Friday, September 18, 2015

Sept. 18: Let's start with China...

...because there isn't a whole lot to talk about in the Irving press.

China is the biggest country in the world, and it's (maybe) on track to have the most economic power and, with that, the most political and military power in the world within decades. That being so, it's odd to see it so rarely even mentioned in the Irving press. We've had far more news of a new hockey rink than on something that could shake our earth to its foundations. So, where to start?

Let's start with the word communism. Discussion of communism in China goes back well over a century. But it wasn't until the rise of Mao-Zedong to power after world war two that China had a government that called itself communist. - the CCP, Chinese Communist Party.

The jounalists around the world were upset about that because they understood that communism was evil. You know, like spitting on the sidewalk or enacting medicare.

In fact, communism is heavily based on Christian principles – like love thy neighbour, help the suffering – evil stuff like that. And that shouldn't be surprising because Karl Marx was a convert to Christianity. It's because it's so heavily based on Christian principles that I don't see it as being practical anywhere in the foreseeable future. There is no nation on earth I have ever heard of that is based on Christian principles.  Certainly, the western world has never been noted for its Christian behaviour.

And Chairman Mao had no religious principles of any sort. He called his party the Communist Party. But there was nothing communist about it. Mao was simply a dictator whose main contribution was to destroy all elements of the old, Chinese society, including Confucianism, That was essential because the old China had been too loosely organized and, despite its size, had, for over a century, routinely been beaten with ease by countries far, far smaller, and had been forced to open up its market to a series of murderous, greedy, and capitalist countries. It had been forced to accept the curse of opium. And forced to pay large sums if its sales were not up to the very high demands of the European conquerors.

Mao may be credited with laying the foundation of modern China. He made it a military power able to defend itself against all those nations – including Britain, Germany, the U.S. - who had exploited it through a century of what the Chinese still call “the great humiliation”.

His economic measures (which were neither capitalist nor communist) were a disaster, particularly in agriculture as some 30,000,000 people died of starvation. (But don't get smug about that. In proportion to the number of people available to die, we're way ahead of him, especially in the Middle East.)

His last years were largely wasted on showy but useless excitements like the cultural revolution. I remember older Chinese speaking to me of those years as a time they lived in fear of mobs, dictatorship, and survived on a diet of cabbage. In Guangchou, they took me to the river where, every day, they had watched the bodies floating downstream.

It wasn't until the late 1990s that China decided to copy the methods of western capitalism. It worked well, at first, with the greatest advancement of economic development ever seen. - but

-that was with a capitalism kept under control by a government that was still a 'communist' dictatorship (though the dictators referred to it as a socialist democracy. It was neither socialist nor democratic; but, economically the improvement for China was immense.)

Actually, it wasn't really capitalist, either. That short period of rapid growth was the result of a bureaucracy that kept a tight grip on the capitalists.  (Note that Norbert. The economic growth was created by very able bureaucrats.)

Then the disease of capitalism showed itself. Those who made money used it to corrupt and buy control of government leaders at all levels. Corruption became epidemic. And, as happens with capitalism, the emphasis shifted from the needs of the people to a single-minded desire for more wealth and power for the rich. The millions who had not profited from the brief economic boom were now left in permanent poverty. The wage gap, as happens in capitalism, grew to rival and even surpass that of the west. And now, it has the capitalist illness of a recession.

I have no idea where this will take us – or China. The country could break up – as it was doing a century ago. It could move into one of the most brutal civil wars this world has ever seen. Or it might go back to Mao's China with a government that stirs constant distractions and hysterias like 'the great leap forward' or the 'cultural revolution'.

Nor can we even guess what effect this will have on us – though, in this small world, it certainly will have an effect on us. We may be watching another step in the decline of the very idea of a nation. Already, the existence of nation states is becoming less useful in the eyes of the great corporations and the very rich. It's major purpose now is to provide them with military power whose use makes the rich richer, and using the news media to convince people this is patriotism. But, as the U.S. has shown in Syria, mercenaries can do this – and do it more cheaply.


