Monday, September 7, 2015

Sept. 7 this is late because my paper was very, very late.


I made a deal for delivery my paper from Irving press to my door early in the morning. It hasn't happened since December. I wonder. If Mr. Irving had made such a deal with a contractor and the contractor later changed the terms on his own, would Mr. Irving forgive and forget?
________________________________________________________________________________

The headline – golly, gee whiz – is “Moncton rocks out to AD/DC. Oh, I could die. I could just die. It's been the headline for days, now – and today there are two stories about it. That's almost two, full pages saying nothing about a concert. Oh, somebody came from Tennessee to see it. Gee, golly, whiz.

The real story about it is that the crowd was much smaller than last time, perhaps fifteen thousand smaller. Remember that next time somebody tells you the 'events centre' is sure to pay for itself.

The second biggest front page story is “Teachers excited for first day of school.” Gee. I hope nobody collapsed out of sheer ecstasy. B4 has a big photo of a fire that looks as though it could have been put out by spitting on it. And there's an exciting story that another rapper is coming to town.

A4 has one, worthwhile story. “One in ten New Brunswick households doesn't have adequate housing.” Essentially, it's a long and very informative statement by the executive director of New Brunswick Non Profit Housing Association. Certainly, there's a lot of sub-standard, jerry-built housing in Moncton.

Editorial page? Well, I don't see the point of the cartoon. It's about how Trudeau needs to jumpstart his campaign. In fact, Trudeau as been rising in the polls. As well, we're coming to the point in the campaign that both Trudeau and Harper like. There's a reason this is the longest election campaign in Canadian history. Harper has piles of campaign money. Trudeau has less, but still enough for the long campaign. The party that's feeling the strain is the NDP because billionaires don't give it money. Harper and Trudeau both hope to win on that.

The editorial is disgusting. It's all about how Labour Day is a salute to Canadian workers for their contribution. It even gives a nod to the unions for a decent living wage, but saves its greatest praise for unions that 'cooperate' with business.

Mr. or Ms. Editorial writer, you don't have a clue what you're talking about.

First, we don't have living wages. Have you taken a look lately at the minimum wages across this country and the U.S. Do you seriously think one can live on that?

Second, the wage gap in Canada and the U.S. is getting worse, not better.

Third, the reason we have Labour Day is not the puking reason this editorial gives. We have it because industrializing Canada had vile and dangerous working conditions at extremely low pay. The Canada of a century ago produced some very wealthy few – but millions who lived in a poverty almost unimaginable. In the cities, people lived in dilapidated shacks, often with no water, no toilets. Some of these existed well into the 1950s and later.

There were six working days a week. - and they were long days. Women could work only as laundresses or servants or factory hands for pennies a day. Children worked the same hours, and were subject to physical abuse daily in the factories. My mother became a household servant at age 11 in a great house. She never, ever spoke of it. And the only time off was an hour to go to church on Sunday.

In Toronto, a teen-age boy lost his arm to a machine that had no protection. He was fired immediately, with pay immediately stopped, and sent home – on his own.

People who tried to organize unions found themselves facing police and armed troops in Canada and the U.S. Many union organizers were murdered by order of company bosses. In the U.S., when state militia machine-gunned tents full of families of striking mine workers, Mackenzie-King stepped forward to manipulate the press to make the bosses (Rockefellers) look like sweethearts.

Unionizing was slow and dangerous – with editorial writers like the one at Irving press always on the side of the bosses. Teachers, slow to unionize, were getting paid $600 PER YEAR – and even less as late as the 1940s. Yes, prices were lower then; but not that low.

Big capitalists of the time were, to put it bluntly, thorough bastards. They still are. That's why they love free trade which gives them the right to fire North American workers, and hire cheap and dangerous and polluting labour, including children as young as five – and even to beat and murder on a large scale. And big Canadian capitalists are up to their ears in this.

Labour Day was founded to honour the contribution of Canadian workers. It was founded to remember those who risked and lost their lives to form the unions that made Canada more livable.

And we honour the workers who hammered the rails for our trains? Like hell we do. It was a miserable and dangerous job. So we imported Chinese to do the most dangerous parts, like dynamiting, where the rate of fatality was very high. Then we stuck the Chinese workers into our vilest slums, confined them to those Chinatowns, and wouldn't let them bring their families over. Canada's racism against Chinese lasted at least into the 1970s.

The railways did much the same with Italian immigrants after World War Two.

This is a disgusting and ignorant editorial. It reminds me of the slimy role that Mackenzie-King played to kiss up to the Rockefellers.

Oh, and we now have a fair living wage? Does the editorial writer know what our minimum wage is?

Norbert, too, writes on a topic he knows nothing about. He says our education system is rooted in the nineteenth century. I doubt very much where Norbert has a clue about nineteenth century education. For that matter, he works for a news medium that has it roots in the eighteenth century, and has been going downhill since the 1890s.

And he blames the teachers and the teachers' union for our illiterate population, though he produces no evidence whatever. In fact, Norbert, as a teacher at all levels for fifty years, I can tell you why many children are illiterate. It's because their parents don't care and because their parents are illiterate.

That's not just a slam. I've taught students from a great many religions and countries. Jewish and Chinese students (possibly Dutch as well) commonly are excellent students. That's because their parents commonly place a high value on education. And it's because their parents read and think, and publicly discuss things like politics, art, world affairs. (In China, I taught students who never missed a class, were never late, always handed in papers on time and who, if I even casually mentioned an article, would have it read by the next class. (There was even a student I had to threaten to hospitalize if he didn't stop taking pills to stay awake all night studying.)

New Brunswick parents have the least interest in schools that I have ever seen. And a very, very high proportion don't read ( certainly nothing more than how to grow a bigger bust or what some Hollywood dimwit is doing.)

And they avoid public discussion of public issues as if it were poisonous. A very high proportion don't think, don't want to think and are, I would guess, afraid of having an opinion in public.

As to your 'brilliant' insight that we can fire teachers because the number of students has gone down – well, think hard Norbert – has it occurred to you that the province didn't have nearly enough teachers in the first place? And now, for the first time, it might have enough?

All you can think about is budgets. I see no concern about the students – not in you, and not in most of the adult population of this province.

Tell me, Norbert, if Irving were to take over the schools and privatize them – as he well might – would you have the guts to criticize him for weak results?

And, while we're talking about budgets, how about digging up the figures on how much of our money is wasted on public/private projects. And how much tax is it that the very rich don't pay in this province?

Norbert, you know nothing whatever about education. This province does have a serious education problem. But it's not the teachers. It's the whole social tone of a province of people who are afraid to think, afraid to learn, and afraid talk about anything except how hot the day is.

We need more teachers – and more school spaces – to educate the parents..

Good columns by Craig Babscock and guest columnist Ross Galbraith who is the business manager of a union.

But, much as I like both, I have to reserve the crown for Alec Bruce. His column is brilliant.

He thinks that universities should be teaching much more about thinking – and much less about job-training. He's quite right. And he's right that learning to think comes from such fields as math, science, history, literature and language. All my teaching experience tells me he's right – so right that I'm not sure business programmes should be taught in universities at all.

Most of the information pumped into students in all fields is memorized for the exam, and forgotten soon after it. But the skills and temperament of thinking will not be forgotten. And those skills are essential for a person in any career.

