Saturday, March 5, 2011

March 4; Normal idiocy in the Moncton TandT - and a thought for tomorrow.

I iwon't waste much time sicussing today's Montcton Times and Transcript because it's mostly just the usual trivia. One item stood out, though, a commentary from one of their favourite "think-tanks", the Macdonald-Laurier Institute. Amzaing how how many of these simiplisitc pieces of propaganda from that institute and its brethren in public fraud such as The Fraser Institute and AIMS the TandT can always find time and space for.

Big business and its friends in the federal Conservative party are determined to cram as many people into our jails as possible for as long as possible. (That, in a belt-tightening budget time, means that the prison system will be so busy finding places to stuff the overflow it will have even fewer resources than it does now to do any rehabilitation. It will also have to cut back on silly things like schools and hospitals to pay for more jails.) Harper likes the idea because it will attract the votes of his kind of people - ones he has managed to scare into believing we have a crime wave going on.

It also appeals to Harper because it appeals to big business. And it appeals to big business because they see a chance to privatize prisons, and make lots of nice profit. Such prisons have been in use for years now in the US. and have a reputation of hell-holes with lots of violence, poor living conditions - and zero rehabilitation. At least one of them was caught paying off a judge to sentence more juveniles to prison and for longer terms.

So Harper will be running the next election on law and order.  (This is the same Harper who did not lay charges or even complete an investigation into the case of Brian Mulroney, and who is not showing much interest in accusations of illegal election spending by Conservatives.)

Anyway, this "think tank" tries to counter the statistics which show Canada has a declining crime rate - not a rising one.  It does so by saying statistics on crime are never reliable. True enough. Lots of statistics are like that. So the "think tank" produces its statistics to show the crime rate is rising. Get that?

They say statistics in this field can't be trusted. Then they use their own statistics to show the government statistics are wrong.

But Harper says more people in jail for longer stretches will reduce crime. Right. The US has more people per capita in prison than any other country in the world. Yessiree. It must be heaven to live in a country as crime-free as the US.

For tomorrow's blog - a follower of this site  is thinking of moving with her husband and children from a Quebec town to Moncton. She asked me if I thought Moncton was a good place to live - especially for children. So I'll take a try at telling her the good and the bad about Moncton. That will be in tomorrow's blog.

Please jump in, and comment.  Correct me where you think I'm wrong. Add things I have not paid enough attention to. Let's all do a favour for someone who is really interested in coming to live among us.

Thursday, March 3, 2011

March 3: World news flash - Harper may not be able to make royal wedding

In its News Today section, The Moncton Times and Transcript broke the news that Stephen Harper may be unable to go to the royal wedding. Kate is, I should think, in tears, and the Queen in bed with a damp towel on her forehead. The story, which will surely change the lives of all of us, takes up a quarter of the page.

There is a picture of a Canadian warship leaving Halifax to head for the coast of Libya. It is a big picture of a bow of a ship about to pass a lighthouse. The accompanying story is two sentences. Well, lots of food for thought, there.  Is it purely to evacuate Canadians? Or have we been committed to a war? If the latter, under what authority did that happen? If it is a military mission, why were we not consulted first through Parliament? Isn't that what we say every November 11 that our servicemen died for? Wasn't that the point of delaying our declaration of war for a week in 1939 was all about? Now all we get is a picture of part of a ship and a lighthouse.

Then there's a non-story about the federal budget. (It won't be public for almost three weeks. So what's to say?)

Then there's a story about a Halifax murder, and the usual rumours about the civil war in Libya. It was a whole page of either trivia or speculation. So much for Canada the rest of the world as seen from the hub of something or other.

There was, for example, no mention of the mass protests in Wisconsin against a state govenment that intends to break unions. Not only have the protests been huge; but the police have joined the protestors.  Think there might be a story in there of some importance?

Nor has The Moncton Times mentioned the story that the US and Canada have been negotiating a deal to send Canadian troops to the US (or American ones to Canada) in case of  "civil unrest". Obviously, somebody up there thinks that serious turmoil is just as possible here as it is in Libya. But it's obviously less imporant than Harper's social plans.

Nor did they carry the story of Hilary Clinton, just a couple of days ago, blasting the western news media as incompetent, shallow, sloppy - and just about every other fault one could think of. She made a point of stressing that she was referring to the privately owned media in radio, TV, and print.  She praised Al Jazeera as one of the best news services in the world, (and so it is.) She might have added to the good ones El-Haaretz (Israel), The Manchester Guardian and The Independent (Britain).  She also suprised me when she said that Russia and China have far surpassed the US in the quality of their English-language news services.