China should be prominent in our news. But it rarely is.
____________________________________________________________________________
There's really not a whole lot to say about the Irving press. Section A has a big gob of sensationalism about the Oland trial. But little else. A story on B5 is intriguing, though. “New Brunswick sees New England's clean energy needs as an opportunity. That's nice. Clean energy is good. But linked to it is a deal to help New England set up pipelines for a mutlibillion dollar gas terminal to export gas from New England….
….but if you set up such a terminal, then surely the point of it is to burn more fossil fuel somewhere else. Forgive me if I don't see the point of using clean energy to help the world to use more dirty energy.

Justin Ray has a superb column on how we can help refugees. If Ray doesn't convince you, you might like a letter to the editor “NDP leader indulging in pointless opportunism.” The letter makes two, stunning points.
1. we did not create this refugee crisis.
2.Anyway, we are heavily invested in regaining the homelands of these refugees, so other countries should be the ones to help them.
I politely disagree. No, I'm damned if I'll be polite. This is a self-serving letter, and it shows no understanding whatever of what is happening.

1. We did create this crisis. Canada has gone every step of the way in following the U.S. and Britain into creating the chaos of the Middle East. We helped to create ISIS. The U.S. financed and equipped a phony rebellion against Syria long before there was an ISIS. It also created the 'terrorists' al Quaeda. That goes way back to before there was any problem in the region. We have supported the policies that have killed uncounted numbers in that region. We now support the mass murder going on in Yemen. And the US drone bombers have been murdering people there for over 20 years. We're in this up to our necks. We have created those refugees. We are responsible for the drowning of a young boy – and thousands of others. And we've done it all for oil billionaires.

2, We are heavily invested in regaining homelands? You count sending a handful of aircraft to machine gun and bomb helpless people in Libya as a heavy investment? You call sending six fighter-bombers to Iran a heavy investment? Macdonald's spends more than that every day to sell hambugers.

The U.S. with British help and some Canadian help are not fighting to save refugees. We're fighting to create refugees.

Now, go back and read Justin Ryan's column.

Alec Bruce is in top form with a column on the dark side of Harper's budget surplus. Well said.

But that's it for section A.

The only story in B section is on B5 “Ministers want universities to stop paying ex-presidents”. This is a very serious problem. University boards of governors are dominated by people with money. The only thing they know how to run is a business – and so they assume that everything is a business. But everything isn't a business. And universities are not a business.

About 20 years ago, I was surprised to be offered the presidency of my university by the chairman of the board. I didn't want to be an administrator of any sort. I was a teacher. That's when the chairman put his lawyers on me. They talked to me about the benefits of the job, and made me read a book on the application of business practices in universities.

I was stunned. My salary would be tripled – at least. With handsome increases every year. And, no matter what kind of a disaster I might prove to be, I would get that for the rest of my life – even if they fired me. (In fact, the president at the time was being fired for some irregular practices. And I expect he did keep his salary for life.)

I refused though, admittedly, at the same time kicking myself.


And that's only a small taste of the damage that is being done by university boards of governors that are way too deep in business methods (abuses), and quite ignorant of education.
_________________________________________________________________________________

Now, wash that Irving press taste out of your mounts, and read these sites.

The U.S., which just want to help people, has spent $500,000,000 dollars to recruit and train Syrian rebels. So, check this from the New York Times.

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/17/world/middleeast/isis-isil-syrians-senate-armed-services-committee.html?_r=1

Karl Nerenberg, now retired, is still one of the best political commenators in Canada. Here is his take on the leaders' debate.

http://rabble.ca/blogs/bloggers/karl-nerenberg/2015/09/mulcair-was-only-leader-to-speak-seriously-about-environment#.VfwlvGTtKAE.gmail

Despite the dodgy title of this next source, I've generally found it to be intelligent and truthful.

http://russia-insider.com/en/politics/stephen-cohen-ukraine-situation-more-dangerous-middle-east-video/ri9709

There's another report on the world getting warmer. But I scarcely need to tell that to anyone in Moncton You think you're seeing refugees now? Wait  (probably not long) until you see farmland turning to desert, sea life disappearing due to toxic waste and warming water. But don't worry. The New Brunswick government is looking out for you. It's selling renewable energy to New England so it can sell more fossil fuel to Europe.

