Saturday, July 14, 2012

Wow! lots of pictures of not-very-old cars

That pretty much sums up todays' news in The Moncton Times and Tribune. Page 1 is headed by a photo of a 2008 Mustang. Now there's something you don't see every day. I mean, not every day. Then there's a picture of a Ford steering wheel. I mean, like, it's all round and everything. Weird.

There is a massive story - in fact, two of them that begin on page one then take up pp. 14 and 15 as well. Together they make one of the largest stories I've seen in a newspaper. Too bad they don't say much. They're about Gregg Ingersoll who takes over the anglophone part of our school district; and they gush about how he's an electrician and has a cottage at Shediac and, oh, just everything. There's even a long passage about how, being an electrician, he could fix the lights and everything at the schools.

Anything that deals with education policy is so vague as to be useless. All we're really told is he's going to do what the education minister wants. Very exciting, I'm sure.

Did the district ever have a director before? Was anything accomplished? I don't know. It doesn't say.

A commentary on the oped page is really a free ad for NB Power.

The one bright spot is Bill Belliveau's column on wind power.

It's amazing what isn't in today's Times and Transcript. For example:

The chairman of the US Federal reserve, Ben Bernanke, has testified to Senate that the US economic crisis is going to get much worse. As well, a recent study estimates that US wars of the past decade will cost 3.7 to 4.4 trillion dollars.  That's quite a debt.

And, yes, all this will affect even the hub of the Maritimes. The US is our largest customer and a major source of tourists. What a great time to borrow a hundred million for an events centre!

The bank scandals  about rigging interest costs, making wild investments, laundering billions in drug money, and driving whole nations into poverty is now well and truly world-wide.  HSBC, the British banking company, has been found guilty of money-laundering, and fined a billion dollars. Mind you, it won't hurt them much  since they just got a three and a half billion dollar bailout.

Why should we care? Because HSBC is the second largest banking conglomerate in the world - all over the world, including Canada. It also owns outfits you may be more familiar with like Household Finance. As well, Canadian banks, too, operate in that huge brothel we call the world banking system. Do you really think they're virgins?

Now, compare that news with what appears on the TandT's Your Business page.

The US has just sent a fourth carrier to join its fleet off Iran. Think maybe they're just funnin'?

An Israeli has been jailed in the US for buying kidneys from destitute Palestinians in the occupied territories, and selling them in the US. No big deal? Well - would it be a big story if a Palestinian were trading in Jewish kidneys? Why?

Mitt Romney is holding a  campaign fund raising dinner at $65,000 a plate - in Israel. No big deal? Would you care to give me a list of other presidential candidates who have held major fund-raising dinners in foreign countries?

Then there's a great chance for Crandall Univesity to show how Christian it is.

Omar Khan, a Canadian citizen, was imprisoned as a child soldier. That's illegal. He was tortured. That's illegal. He was tried by a military court. It's illegal to try a child soldier by a military court because such a court accepts testimony obtained by torture. It also withholds evidence from the defence. He was found guilty (predictably) - with the proviso he would serve his term in Canada.

Now - in almost all cases of citizens of western countries being captured by US troops, they have immediately been turned over to the country of their citizenship. It happened to Australian citizens. It happened to British citizens. In fact, both Britain and Australia demanded it immediately on capture.  Canada is the only country that never even asked.

It was months ago that the US said he is ours. Canadian courts have cleared the way. But Harper won't lift a finger; Omar Khadr, a Canadian citizen, still sits in solitary at Guantanamo.

What a wonderful opportunity for a Christian institution to manifest its belief in love, forgiveness, all those good things by making a public statement to Mr. Harper. And it's okay. I mean, it's not like he's gay or something.

Actually, it might be a good idea for all the Christian clergy of Moncton to discuss this in their churches. But there's not a chance in hell that any of them will. Stephen Harper is not the only Christian who just talks the talk and walks the walk.

Finally, for a paper that was going to tell us all about shale gas, the Tand T has missed some pretty big stories. One of them tells us it is impossible to make shale gas safe without spending so much on maintenance that the cost would be prohibitive - and it still wouldn't be completely safe.

A reader was kind enough to send me the web address - so I pass it on to you.

http://www.gregpalast.com/fracking-in-Ireland-and-beingdependent-on-halliburtons-mud/#6369

As always, there's also real news if you google Moncton Free Press.









Friday, July 13, 2012

July 13: Target to take over Zellers.......

......Wow! Stop the presses. Front page for sure.

Meanwhile, the only important story in section A is on p. 2. All NB Liberal leadership candidates have taken a position to delay fracking. It is not, as the story seems to suggest, an anti-fracking position. It is a position favouring further study. It is also a story that tell us virtually nothing. Reporters are not supposed to just write up press releases. They've supposed to ask questions. But those of the TandT never do. So here are a few of the more obvious ones.