Ms. Clinton's aim, I gathered, was to demand a higher quality of propaganda. Well, I suppose it would be better to have high class junk than low class junk. But she's certainly right in her evaluations. The reality is there is not a single newspaper of world-class quality in Canada or the US. That includes even The New York Times and The Globe and Mail. American news commentary is so silly that  I once thought I was watching some satirical comedy show. (It was the first time I had Fox News on TV.)   Private radio and TV are of abysmally low news quality.

Even with such feeble competition, the Maritimes comes out low on the scale. For trivia, misleading reports, ignorant editorials, lack of insight and lack of jounalistic integrity, you would have to go to the US to find worse news media. (Or, perhaps, those parts of Russian and Chinese news that are designed for the locals, and not for the English language services.)

The Moncton Times and Tribune is not as bad as most other papers. It's commentaries, though of mixed quality, are often excellent. But it is terribly weak because of its bias, the often dreadful quality of its editorials, the trivia of its news, the weakness in providing any context to help readers understand the news, the neglect of major developments, and its lack of integrity and of ethics.

Perhaps The Moncton Times and Tribune could start a campaign to ease the humiliation that the Royal couple must be feeling. It could start a campaign to collect a wedding gift from the people of Moncton, something that would indicate a sacrifice on our part to help make life more meaningful for Kate and what's-his-name. It would be a wonderful bringing together of Monctonians of all social levels as they took their offerings to local collection  sites all over the city, sites that would soon be mountains of paper coffee cups with the rims not yet rolled up.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

march 1: March came in like a lion - accompanied by two jackasses

The lead editorial was an excellent warning that Moncton's streets are poorly plowed. Thought the clearing of roads is quite good,  the clearing of sidewalks is far below acceptable. Indeed, its often non-existent. The removal of snowbanks is appallingly bad, and very dangerous. This is an important editorial, and well-written. That's the lion.

Jackass no. 1 - This one is really two people writing for the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, another of those propaganda "think tanks" which appears to be aimed at supporting the Harpers, Bushes, and corporate leaders of this world. This report is on Canada's northland security. At least, that is what the title says. Unfortunately, it was written by two professors - almost a guarantee that it will be badly-written gobbledy-gook. (I attended universities for ten years as a student, and taught in them for over 35 years. I came to know a great many incomprehensible lecturers and writers).

It is bad enough that The Moncton Times&Transcript routinely features this sort of propaganda. But a half-awake editor should realize that this, besides being propaganda, was written by people so incapable of communication that is it higly unlikely any reader will understand it.

It's full of buzzwords that are never defined. For example, it focusses on "Canada's traditional views of foreign policy", especially in terms of the Arctic. Anybody care to tell me what that means? I taught Canadian History, and was a close friend of a noted historian of Canada's North  And I have no idea what these writers mean.

Then it babbles about modern globalization trends after the Cold War which has led to more attention paid to  humanitarian crises, and the reinvention of intenational organizaions. I presume this means that the traditional views centred on military force to protect soverignty - and it is these traditional views that we should return to.)  If this is what these esteemed scholars are saying, they're full of it. Canada has never had anything close to a force capable of exercising sovereignty in the Arctic, and we have even less these days.

We pay more attention to humanitarian crises? Like hell we do. Aid has, if anything, gone down since the end of the Cold War, Nor am I aware of anything like a reorganization of international organizations. The UN, for example, and international law have both been victims of deliberate de-organization.

Then there is high praise for Stephen Harper and his vigorous stance on the military defence of the Canadian Arctic. What stance? Our capacity to defend  our Arctic is probably lower than it has ever been in our history. Nor can it recover. Harper has committed out defence budget for years to come on Canadian armed forces designed to help out in American wars.

Oh, and just guess which neighbouring country has been prominent in refusing to recognize Canadian sovereignty in the Arctic, is the biggest threat to it, and has many times violated it. So far,Mr.Harper hasn't made even a peep about that.

This column is pure gibberish and buzz words written by people who do not know how to communicate - and who have nothing to communicate.

2. The second jackass is the person who wrote the second editorial, "Jumping the gun".  This is a rant designed to build distrust of the public schools, including teachers and administrators, so we the public can be manipulated into letting AIMS and corporate leaders  interfere with them for private profit.. AIMS and other "think tanks" as well as The Moncton Times routinely use school closings due to weather as a means of fomenting that public distrust.

We know now that the day the schools were closed wasn't really bad. We didn't know that when the decision had to be made. . Even in these days of forecasting, only editors can see around corners to know what is going to happen. Mere mortals have to make guesses. This is a win-win situation for think tanks and ethiically defective editorial writers.If the school is closed, and the weather is not what was feared, then the administrators are incompetent. If the school doesn't close, and the weather causes death or injury, then the administrators are incompetent.

In ending, the editorial writer says the schools could have been open for at least three quarters of the day. Well, yes. That would be a very sound decision for someone who could see into the future. But as a piece of advice for how a school system should react to storm warnings, it's as useful as telling it to buy a deck of tarot cards.

