.

The thirties and forties were stronger in full-page dramas- like Dick Tracy and Li'l Abner. These so captivated audiences the mayor of New York attracted a big radio audience every Sunday when he read the comics over the air.

Then came the years after World War 2 of questioning, of insight, of irony, of intelligence, of comics designed for adult minds, all done with pretty sophisticated humour. The first was Peanuts. Then Pogo and, oh, during the Vietnam war -Walden's Pond, Calvin and Hobbs..all gone. All replaced with the mindless and unfunny trash we now get. I'm still trying to find the humour in today's Arlo and Janis. The first frame shows a picture of a packed closet. The second frame is a packed garage. The third is a packed attic.

The last is Arlo and Janis having coffee in the kitchen. Janis says "We're buried in stuff." Arlo says, "An apt metaphor as ever there was."

Oh, I long to live again in the days when Pogo said, "We have met the enemy; and he is us."

Those comics of the 50s to 70's or so also had the courage to attack the rich and powerful in our society - and to do it with wit. Today's are all just blah.
___________________________________________________________________________
We won't talk about the news in section A because there isn't any. The big story is about a stray cat that was sick but is getting better. Even ace trivia reporter Brent Mazerolle can't bring this one to life.

The editorial page saves the whole paper with Alec Bruce's column on Charlie Hebdo with the only intelligent column on this subject I have seen in all the news media I look at every day. As he says, Hepdo was a small time, trashy tabloid that catered to hatreds and prejudices. Now it's a big time, trashy tabloid that caters to hatreds and prejudices.

Norbert Cunningham has a column on terrorism, but obviouly has not the faintest idea of what he's talking about.  Eric Lewis has one about how we all should have household insurance. To bad he has nothing to say that wasn't said in the newspaper story on exactly that subject just a few days ago.  Brian Cormier is Brian Cormier, a featherweight in a world of lightweights.

The first page of NewsToday has a story about how our side is good -and tells us the horrifying news that the weapons used by the shooters from foreign countries. Wow! They should at least have used French weapons. In fact, the whole world is flooded as never before in history with weapons from foreign countries. And very large numbers of them are made and sold by companies in France, Britain, the US....If it weren't for the arms industry. the US wouldn't have an economy.

I thought of  the profusion of military weapons in the world when I was shopping yesterday at Canadian Tire. I was astonished to see mint condition Nagant rifles, the Soviet rifle of World War 2. Each had a bayonet bolted on it. (It could have been removed, and I wondered why on earth Canadian Tire hadn't removed it.) I suppose hunters are expected to shoot the deer, then charge with the bayonet to finish it off.

And rifle design had changed since my shooting days. A significant number are designed to look like the most threatening of combat weapons. Why? Are we trying to scare the deer? It was even more noticeable in the air gun section with its guns for children and target shooters. Most of them were designed to look like combat weapons. Why? Most combat pistols are not a very good shape for target shooting. And what's happening to our children when we give them toys designed to look like particularly vicious combat weapons?  That includes the air rifles - and most of the latter were terrible designs for target shooting.

If I were a policeman and a child pointed one of those at me, I would have no hesitation in shooting. It is irresponsible and almost insane to distribute such weapons to children as toys.

On B3, the Irving press at last tells us why oil prices are in the toilet. It's because Saudi Arabia is deliberately flooding the market to drive prices down. Why? Well, Saudi Arabia is not Santa Claus. They're doing it to destroy the shale gas industry. Once that's done, the price will go right back up.

Will it work? I doubt it. Notice we haven't read much about shale gas lately? That's why Gallant is being allowed to continue his moratorium. But once the Saudis start cutting production again, the shale gas industry will tell Gallant to get on  his horse and present the report saying that shale gas is perfectly safe. It shouldn't take more than a year.

Meanwhile, the US supports the price drop as a way to cripple the Russian oil industry and the Russian economy. That probably won't work either. American behaviour, especially in Africa and the Far East is forcing a change in the East. China is committing itself to a close alliance with Russia, usually its enemy. Others are joining. I would not be surprised if it comes to include India and Iran and parts of Latin America.