1. If the Liberals think the information on fracking is inadequate, what were they thinking all their years in office while they allowed it to go on? They had virtually no regulations in place, no inspection, and gave out no information. This sounds very much as though the Liberals must be one, incompetent bunch.

2. If the Liberals are so gung ho on renewable resources, why have they not even whispered about it till now? Little PEI was experimenting with wind power forty years ago.

3. When, in the last fifty years, have the NB Liberals opposed anything the Irvings wanted? Why are they doing so now? Or -are they doing so now?  Consider this possibility. (This is me, Graeme Decarie Enbridge Irving ,speaking.)

The profits of natural gas are too low to continue exploration right now. And the public opposition is too strong. So, we have a situation in which it is not worth going ahead - for now. That gives us shale gas explorers time to straighten out the politics.

The Conservative have made too many enemies to be any more use. Dump them.

The Liberals will use a couple of years to chatter about studies. Nothing else will be happening, anyway. If, by the end of that time, the price of gas goes up - and it will - then we start another soft sell.

By this time, New Brunswickers will have jumped back on the Liberal/Conservative merry-go-round. But this time the soft sell will work because the Liberals will seem like the good guys (for a little while.  Their colours will start to show again; but by that time the wells will be in operation.  If necessary, we can then dump the Liberals and back the Conservatives on a platform of, say, tougher regulations).

Too bad TandT reporters don't know they're supposed to ask questions.

That's it for section A.

NewsToday has the usual Reuters story on Syria and, again, Reuters is getting all its information from the rebels. There has been nothing in these stories to give a hint of how dangerous this situation is.

Russia has sent troops to Syria. It has also said it will send naval ships to escort its commercial shipping to and from Iran if the US tries to block it. The US has already sent major naval units and troops to the area. China and India have vital interests in Iranian oil. Israel has made it clear it is eager to attack Iran and, possibly, Syria and Lebanon. Syria and Iran are the closest of allies. And attack on one is, in effect, an attack on the other. The US is virtually a prisoner of Israeli policy - with leading Republicans demanding war immediately.

The reason given for intervention is that Iran is developing a nuclear bomb. There is no evidence it is. And major figures in Israeli and US intelligence have said it is not.

However, on both sides in this showdown there are nuclear stockpiles - US, Russia, China, Britain, France, Israel. Six countries. And it takes only one fool.

Use your own imaginations and your own common sense.

The Business Page breaks a big story - NB is an important centre for the arms trade. I have a bigger story. On a per capita basis, Canada is the third largest exporter of weapons (oops, sorry - defence) in the world. Talk about a military-industrial complex. And where do these arms end up? Some with allies. Some with enemies. Some with gangsters - as in the case of Mexican drug gangs. What the hell. It's business.  Good for jobs.

Liked Alec Bruce's column.  Disagreed with Gwynne Dyer. But it's informed and well-written - and that's what it has to be.

I had earlier promised a list of little known facts about Canada that should make the news. But you'll never see them in the Times and Transcript. Here it is.

Here is where Canada stands in the world, - on a per capita basis. That is, other countries may be worse than us in these fields - but only because they are bigger. On a per capita basis, we are the biggies.

1. Mining - world's leading mine developer. World's worst recycler of mining products.
2. forestry - heaviest forester, worst recycler of wood and wood products.
3. heaviest user of energy - electricity, oil, gas, etc.
4. world's leader in consumption of non-renewable materials.
5.Leading source of depleted uranium for weapons. (Depleted radium is used to make shell cases so hard they can penetrate almost anything. However, they also seem to be a major cause of cancer - as in Iraq cities which were shelled by US and British troops and where babies are now born with cancer.)
6. Major supplier of uranium for nuclear warheads - including for the two countries most likely to use them, India and Pakistan.

The TandT should either get serious about its business page - or scrap it. The same holds for NewsToday. There is nothing here that is not better covered on radio and TV. It would be more useful to have several pages of commentary by syndicated columnists of quality (not hacks as in National Post). There is really no point in news which doesn't have enough comment to give it meaning.

Oh - re the weekly column by Lynda MacGibbon - Lynda, you're a good writer,and you're a sensitive one. Usually, you write about the contrasts between Toronto and Moncton - as, today, you wrote of your balcony garden in Toronto as compared to your garden in Riverview.

It's good. But I think you need to remember more that you are writing about a contrast. In this case, for example, we need a stronger sense of life in a residential tower in Toronto. We know enough about the Riverview end of it - but not enough about the visual and physical experience of the Toronto end.

There's a great deal that Monctonians need to know about the range and variety of life in a big city - and how Moncton compares. We need that here because Moncton isn't really a city. It's more a rising town, heavily oriened to consumerism, narrow in its intellectual and entertainment activity. (That's not a condemnation. It's the natural result of being a small city with a monopolistic and tenth rate press -and rather isolated as cities go.) Nor does it suggest that Toronto is better. In fact, I've never liked Toronto. On balance, I prefer Moncton.