And anyone who thinks that three quarters of a day is so crucial to a child's education obviously has no experience of teaching and no knowledge of education. 

But this is worse than ignorance. This is The Moncton Times doing what it so often does - pimping for corporations who want to make money out of our children. And that is really contemptible.

Monday, February 28, 2011

Feb. 27: "We Say.." oh, get stuffed.

Todays' editorial, "Let free market decide for itself", sets a new level of ignorance of history, economics and reality.

It began,  sensibly, with approval of the government for refusing help to an uncompetitive poultry farm. Then it drifts into a rant about how the free market is a sort of magic wands that solves all problems. And that any government "interference" is harmful.

1. For the wealthy, there is no such thing as free market. A chicken farm has to go  on the "free" market. Large banks and automobile companies get saved with "government interference" in the form of loans and grants.

2. Large corporations are often formed in the first place with government loans, grants and subsidies.
When the CPR was built, it was largely financed at the risk of Canadian taxpayers who guaranteed the interest on its bonds, who gave it direct loans and cash grants,who gave it the land the build on (and far more  land that contained vaulable resources.). It also protected Canada Packers,and Bell, Massey, the CPR, all sorts of corporations with high tafiffs to cut out foreign competition. It also imported labour from China and Italy and Europe to build them at dirt cheap labour rates. When workers asked for high wages, Canadian government sent out the militia to shut them up. All at taxpayer expense.

Does the editorial writer know nothing of Canadian history? New Brunswick, like Canada as a whole, was largely built at the expense of most Canadians - with the the profit for it going to the "free market". Just look around you right here in New Brunswick. How did so much of our forests end up in the hands of one corporation? How come some corporations get cheaper electricity rates?  How come the only place to get print news about NB is from a news corporation owned by one family?

3. How come so many large corporations get government contracts without having to worry about competitive bidding?  How come a hockey business can get a rink built for it at taxpayer expense? Some free market!

4. As for government regulations, Canada has a reasonably healthy economy because of regulations that were in place (long before Harper). Without those, we now be in the economic toilet with the US. In fact, if the editorial writer knew anything about economics and history, he would know most most of the world learned in World War I of the necessity for regulations. Without them, some corporations will act foolishly and greedily, causing enormous damage.

Business in Canada and the US never liked regulations - for much the same reason bank-robbers drug dealers don't approve of laws. That's why they pay off governments to look the other way, or to ease regulations as St. Ronald Reagan did, leading the US into its current mess.

Corporations spend big money to convince us all to be suckers, and make them even richer. That's why they pay the bills for political parties that are their puppets, run bogus think tanks like AIMS, and use their control of most of the news meda that write the sort of ignorant and predatory drivel that appears in the editorials of The Moncton Times and Transcript.

Big corporations did not build Canada or the US. Canadians and Americans did it by protecting them from competition, giving them money and lands and resources - and covering the costs with low salaries while they're social betters sneered at them for not belonging to their parasitic class.

Business us just hampered by regulations? Well, it wasn't regulations that made the current recession. It was governments that lacked regulations or, in many cases, ignored them. It wasn't government regulations that poisoned the Gulf of Mexico; and it isn't government regulations that are now poisoning Alberta.

History has proven we need some government regulations on business. History has proven that if we do not have controls, we cannot expect big business to act responsibly.

And the very idea that political parties, most of which get their money from large corportions, are forcing regulations on their paymasters is infantile.

I wonder if this is the same editorial writer who said children must listen to O Canada every day to become patriotic. But, oh, even with O Canada blasting at top levels, it's hard to be proud of a country that is home to The Moncton Times and Transcript.

Saturday, February 26, 2011

Feb. 26: Sometimes, it's not their fault

Today's headline: Another storm hits NB.

I read the headline, and a light flashed in my mind. Of course. I had wondered what made it so hard to see out the car windshield last night. And I wondered what all that white stuff was that I had to wade through to get my paper this morning. (Congratulations to the T&T deliverer who had gone through a foot and more of snow at every house to get the paper as close as possible.) My quick mind put two and two together. It must have been  - a snow storm.

Yes, "Another story hits NB is a pretty ridiculous headline.  But that's not the fault of the editors.

The nature of any newspaper is that any news in it is at least a day old. Of course, we already knew that a snowstorm had hit. But how could it be left off the front page without some readers complaining that such a storm should have been covered? You're damned if you do and damned if you don't.

Until almost a century ago, a newspaper was the only source of news. When they relied on sailing ships for information, it was commonly weeks late in reporting events. Even to the early 1900s, newspaper news could be days old, even older. There was no source of instant news. Then came radio, TV, and the web.