The greed of western big money and the US pursuit of world domination is reshaping the international affairs of the whole world. The thrust of it is against the US. And Canada is, unhappily, closely associated with the most hated nation in the world.
_____________________________________________________________________________

I'm surprised that Canadians are surprised to see some Muslems involved in violence and abuse of others. And they say it's part of their religion.Have we already forgotten what happened only a short time ago? When we apologized for what our churches did in abusing and sometimes killing native children in residential schools? That damage is still there. Us Christians did it, and it won't go away for a very, very long time..

There's a very good book on the damage it does when we intrude in the organization of another society. The damage is dreadful and long-lasting, even if done with good intentions, and even if the other side wants us to do it. There's book is - Pankaj Mishra, "From the Ruins of Empire". It tells of how nations were socially destroyed and left adrift by conquest - and how the destruction happened even if the countries were eager to westernize.  He, optimistically, I think, says that Turkey, Egypt, China, Japan are recovering.  I doubt that, They are changing. But a change is not the same as a recovery.

For that matter, our society is changing rapidly. The capitalism of just sixty years ago is gone, replaced by a capitalism which has no nation and is beyond the control of any government. In consequence, we are losing our social structure. And, in the direction we are going, our society will not survive. That's is not being over-dramatic. Common sense should tell us that neither the economy nor the state can survive when almost all of us get poorer every year, and a very tiny number get richer every year. That is a certain recipe for world economic collapse, and for world violence.

A warning, though, about this book. I once had to read an 800 page book, in French, by a Russian communist scholar, on rural and small town life in France during the reign of Louis XIV.( I can safely claim I have no expertise in any of this things I mention in that sentence.)

And it was a breeze compared to Pankaj Mishra at less than half the length. Mishra is an academic who has not the faintest idea how to write for a general audience. Moreover, he assumes we are all familiar with the who's who of the nineteenth century in places like Turkey and Japan. In fact, I am not familiar with them. This is one, tough read.

However, skim through it. I won't say you should read it quickly because nobody could. But don't fuss over understanding every sentence. Get the general idea of what it means to make a quick change in any social order. Get an  idea of the difficulty of making such a change, and the even greater difficulty of making the sort of change that your people can handle. This is one of the most thought provoking books I have ever read.

(The Russian, marxist historian was  Boris Fyodorovich Porshnev. His "Les Soulevements Populaires" was published in Moscow in 1948. Don't even think about it.) 
_________________________________________________________________________

Above all, forget the caricatures of good and evil we get in our news media, especially on something like the Paris shootings. 'We' and 'they' are neither evil nor good. We and they, all of us, are just people. And forget the recent eloquence about the French love for freedom and free speech.

Yes, there was a French revolution against dictatorship by the king. But that was closely followed by a dictatorship by Napoleon, then by another king, then by another Napoleon. For a century after the revolution, France was scarcely a model of democracy and freedom.

The revolutionary government made a spectator sport of killing people by beheading. In fact, it was called The Reign of Terror. For that purpose, France was the first to adopt high volume, public beheading by using the guillotine. Al Quaeda are just amateurs trying to catch up to real pros. In fact, France routinely used the guillotine until 1977. There are lots of videos of beheadings in France, many of them public, on youtube.

By the way, did you know that torturing foreigners is illegal by international law?. However, in the US, torture is quite legal if used against American citizens. American prisons have always used torture.

And France has one of the worst records of anti-semitism in the world. Look up the Dreyfuss Affair, a case in which a French army officer who was Jewish came close to being executed for a crime he had never committed.  And there is not the slightest doubt it was because he was Jewish. Russia was anti-Jewish. So was Ukraine, particularly the part of Ukraine that is on our side, and that has the Nazi party prominent in its government. The Netherlands is deeply anti-Jewish. I learned that when I was living there. Jews from Spain and Portugal fled to England to escape persecution. But England accepted them only because they paid protection money to the king. (Later some fled to Canada which is why there is a Spanish and Portuguese Synagogue in Montreal.) But Canada and the US would prove to be as bad anything they had fled from well into the 1950s.