Thursday, September 17, 2015

Sept. 17: Another trivia day in the Irving press....

We'll go quickly through the Irving “news” of the day.

The lead story on P.1 is a real, lead story. It's about a daycare which was closed abruptly, and done in such a secretive fashion by the government that we are left wondering what this is all about. Employees were fired; parents were in a quandary – and nobody seems to know what it's all about. Underlying it all is a hint that the provincial government was very slack, indeed, in dealing with the situation – whatever it is. We should be demanding a full explanation – and soon.

Below it is another black eye for the provincial government as two schools in the Moncton area that were undergoing renovations were not ready for the new, school year. That suggests either poor planning or not giving much of a damn.

But those two stories are pretty much it for all of section A news.

The Oland trial is on p. 1, and I can see we will be getting day by day front page coverage of this. And that is just sensationalism. More to the point would be a story on why JDIrving Ltd. paid a large settlement for the Lac Megantic disaster. As a rule, innocent billionaires don't pay large settlements.

In other fast-breaking news, a local village misses its grocery store which closed. Volunteers are helping to lay fresh sod in a local park. And there are two photos to show us what volunteers laying sod look like.

The editorial shows its usual courage in tackling a subject of great importance and controversy – the restoration of the former Moncton High school building. The is crucial, says the editorial because---because –- well –-it's old. And maybe we can do things with it like---well--you know….

Norber writes a column about how unpopular the provincial government is because it has not solved our economic problems. In the same column, it's obvious that Norbert doesn't have any solution, either. And both he and the government suffer from the same problem. In the minds of both, there is no room for looking at the role of the very rich in creating our economic problems.

Rod Allen writes about the local wine industry but, alas, has nothing to say. Surprisingly, even Alec Bruce has nothing to say.

The only commentary worth reading is the guest commentary about what the John Howard Society is doing to provide homes for the homeless and the disadvantaged. This is a commentary both interesting an encouraging. And it's not a coincidence that it is the only one whose focus is on people.
Section B is worse.

The banner headline for Canada&World news is that the province of New Brunswick is hiring a physician recruitment co-ordinator. Now, I yield to none in my admiration for governments that hire physician recruitment co-ordinators. But I would humbly suggest this is not a major item of Canada or world news.

Most of the front page is covered with photos and a story about the murder of a father and his two-year old daughter in Alberta. This was also front page of this section yesterday. They're milking this story – and that's sensationalism

On B2, the big flash is that some streets and houses in Havana are being cleaned up in preparation for a Papal visit. This, its seems, is the most important news coming out of Cuba. It's worded to give the impression that this is all part of a typical and evil communist plot. ( Lord, I wish these journalists would learn what 'communist' means.)

In fact, it's not unusual for host countries to do this sort of thing. And it's surely not the most important thing to know about the Papal visit. And, if they have space to run this nothing story in the paper, how come they can't find any space for stories about the poverty and brutality – and murder – imposed on much of South America by Canadian and American capitalists. (Of course, they'd first have to look up the meaning of capitalist.)

Funny – there are almost never any stories about South America or the Caribbean states, though all of them are blessed with North American capitalism.

Then, on B6, of 'Canada&World” news, there's “Air Canada pilot diverts flight to ensure dog's safety” Ah-h-h.

Oh, and there's also a big story that Harper may go to the Supreme Court to ensure that devout Muslim women remove the Nigab that covers their faces. He says we have to see their faces to be sure of their identity. Damn right. They could really all be terrorists. (Uh – what do terrorist faces look like. And, anyway, how would removing the nigab improve the judge's knowledge of who they are? After all the citizenship judge who hears the oath has usually never seen the person before.)