Alas! I have little hope of the universities. For a start, the boards are commonly dominated by the wealthy who really aren't interested in people who think, and who want money-making to have the prestige of a university degree. (And they also happily donate money in exchange for an honorary degree.)

As well, university teachers tend to the strong on ego, praise, recognition. But those don't come from being a good teacher. In fact, an interest in teaching is often looked down on as suggesting a feeble mind. No. Egos and reputation are built on publication. (You can read news stories in the Irving press for confirmation of that.)

In consequence, I suffered some nine years of really boring, forgettable, and useless lectures- - with only one or two exceptions. But that's what universities are like – and likely to stay that way.
__________________________________________________________________________________

There's only a little of importance in Canada&World.

The lead is quite a startling story about 43 students murdered in Mexico. I think it was about a year ago.

There's a big photo of a gathering at Vancouver, highlighted by the release of whlte balloons over the harbour. It's in memory of two Syrian boys, refugees, who were drowned. I would be more touched if they also flew them for the million or so children killed in Vietnam, Iraq, Pakistan, Afghjanistan, Libya, Guatemala…
.
I'm not crazy about selective grief.

The NDP is calling on Harper to accept many more refugees immediately. But Harper has never shown interest in refugees. He knows it could cost him votes. Case closed.

B2 has “Vatican to shelter refugees fleeing war, hunger; pope wants other to do the same.” I'm not a Catholic. But sometimes I wish the pope were prime minister of Canada.

On B3, the Conservatives are giving $15,000,000 to museums. Well, that's the way elections work. Many, perhaps most, voters decide who to vote for based on relatively minor matters like this. Big mistake. We have to learn to look at the real issues.

But don't worry about the Conservatives. It's not their money. They're buying us with our money.

The same page has a story about Elizabeth surpassing Queen Victoria in years as ruler. I'm no admirer of royalty. But Elizabeth (and her father, George VI) played their roles to perfection. They have been, without doubt, the outstanding British monarchs of at least 3 centuries.

The story says Elizabeth and Victoria had much in common. Nonsense. Victoria was an unpleasant woman interested only in herself, did nothing for anybody, and who only rarely appeared in public for fifty years.

Egypt has confirmed its decision, finding three journalists (including on Canadian) guilty of belonging to a terrorist organization. The evidence Egypt has presented is absurd. Egypt was, briefly, a democracy. But the U.S. didn't like that. So it overthrew the elected government and installed a military dictatorship. The U.S. is, you know, the land of the free and the home of the brave.

Will Harper demand the Canadian be deported to Canada to face a real trial? Not likely. Not unless Obama tells him to do it.

Section B, Canada&World, has only 4, lousy pages. Most of them are taken up by trivia – like the story about a policeman in Texas who pasted a sign “In God we trust” on his squad car. There isn't a single story of any great importance.


If people in New Brunswick are, as Norbert suggests, suffering from illiteracy and general lack of knowledge, he doesn't have to examine to schools to find out why. He just has to look in a mirror.

Sunday, September 6, 2015

Sept. 6: Short on a sunny afternoon....

....and credit where credit was due.

In Saturday's paper, I forgot to look at the Faith Page. Big mistake. Reverend Richard Jackson has an excellent column on the distinctions between loyalty and patriotism on one hand  - and faithfullness on the other.He cites an American quotation - "my country right or wrong. But my country"  as an example of loyalty and patriotism - but certainly not of faith.

It's an excellent point. So let's go to where the rubber hits the road. In 1937, some 1500 Canadians volunteered to fight fascism in Spain. They were called the Mackenzie-Papineau Battalion, and they served in what was called the International Brigade. They went to Spain because the democratic republic of Spain was being attacked by a fascist general named Franco. And Franco had lavish help, including tanks and bombers, from Hitler and Mussolini.

The Canadian and American and French and British governments were furious at the International Brigade. Canada immediately passed a law making it illegal to fight in foreign wars (a law we seem to  have since forgotten.)  It's ironic that our prime minister who passed it was William Lyon Mackenzie-King. He was named after his grandfather, William Lyon Mackenzie - the man who was a storied rebel and whose name was part of the name of the Mackenzie-Papineau battalion.

They were fighting fascism - Hitler, Mussolini, and Franco. But, as late as 1939, Canada felt no pride in that. The RCMP for   years spied on their families and, when they returned, spied on them. (Incidentally, only half would live to see Canada again.) When they did return, Canada, Britain and the U.S. put every possible obstacle in their way. They were labelled "premature anti-fascists" - and spies would follow some of them the rest of their lives.

The same thing happened to Charlie Chaplin when he made the film "The Great Dictator" in 1940, a year into the war. It was also the first Hollywood film to criticize Hitler and his treatment of Jews - and he had to finance it himself because no Hollywood film studio, including all the Jewish owned ones would touch a film critical of Hitler, After the war, Chaplin was hounded out of the U.S. precisely for  his criticism of Hitler.

The usual excuse for this treatment of those who opposed fascism 'pre-maturely' is that they were communists. Some were. I met some in my teens and twenties. They were communists. But they weren't Stalins. They weren't evil. They weren't terrorists. Many years ago, I knew a number of them, mostly Jewish. They were the most compassionate people I have even known. They were - dare I say it? - Christians in a  way damn few Christians are. (And they all abandoned the party when Kruschev revealed what Stalin was really like.)

This November 11, the first Canadians to give their lives fighting fascism will not be mentioned. They never are. And the Canadian Legion never mentions them. Why?

What they did was wrong. Unlike the soldiers of 1939, they could not be portrayed as going to war for loyalty or patriotism. They went out of faithfulness and compassion. And that's naughty.

Perhaps Reverend Jackson might be interested in giving a sermon on this on the Sunday nearest Nov. 11 -  in memory of those Canadians who were premature anti-fascists.

Incidentally, there's an even deeper meaning to this story.

Canadian, American, British and French capitalists just loved Hitler. They thought fascism established a wonderful relationship with capitalism in destroying democracy, and bringing capitalists into political power. It was also, in the hungry years of the 1930s, their defence against the spread of communism and socialism. That's why many of them gave Hitler the money that  brought him to power. That's why the U.S. government had no great interest in the war until late 1941, when it seemed that China was up for grabs. That's why, when memories of the great depression were still strong in the 1950s, Senator McCarthy of the U.S. staged his communist witch hunt.

And why did the British and French empires go to war in 1939? It had nothing to do with saving Jews, though our governments knew all about what was going on. It was because they feared that Hitler was beginning to build his own economic empire which would challenge those of Britain and France. The U.S. did not go to war in 1939 - because Hitler and Mussolinin were no threat to it.

There were, I'm afraid, a lot of fascists in the upper ranks of western business in 1939. And there still are a lot. And they are, as they were in the days of Hitler and Mussolini, fascist in their behaviour.

There's a sermon in that - a sermon about loyalty, patriotism  - and faithfulness.
__________________________________________________________________________

There's a bizarre story out of West Point, the U.S. military academy. Students were engaged in a pillow fight, using pillow case stuffed with metal objects. Thirty were injured, many with concussions.

Isn't that behaviour a little odd?

Recently, there was a (hushed)  scandal about Canadian women in the military being sexually assaulted by soldiers.

Why weren't more questioned asked about this? There's a documentary by Gwynne Dyer that touches on this. As well as I can remember, it's called The Profession of Arms.