And the Jews? Depends which Jews you mean. Sephardic Jews, the ones who lived in Palestine for centuries got along quite well with Muslims. Ashkanaze Jews, the ones from Europe - and the majority in Canada - have a hatred and intolerance for Muslims which is reminiscent of Nazi hatred for all Jews. One of them, a tool of Israeli propaganda and a publisher in Montreal, recently denounced me on Facebook as a Jew-hater because I have criticized Israel.  (It thought of this when I read a story on today's B3 on federal candidates in Montreal. I knew all of them, some quite well, and he was one of the candidates. For Harper, of course.)

Forget the caricatures. There ain't no good guys and bad guys out there. Not on either side. We and they, all of us, are just people.


Tuesday, January 13, 2015

Jan.13: What is a news story?

A news story tells us what happened. That's all. It does not tell us what to think of it. That is not the role of a reporter. A columnist can try to tell us what to think. That's why the columnist's writing is listed as a column, and not as news. Any reporter who uses news to express his or her opinion needs to be spanked and sent back to journalism school. And any news editor who would run such a story (I believe it's a David Gauvin for this one) should be fired on the spot. I intend to write the Irving press ombudsperson on this one - but with no great expectations.

It's in the issue for Monday, January 12, section B, page 1. The story, about the Paris shootings, come from The Associated Press. (which doesn't surprise me at all. Read this carefully.

"Blood-curdling, al-Quaida-inspired murder that tore at the heart of the nation which raised him wasn't ghoulish enough for Cherif Kouachi."

This is the kind of "news" writing one usually finds in supermarket tabs which enjoy a huge sale among the gullible----as in "...and then the depraved beast reached his filthy hands out to tear at her delicate, pink panties..." An ethical reporter does not use emotionally loaded language. An ethical newspaper does not print it.

Our newspapers never used such language in reporting on the American lieutenant in Vietman who ordered his men to slaughter a whole village, some 800 men, women, and children, and quite innocent. In fact, the North American press had to be shamed into reporting it at all. And when the lieutenant was found guilty and was sentenced to prison, the president pardoned him that next day. And there was no lurid reporting of that. either.

Our press is also turning this into an issue of free speech and, intellectually, satire.

I have looked at the cartoons. Neither free speech nor satire is an issue here. In the first place, no country in the civilized world allows absolute free speech. It does not exist, and it never has. As my elders used to tell me when I was a kid (lord, elders can be annoying), "Stop saying things like that. Nobody is allowed to shout 'fire' in a crowded theatre".

Every civilization I have ever heard of puts limits on what we can say. Canada, the US, Britain, France all have laws limiting free speech. And the US, Britain, and France have all imposed severe limits on speech in their days of empire. Indeed, in parts of the American empire, to this day, you can get killed for speaking too freely. Ask anybody in Guatemala.

As for satire, I have seen the cartoons. I know what satire is. And these ain't satire. If they are, then I shall start a magazine showing cartoons of leading New Brunswickers that show them sexually assaulting cattle. The Charlie Hebdo cartoons are at that level. And they have only one purpose, to cause hatred. If you find them funny, then for your next birthday party, I can get  you a comic who entertains by blowing out the candles - with farts to the tune of happy birthday to you....

What they have done is to stir up fear,  hatred, paranoia, manipulation that could well lead to millions, many, many millions of deaths. This is not about satire or free speech.

For example, huge demonstrations all over the world don't happen by accident. I don't think we have ever in history seen such big and widespread demonstrations. That happens with organization and money - big money. And we had forty "world leaders' leading the street procession in Paris. Gee! How many world leaders attended demonstrations when the US murdered millions in Vietnam - and millions in other places. How much of it is even reported? Think. How much to you know about American drone attacks? How many have their been? How many people killed? How many innocent? How many children?