The T&T can be criticized for being trivial, misleading,biased, and even loutish. But an even deeper problem, which it shares with most newspapers, is it's news is out of date even as it is being printed.

What we need is not headline news so much as context for the headline news. There's a civil war in Libya? What do we need to know to understand that?  Our public schools rank lower than Manitoba's? Interesting. But we need to know a good deal about what that means. Education isn't a horse race in which the winner by a fraction of a second is good, and all the rest are dog food. Is Manitoba way ahead? Or is it a difference of two percent - in which case it's no signicant difference at all. Nor does it prove there's anything wrong with the system. In fact, parents and economic and social environment are far more important factors.

We need context. We need to understand the big picture. We know Haiti is poor. We don't know how it happened - so we really don't understand anything about it. (After all, Haiti produces big profits for exotric fruit plantations and for clothing factories. Why not for the Haitians?)

We know there's a good deal of anti-Americanism in Egypt. Is there any reason for it? Or is it just that them there ay-rabs is all fanatical terrorists? Without context, the headlines and news reports are largely a waste of time.

Radio, especically private radio, and TV, especially private TV, are poor at providing context. Radio relies heavily on "pesonalities" who attract listeners, but who rarely know anythng about the context at all. TV relies on show biz fast pacing, quick bits and on to the next story.  The web can be good - but there are also lots of crackpot and propaganda sites out there; and it takes a bit of experience to sort them out.

We have never in history had such an abundance of information. We know we're at war in Afghanistan. But without context, we don'tt know why we're there. (No. It's not to protect the womenfolk; and it's not because Saudis crashed planes into the Trade Center.)  We know we had a snowstorm. But, without context, all that we know is that we had a snowstorm. What does it mean?

Newspapers have known for years that they have to develop a new approach to covering news in a world that has so much more news so quickly available. They haven't found that new approach; and there's no doubt it's going to be a difficult problem. But we have to move on it quickly because the damage to rhe reader is already pretty serious..

All over the western world, at least,, the control of print news has fallen into the hands of local and regional monopolists - usually monopolists with an axe to grind. The result is that we have a population that knows more but understands less than any society in history. And the newspaper has become simply a device to keep people abosrbed in trivia and propaganda.

People need to understand. They need context. If we go on using the news just to keep people ignorant of what is happening, to manipulate people by encouraging fear, hatred and prejudice, we shall pay a heavy price. And very soon.

Friday, February 25, 2011

Feb. 25: Wow! Superb editorial and op ed pages in the Moncton T&T

Credit where credit is due. And more than due. Today's editorial and op ed  pages are not only the best I have ever seen in The Moncton Times and Tribune; they would do well in any comparison with some pretty fine newspapers. Everything on those two pages is first rate - the editorials, Alec Bruce, Norbert Cunningham, Janet Keeping of the Sheldon Chumir Foundation For Leadership Ethics (though her commentary would have been better without an anti-Moslem slur), and Lynda Gibbon. All are well worth a read; but I'll concentrate on Norbert Cunningham partly because it shows what he can do when he really clicks on the afterburners; and because  every New Brunswicker should read what he has to say.

Using several reputable sources, Mr. Cunningham makes several points that we need to understand. He does it by squarely attacking myths, and facing realities that don't often get faced. He begins by citing a New York Times statement that the American empire is in decline. Most North Americans don't even realize there is an American empire. But there is. It is the successor of a long line of western empires (Portugal, Spain, Italy, France, Belgium, Germany, The Netherlands and Britain.) The only modification I would make to the statement that the American Empire is declining would be to scratch declining, and replace it with collapsing.

Among 33 advanced economies, Canada comes out as among the best in five of nine categories, and is never among the worst.  The US has three worst of the worst, a simple worst, and some middlings.

Canada is among the best countries in democracy. The US is middling; (and that is kind.) In poverty, Canada is middling. The US is worst of the worst.

Then - the lines I never expected to see in The Times and Tribune. In public education, Canada ranks among the best in the world. The US ranks among the worst of the worst. That's important because the US system with its school rankings and standardized testing is the one AIMS has been urging us to adopt - with full support from the Moncton Times and Tribune editorial writers.

Everything on those two pages was solid commentary and first-rate writing. For the first time, I'm not sorry I have a subscription. I happily applaud five people who did a great job.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

Feb. 24: an addendum

On Thursday, March 3, I shall meet as I always do the first Thursday of every month with a current events group at the Moncton Library from 2pm to 3 pm.

The library sends a notice to The Moncton Times and Transcript as a part of its announcement of programmes to be listed in the "Monctono This Week" section.  The Moncton T&t, bush league as always, publishes the list. But it usually deletes my group and my name. It has done so again this time.

We open with a topic for ten minutes or so. Then it's open to whatever people wish to discuss. If you're in the Moncton area, please drop by.