A soldier's job is to be ruthless, to have no respect for human life or human decency. That's not a criticism of soldiers. That's a reality that is built into their training. That's why drill sergeants shout and spit in the faces of recruits. Any humanity or compassion is a handicap in war. Violent behaviour is encouraged.  In the final analysis, we are the ones who demand that. That is what we have done to those we remember on Nov. 11. We owe them thanks. We also owe them apologies.

Thus the pillow slips filled with metal. Thus the sexual assaults.
________________________________________________________________________________




Saturday, September 5, 2015

Sept, 5:The teaching of lies.

The following site was sent to me by a reader. I think it's quite true. It tells us what the U.S. government really is – and it could well have added Britain and Canada as eager puppies running along behind their master.


The U.S., Britain and Canada are moved to compassion by the sight of a child lying dead on a beach.
How come we didn't much notice the story of a Somalian teenager who was tortured and beaten to death by Canadian elite troops? How come nobody even asked why they did it?

I can tell you why.

Soldiers of all armies are trained to hate, to want to kill, to be indifferent to human suffering. They have to be, and the training is quite deliberate because nice guys aren't much use in a battle. It's not just courage that counts. It's also a desire to beat and torture and kill. That's why soldiers of an 'elite' Canadian regiment kidnapped a teenager, and beat him to death for the fun of it.

When we go to war, we brutalize those we send. There's no other way to go to war. The pace of this brutalization was stepped up after World War Two when it was realized that it took some 60,000 shots for each enemy killed. Psychologists said that much of that was deliberate misses by soldiers who didn't want to kill. That's when armies really pumped up their teaching of hatred and even joy in killing. Now the rate of bullet wastage has been dramatically reduced, Praise the Lord.

That's why snipers, especially, are trained to kill with indifference to age or gender. And that's what made a national hero out of a killer whose story was told in American Sniper.

But few people will see it that way. We see wars through the eyes of our news media, and of the history we learned at school. We're good. The other side is bad. Always.


Tell me what was good about the slaughter of native peoples and the destruction of their societies and the theft of their land by our ancestors? The recent Truth and Reconciliation Report for Canada is already dying without so much as a whimper. It's not an election issue. And it won't be – because every politician knows that most Canadians don't give a damn, and don't want to hear about it.

In U.S. history, General Custer is a hero. In fact, at Little Big Horn, he was attacking native people on native territory with the intention of killing them all. Custer loved killing. Then there's the story of the American admiral who forced Japan to open up to American business over a century ago. Yep. He just appeared. And that was it.

Well, actually, he shelled Japan, killing many innocent people.

We feel grief at the sight of a drowned refugee child? Where is the grief for the million and probably more children killed, mostly by the U.S. and Britain (God save the Queen) , in Iraq and Afghanistan and Pakistan and Yemen and Somalia and Guatemala and many other countries around the world? And George Bush is still welcome as a regular attender of his Christian church. (So is his daddy who was a major figure in the Guatemala massacre of civilians, including babies. And Hitler, bless his heart, was a believing member of the Roman Catholic faith.)

Oh, but when an American platoon murdered a whole village at My Lai in Vietnam, (yes including babies) – well, the good Christians of the U.S. wouldn't tolerate that. They put the lieutenant on trial. And he had to stay in jail for a whole night until he was pardoned.

Isn't it awful the way ISIL cuts heads off?

Will we offer any significant help for those tens of millions of refugees from the middle east? There's no sign of it. Harper won't do it - and he won't do it because he knows 1.Canadians don't care. 2. Canadians are profoundly racist. ( That's why Canada wouldn't let Jews in, even after 1939.) For the same reason, the U.S. won't do it. Heck, the U.S won't even help its own people. It's too busy shovelling all its money into war spending and profound corruption.)

Our history teaches us that we are good. And that goodness strongly implies that we are a superior people. The British Empire murdered and brutalized millions to make a small number very, very rich. But we were taught it was glory - “...make her victorious, happy and glorious...” And, of course, it was linked to the will of God as in God save our gracious – whoever.

The U.S. is a carbon copy of the Britain it rebelled against, but is even more buddies with God – whether they call it Manifest Destiny or American Exceptionalism.

We think we're nice people because that's what our history books and news media tell us. We aren't. As much as any other nation, we killed that three year-old who washed up on a Turkish shore.

And, as always, we're going to put all the blame on somebody else.

Oh, our provincial premier has sent $50,000 to the U.N. for aid. We can't send more because we really need $100,000,000 for our hockey rink.

You might guess from the length of this opening that there isn't much in the Irving press today. And you would be right.

Once again, we get a full dose of nothing, this time for two pages, about the AC/DC concert. A full page is photos of people who have come to attend it. There are seven, big photos which are invaluable if you care what people who go to an AC/DC concert look like.

The headline story “'leave us alone,' seniors groups tell premier” is misleading because that's not the central point of the story. (After all, we knew they were going to say that. Maybe that's because the editor wanted to smother the real story.) And the real story is the premier told them to get lost.
The editorial is about – guess what – the AC/DC concert.

There is an excellent letter to the editor - 'Let's see moratorium on 'Heritage demolition'. Moncton has very little sense of its own history and, frankly, Resurgo doesn't do a whole lot to help. If only for the sake of attracting tourists, the city should take a much more organized approach to preserving its history and making it meaningful. Hint to our media – in Montreal I did a broadcast on what our streets were named after ( and when and why they were named and what that told us about history), and it led to such a demand that I had to make it a series that lasted for a year. A city with two universities should be able to find someone who can do that.

Norbert has an excellent column on the failure (or refusal) of many parents to get vaccinations for their children. On my first day in grade one, I would not have been allowed into the school without showing my vaccination. For all of us, a vaccination mark was a thing of awe and pride. I cannot understand a society that would allow a quarter of its public school students not to be vaccinated – and 60% of daycare children???

This would have been considered completely unacceptable even in the middle ages when I went to school. Such children are a danger to our children and to all of us. School boards and parent groups should be raising hell about this.

Brent Mazerolle has a well-told story about the restoration of the Petitcodiac river. It has common sense, sensitivity – and really good writing.

One guest commentary is by our provincial minister of Post-secondary Education, Training and Labour. It's a standard political spiel that says nothing except that your government is doing a wunnerful, wunnerful job. And I strongly suspect it was not written by the honourable member.

The other guest column is by Beverly Barrett. It's about the city's failure to protect historic houses. It's quite good (though if you read it carefully, you will find an unintentional obscenity in there). But it's still a good column and, in any case, I get the feeling I wouldn't want to pick an argument with Beverly Barrett.
Canada&World opens with a headline that our provincial premier is willing to take in refugees from the Middle East. I heartily support that.

I grew up a short walk from my city's Syrian district. I went to school where Syrian children became some of my best friends. Our end of town and poor and violent. But that was us Canadian-borns. The Syrian kids were pretty good. Their parents worked hard, most did well over the years. (The father of one boy became the founder of Dollar stores.) And the children did well, too, many of them entering professions – and this in an end of town where most of us would become cheap labour.

By my late teens, most of my friends were Jews. Most Jews at that time lived in a neighbouring district that was as poor as mine. Like the Syrians, they worked hard, and made sacrifices for their children. Later, as a university teacher, I taught students from all over the world – China, Palestine, South Korea, The Netherlands, Africa…. I even had a student I never really saw. She was a Muslim with a veil that left only a narrow slit for her eyes – and the eyes were hidden behind sunglasses. And, of all things, I taught her military history. She attended every class, and she did good work.