And three million people marched in Paris. How inspiring! And how many marched when French armies were torturing and murdering people in Indo-China, Algeria and Tunisia?

I very much fear we are watching an orchestrated campaign to justify one hell of a war. Our politicians are in on it. So are our newspaper owners. On the basis of some loutish cartoons, we are laying the groundwork for a war that will almost certainly go global. And we are tarting it up with absurdly grand titles like "freedom of speech" and "satire". We are being played like fools. And we are acting like fools.
___________________________________________________________________________
There are also a couple of amusing news pieces.  On the same page, we h ave Harper honouring John A. Macdonald.  And everything he says is pure malarkey. Harper called John A. "a shining example of modesty, hope, and success".   No, he wasn't Stephen. Like you he was a front man for big business - first for Canadian big business, then for British big business. That's what confederation and the CPR were all about. He was also as corrupt as a - well, as a conservative. The only thing making him more attractive than Harper is that he was an alcoholic.

Mind you, we had a prime minister from just over the border in Nova Scotia who was possibly even more corrupt than John A.

This is all part of a series of Government "history" commemorations that Harper is planning to show how patriotic he is. There's a letter to the editor of the TandT in Tuesday's paper from the Hon. Shelley Glover on how we will learn and be inspired by our country's history - just as in the celebrations of 1812 and World War. Come off it, Shelley, nobody learned anything significant from those "celebrations". This is pure politics, and getting Stephen re-elected at our expanse.

Oh, and we have special assault troops going up the Arctic to look out for spies. I'm not sure why. After all, the only country to openly reject Canada's claim to the Arctic is the US. It routinely sends ships through the northwest passage without asking Canadian permission. ( And the Canadian government routinely pretends it gave the US permission.) The only time an American ship was every stopped was by Inuit who parked their dogs and sleds on the ice ahead of the American ship.

______________________________________________________________________

For Tuesday, Alec makes some good points at the expense of Premier Gallant. Gallant has said he wants  consultation with all New Brunswickers to solve our economic problems. Uh, Brian, all New Brunswickers are not financial experts. In fact, most of us ( almost all of us) are not. To say you're going to deal with the economy by general meetings is like a doctor stopping in the middle of an operation so he can consult with all New Brunswickers on how to do it.

In fact, dealing with the problem is what YOU were elected to do.

Norbert gets all excited, saying the TantT cartoonist make the most powerful statement of all on the Paris shootings. Norbert, neither you nor I have seen as much as one percent of all the cartoons on those shootings. I saw nothing original in his point of view - and nothing helpful.

By the way, flying a flag at half-mast does not mean putting it half-way down the pole.

Alan Cochrane does quite a decent column about the Paris shootings. Without quite saying so, he makes the point that to speak of free speech in loose terms is a dreadful mistake. He closes, "Freedom of speech is a wonderful thing, just like the debate over how to use it responsibly."

He also points out that it can be used to spread hatred and violence. Bang on.

Section B3 has a predictably big news story that French Jews are fleeing to Israel. That raises an important question. Where can Palestinians flee to?

As it is, Israel is stealing their land and destroying their homes. What will happen as the population of Israel grows? (Too bad all those world leaders in Paris didn't show up recently to protest when Israel was killing a lot more than a dozen cartoonists.)

On the same page, Pope Frances denounces "deviant" religions that cause violence. Too bad he didn't notice all the Christian in such deviant religions - the ones who say that God is on our side, that the US has God's wish that it should rule the world, that for the US to invade Canada in 1812, Mexico later, and native peoples all the time was part of God's "manifest destiny" for the US. In fact, you can find deviant religion in just about every Christian group I can think of from Baptists to Roman Catholics.
________________________________________________________________________________
But the story that scares me is the one about Paris. This is being orchestrated very skilfully, and with big money behind it. The use of terms like "free speech" and freedom of the press)  is a clever use of emotive  language to rouse hatred and fears. We are being manipulated for something very big, and the news media have signed on. And it is likely that a great many, a very great many, innocent people are going to die.