But there are striking contrasts - some in which Toronto comes off better -and some in which Moncton is the winner.

You're a good writer and sensitive one. You can do this. And it would be a real service to Moncton.








































w

Thursday, July 12, 2012

July 12: a real news story on p. A1

Breaking with its tradition of the top story of the day being something about a cute budgie, The Moncton Times and Transcript led with a well written story by Brent Mazerolle about how the Canadian Teachers' Federation released a poll showing that teachers want more freedom in the way they teach. It's a good story. To bad they couldn't find a good editor to write the headline.

The poll reports on Canadian teachers. The headline reads "N.B. teachers..." Good reporting. Bad editing.

The teachers have a point. When I taught elementary school and high school, I was tied down by all sorts of rules that limited how and what I could teach. But, in university, where nobody knows how to teach or cares, I had a wonderful freedom to learn what my students really needed to learn, what it was a waste of time to teach (because it was useless and would be forgotten after the exam); and I learned ways that would be most effective in helping them to learn.

Universities are lousy teaching institutions. But if you want to teach, you can have freedom in them. Public schools are far better teaching institutions; but they could better still if teachers had more freedom and less interference.

One of the worst examples of interference is the intrusion of a right wing "think tank" (Atlantic Insitute of Market Sudies) into our public schools. It sets quite worthless exams to conduct scientifically fraudulent rankings of schools and teachers. The existence of those exams forces schools to teach For the exams. Goodbye freedom and goodbye learning what's best for the students.

The Irvings, incidentally, are not unconnected with this scheme. It originated in the US as a sort of nose of the camel.  The intent there was to open the way for privatization of the public schools. It worked.  Creeping privatization in the US now makes it almost essential to go to fee paying "public" schools if you want to get anywhere. At the same time, the US has dropped from its educational ranking of 18th in the world to somewhere below hundredth. (136 was the last number I saw.)

When you visit your child's school, does it have posters saying something like "Our goals for the year - 10% improvement in reading skills - 12% improvement in math...."? That's part of the game - as if the school were a factory, and children were toasters going along an assembly line.

This lead story is important, and worth reading.

The rest of section A is for insomniacs.

The biggest news story in News Today is on the defection of a Syrian ambassador. Actually, it's two days old. Reuters must be having a sale of old stock.

More interesting is the news that didn't make it at all. For example:

The TD bank has frozen the bank accounts of Iranian-Canadian citizens. Notice the word Canadian. These are Canadians. Some of them have been Canadians for ten, twenty years or more. I commonly had Iranian-Canadians in my classes twenty years ago and more. So why are the accounts frozen?

Because the US wants the world to impose economic sanctions on Iran. So Mr. Harper saluted and said, "Yes, sir."

There are some problems with this.

1. To impose economic sanctions is, arguably, an act of war. When did parliament approve a war? Or even discuss this? It most certainly can lead to war - and by having imposed the sanctions we shall then have comitted ourselves to take part in the war - with no legal approval. You know, the right of Canada to declare war for itself? That, according to what I hear every November 11, is what our soldiers died for in World War Two.

2. The reason given for al this is that Iran is building a nuclear bomb. There is no evidence it is. In fact, senior figures in the Israeli army, Israeli intelligence, and American intelligence have publicly said it is not.

3. The last time Canada did this was in World War Two when Japanese-Canadians, most of them born here, had their property confiscated and were put into concentration camps. I know many of them well. I have watched them shake with pain and humiliation, to this day, whenever I can get them to talk about what they suffered.

4, So far, only the TD has announced freezing acounts. Why only the TD?

Hey, don't worry. If you get your news from the TandT, you don't even have to know it happened.

A film called The Last War Crime was shown at Cannes. But you will see it - if you see it at all - in heavily censored form. The US government does not approve of it.

No, no. It's not sex. It's about Bush's vice-president, Dick Cheney, and how he was the man who set up the wide use of torture by the US  army and its intelligence agencies. But don't worry. You're not likely to see it in Moncton - or anywhere else in North America.

Canadian mining companies, with their world-wide record of environmental poisoning, dreadful working conditions and low pay, are being kicked out of Bolivia. But if us Canadians want to read about it, we have to go to a middle east news source, Al Jazeera.

There is chaos in Britain as 14 major banks have been caught in irresponsible and, according to the British government, illegal behaviours which have stolen billions of dollars. It's very similar to the behaviour of American and European bankers which has driven tens of millions - probably many more - into debt and poverty for generations to come.

The American and European response has been to blame the poor, and to give money to the banks and to bankers, while leaving the poor to pay taxes and to starve. The British prime minister is talking criminal charges.