The only difference I ever saw between the Canadian-born and the immigrants was that the immigrants worked harder and were more willing to make sacrifices for their children. New Brunswick should welcome all the immigrants it can get.

There's a whole page on how Clinton didn't understand the email system when she became secretary of state. So who cares?

There are several stories about the refugee crisis, most of them not very helpful. The most active European countries in accepting refugees are Austria and Germany. (Hey! I remember Austrians and Germans. They're the evil people I was taught to hate when I was a kid.)

For the Canadian point of view, we have Mulcair and Trudeau in favour of helping refugees. This, on B5, is a story worth reading. Harper thinks the answer is to kill more people. Of that choice, he says, “Forget about how wrong that is from a humanitarian compassionate sense.” Well, that's honest.

He also says that ISIL is the root cause of the war. Oh? Weren't we killing people in that region long before ISIL existed? And weren't we killing Africans by the tens of millions for centuries before that? And aren't we still killing them?”

It looks to me that the cause of today's scale of killin
g, looting, impoverishing and greed is ---us.


We need refugees who aren't like us. They would give us a bit of class.

Friday, September 4, 2015

Sept. 4: A long one. Sorry.

It is now 2:15, and my breakfast copy of the newspaper has still not arrived. I am told it may come at 3 p.m. It will not be delivered to my door in this large building. We we haven't had delivery to the door since December, and never before 11 a.m. or so. Irving press is one hell of a bad newspaper chain from editing and leadership, to bad (and worse) news judgement, all the way to top management. The vice-president is a person who rose from cub reporter to his present position with remarkable speed. It may be because he is the most brilliant news manager in world history. Or it may be because his last name is Irving. (Nah. Can't be that. We all have equal opportunity in this wonderful land.)

The front page sets the tone for the rest of the paper. The big, smashing news of the day is that our premier is going to meet with seniors on Friday. They've been asking for a meeting for weeks. I wonder how long Mr. Irving has to wait for a meeting with the premier. (or, perhaps, how long the premier has to wait for a meeting with Mr. Irving.)

Fans of AC/DC are on their way to Moncton. Who woulda guessed? And there's a photo of three people who are organizing a fund-raiser for support of the families of military and police.

I'd be more impressed ---
1. if families of military and police didn't need charity to survive.
2.if organizations. like “Lest We Forget” would really remember all the veterans and question why they were sent to risk their lives, health and sanity to fight American wars. To remember them is to remember all of them, and to remember our responsibility to make our decisions on whether they should be sent.
3. if the people of Moncton were to demand to know who sent three police armed only with pistols to arrest a man who was known to have at least two rifles.
4. if the people of Moncton were to demand to know where he got those rifles, how available such combat rifles are on the market.
5. if the people of Canada were to demand to know why Harper destroyed almost all records of who owns such guns.

And the rest of section A news is just as informative.
There's a nothing editorial on Resurgo Place. The editorial suggests it will revive downtown and the Main. I have no idea why that should be true.

Norbert writes another commentary on Right to Information from governments. He really has nothing to say except to attack university teachers who do research. I don't know what New Brunswick is like, but in any research I did in Quebec and Ontario, I was almost invariably allowed to go to the shelves and get it. And, if I needed advice, it was no problem to get it. And I was never charged to get it. Such charges could be quite a burden for research-oriented professors – and would be a disaster for graduate students doing research.

I really don't understand why we should require permission to see information about the actions of democratically elected people. Information we can't see should be very exceptional. As a general rule, it should be on the shelves, and we should be allowed to look at it if we want to. (Yes, of course there will be exceptions that might require permission. But there's no need to make exceptions the rule.)

There's a particularly objectionable comment “...much of it is faculty getting the government to do their research for them – free.” No, Norbert. It's government providing a service that is essential – just like parks and sidewalks.
I wonder when Norbert will write a column on Mr. Irving getting something free from the government.

Cole Hobson has an almost childish commentary on how local baseball players do us proud. I liked baseball. I liked playing it. I like watching it. I had a brief acquaintance with the best fastball pitcher I ever saw. It's fun. But why on earth should it make us proud?

He also says team sports are a great way to build relationships and learn life skills. That's bunk. The value of sports to build character, life skills, etc. was an idea invented by the British aristocracy to raise themselves above the working classes. That's why the Olympics were originally intended for amateurs only. It was to keep out the peasantry who could afford to play only if they were paid for it. That's how football became an important university sport – because way back it was amateur and for the “better sort” only. To this day, there are two categories of cricket players in Britain – 'players' and 'gentlemen'.

The guest commentary is on surgical wait times. It's okay – but doesn't say much.

Alec Bruce has a good column on retirement and the coming bulge of baby boom retirees in New Brunswick. He thinks many of us should work past retirement. I think he's right. Retirement is boring. It just turns us into people who sit in a corner and mumble to ourselves.

Canada&World has always been uninformative, but it's become truly awful in the last few months. Perhaps the most gripping story is on B4 “Pope pops out of Vatican to get new glasses”.

On B1, Omar Khadr wants his bail eased so he can visit his family in Toronto. No response yet from Harper. And there may not be one. Harper is a big talker, weak on doing. Khadr should never have been imprisoned. He was fifteen. It is against international law to put a fifteen year old in a military prison. He should never have been tortured. That's against the law, too. Did he kill an American? We don't know. He confessed only to end the torture. And the trial at which he confessed was a purely military tribunal – which operates well below the standards of a criminal court. And if he did kill an American, he was being attacked at the time by Americans who were shooting at him. What would you expect a 15 year old to do? Throw flowers?

Under the law ( and with any decency), Harper should have demanded that Khadr be returned to Canada immediately after he was captured. But there wasn't a peep out of Harper. And when he was released to Canada, Harper should have been him in rehabilitation. Instead, he put him into maximum security. Khadr should have been a free man long ago. But he still isn't. And he's not likely to be as long as Harper is still kissing the American rear end.

(Yes. I know some readers don't like Khadr because he is accused of killing an American soldier. But the law has nothing to do with who we like or dislike. Besides, American soldiers have been known to kill and rape people by the millions.)

B3 has an important but incomplete story about a three-year old refugee boy whose body washed up on a beach in Turkey. His brother died at the same time. The younger one caught world attention in a photo of his body as it lay, lapped by the sea.

Next to it is a story “Harper says beach image heartbreaking, steels resolve to fight ISIL”

Harper is a callous liar – at several levels.
His resolve to fight ISIL amounts to a piddling six fighter-bombers, an insignificant force in the region. And those fighter-bombers are creating refugees just like that boy who washed up on the shore. And, for that matter, they're killing innocent people on the ground. That's unavoidable with aerial attacks.

To make it worse, killing ISIL people will NOT bring peace. Western behaviour over the last century is what created ISIL and what will create worse ISILs if we go on behaving this way. In fact, there seems to have been direct American involvement in the creation of ISIL just as there was in al Quaeda and other 'terrorist' groups.

Harper's 'steel' resolve has nothing to do with fighting terrorism. And it certainly has nothing to do with helping the millions of refugees because Canada has not done a damn thing to help them. The few who do make it to Canada can expect to find themselves, the whole family, committed to prison until their cases can be examined in -----maybe six months, maybe a couple of years. Maybe forever if you're a woman wearing a veil.

Harper's help, or lack of help, for these people is contemptible. This is typical of Harper – the big mouth, and the lack of action unless it's to help billionaires and the American Empire.