Monday, January 12, 2015

Jan. 12: Matthew 7:5

Today, the Irving press joined the stampede of hypocrisy over the Paris shootings. It's all over the editorial and op ed pages in a massive display of ignorance, racism, and irresponsibility. And Alec Bruce leads the charge. And this time, it's dangerous because they've missed what this issue has become.

(The editorial says nothing but to babble about the new high school. They don't seem to have an editorial writer who has ever even heard of a world beyond Champlain Mall.)

We are being led into a very dangerous situation, terminally dangerous. The news media are being manipulated into creating that dangerous situation. They babble about freedom of speech. But freedom of speech is not the issue. We are being manipulated by our own racism. And we are likely to pay one hell of a price for that.

And our news media have utterly failed to give us the information we need. So let's take it in stages.

1. Whenever one society interferes with another, you get a social breakdown in one of them. In the early  to mid-19th century, Turkey eagerly tried to westernize. It encouraged trade with Europe, copied European economics, built European-style universities It tried passionately to become European.

The result was a Turkey that, by late nineteenth century, was called "the sick man of Europe". It was broke. Its traditional society, its craft-based economy, had been shattered with disastrous effects on the lives of ordinary families. The people were lost in a strange world in which none of the values they had been raised had any meaning. And this was in a country that wanted to be European.

China went through a similar experience, and descended into a chaos of starvation, poverty,abuse, civil wars - often just wars of bandit gangs supported by the western powers - heavily dependent of opium which Britain had forced on them. It took China a century to even start on the road back, another half-century to get where it is now, and it still has a long way to go before its people feel they are a society again.

It is quite possible, even probable, that the US is facing such a breakdown. this one a breakdown caused by racism (black, hispanic) and class privilege (the super-rich above everybody else). It is very, very close.

There are examples of this all over the world- as with native peoples in Canada and the US. Often, the experience will drive people to religious extremes - as it did with the French Catholics in Quebec after the British conquest. Until the mid-nineteenth century and later, schools were organized by religion; the churches ran hospitals, child welfare programmes, social programmes of all sort. No Quebec government would have dreamed of passing legislation without first getting the approval of the Catholic bishops.

2. Us. For centuries, the west had the advantage of being way ahead in industrialization, global transport, weaponry, military skills. It used that power to destroy societies and values of the rest of the world. (They called it bringing civilization.) They didn't give a damn about the people. They didn't. And we don't. And the reason we don't is..

3. racism. All western leaders I have ever heard of were openly racist. (Yes, that includes Abraham Lincoln. He freed the slaves. But he would never dream of letting his daughter marry one.) They were racist. Most of them still are. And we are.

That's why the US could kill over a million Muslims in Iraq, men, women and children, and destroy everything those people needed to live on - and we didn't care. They could murder a quarter million Guatemalan civilians - and it didn't even make the news. Nor do I recall candlelight vigils when French troops were torturing and murdering in Vietnam, Tunisia and Algeria.

We are racists. We are smug about it. We  lie to ourselves about it. But we are racists. Either that, or I missed the columns when Alec Bruce ever called the Americans or French, or Dutch, or British (or us) barbarians. He has never called us obscene. And, irony of ironies for a man who writes for the Irving press, he babbles about our commitment to freedom of the press.

And de Adder's cartoon is a sample of righteous anger at this attack on the freedom of cartoonists? I must have missed his cartoon about the Irvings. I must have missed the one about American slaughters of innocent people all over the world. I must h ave missed the ones about Canadian mines that abuse people in other countries, work them as worse than slave labour, and kill them on a whim.

What a collection of ignorant, racist and/or gutless hypocrites!

I have no doubt some people will read this and say I am supporting extremists. In fact, I have not said anything about the extremists. What I'm saying is we ALL have the flaw of being open to extremism and we have ALL do it.