No. I think Harper has the right idea; but it needs development – something like...all people taking the oath of citizenship should have to take it while naked. (And we could charge admission for spectators.)


Almost all in this paper is trivial. There can be no doubt that editors for the Irving papers deliberately ignore major news, and search for the trivial and the sensational. This is gutter journalism.
____________________________________________________________________________
Recently, I was watching a TV debate among U.S. Republicans running for the leadership. The main debating point? It was the threat of raping Mexicans crossing the border to take jobs from Americans. As it happens I have a relative who lives in a region with a great many of those Mexican immigrants. He tells me they get only the most menial jobs that Americans don't want. And they get even those jobs because employers know they can get away with paying them next to nothing. If there are villains here, surely they are those American employers.

Up here, the latest election issue is Muslim women wearing the higab as they take the citizenship oath.

These are issues that play on racism and fear and hatred. And it is these issues that a great many Canadians and Americans will base their votes on. And these are issues that have nothing to do with the problems we face.

Biased and ignorant and trivial news media have a lot of responsibility for that. The Irving press is one of the worst – perhaps even the worst. But bias, ignorance and triviality are staples of North American news consumption.

Here, in New Brunswick, we badly need to know how much (or how little) our wealthy actually pay in taxes to the province. We have to know why the wage gap is out of control. We have to know how much our government gives away to corporations in loans, grants, cheap prices, and boondoggles like Private/Public partnerships. We have to know how much of their profit is hidden.

But we don't. And the Irving press never mentions the issue – just as it rarely mentions any issue of importance.

In a way – and let's be frank – this sort of thing is built into the New Brunswick mentality. Originally, the powerful and wealthy of New Brunswick were those who had the timber contracts. The election candidates were usually them or their puppets. On election day, the voter had to step up to the voting station, and say in a loud, clear voice who he was voting for. Everybody knew who everybody else voted for. And the timber bosses knew. And anyone who voted for the wrong candidate knew he could never find a job here again.

As a result, non-thinking became a provincial characteristic, reinforced by village life in which having any opinion about anything could create enemies among one's neighbours.

The role of the Irving press is to preserve this. And that, at least, it does well.

We need to know where political parties get their money from. I don't suggest here that all or even most politicians are corrupt. (Some are, of course, and leave politics a lot richer than they were before.) Some are honest. Some are in politics simply to tickle their own egos. And many accept a sort of honest corruption. They seek large donations from the rich, knowing that these donations are intended to buy them. They justify it to themselves as something our form of democracy makes necessary if you want to win – and that, at least, is quite true. Spending on elections is out of control – with two results.

Parties that are based on principles have a hard time trying to win. Parties with no principles routinely do well. And that means that parties with principles often have to soft pedal those principles if they want to win.

That's why, in the U.S., democracy ceased to exist a long time ago. And it's in serious trouble in Canada.

We, in Canada, particularly have to know how American policies affect us and our place in the world. Small in population, we now depend on the U.S. for protection. But there's a problem in that. The U.S. has no interest in protecting anybody. Dominated as it by corporations, it exists to conquer and exploit ( including us – just as it exploits its own people.)

As a very junior partner, we are invited to join the U.S. in conquest and exploitation. Our corporations support that because it ensures they get a place at the trough. But we don't get much news on that. We don't get news on why it was necessary for us – or anybody – to bomb Libya. ( Oh, I know, I know. Ghadaffi was a bad man. So was Bush. So is Obama. So is the king of Saudi Arabia. But we don't bomb them.)

We get no news of what Ukraine is really all about. Or Syria. Or Yemen. We still don't know why Bush and Blair lied in order to invade Iraq.

Ukraine, like Greece, has been bled dry by international bankers. The people of those countries no longer have any control over their own affairs. And it is very likely the greatest threat to the Kyev government is not Russia. It is that country's strong, neo-Nazi movement. As well the latest free trade deals – and some of the old ones – effectively deprive nations of the right to control their own environment and their own economies.