And billionaires and the American Empire are really what our air force is fighting to defend in the Middle East. We aren't helping refugees. We're creating them. We aren't there to bring peace because, for a start, no amount of killing is going to bring peace.

We're there to keep control of oil in the hands of western oil billionaires. That is why a 3 year-old washed up on a Turkish shore. That, and and cutting off any Russian oil billionaires from getting into the European market by sending it through Syria, is why tens of millions are fleeing their homes and dying of starvation, exposure, drowning, disease. And Harper knows all of that.

In his commentary, Cole Hobson says our local baseball players do us proud. Perhaps, in some circles, they do – a little bit. But Harper's behaviour and our acceptance of it does not make me proud. And it should make all of us ashamed.

It's possible I know at last one of our pilots in the Middle East. I taught some of them in military history. They were good kids, intensely proud of being Canadian, and intensely proud of heading for a life of service to Canada. It made me proud just to know them.

But I know they never planned to serve billionaires, to kill randomly, to create millions of refugees, to starve innocent people, and to start a three year-old on the voyage that would lead to his body washing up on a Turkish shore. They were made to do it by immoral bastards like Harper and Obama and Bush.

As a footnote to this, it could get a hell of a lot worse. Harper, with his big talk and little action in kissing up to oil billionaires has put us in a terrible spot. We are now committed to two, battle areas that have nothing to do with us. At least, not unless you're earning at least a million dollars a year.

We have forces committed to Ukraine and Iraq. The conflicts there have nothing to with us. Both conflicts were created by U.S. interference. Both benefit only the very rich. There is nothing in it for most Canadians, nothing in it for most Americans. But if things go wrong, and they almost certainly will, Harper has committed us to the greatest and most destructive wars the world has ever seen.

And please don't tell me ISIL is wicked. Think first about the little girl in Vietnam, running and screaming down a road as she was consumed by the flames of American napalm. Think, too, about the millions of dead in Vietnam, Central America, Iraq. Afghanistan, Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia. Think of the torture cells. Think of the respected psychologists who trained the torturers. Think of countries like Haiti held down in deep poverty and short lives by the U.S. with the help of Canadian 'peacekeepers'.


The Brief, from nbmediacoop for September has a short but compelling story

A nun, Sister Stella Matutina talks about Canadian mining companies in The Philippines who dump their hazardous wastes on the shores and in the waters of the region. There's nothing new about that kind of dumping, or about Canadian mining companies being involved in it.

One of my daughters worked for a time in an African country. The shores were lined with monster dumps of hazardous wastes brought by ships from Europe and North America.

In 1993, Canada sent peacekeepers to Somalia, a country on the Arabian Sea. You should find the official record if you google Veterans' Affairs Canada. (the official record dances around an outstanding event of that peacekeeping – Canadian soldiers tortured, then beat a Somalian teenager to death for no reason.)

Peacekeepers were sent partly because of civil war in Somalia, but also because pirates operating from Somalia were a severe threat to shipping in the Arabian Sea. That's what our news told us. But it never told us why so many Somalians became pirates.

It was because mining companies from around the world were dumping their hazard waste, mountains of it, along the shores and in the sea off Somalia. Farming land was destroyed. The fishery was destroyed. And, for most people, there really wasn't much else in Somalia.

Canadian companies are big in mining all over the world. And they have a long history of polluting, impoverishing, and dumping everywhere they go. People who complain can get killed. And often do. Sister Matutina has been threatened many times. And it's not just threats. 100 activists on her home island have been killed just in the past two years. (But don't worry. No clergy in New Brunswick have ever been threatened. And, as long as they write tweety-bird sermonettes, they're safe.)

Much of the waste dumped in The Phillipines comes from Canadian-owned mines in other parts of the world, including Canada. And the Canadian government is complicit in it, even though the practice is banned by international convention.

And just wait for the Trans-Pacific partnership deal to go through. It will make Canada, itself, a legal dump for hazardous waste.
Then there's an interesting post. It's in a site I treat with caution, but Paul Craig Roberts is extremely well-informed, and I have found his columns thoroughly professional and honest.


And the general lesson from all this?

No society can survive an economic system unless there in (honest) governmental control of it. Invariably, lack of such control leads to unending wars, and dreadful exploitation. That applies to ANY economic system. Capitalists who babble about letting the market decide are really saying “ We will decide.” And the decisions the 'market' makes inevitably end in suffering and killing.

In a democracy, we expect governments to decide. If the decisions are made by “the market”, then we don't have a democracy. That's why we can see the decay of democracy all around us.

We vote for a government because we expect it to make decisions for our well-being. “The Market” doesn't do that. And those people who have come to make “market” decisions have no interest in us – only in profit. And you can see the results of that all around you.


Thursday, September 3, 2015

Sept. 3: I can't even pretend to understand why....

....but the Irving press seems to get worse each day. I'll just go over it briefly for today, then move onto something worth talking about.

In section A, "riggers,stage crew assemble giant AC/DC stage". Please. This isn't news They're doing what they are supposed to do. It's no surprise, and it in no will affect the course of our lives. (If they weren't assembling the stage, that might be news - but not page 1.)                      

"Nova Scotia orders review of fuel system" So?   "Province's stone quarry industry a shadow of what it once was". A well-known rapper (well-known in circles in which people listen to rappers) is coming to Moncton. It's accompanied by the usual photo of the whole group of five looking very conciously important as they stride ---somewhere.

The only story worth reading is on A2. "St.Norbert becomes 1st of five Catholic churches to close." No matter what one's religion might be, the slow collapse of Christianity in the western world signals enormous change in our society. This makes it worth asking what the consequences will be.
___________________________________________________________________________
The editorial is yet another commentary on how the import of beer from Quebec should be freed up. There's even a suggestion that this issue has 'sparked' debate in our federal election, taking us from 'more mundane' subjects. In fact, this is, according to the editor (as he reigns his chariot horses to their rear legs) denying the free market a chance to work.

Donne-moi un break.

On the issue of access to information, Norbert says we have to create a culture of openess among politicians and bureaucracy. Neat idea. But this province has never in its history had a culture of openess. So let's go for it, Norbert. Write a column on how the government should open the books on how much we give the wealthy every years, and how much income tax they don't pay. I can't wait to read it.

Rod Allen offers a column largely about himself - which appears to be the only topic that interests him.

The guest column is superb. It's about saving health care money while making the system more effective. Note, all you columnists at Irving press - this excellent idea comes from two medical people, not from business leaders. Medical care is not a business, and will not work if we try to impose business methods on it.

Alec Bruce examines a topic worth examining - the turnout of voters at elections. It looks as though it will be better than usual. That's good because it's generally been going downhill for  years. In the U.S., it is hitting some of the lowest levels in history - almost certainly the result of dissillusion, especially since 1960 or so, and made worse by the virtual impossibility of creating a third party. That's likely to mean serious violence in the near future.

I don't know why it's happening in Canada - unless it's a milder form of the U.S. case combined with the lack of informed and honest commentary in our news media.

Oh - the cartoon. A good cartoonist has to be a good artist. And de Adder is certainly well above the national average as an artist. But a political cartoonist also needs the skill of being a shrewd political analyst. Today's cartoon suggests a problem here.