4. The issue is freedom of speech? Oh. So how come we have not condemned Canada's language laws which we call laws against hate speech? And if we have freedom to speak, how come people who say the wrong things can go to jail? And if our news media have freedom of speech, how come they all sound pretty much the same?

Did the US allow free speech in Vietnam? in Iraq? in Afghanistan? in Guatemala? Did France allow it in Tunisia?  In Indo-China? In Algeria? If not, (and they most certainly did not) why didn't we hear about it?

5. Craig Babstock offers a column, again on free speech, but even sillier and shallower. He talks about the importance of satire and the right to satire. Well, we all like satire. But we only like the kind of satire that we agree with. A satirist plays to an audience that already agrees with him.

If you don't think so, try doing a standup comedy sketch about Jews in Belsen - and do it in a synagogue. In fact, we have laws against that.

The cartoonists should not have been killed. But let's not kid ourselves about what they did. Their satire wasn't just making fun of people. If I were to call Craig Babcock a half-wit, that would not be satire. It would simply be an insult. In the Charlie cartoons, I have yet to find any satire. There are only insults, and insults publicly thrown at a whole society.  Tell you what, draw a cartoon of Muhammed urinating on Jesus, and show it around at a Baptist church service. See how many call it satire. (In fact, you might get arrested for doing that in a bar.)

6. Steve Malloy says that our free society is fragile. Steve, we are watched constantly by domestic spies who report us to various power groups in Canada and outside.Almost every election in Canadian history has been won by a party with big, corporation money behind it. You work for a newspaper that rigidly controls what information was are allowed to get.

Tell you what. If you are big on a free society, then write some columns on what we need to do to get one. Criticize our news media for not being honest. Raise questions about domestic spies. Find out how much money Irving gives, and to which parties. Then we'll talk.

7. The biggest danger here is that this incident is being used to manipulate us.  Some people want a war. No matter who it is, we would be damn fools to give it to them. Any such war would quickly become a world war, complete with nuclear weapons.  Any such war would be the last one.


Sunday, January 11, 2015

Jan 10 and 1/2: The two big stories.

One of the big stories in the Irving press now is, of course, the shootings in Paris. And the reports are stuffed full of rage at what they call an attack on free speech.

The other big story is about the Professor at UNB who is alleged to express racist opinions. People want him fired.

Think about that.

An attack on free speech is dreadful when it's done by Muslims. But it makes perfect sense when so many of us want it done at UNB.

There's a vigil in town for those who were killed by Muslims in France. All the best people will be there,  I'm sure.

I'm so sorry I missed what must have  been huge vigils when the US was murdering Vietnamese, Guatemalans, Itaqis, Libyans and many others by the millions.

Of course, the Paris killings were worse because they were attacks on free speech. I mean, we really believe in free speech. That's why, if I were walking down a crowded main street and shouted to a man and his wife that she was a diseased whore, and he hit me,  the courts and the public would be with me all the way.

So these people really think the US was murdering Vietnamese right down to babies by the millions in order to protect free speech? Do they actually think the US even allowed free speech in Vietnam? or Guatemala? or Iraq?

In the US some 50 years ago, an American Senator named McCarthy destroyed the lives of many people simply by accusing them of things that made him think they were communist. Often, there was no evidence. Certainly, there was no evidence they had ever done anything communist or had in any way endangered the US.  There was just rumour - started by McCarthy. But it was enough. They were destroyed. Many of them had been had been Hollywood stars. And that scared the bejesus out of gutless wonders like Ronald Reagan.  Reagan and his ilk scrambled to the committee hearings to save their skins by offering to volunteer the names of people they thought might be communists.

Free speech is severely restricted in both Canada and the US - sometimes by law, sometimes by other means. You want to test that? Okay. Go on radio to freely express a severely critical view of Israel. And it isn't just a matter of law.

Newspapers and private news media across North America broadly express the same views about just about anything. They are not designed to promote free speech or free thought. They are designed as propaganda.