Western Europe, the home of collapsed empires, has many countries in economic trouble – and some, like Spain, in danger of breaking up. The British Labour Party has just chosen a very radical leader – in response to a wealthy class which has privatized many public services like police and schools, and has allowed large numbers of British to get poor so the rich can get even richer.

U.S. corporations have made the Caribbean, Central America, and much of South America into places where people live in poverty and ignorance, and die young. Some countries are polluted beyond repair in anybody's lifetime. U.S. killer squads are active in any country which objects. And Canadians are partners in all this.

The U.S. has made it clear it wants war with Russia. But it almost certainly cannot beat Russia in a conventional war. Luckily for all human life, the U.S. is now tied up in fighting ISIS which, I suspect, it also cannot beat – partly because the American people, though some love talking about war, have not been crazy about supporting war since Vietnam. Even hero George Bush Jr. who just loves to swagger in his bomber jacket was a draft dodger. Anyway, that may not matter since the U.S. also seems to be helping ISIS to destroy Syria – which is what this fighting was all about from the start.

Now we are asked to be indignant that China is claiming some islands off its coast. In fact this is the way the U.S. got Hawaii – which is a lot more than just off the coast.

It's quite obvious that the U.S. is training its army and its police in case they have to fight a war against the American people.

The U.S., which decreed, after World War Two, that Japan would never be allowed to have anything but a home defence force, has recently ordered Japan to boost ifs forces to invasion status. The Japanese people don't want to. But the U.S. gives them no choice. And there are only two, possible targets for such an invasion – China and Russia.

All this is just a very small part of what is going on in the world. And the rest of the world is no longer far away from us. This is no longer the world of 1800 – or even 2000. But scarcely a word about any of this has ever appeared in the Irving press. Of course not; its purpose is to keep us unthinking and meekly obedient – just as in the old days when the timber bosses told us who to vote for.


For the sake of their children and for their own sakes, New Brunswickers have to demand the right to more information, and they have to develop that fundamental courage – the courage to say what they think.
_________________________________________________________________________________

Wednesday, September 16, 2015

A really bad day, even by the standards of the irving press.

(I  have had unspeakable grief with this column - with parts disappearing, other parts  duplicating themselves. I've tried to correct it all, but there may well still be mistakes.)


The issue reported below wil seem unclear to those who haven't worked in a university. So, in clearer terms, a professor whose salary was paid by a donation from a wealthy person (a senior executive of Royal Bank of Canada) was threatened with loss of her income when she wrote a blog that he didn't like. It is quite common for people who have money and influence to buy professors with fancy titles and super pay. But they often insist the professors should stay bought.

I was approached early in my career to pimp for the oil industry. Perhaps to write a gushing history of what great guys its executives are.

It happens. Always be careful which professors you trust, no matter how eminent they may be.








September 2015



UBC launches academic freedom investigation

An internal investigation is looking into allegations that UBC professor Jennifer Berdhal’s academic freedom was violated after she posted a blog entry about the University President’s sudden departure.

Prof. Berdahl says UBC Board Chair John Montalbano contacted her and suggested that the article harmed the reputation of the Board, raised questions about her academic credibility, and jeopardized her funding from the Royal Bank of Canada. Montalbano is vice-chairman of RBC Wealth Management, and in 2014 he and his wife established the Montalbano Professor of Leadership Studies: Gender and Diversity position held by Berdahl.








The storbelow come from a site that is commonly regarded as suspect, though my experience is that it has often proven more truthful than our private news media. And, you know, it's tough to find stories about Syria told from a Syrian point of view.



https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GrEPadG0pQk

https://www.youtube.com/user/SyrianGirlpartisan


In all of this turmoil, Canada sits in a dangerous position. We cannot possibly defend ourselves against an American attack. And, yes, Virginia, such an attack is possible. 1812 did not change American attitudes. The RCMP was created largely because Canada wanted a military presence on the prairies. But that would have displeased the U.S. which had not given up its hope of annexing our west. That's why we sent an army there – but called them police.