That may be tough. His own government is up to its ears with close ties to banking. And one-fifth of the members of the House of Lords are directors or advisors to the banks.

Oh - a little item. Republicans in the US are running hard on the platform that they are Israel's best friends. In this, they have the support of the powerful Israeli lobby in the US and Canada. The lobby is powerful because it's a major source of propaganda and party funding. In fact, that lobby is the reason Harper has made it a point to commit Canada to war if Israel ever goes to war - even though he has never bothered to consult parliament on it. And if you disagree with the Republicans or Harper, then you're an anti-semite.

Funny thing. Recent polls show that a large majority of Jews in the US vote Democrat. I guess that makes them anti-semite. I wonder whether Canadian Jewish Congress would rank me an anti-semite if I were to say that a majority of Jews in Canada do not vote for Harper.

Oh, what the hell. CJC already calls me an anti-semite. Almost all Jews I have known - and I have known a great many - vote Liberal or NDP.

Excellent columns, as usual, by Alec Bruce and Jody Dallaire. Trivia, as usual, by Rod Allen.

Norbert. A very sensible and well-written column. But he cannot use the words government and bureaucracy as anything but swear words. He does it just once this time; but oh,  it's annoying - and simple-minded. As well, I cannot respect a columnist who routinely pours contempt on government and civil servants, but would never dream of doing it on corporations or their executives.

Wednesday, July 11, 2012

July 11: Something good....

Today's editorial is good. It's well-written. It's logical. There's no rant in it. This is what an editorial should look like. The subject is the great plan to allow parking on Main St. The editorial writer is calling this a "half-baked plan". I think he or she is right. But that's not the point.

The point is that, agree or disagree with it, this is a clearly written, well-explained opinion. There's no rant, no name-calling. This is what we should be seeing every day.

Then to Norbert Cunningham. And he's just as good. This is a well-written and well-reasoned column. The language is calm, but firm. There is no use of prejudicial language or insinuation. Good stuff.

(A reader suggested to me I should have said that Norbert's column of yesterday was well-written. It was. But I didn't mention it one way or the other becaue it was about the "god particle"; and my understanding of physics is close to zero. I should have said it was well-written - but then just admitted that my ignorance of the subject permitted me to go no further.)

Contrast the editorial and Norbert to the rest of the editorial and op ed pages.

We get a For The Record column written by a hack (senior fellow) for a propaganda outfit called The Fraser Institute that is financed by big business, and wants to privatize everything. It's a clone of Atlantic Institute for Market Studies. It argues that more private airlines competing in Canada would drive down prices. So he says, would removing the airport tax.  Oh?

If we remove the airport tax, who will pay to maintain the airports? Me and you. That's who. So how does that put us ahead of the game? All it really does is to subsidize airlines at taxpayers' expense.

Then, note the implication in his column. He says that more competition by private airlines will reduce fares. Oh? Gee. That must mean they are now overcharging us.  And it must mean that if private business gets so big it doesn't have to worry about competition, it will rob us blind. Gosh. Is that true, Mr. Irving?

In fact, we used to be able to control air ticket prices very effectively and even make money out of it when we had a public airline called Air Canada. Thank you for privatizing it, Mr. "suitcase full of money" Mulroney.

Then we come to the oped page. It opens with a column by Eric Lewis who thinks that parking on Main St. is a great idea, and working well.

Maybe so.....but.......

An editorial that is unsigned is supposed to represent the collective opinion of the whole newspaper. I've always thought that a silly idea. How can a newspaper have a collective opinion? But that's the idea; and that's why editorials are not signed. I once discussed this with the editor of a major newspaper. She said she believed in this principle so firmly that she once decided she had to vote for a party she didn't like - because all the other editors had decided that the "newspaper" was going Conservative on this one.

But here we have Eric Lewis, a member of the newspaper staff, going nose to nose with the editorial.

Hello, Mr. Editor? If your newspaper has a policy of having a "newspaper" opinion, enforce it. If it doesn't (and I think it shouldn't), then use signed editorials.

Brian Cormier presents a touching and well-written story. But why is it on an opinion page? It doesn't give us any insight into the news. It's a good story. But it's not news; and it's not commentary.

The only news story worth reading is on p. A6, reporting on problems of the public consultations which Alward uses so often and, as this story implies, both wrongly and badly.

There is the almost daily Reuters report on Syria which has yet to mention a rather important detail. It is possible that the majority of rebels in Syria, the ones we are sending money and weapons to and we are threatening to intervene for, are Moslems either tied to or sympathetic with Al Quaeda.

Didn't we invade Afghanistan on the claim we were fighting against people like that?  (Actually, Al Quaeda had nothing to do with the invasion of Pakistan. But that was supposedly the reason for our troops being sent there.)