Then there are the social pressures. Here in New Brunswick, early in Alward's term as PM, Irving announced in an op ed piece that he was in coalition with the government. Coalition. That means he was a member of the government - without even getting elected. And he announced that he would be planning the economic future of New Brunswick (which is what I thought was had just elected a government to do.)

Nobody, no news medium, no speaker, nobody said a damn word. You can kill freedom of speech without laws, and without guns. All you need is power, and people who are afraid to use free speech. And we certainly didn't see any freedom of speech about this in the Irving press. Here, in a province of hundreds of journalists -editors, reporters, commentators,  nobody had the nerve to say it was illegal and unconstitutional for anyone to just declare himself a member of the government.  Or none of them had the brains.

Conformity and lack of free speech in the US is so common that both of the political parties are far right. It's safer that way. And that may explain by more than half of American voters don't bother to vote.

The US has recently been caught, with lots of evidence, of disgustingly illegal practices in torture. So - where's the big news media coverage? Where are the calls for judicial action? Nothing has been done. Nothing is going to be done. And nobody is going to say a word.

We also know, according to the report, that Canada was involved. But most of the Canadian news media didn't even mention that.

Have you ever seen a criticism of capitalism in our news media? I never have. Gee! It must be the most perfect system ever developed in all of human history. Ever see a criticism of anybody rich in the Irving press?

A deranged young man kills three police. He's arrest, tried, sentenced within a few months. Long before that, a rich man in Nova Scotia was arrested and charged with killing his father. Ain't nuthin' happened yet. The first story, here in Moncton, is still being written up as a tribute to the spirit of the people of Moncton. Okay. And what does the other case tell us?

Now, both Canada and the US have secret police to record everything we say or do or read or think. And it's admitted that this information is handed over to a national council of CEOs.  Boy! Talk about being confident of our right to free speech.
__________________________________________________________________________

But something else is happening in the Paris shootings. We are getting lots of hype about how this in the news media - how this is especially terrible because it's a threat to free speech around the world.

Sorry, kids. Free speech around the world went out the window a long time ago. Obviously, this is being used to increase our hysteria and fear about Islam.  Why?

Well, that's what happens when somebody wants a war. Somebody drums up high levels of fear and hatred and hysteria. The   question here is who and why?

Were the killers trying to start a war? I don't see why. They already have one. Does the Muslim world gain anything from the attack? Well, shooting cartoonists is hardly likely to defeat the western world. Was it the act of just those individuals? Quite possibly. And shouldn't our news media be checking that before they whip up an orgy of hatred and fear?

Is it somebody else who wants a war? Quite possibly. No country ever calls itself an aggressor or greedy or murderous. Never. Any country that wants a war first puts up what's called a "false flag". When Bush wanted to invade Iraq, his "false flag" was that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction. (Why did nobody mention that lots of countries, including the US, have weapons of mass destruction?) If you read the history of any country, especially the history books written for schools and the popular ones that become movies, you'll find that every country that ever went to war did it because it was forced to. Right. The British had to invade a fifth of the world because Nigerians were threatening them. The US had to invade every country in Central America because each of them was a threat to American citizens. Oh, and it had to overthrow democracy in Haiti so it could bring democracy to Haiti.

What they all do is to play up an incident that can justify a war or justify it in the press, at least. Is that what is happening now? It's very possible. The time for US corporations to make their bid for world domination is running out fast.

This could, for example, be preparation for an assault on Iran to knock out a major ally of China and
Russia. If so that would almost certainly force Russia and China into a nuclear showdown.

Or it might be an excuse for a massive assault on Islamic Africa and the middle east. Either reason would be insanity - but greed and power do that to people.

Meanwhile - I think I talked in a blog about how nations come to a stage in which their societies break down. Certainly, it's happening in the Islamic world. That's why we're seeing the rise of what we call extremists. And it looks as though it could be happening in the US and much of Europe. And I prefer not even to guess where that takes us.

2015 is shaping up as a very dangerous year, perhaps the most dangerous this world has ever seen.