It portrays Trudeau as 'tweedletax', and Mulcair as 'tweedlespend'. In fact, left wing parties don't have a record of being big spenders. Oh, I know. The gossip over a few beers and a shared pipe, punctuated by hits on the spittoon, is that the NDP have a record of being big spenders. They don't. Historically, the big spenders have been right wing parties - and in more countries than Canada. The big spender in Canada now is Harper; and he's the biggest we've seen for a while.

As for Trudeau and the Liberals, that party was a big taxer in World War Two. And lucky for us it was.  On taxing in general, though, it has a record very similar to that of the Conservatives.

Just thinking out loud, this looks to me like a loaded and biased cartoon.
______________________________________________________________________________
As for Canada&World, a big story (this will have echoes in national capitals around the world) is that a family in Nova Scotia lost its pet llama - but found it again. In Illinois, police are searching for three suspects wanted for a killing. In Rhode Island, a Fox news anchor is suing Hasbro for its toy hamster with her name on it.

There is almost no significant news in this whole section - and almost no sense of what it means to us.

The one piece that has some connection with us is that in Alberta, a group called "energy Citizens" is conducting a campaign  about how good oil is for us. It was organized by the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers. So don't even think about climate change.  I wonder if we can expect a similar campaign from our own, friendly, neighbourhood petroleum producer.

It's designed to counter a campaign by Greenpeace.
___________________________________________________________________________
C2 has good advice by student columnist Aurelie Pare on how to study . So I'll toss in the method I used - free.

I had failed high school, then somehow got into university to complete a truly awful B.A.  One grad school said to me when I applied for an M.A., "This is beneath contempt." Somehow, I talked my way into Acadia for a repeat undergrad year. And I knew I had to get real or it was back to a lousy factory job. So -

Day 1.  Read all notes several times  (five or six) for day 1.
Day 3, review day one notes several times. Also read day 3 notes.
Day 7. read day 7 notes. Briefly review day 3 and day 1.
Day 30. read day 30 notes, plus days 1, 7, and 3
             follow this pattern every day, including Saturday and Sunday.

For the last couple of weeks of the course, review everything.

It shouldn't take more than a half hour a day - and maybe an hour  in the home stretch.
It works, I got straight As.

Of course, you don't really learn much by memorizing. But memorizing is mostly what university is about. I remember very little from any of the courses I took. But they got me to be a prof - and that's how you really learn - by teaching. Loved it.
_____________________________________________________________________________
I spent more time on all the above than I meant to.

What I wanted to write about was how news media which simply report what is happening now, don't  give us much idea of what 's going on. Events have to be placed in a context. You cannot understand the popularity of Donald Trump just by reading the news or watching him being interviewed. He is a product of some 350 years of American history.

But knowledge of history is commonly (usually) dead wrong.  

Americans live in a history most of which, like much of our Canadian history, never happened.

American history teaches that Americans are good, are motivated by freedom and equality. In fact, American history is nothing like that. Its history, beginning as a set of British colonies, was a history of aggression, destruction, murder (where do you think all those 'injuns'  disappeared to?) It was guided by greed, theft of land, slavery. Nor has it ever brought democracy to the world. On the contrary, it was an empire from the start which expanded into Mexico, South America, Asia, and now aspires to be the ruler of the world.

But, raised as we in Canada are, Americans see themselves as good, kind, peace-loving, and democratic. It follows, then, that whose who oppose them are evil. And those who shoot back at them are cruel, even terrorists.  And that is reflected very much in American news media.

One of the crises the U.S. faces now is that many Americans are losing their belief that they are all equal. You only need to look African or oriental or poor to realize that.  This is coupled with a half-understood sense that their democracy is failing them.

That's why so many Americans are turning to the 'different' candidate, a television clown named Donald Trump who seems to have no policy at all, except an anti-Mexican one that plays to the fears and hatred generated by a  lying press.

This is the result of a disillusionment which has long been driving voter turnout down. Crippled by their vision of history, most cannot see what the real problem is or even what they really want.

Harper has played much the same game, and so have Canada's private news media. The Irving press is probably the lowest version you can find among our private news media.

There are no big issues in this federal election campaign in Canada because anyone who tells the whole truth about what we need would be committing political suicide. Canadians have their own fictious history and their own forms of racism that prevent them from dealing with truth. Like the U.S., our image of ourselves and the world is a false one based on false images of our history. And it's all made worse by news media that are propagandizing or, like the Irving press, keeping us trivial.

Meanwhile, some huge changes have taken place around the world.

The very wealthy have come to exercise political power in this world, and at a rapid pace in the last 30 to 40 years. Not only are they now allowed to run free of any control, they have effectively become our governments. And they can control us because they control most of our news media. And their only moral values are greed and profit.

This is not just in the U.S. Canada is following the U.S. decline in democracy very, very closely. So is Britain. So is Russia. So is China. That's why I don't refer to these countries as full democracies or even as dictatorships. They are all owned and controlled by the very rich.

 Greece and Ukraine have both effectively lost democracy. Both are now governed by international bankers.

What all this has led to over centuries and to this day is the social destruction of countries all over the world. Stable societies no longer exist for Latin America, Africa, the middle east, most of Asia. Nations have become simply a means to humiliate, bully, starve, kill people in order to make a profit for the very wealthy. And Canadian and American captialists are no angels in all this. Nor are we, even as we are victims of it. It's what we have always been - except in most history books.

That's why the story on the closing of churches caught my eye. No world can survive without a sense of morality.  (By the way, though I have been known to lead services, I have not gone to any church for five years. And I suspect most Christians wouldn't recognize me as one.) But morality, from some source, is essential to our survival. And we aren't getting any morality from 'capitalist' oligarchs turned loose to feed on us.

Wednesday, September 2, 2015

Sept. 2: A bad day at the Irving press.

For an opener, this warning. The report that Russia is intervening in the Syria war has been denied by Russia – and has not been supported by any other news source. It appeared on an Israeli site, Ynet News. But Russia has denied it, and there is no sign of any confirmation coming.

__________________________________________________________________________


Back in 1867, newsprint was expensive. The price of printing was expensive. And most people didn't have much money. So the only market for newspapers was the relatively well off. That meant the big news had to do with ship arrivals and investments, with only bits of news about the world. Then there were a few newspapers subsidized by political parties to spread their propaganda. A notable leader in this was the Toronto Globe, subsidized by the Liberal party. Another category, but a small one, was that of newspapers subsidized by churches. Altogether, their circulation was small, and their news very limited.

The technology of the late nineteenth century changed all that, making it possible to print the paper far more cheaply so that it could be sold for as little as one cent. Even in the 1940s, many Canadian newspapers still cost as little as three or four cents a copy. Just about anybody could afford a copy. And that added hugely to the value of the newspaper as an advertising device.

Quite suddenly, the newspaper became very, very profitable and, with their huge readership, very influential. But there were problems with all this.

To draw the readers, the papers had to come up with news that was exciting, often because of its propaganda appeal. At the end of the nineteenth century, the big news was about a brave English army officer, a colonel, who was valiantly and brilliantly holding off a massive force of Boers in a town in South Africa called Mafeking. His name was Colonel Baden Powell.

It went on for months with a public that couldn't read enough about this gallant Englishman, this living proof of British racial superiority.

When British troops relieved Mafeking, the army wanted to fire Baden Powell. It had taken a large party of the army months to get to Mafeking, a place Baden Powell wasn't supposed to be defending in the first place. In fact, he had been an incompetent ass in his defence of the town. But they couldn't fire him. He was a world hero. So they had to promote him to general. Baden Powell got their message, though, and invented a new career as founder of the Boy Scouts.