There was another threat to attack Canada shortly before World War One. It didn't happen – but only because Britain gave away some disputed territory so the U.S. wouldn't invade. Now, the U.S. wants Canada to help fight its wars which benefit only big business, and U.S. oil is already moving into our north – which the U.S. doesn't recognize as ours.


Harper's policy has been to act as a colony of the U.S. while, at the same time, avoiding the price of cooperation as much as possible. That's why he accepted sending our army to Afghanistan – but pulled it out early. That's why he sent fighter bombers to Libya and then Iraq – but sending as few as he could get away with. That's why we've had ships and soldiers in the Ukraine region.


The trouble with Harper's game is there comes a time when you get a toe in – but then can't ever get out again.


I've spent a lot of time on general commentary because there's to little in the Irving press to talk about.


The lead story in Canada&World is about how police have found the body of a very young girl in Alberta who was kidnapped and murdered. We certainly should expect to be informed about it. But in a world of 100,000,000 refugees, one with thousands of very young children being murdered by bombs, by drowning, by exposure, by starvation, by lack of medical help every day, and with, probably even more becoming orphans in a world at war, the story of one girl in Alberta, though certainly as important as it is sad, is not the lead for a section of world news.


This is a story that is featured for the same reason that some people get all excited to read the latest scoop on who killed Natalie Wood, or why Harry left Jane. This is what is called sensationalism. It's a means of selling papers to people who love to be shocked. It's bad journalism. And it's distasteful.


And there's really nothing else in the section worth reading.

The first page of section A is passable. But that's it for news.


The editorial is passable in attacking the government for its dangerous neglect of daycare centres.

Norbert's column advocates keeping Syrian refugees out of New Brunswick. He also should do a bit of reading about Syria before passing on his ignorance to readers. 1. Syria is NOT a strict Muslim country. That's why ISIS, which is strict Muslim, is attacking it. In fact, Syria has, for a thousand years and more, had a sizable Christian population.  2.Syria is not and has not been fighting a civil war. That's a myth spread by papers like the Irving press. The so-called rebels have, in fact, been mercenaries hired and armed by the U.S., Saudi, and other friends.
So, okay, all you refugees. Go die somewhere else.

Brian Cormer's column is NOT a commentary. It's a story told over a beer, and there is no good reason to read it. Alec Bruce, for reasons not explained, tell us how he hurt his toe. The guest commentary is a reasonable one by a retired professor of medicine. But he's writing it as project for Atlantic Institute of Market Studies – a propaganda house for big business. Somebody should have a little talk with him.

Tuesday, September 15, 2015

Sept. 15: Good Christian men rejoice!



Still got your Charlie Hebdo T shirt? You remember, Charlie Hebdo was that freedom loving cartoon paper in France that we all cheered for when it was attacked and some of its staff killed for its almost obscene cartoons making fun of Muslims, especially Muhammed.

Christians all over the world cheered, and bought T shirts that screamed their support for Charlie Hebdo.

Well, get your T shirt out again, and be ready to cheer once more for free speech and Christian morality. They've just put out a new cartoon issue. The Irving press didn't carry it though they, as I recall, cheered as lustily as all right-thinking people did when Charlie Hebdo first came to world attention.

This time, the issue features Muslim child refugees. You'll laugh till you cry. One of the cartoons is of a giant Christian standing on the water. Beside him are the legs of a Muslim child sticking above the water.
The caption is “Christians walk on water. Muslims sink.”

Ho-Ho-Ho.

And there are lots of others that are just as good. Here's the story.


Hitler would have admired this. So will lots of western Christians. And some papers just won't bother reporting it.
Also missing from Irving news is the development of a Christian assault rifle in the U.S. It comes complete with a crusader shield with a Christian cross on it, and with a quotation So from the Christian (and Judaic) gospels engraved on it. Psalm 144:1
“Blessed be the Lord my rock, who trains my hands for war, my fingers for battle.”

Just google Christian assault rifle for the whole, spirit-building story.