There has scarcely been a word of news on the scandals that have continued to sweep over banking and other commercial circles in the US and Europe. Even the great banks of England have been caught up in wildly irresponsible and probably criminal behaviour that amounts to thefts of billions of dollars from the public. There is now a stampede on in Britain to get money out of commercial banks and into co-ops.

Our banks are okay? Maybe. But remember that our banks do not operate on an island cut off from the rest of the world. They are interlocked with banks everywhere. That makes Canada vulnerable in the same way that a virus from Somalia can mean trouble for us.

And there's a great story in the Washington Post about the newest heroes of the free world. These are intrepid men who are officially called pilots. They even wear pilots' flying gear when they go on bombing missions. But they never leave the ground. In fact, most of them never leave the US.

When it's time to work, they suit up, and sit down at a video game that looks just like a cockpit. And then they aim drones at targets on the other side of the world to kill people who "might" be "suspected" terrorists. In their mess halls. they jokingly call the bodies bug splat.   (Well, that's so much nicer than calling them people or - as they often are - children or even babies.)

 At the pilots' end it's a video game so realistic they think they're there. At the other end, it's death for real people - some of whom could be real enemies. You never know.

Now, these heroes are going to get the recognition their courage merits. Drawings, names and descriptions of a whole new set of medals is underway. One suggestion is DWM - Distinguished Warfare Medal.

Watch for the movie.

Oh, guess which country is, per capita, the leader in the world for both mining and failure to recycle mining products - and which is  the leader for deforesting and failure to recyle forestry products. And the third in the world as an arms seller to - whoever wants them or can get them.

Tomorrow. And, no. You won't find it in The Moncton Times and Transcript.

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

July10: lesson one: the headline

The headline should reflect the theme of the news story. That's important because the headline is what people remember. In fact, it will often be the only part of the story that will be read. To write a headline that does not reflect the theme of the story, then, is to give a false impression. It is the sort of false impression that is often called lying. In journalism, it is called unethical. This is the first lesson of journalism school.

The truthfulness and accuracy of the headline are so important that it is usually written - not by the reporter - but by the editor for the page. (So let's remember to put the blame where it belongs.)

In this case, as well, it has been treated not as an ordinary story but as a SPECIAL REPORT, So one would think of it as one to get right. Now, look at the head at the right of p. A1. "Chemical control constantly improving: industry."

But the first column, a half-page one, is not about the industry at all. It's about a woman who suffers a chemically-caused epilepsy, and who has written to newspapers across Canada that the use of chemical sprays in gardens, for example,.is more dangerous than people realize.

That's the story. And one would expect a newspaper to consult - oh - say, doctors about this - or scientists - or somebody who is an authoristy on human reaction to such chemicals.

But there's not a word to suggest any such checking. Instead, the story suddenly switches to what is really a different story - FOUR columns of statements from executives in the industry that everything is okay - and no evidence presented at all.

Imagine if people complained of getting sick from the air near the refineries in St. John. The Tand T would a short column on that - with no checking with doctors, etc. Then it would write four columns from Mr. Irving and assorted execs saying the air in St. John is wonderful, and they often go there just to enjoy breathing it. Case closed.

We actually pay to read a newspaper that lies to us.

Well, it doesn't always lie. Sometimes, it's just juvenile. Take a look at today's op ed page. Big column by editor-at-large Alan Cochrane. Big - and so juvenile it could have been titled vroom-vroom.  The great day of the writer's life, it seems, came on Saturday when a whole, big bunch of motorcyclists all crossed the the bridge to PEI, all at the same time and all going vroom vroom.

Metro, he says, is still echoing from that epochal moment in Canadian history.

The tone of the whole vroom-vroom reminded me of the crush I had on a girl in grade three; and how I'd borrow a bike to ride down her block.  Then I'd pedal faster and faster so my feet were just a blur, and I'd figure she'd be looking out her window and seeing me. Vroom. Vroom.

Seriously, who gives a damn if a bunch of people on motorcycles (or in Ford pickups or  on skateboards) cross the bridge at the same time?

And it ends with a good, half-column that is really an ad for a motorcycle dealer.

This is supposed to be a page of thoughtful and informed comment about major issues. Check Gwynne Dyer in the column below it for what thoughtful and informed comment looks like.

What the staff-writers give us, inistead, is juvenilia.

These two examples - the front page story and the op ed one by Cochrane sum up much of what's bad about the Moncton Times and Transcript.
1. It lies.
2. When it doesn't lie, it's trivial.

And these are related bads.

The TandT is a newspaper only in the sense that the old, Soviet  Pravda was a newspaper.

It exists to mislead us about what is going on in the world.

I exists to feed us trivia so that we won't even think about those things we need to know about.

Then, for an example of confused reporting and bad headline writing all in one, check out the bottom of p. A1. "Moncton parking changes take hold". This is about Moncton's leap into the future with on-street parking, the idea being to generate business for downtown shops.