The newspapers won by playing this for sheer sensationalism. There was no attempt to find out the truth. Sensationalism sold papers. The truth didn't.

In the U.S. William Randolph Hearst took it a step further with his newspaper that spread propaganda favouring a war with Spain. It worked, as the U.S. began its overseas empire-building with the brutal conquest of The Philippines, and then its early interventions in China.

Newspapers became a big business, and so, necessarily owned by wealthy men. And they used it to make money out of sensationalism, and to make even more by using the propaganda power of the newspaper so they could get control of political decisions. The same thing happened in radio and TV with, for example, Fox News. Sensationalism and lying propaganda – those became the staples of almost all major news media in the world. (In Canada, CBC was an exception to the rule. But Harper will change that as soon as he can.)

The Irving press has carried on the tradition of sensationalism and propaganda, and added a third tradition of its own. It's boring.

The news in section A concentrates on boring.__________________________________________

The editorial is better than usual, if still short of smarts. It raises the issue of the decline of the village of Cape Tormentine, suggesting it should be an issue in the federal election because it is linked to the whole future of rural life in this province.

Sure, a Canada racked by concern about recession would certainly change the whole election as it realized the towering importance of rural New Brunswick to this whole nation.

The idea we should address this problem is a good one. But there is no way we can made this a federal issue. To say we can is just dumb. It's a provincial problem. And I have never read any provincial politician say anything about it – and I have never seen the Irving press offer an intelligent suggestion.

The future of rural New Brunswick is an important problem. It raises issues of transportation, medical care, education for both children and adults. And I don't see how closing schools and firing teachers is going to help in solving the problem. Of course, it does solve the problem of saving money so that the premier can give more welfare to the rich. That may be why the Irving press hasn't said much about it.

Why not? Well, it's safe bet that the owner of the Irving press has not the slightest interest in rural News Brunswick except cutting down its trees with cheap labour, and exploiting its minerals for as much profit as possible for him.

The first rule of our form of capitalism is that people don't matter. Only profits matter. (Oh, and they should be hidden to avoid paying taxes on them.)

Norbert treats us to the greatest issue of the day facing this province. He says we should be allowed to bring in beer from Quebec. In a way, making that a big issue manages to be both irrelevant and low-level sensationalism.

Hump Cormier doesn't have commentary. He has cute little story about how he doesn't like dark rooms. And he gets paid for this crap. When will this newspaper learn what a commentary is?

The guest editorial is, we are told, by the vice-president of Canada's leading Christian think tank. It's called Cardus. I've never heard of it. But here's a hint – if the byline has to tell you it's our leading Christian think tank, it almost certainly isn't.

I am sympathetic to its declared goal of bringing religious (but, apparently, only Christian) values into social planning. But I would like to know much more about its funding, and the qualifications of its researchers. As for this commentary, few will read it because it's confusingly written, has hints of political bias, and, in the end, really doesn't say anything. Nor do I see any hint of religious roots in his concern for the way we elect people.

The headline for the story, by the way (a headline usually written by the editor) has no link that I can see to the message (if any) of the commentary.

Alec Bruce saves the day for the whole paper with an excellent column on renewable energy. However, I don't think the boss will like that column. There's no money for the boss in renewable energy.

Section B is a disaster area with big stories on “Accused in Pokemon competition threat case denied bail (Boston); “Kentucky clerk still refuses to issue same-sex marriage licenses”. This is just sensationalism, if at a very low level. I suppose it might thrill people who have a sexual climax when they see dogs sniffing each other.

The only interesting story is on B4. The RCMP has laid a charge about a former Syrian intelligence officer for torturing a Syrian-born Canadian named Maher Arar. Now, get this.

In 2002, Arar was detained in New York, and deported to Syria where he was immediately jailed. Obviously, this was arranged between Syria and U.S. intelligence – and it seems to have been based on false information from the RCMP.

There, he was tortured. (How awful. Americans and Canadians would never do that.)

The charge will never lead to arrest, of course. The torturer is still in Syria and in the middle of a war. But there's an even more intriguing element. Somebody, presumably in the RCMP, is quoted as saying this will send a strong message to people who commit terrible abuses in faraway prisons.

What an absurd statement!

An unenforceable charge is going to send a strong message?

Okay. So when does Canada send a strong message for the illegal detention and prolonged torture of Omar Khadr? Why didn't Harper lead the way in standing up for a Canadian citizen? When do we or any other country plan to send arrest warrants to Bush and Obama for the thousands they imprisoned and tortured – and almost certainly are still torturing? - not to mention the torturing of Americans that still goes on in American prisons.

In fact, in all these years, not a single person involved in decades of massive U.S. torture has been accused of anything Nor has any accusation been made against Canadian officials who cooperated with it.

The only people who now face prison or, quite likely, death are the few who had the honesty and courage to release the truth of what was going on.

Tell me how Canada and the U.S. are any different from Nazi Germany or Fascist Italy.

Just to read that dreadful statement….”….will send a strong message...” is enough to make one feel ill at our hypocrisy and sanctimony. For an historian, it's dismaying to see what we have done to what was once one of the most highly respected police forces in the world. I thought of that when I saw the camouflage gang with combat rifles at an anti-fracking demonstration here in New Brunswick. Now we have this story of a further decay created by Harper's kissing up to the U.S. and its fascist ways.

And the editor who wrote that headline should have had the brains to know that the headline is NOT what this story is about. It is NOT about a charge being laid because it will never be enforced. It's about the moral decay of Canada, the U.S. ( and more than a few others) who welcome the fascist states we have become. Fascism and capitalism are close friends. A major feature of Mussolini's fascism is that it made big business automatically a part of any government

In sum, we really need much commentary, informed commentary (and not about somebody who doesn't like dark rooms).

The news story, as rule, tells us very little. We need to know the background to the news if we're going to understand it. That's why I wrote so much about Chinese history in yesterday's blog. Reading the news is just not a very good way to learn the meaning of the news. We need informed (and honest) commentary. The best media for that are newspapers and radio. People are involved in radio and media. With TV, they just look at the changing shapes and colours.

But most commentary in the Irving press is trash. And most radio is just a modern equivalent of the old Juke-box.
____________________________________________________________________________

For a look at what is happening in the middle east, see the site below.




The next site below deals with a ruling from the World Trade Organization that India must give up a massive plan for renewable energy. The reason? It discriminates against foreign capitalists by cutting into their oil profits, and not giving them a piece of the action. We're in for this sort of thing – and much more – if Harper gets his Trans-Pacific trade deal through.






Tuesday, September 1, 2015

September 1: The importance of fiction.

Damn. I spent hours on a long blog - and lost  it all. So this will deal with the same themes, but be much shorter.

Norbert Cunningham's column today deserves a careful read and some serious thinking. It's about what he calls national 'fictions'. We live in a world of reality - hills, trees, sun. But we also, as societies, depend on things which depend on fiction. A piece of paper money, even of a thousand dollars - has no value in reality.  It's just a piece of paper. But we make it into something important to us. National boundaries have no reality. They hadn't existed for millions of years until they were created in our minds Religion is not a reality (unless it's yours). It's a construct that we have all reconstructed many times. The royal family is royal only because we say it is.

These 'fictions' and many more, including patriotism,  are made up by us. And they're important because they are part of a large package called national culture that tells us how we should live and behave.