I wonder whether the sermonette on Sunday's faith page will talk about this. Did you know that Hitler always proclaimed himself a devout Christian? And he meant it.

Some day, the churches will have to come out and tell us all what real faith is about.

(Nah. They won't.)

Only two stories in section A news are worth reading. One is at the bottom of A3. “Nordia says deal with province inked before competitor closed.” But, as is common, that headline is not the point.

A call centre has been given $835,125 by the provincial government to set up business in New Brunswick. But – a large number of the employees to be hired will come from people laid off at a call centre which just closed. That one, just five years ago, had been given $8,000 – for each worker it hired - from us generous tax payers per worker. Well, as those are rehired, we greatly increase our cost per job. Brilliant planning.

You know, these 'capitalists' who courageously run economic risks to become wealthy are always, with help from Irving editors, looking for government handouts while, at the same time, saying government it inefficient.

Some governments are inefficient – but, in New Brunswick ,the inefficiency shows largely in handing out gifts to capitalists.

A better piece of news appears on A6. It's about Elementary Literacy Friends, a volunteer group that helps children who have reading problems. The is something this province desperately needs more of. It helps the province – and it changes lives as nothing else does. We especially need it now that our government has decided that N.B. children are already too smart. That's why it plans to save money firing teachers and closing schools. (That way they'll have money to give to “entrepreneurs” who are too shy to come here unless we give them money.)

Read the rest of the news in Section A only if you're terribly, terribly bored.
The editorial, though long and boring, has nothing to say until it's final, three sentences. Ini brief, they say we gotta fire teachers and civil servants because we really, really need a new hockey rink.

Gwynne Dyer has a sad but very true appraisal of the weaponry in the world. He says, in effect, we don't have to worry about robot wars because they're far in the future, and we already have weapons that are too destructive – but useful for destroying poor countries without risking the lives of our good ol' boys.

The headline for Alan Cochrane's column tells us that a drowning tragedy delivers lessons on how we can all minimize risk. Well, that would be a good topic. But he says nothing about it until the last sentence. And that sentence is a limp and useless piece of advice. “The best we can do is to try to live safely….”

Is there anybody on that staff who knows anything at all? It's not just Cochrane. It's the editorial writer. It's the editor who approves these silly columns.

The guest column is about Nov. 11, and it's by the honourary Colonel of the 8th Canadian Hussars. (Honourary Colonels are non-mililtary people who are appointed, usually, because they have connections useful for the regiment or donate large sums to it. Hint to the commentary editor, honourary is properly spelled honorary).

Now, the 8th Hussars had a very fine record in World War Two. That's especially true because they had to use the Sherman tank ( like the one at Centennial Park.) The Sherman was reliable, but badly under-gunned and, also with inferior-shaped armour, it was outclassed by most of the German tanks it had to face. Standard practice was to use at least three Shermans to deal with one German Panther or Tiger – and that often meant the loss of two of the Shermans and their crews. (The British and Canadians up-gunned some of their Shermans later in the war. The Americans never did. Remember the film “Patton”? There's a scene just after the German surrender in which Patton was looking forward to invading Russia. We're all lucky he didn't. The Russian tanks outclassed even the German ones.)

But to return to the column. It makes the eternal Nov. 11 mistake. Nov. 11 is remembering those who served – as we should. But it is not – or should not – be an occasion for glorifying war, and seeing only heroism.

Our people died, and many were crippled physically or mentally for life. We remember on Nov. 11 to help survivors and their families. And we (should) remember to make damn sure that if we send our people to risk their lives again, we will know WHY they were sent. And we will make sure it is necessary.

We do NOT know why they were sent to Afghanistan where 158 died – incidentally while killing people that we don't know why they had to. We did it in Libya. Now we're doing it in Syria. And now we're setting up to do it in Ukraine. And not one Canadian in a thousand knows why. How could they know? For a start, our news media have never been honest or inquiring about the “why”. Nor, incidentally, have our chaplains. (A Canadian chaplain in Afghanistan used a sermon to assure our troops they were doing an important job. Why was it important? And if it was important, why did we pull them out? Nobody asked. So nobody told.)