The first three paragraphs say it's going well. The fourth one says it's having no effect.

The story is continued on p.A7 with a new headline, "Downtown parking results positive" - which seems to contradict the earlier statement that it was having no effect. There is no significant evidence for any of the statements above.

So what do we really know so far?  Nothing. And it took the best part of a page to say nothing.

Meanwhile, it also said nothing about shale gas, Moncton High, or anything else of any importance.

Gwynne Dyer has a column well worth reading. But that's pretty much it.

There's very little on the plodding pace of investigation into the abuse of election laws in the last federal election - strange that it should go so slowly with a government that has a thin majority and thick plans. However, we can't be surprised. They'll still haven't done anything about the case of Brian Mulroney getting money in a suitcase. Remember that one?

But - if you're turned on by the thought of riding a motorcycle over the PEI bridge with a whole bunch of other motorcycles, and if you need to change your diaper at the thrill of people looking at  you, this is YOUR paper.

Vroom. Vroom.

Monday, July 9, 2012

July 9: Our aristocracy

The first section of today's Moncton Times and Transcript will be a treat for those who just love close-up pictures of rubber boots in the mud at a rock concert - or a picture of a copy of the Mona Lisa propped beside a chair at a flea market. That, seriously, with ads, pretty well sums up the first section - with one exception.

There is an important news story on p. A2. It's an interview with Professor Tom Buckley at University of New Brunswick, a specialist in the sort of public consultations we've been having lately on shale gas. Such consultations can be very useful - if the appropriate ministers are there. They are the ones people want answers from, not a collection of appointees. And it is the ministers who have to be reminded that they, not the appointees, are the ones responsible to the public.

Professor Becker cited cases in which public consultation was very effective - precisely because the cabinet minister was there. But when ministers aren't there, it is easy for them simply to distance themselves from the whole thing.  ( And that, of course, is why they came up with the bright idea of a appointing a committees to run the consultation. It's quite possible, even likely, that the appointees got their jobs because they will produce on 'helpful' recommendations.  And it's also close to a certainly that the government doesn't intend to pay any attention to the recommendations, anyway. It's a snow job.)

Professor Abelson of McMaster University added another caution. Discussions that come late in the policy making process are pretty ineffective because by then so many options and alternatives have been closed. (And thirteen years after the beginning of shale gas operations is more than a little late.)

Professor Abelson had more to say on the question of timing - but the story suddenly stopped in the middle of a sentence. Perhaps the editor needed the space for that photo of a copy of the Mona Lisa.

Still, this news story is a must read.

There's also a reasonable sort of editoral, not a great one, but reasonable. And that's it.

There's not even a funny story in today's copy.. For example, it missed the news that the US government will spend 54 million dollars in a year for ads to discourage smoking. But it spends 200 million a year to subsidize tobacco farmers.

The Business Page is just a collection of scattered items from no place in particular; and picked, seemingly at random, from whatever Reuters has for sale. Most of it, as always, will be of interest to very few readers.

With nothing much in the paper, maybe this is good day to talk about the upper levels of our business world, and the attitudes that develop at such levels.  I mentioned not long ago the Halifax woman who mixed in such circles; and how she was so upset that "Bob" Stanfield, the underwear king, lost a federal election to Pierre Trudeau. "After all, it was Bob's turn."

Of course. it was Bob's turn.  Bob was rich. Came from an 'old' family (which means it had been rich for at least two generations.) Bob was not just a common person. And so it really was his turn to be prime minister.

The world has been there, done that, many times.

In ancient Rome, those with money and influence were able to become leaders by heredity. One daddy would become rich on the grain trade - and then his eldest son and his son and his son would be senators forever. Another daddy would make his mark as a great general; and on that would claim the throne for himself and then his son and then his grandson (allowing for assassinations along the way).

Some odd things would happen to these leaders through the generations. Absolute power encouraged absolute greed. The emperors and senators lived in a splendour we can only imagine. The dining areas of the rich included a vomiting room, with a supply of feathers to tickle the inside of the throat so that the diner could get rid of the larks' tongues and wine he had just enjoyed, and could go back for more.

But most of the Romans lived in wretched poverty. The 'wage gap' was best reflected in burial practices. Caesars and Senators received magnificent monuments. The rest were simply tossed into vast pits -garbage dumps, really. A friend who did archaeological work near one of them said its soil resembled molasses.

And, in their arrogance and greed and self-worship, many of the leaders, especially the caesars became quite potty. One emperor, for example, got seasick so, when the boat docked, he sent his whole army into the water to beat the waves with whips, pierce them with spears, and slash them with swords.

Caligula believed he was a God - and felt he needed to look more like a God. So he had his chin pierced to accept curly, gold wires as his beard.  Hadrian's  phantasies were less painful. He liked to stand in his pool, naked, while little boys dressed as fish swam around him.