Norbert goes off to some very false conclusions in his final paragraph in which he repeats silly ideas he has been pushing for years. But his main point is a valid one, and worth thinking about.  No society can survive or be stable without its fictions.

And that takes us to China's recession.

China is a nation thousands of years in the making. In those years, 'fictions' of religion and governance and changing boundaries, 'fictions' of behaviour and social roles created a Chinese nation of peoples who, millenia ago, had little resemblance to each other.

With the development of reliable sea transport in the western world of 500 years ago, it became possible for western countries to reach almost every part of the world and, with superior weapons, to defeat them.

That's what happened to our native peoples. The attraction of the Americas was land and gold. The attraction of China was, at first, tea. Europeans, led by the British, couldn't get enough of it. And the huge population of China suggested even greater possibilities in trade

That's when British capitalists used their control of the British government to send soldiers (cheap at pennies a day, but fired by talk of patriotism and glory) to conquer India and to give large areas of fertile land to British capitalists who then used dirt cheap Indian labour to grow and process opium.

The big market, obviously, would be China. The Chinese government, though, made opium illegal. So, the capitalists went back to the British government which then sent ships and soldiers to fight the "opium wars" with China. Again - lots of waving flags, cheers for the British heroes, glory, God bless the king...  With their superior weaponry, the British beat the Chinese, and forced them to sign what, to this day, is remembered as 'The Great Humiliation'. China was forced to accept the importation and sale of opium. Worse. The British set a minimum, yearly quota for payment. It's hard to make a comparison with today, but in today's money, it would probably be billions. China had to pay whether all the opium was sold or not sold.

Thus began over a century of decay, of the collapse of governments, the impoverishing of the people, of civil wars, of starvation, collapse of traditional religion. All those fictions that sustained a Chinese society collapsed.

(I might add that the bulk of the British people got nothing out of this "job creation". Most lived in vile conditions. Only the capitalists got richer.)

Wei Yuan, a Chinese scholar, was the first to understand what was happening. He had realized, even before 1840, that the fictions of Chinese society were being destroyed and, with them, the nation of China, itself. He was the first to realize that China had to redevelop itself by adopting some of the ways of the west while not becoming simply an extension of the west.  That's why he started with a revision of Confucianism so that the fiction of Confucionism and, with it, China, could survive. Otherwise, China would cease to exist. (It was a brilliant insight. You should read about him Norbert. He was brilliant. He set the stage for the transformation of the biggest nation on earth. And he wasn't a businessman. He was - get this, Norbert - a civil servant.)

There followed years of struggle, of civil war, of even more intrusion by British, Portuguese, Americans, all of whom increased the damage. It got much worse in the 1920s with the rise of Chiang Ki Sheck, a henchman of the biggest drug dealer in the world, a dependent on U.S. capitalism and, of course, a convert to Christianity.

But it was Mao Zedong who emerged as the winner. He was certainly brutal (as the leaders of most major powers, espcially the Christian ones, always have been); and he was dealing with towering economic and social problems after the years of chaos. But he did bring order back to China, and saved it for the selective choices China has made since to be able to defend itself (as it proved as early as the Korean War), to adapt to western economics. In short, without Mao, for all his brutality and murder, there probably would not be a Chinese nation today, just a sinkhole of poverty and misery created by western capitalists over the last, several centuries.

China has reinvented its 'fictions'. It still has a way to go. But there is a Chinese nation, and there are a Chinese people again.

Understanding this is fundamental to understanding what is happening in the world today. Western capitalism, unregulated capitalism, is still breaking down the 'fictions' of societies all over the world. And the loss of those fictions has meant chaos death, starvation, refugees, horror, espcially in the Middle East and Africa.

Its not because of Islam. It's not even because of extremist Islamics. They are not the cause. They are the result of what capitalism has done in destroying the fictions and cultures of societies.

Capitalism has only one reason for existence - to make profit for its owners. It has no moral code, no concern for people, no sense of what a society is. It does not even exist to create jobs. It creates jobs unwillingly, and at the cheapest possible price. That's why children are working (sometimes for Canadian companies) as early as age 5 for pennies a day in places like Central America, Congo, Haiti...

That's why the greatest challenge facing our world is to bring capitalism under control. I'm afraid, though, the U.S. is a lost cause. Capitalism has, since 1775, stifled American thought with its own fiction of a history that never really happened, and a society that never has been one society. That's what has taken us to Donald Trump and Sarah Pailin.

Having a fiction is necessary for any society. But having a fiction with no reality at all  almost certainly leads to a breakdown - as we may be watching even now in the U.S.

I thought of China today, because it's in a recession. Since it is now a major trade partner, that's bad news for us. And it could be dangerous news for China. Is its fiction now strong enough  to carry it through a recession? Or is it in for more breakdown and disorder?

Before you cheer for the latter, consider that China has a huge nuclear arsenal.
_______________________________________________________________________
The lesson of all this is also why I choose the party I vote for in Canada. Unregulated capitalism is and always has been a destructive force in society. That's because it doesn't give a damn for society. It lives only for its own profit. It keeps Central America in poverty, hunger and misery while stealing its resources. (The Cuban revolution didn't happen just because Castro was an evil, cigar-smoking man.)

I look for the party whose first priority is the needs of a society. Neither the Liberals nor the Conservatives are in that category. Nor has either of them shown any interest in regulating capitalism in the last 60 years.
____________________________________________________________________________
The Irving press didn't have much in it today. Almost all the stories were trivial and of no importance.

B1 leads with the story that premier Gallant is all excited at the need for a natural gas pipeline through New Brunswick. That's an odd thing to get excited about when we're already experiencing climate change, and experiencing it so obviously that even billionaires don't lie about it any more. Got any thrills of excitement to share on that, Mr. Gallant?

B4 has a story about a grenade exploded by protesters outside the Ukraine parliament in Kyev. It has all you need to know except the identities of the protesters. No, they weren't russo rebels from the east. They seem to have been mostly from western Ukraine, and from a sizable group in that land of freedom. They're called Naziis. The real thing.

The editorial is trivial and brainless. The City View commentary claims to be about taking the bus to work. In fact, it's all useless chatter about AC/DC coming to Moncton. I can get more interesting reading in a tabloid that has headlines like "Darling Prince George does first piddle in toily-woily."

The guest column is, again, from a propaganda house financed by billionaires. (Simon Fraser Institute). Simon would have been so embarassed!

And I have just one  quibble with Alec Bruce. The New Brunswick law that bans the importation of beer from Quebec is not really the result of prohibition. It became a law because of prohibition. But it was kept a law for reason that had nothing to do with prohibition, and everything to do with liquor profits. Prohibition is much misunderstood. I'm a bit sensitive about that because long ago, I did an article on  it for a book called, I think, "Oliver Mowat's Ontario."

I also have seen a story that I cannot confirm. It is that Russia is sending troops and aircraft to defend Syria against ISIS. If so, the U.S. (and Harper) will be wildly indignant. But Russia has as much right to be there as we do - more, actually. It has a longstanding treaty with Assad's Syria, and Syria is important to the Russian economy.

However, if the story is true, this could be very dangerous.

The official policy of the U.S., stated by Obama and others, is American Exceptionalism which means the U.S. has the right to do whatever it wants anywhere in the world, regardless of the law. In short, it means the U.S. rules the world. And Putin, for all his faults, is not a man to be bluffed. And the U.S. is in election mode.

I'll try to check this story out.

And so to bed.