As for our military heritage, Canadian performance has always been good. General Currie, who led the Canadians in World War One was so good that the British government considered putting him in command of all Imperial forces in Europe.

But out 'military heritage' has not always been necessary or desirable.

The first Canadian to win the Victoria Cross was a Canadian (he was from Nova Scotia,). He caught the medal for his bravery in killing people in India. So – why was a Canadian killing people in India? As well, why do most Nova Scotians not know this? (It might be because he was black.)

Canadian forces well into the second world war were profoundly racist toward Canadians who were Black, Oriental, or Native.

We executed 25 of our own soldiers in World War 1.

We had no reason to send troops for the Boer War. This was a war to make it possible for very wealthy British to loot the goldfields of South Africa. There was no other reason for it. They wanted us there because the wealthy British knew a war was coming with Germany, and they wanted to set a precedent that Canada would participate in all British wars. We killed Dutch settlers in battle. We also, by neglect, killed some 15,000 Dutch women and children and elderly people in concentration camps run by the Canadian army.

The message of this commentary in today's paper is that these were all splendid chaps who freely laid down there lives to bring freedom. There is no large collection of people anywhere on this earth who lay down their lives to defend freedom or anything else. There is no group of people who are all splendid chaps.

As a child, I knew many of the volunteers. Most had little education (the average education of Canadian soldiers in WW2 was grade 9). Most of the ones I knew had less than that. Most had no jobs, and no hope of one. That's why they joined. My uncle joined in 1939 to get away from his wife and family. My father joined for reasons I have never understood.

My best friend's older brother joined to fight the Korean war. He new nothing about Korea or what the war was about. With his grade four education, he couldn't even spell it. But he loved power, and he loved the feeling of power he got wearing a uniform and boots that clicked on the sidewalk. He came home badly wounded, and suffering a mental illness he would n ever recover from.

Sometimes, we have to fight wars. But there's nothing glorious about them. That's especially true in modern wars because their weapons are so indiscriminate that, for all of the 20th century and since they have killed more civilians than soldiers.

Yes, we should remember those who fought. Yes, we should care for them and their families. But we should also remember those who will fight in the future – and make damn sure it's necessary to make them destroy their own lives. Patriotism isn't good enough. We need moral and ethical principles, too.

Alec Bruce is, as usual, excellent.
There's very little in foreign news. And just a few pieces caught my eye.
(sorry about all these lines that appear at this point. My computer just does that.)
B2 has what, I suppose, is presented as a shocking story. “Syrian woman subjected to beatings, electric shocks for opposing Assad regime.” This is, of course, terrible. But it's hardly for us to be indignant. Canada has fully cooperated with U.S. torture which is, probably, on the biggest scale every known. And our side doesn't kid around with just electric shocks. So how come we've never had much reporting of that? And how come there are so few demands for Bush and Obama to be tried for war crimes. How come we don't get editorials saying Harper should face a court for cooperating with war criminals ?
B4 has a story on Russian intervention in Syria which is much better than the usual reporting because it offers some analysis to make the story meaningful. And the analysis is probably right. Russia is intervening for Assad and against ISIS because this will give it an economic presence in the region. And the U.S. is opposed to that because its billionaires, rather like the Russian ones, want to have it all to themselves. The jarring note is a quotation from the U.S. ambassador to the U.N. who says Assad cannot stay because he is responsible for one of the worst torture campaigns in modern history. Think about that – coming from a U.S. official.
Then there's a gem in reporting the fighting in Yemen. The Saudi-led coalition is fighting in Yemen to restore the rightful government. Puh-lease. The Saudi-led coalition is led by dictatorships. To say they are doing it to restore the elected government is absurd. Anyone who proposed elections to that gang would be beheaded. (no exaggeration). And, even if they were serious, then the bombing of civilians and starving millions of them as well as cutting off medical aid for the rest is a bizarre way to bring back a government (whose election was not all that legitimate in the first place.)