The inheritance process was repeated in medieval Europe. This time, it began with warriors who were able to subdue large numbers of people to be their slaves. The early castles were not so much to protect them from foreign invaders, but to protect the lord and his soldiers from their own people.

Over the centuries, the most powerful lords were able to establish their authority over other lords, and name themselves kings. Once again, the arrogance, greed and self-indulgence became extreme, and the 'wage gap' unspeakable.

And once again, the rulers were heirs with all the power and wealth of their ancestors - whatevet their brain capacity might be. By the 1600s, Louis XIV found his aristocracy so utterly brainless and incompetent that he turned to the middle class to recruit people with enough intelligence and ability to become what we now call the civil service. Business would later model itself on the civil service.

Britain, though more slowly, went through the same process. In a first step, an aristocratic family would send the eldest son to the House of Lords. That's why the House of Lords has always been a bit of a potluck supper so far as brains are concerned.

Other sons, if they showed signs of normal intelligence became diplomats, colonial officials or, with their connections, MPs.. And the slack-jawed sons became officers in the army. (That remained standard practice in the British army well into the twentieth century. There were, of course, exceptions who turned out to be brighter than expected, like Wolfe and Wellington. But they were exceptions. And even Wellington, a brilliant commander, proved a disaster as a prime minister. Winston Churchill, a similar case, was a brilliant prime minister for a time of war; but he was a disaster whenever he put a hand to military affairs.)

And now, especially for the last 25 years or so, it's been happening to us as the children of the very, very rich become our rulers. It has been happening for several centuries, of course; but it has really taken off with the changes made by President Reagan and Prime Minister Thatcher.

The very rich were given free reign to do whatever they liked. Controls were slashed. Political funding was so loosened that most of our  political parties are up for sale to the highest bidder. Education, which should be fully available to anyone of ability is now and increasingly only for the rich. In the US, any child whose parents cannot afford a private and partially private school doesn't have a chance.  University is even worse.

No-one has taken advantage of the power of money combined with newspapers and TV more than Rupert Murdoch, the Australian news king who distributes (wildly biased and lying) news in Australia, Britain, and the US. In Britian, he is so powerful that he has full access to cabinet ministers and the prime minister on a regular basis. And prime ministers, like Tony Blair, who cooperate with him become very, very wealthy men. Nobody knows how widely And and how illegally his tentacles stretch. But it's very far, indeed. And there can be no doubt about the illegality of it.

The gambling, irresponsibility, and extravagant pay -  and criminality - of bankers all over the world is what has caused our world economic crisis. But nobody has been prosecuted for it. Indeed, the people who did it were given bonuses; while the taxpayers were plunged into debt that will never be repaid.

Most of the corporation world has gone in the same direction. While we lock out bus drivers in a quarrel over a tiny percentage of a raise, corporate bosses can expect bonusses in the millions. In fact, they can get that just for being incompetent and getting fired. Imagine what the pay and bonusses are like for the ones who actually know their jobs.

And, increasingly, it's by inheritance. Of course. Those who are born rich and connected have an immeasurable advantage over everyone else.

(Imagine a man who, in his twenties, was a drunk, a druggie, had never had a job, had such low marks on his BA he was not eligible for graduate school, and was dodging the draft. Who could imagine that within a few years he would get his first job - as president of an oil company - which went broke- and then become Governor of Texas and then President of the US. His name was George Bush. And, yes, his daddy was rich.)

And, of course, they become arrogant in their power. (Remember Mr. Irving's announcement of a year and a half ago that He was in coalition with the government, that He had appointed a committee to advise the government on future economic development of the province. And there is now a committee of his boys officially advising the government on how high our taxes whould be - and how low his should be.  We can only hope we stop short of the gold beard and the little boys dressed like fish. As for the waves, though, we won't whip them.  The plan is to poison them.)

Meanwhile, everybody else has been getting poorer. Of course. Greed and arrogance create wealth - for the wealthy. They create deepening poverty for everybody else. You are watching that all around the world right now.

Combine that with the fact that business ability - how can I put this kindly - is not quite the same thing as governing ability or wisdom. Nor is it necessarily genetic. In fact, any system based on heredity is bound to produce more than a few droolers. And when you combine that with power and arrogance, then the wheels pretty quickly fall of your society.

We've been there. Done that. We should have learned by now. Government by an aristocracy does not work.

Capitalism can work. But we don't have capitalism. We just have greedy and irresponsible people with enormous power. That's not capitalism. That's aristocracy.


Saturday, July 7, 2012

July 7: I didn't actually win the $50,000,000, but...

It was last night's lottery. Fifty million plus fifty more of one million each. I had one number right. I took that as a good sign for things to come; so I'll buy another ticket. The world needs people like me to keep the tax rate down.

There's no point in reading most of today's Moncton Times and Transcript unless you have a passion for reading rock concert ads  disguised as news stories and an editorial - or, perhaps. a fascination with reading the names of graduating students at various high schools where you don't know anybody. You might want to read Bill Belliveau's commentary on the edtorial page just for the thrill of figuring out why he wrote it. If you do figure a reason for it, let me know.

Norbert's column is an interesting rant. It's not interesting because of any insight it has into the subject (government waste) but, rather, for insight into how we get brainwashed by editors who are themselves brainwashed.

Norbert says governments are wasteful. So they can be. And he blames it all on bureaucracy. And that's his first mistake.

1. He doesn't know what bureaucracy means. He doesn't know that private corporations have bureaucracies, too. He also doesn't seem to know that most of our wasteful spending decisions are not made by  civil service bureaucrats at all. They are made by our elected leaders like, say, Peter MacKay who has led us into a spending nightmare for our new fighter plane. And like Bev Oda, who just resigned because of her wastefulness. She, like young Peter, was not a civil service bureaucrat. She was an elected representative who not only wasted money scandalously for eight years but is now rewarded for it with a pension bigger than I get from a lifetime as a teacher.

And remember how Stephen Harper went to a hockey game in New York, complete with an  entourage of bodyguards, secretaries, etc. and tried to stick taxpayers with the tab? Harper's not a civil service bureaucrat, either.

2. Norbert appears to be unaware that there are studies of government spending in both Canada and the US for many past decades now. If he would read them, he would learn that the big spenders have been those governments we call Republican or Conservative. The Democrats and Liberals have been more careful. And the lowest spenders in Canada have been NDP governments. Gee! Maybe there's a column there, Norbert. And maybe you'll write that column - when the first Tim Horton's opens on the moon.

3. I have never seen a column by Norbert on wasteful spending by private corporations. Why not? All that money comes from the same place. And we pay for it. We pay for it taxes. Or we pay for it in higher prices. But we pay for it. Where else could the money come from?

4. A politician gets too much in pay and pensions? Get real, Norbert. Senior execs of corporations get salaries and bonuses that are beyond the wildest dreams of pime ministers or presidents in democracies. And if they get fired for doing a lousy job, they get severance packages in the millions. Where do you think those goodies come from, Norbert? Good fairies?

5. Corporations also get huge breaks in income tax payments and gifts from government, benefits that are not given to either politicians or civil servants; and that must be made up for with our taxes.

6. Anyone who has read anything about the scandalous behaviour of banks in the US, most recently in the UK, and in western banking in general has been stunned at the scale of wasteful, fraudulent and criminal behaviour that has characterized that private sector. It dwarfs even the worst excesses of the Bev Odas and Peter MacKays of this world - and leaves the whole civil service way back in the dust. But Norbert has never written a word on all this.

Kiss ass all you like, Norbert. But don't inflict it on us as required viewing.

Why is it worth spending this much time on Norbert?

Newspapers are full of Norberts. They build up a mindset for constant anger at civil servants who don't deserve this abuse. They divert attention from the real pillaging being carried out by some politicians (not all, by any means), and from the almost unimaginable scale of grand theft practiced by large corporations.

They use words inaccurately, and so convert them into swear words whose only meaning is to provoke an emotional reaction. Bureacrat is a good example. Here is a quite respectable word for a job sector that was created because it provided needed skills. But Norbert simply uses it as a swear word. He also completely ignores the existence of bureaucracy in private business. The result is that  bureaucrat becomes simply a swear word; civil service becomes the equivalent of child molester, anti-semite, nazi pig.

Does Norbert believe what he writes? Probably. As I said above, he's been brainwashed by a generation of editors before him. (He also knows damn well just how long he'd have a job if he dared to tell the truth about the corporate world.)

The result is a reading public that is hopelesslly misinformed, that wastes its energy getting angry at the wrong targets, and that continues to accept abuse from the real villains. Columns like this also pour abuse on people who don't deserve it, and who are in no position to defend themselves - not even against retired editors who don't know what words mean.

de Adder's editorial cartoon is a good one. It reflects what, I think, is a political reality. It does it with humour. It's not "picking" unfairly on anybody. This is what an editorial cartoon should be.

The op ed page comment by Gwynne Dyer is a model of solid, informative comment. Ulike the rest of the TandT, this one makes the news understandable. He's bang on about what's really happening with Iran and why. He doesn't give much sense of why this is so very dangerous. He couldn't. That would require a whole, new column. But it is a situation as dangerous as any you are ever likely to see. And, yes, it could be extremely dangerous even for Moncton.

PS - a reader sent me a private note that I should use spellcheck for my blogs. He's right. I am often embarassed to see the spelling errors, even after I have proofread and published. But I don't know how to use spell check with a blog site. Does anybody out here know?