Thursday, November 7, 2013

Nov. 7: I just can't keep up....

I have pages of notes on blunders and shabby journalism by the Irving press. But I can't use them because every day, I am overwhelmed by ths lastest and numerous travesties that appear in these papers.


Today, we're treated to yet a another big, front-page story about garbage collection in Moncton. I'm not sure how many days (or weeks) this has been a feature story in the Moncton Times and Transcript but "frankly Scarlett, I don't give a damn."

The story, by Cole Hobson, is well reported - but it's still tripe. Hobson is too good to waste his life in the Irving press.. He should be making contacts in the real world.

Then page 3 and two (count them) two ads for the casino - disguised as news stories. On p. 7, there's a big news story (ad) about a pastry shop that is now going to serve meals.

In fact, the only news story in Section A worth reading at all  (and again by Cole Hobson) is about a report on the state of the rail industry to be released soon. The rail system is not only neglected and  unsafe; there appears to be deadly abuse of it.

Alas, this report doesn't look at the surely criminal neglect of our tracks or the abuses by shippers or the government's secrecy about railway safety regulations  (if there are any).  It doesn't take a hard look - or a look at all - at Lac Megantic.

This is a report about the neglect of Via Rail and the decline of passenger service. In a way, the report doesn't matter because Harper won't be doing anything, anyway. But it is a problem we should know about.

So passeth Section A.
_________________________________________________________________________

Meanwhile, we are living in days that will be staples of every Canadian history book for generations. There's a story  about it "Questons raised over senators" on Section C, p. 1. Alas, it's completely off the point. It's from The Canadian Press, whose reporters seem to be a clueless lot.

The great issue is NOT whether suspended senators will lose their dental iinsurance, etc. The issue is that Senate had no power to suspend them in the first place. The Senate has broken the law according to the Canadian constitution.

If the three senators have created a crime, then there should be charges laid, and they should face a ciminal court. That is the law. It is not only the law; the right to know the precise charge and to be able to offer a defence in the courts is fundamantal to any democracy. Senate has not only broken the law according to the Canadian contutuion; it has denied a right fundamental to any democracy.

The Senate did that to protect the Prime Minister from another fundamental rule of a democracy. It's not a law. But it is still essential to any democracy. The Prime Minister must not lie to the House of Commons.

Harper has lied, if only by ommission. He has avoided the fundamental question. He knew that Duffy and Wallin lived in Ontario. He knew that the constitution plainly requires senators to have their main residences in the provinces they represent. So when he appointed Duffy and Wallin, he knew he was breaking the law.

But he has refused to answer that question - and the Senate suspensions are a way of dancing away from the issue. So the Prime Minister has arranged for Senate to break the law.

This has never before happened in Canadian history. Nobody can guess the consequences of this, and of the precedent it sets. But they could be serious, indeed. But what Irving press gives us in its big story is some mindless drivel about senatorial dental plans.

This a a prime example of why we need opinion columns in a newspaper, to deal with the meanings of the news. But what do we get?

We get the usual, half-wit editorial on the "events centre".  We get Red Allen babbling in what he thinks is sophisticated wit about something nobody cares about. And, really, the old joke about wife no. 1 is  quite played out. Give it a rest.
_______________________________________________________________
Most of News Today is a big story about ten people getting the Order of N.B. (I've never before seen such an  award-happy province. Is there anybody left who doesn't have an order of NB?)

Then we have half a page on two people named humanitarians of the year. One of the them,  I'm sure, deserved it. As for the other - well being a humanitarian is a lot cheaper than paying taxes. And you get an award for it.

oh, yeah. Then there's a half page of pictures of people getting awards.
______________________________________________________________

Another oh,yeah. Alward is going to require lobbyists (people who bribe politicians) to register as lobbyists (so that the process will be more open and transparrent.)

Come off it, Alward. We already know quite well who bribes the government in New Burnswick. And that has done nothing to make it open or transparent. The US has registered lobbyists for many, many years. And in the US, the lobbyists actually run the country while making the elected congressmen multimillionaires.. I don't see how it has made the slightest difference in anything.

Tell you what, Alward, if you really want an open and transparent government, why not just give the lobbyists the boot? Then the people running the province would be the ones we elect. Wouldn't that be nicer?
_____________________________________________________________

The editorial (yet again) assures us that an "events centre" would be profitable. Great. So let the people who are going to get the profit pay for it.   Isn't that the way capitalism is supposed to work? What are you at the TandT - a bunch of commies?

Alec Bruce is not at his best. He describes anti-shale gas people as ones who are defending the people against big, bad corporations; and are taking a stand in the absence of a trustworthy, faithful government. Then he adds that such talk is a lot of nonsense.

Chap shot, Alec. And not one of your brighter moments.

Are you seriously suggesting that big corporations are run by sweethearts who do only good to othets?
Are you suggesting we HAVE a government that is trustworthy and faithful? If so, I  suggest you are the one who is talking nonsense.

Beth Lyons has far the best column in today's paper.
________________________________________________________________

And, once again, I have no space to list the stories that the TandT missed. such as -

1. The CIA and the US army has been using medical doctors to be activly involved in torture - helping the torturers, not the victims. And that is, to put it kindly,  highly unprofessional.
2. We have had few details on the Canada-Europe trade deal. But remember this. It is not standard practice to permit companies to break environmental regulations and to ignore other Canadian laws.
If what they do becomes so harmful that government feels it has to step in and stop the damage, then the foreign company has the right to sue the government for what it claims are lost profits.

That's right kiddies. A foreign company can come here, pollute wildly, destroy whole regions sicken and even kill people - and if the government tries to stop them, they can sue for billions. It's been done. Often.  Oh, brave new world.

3. It looks as though a Syrian peace deal can't go ahead because the UN, with US agreement, says the rebels must take part. The US also says that Assad must not be a candidate in any future election.

What the hell is going on?

Why should the rebels even be asked to attend talks on the future of Syria? Most of them aren't Syrian. They're foreigners. They're illegal invaders.

As for a rule that Assad cannot be a candidate in an election - why? the whole point is to establish a democracy. In a democracy, the people decide who will rule them. What gives the US the right to decide who can run in a democratic election in another country?

It's looks as thought these talks are being set up to fail.

4. As Israeli/Palstinian peace talks resume, Israel is bulldozing the homes of 15,000 Palestinians who are Israeli citizens living in Jerusalem. It is also accelerating it annexations of Palestinian territory, expelling the palesinians and destroying their homes, then giving the land to Israelis.

So that looks like another peace negotiation being set up for failure.

But don't worry. If you read the Tand T , you don't have to even know about these things.
 

Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Nov. 6: Keeping New Brunswick in a stupor...

The national story today that cried for an op ed opinion was ignored. We got an op ed piece that it's a good thing we have emergency services preparing for any railway accident in the city. That gem of wisdom comes from Eric Lewis.  Mr. Lewis,  I think most of us figured that out for ourselves when we read the news story on it.

And Brian Cormier....well,  he's Brian Cormier.

Meanwhile, in real news -

The Senate has accused three members of criminal behaviour, and   assigned a punishment of suspension without pay. This is not a minor matter. It is one hell of a precedent for the political future of this country. Unlike any other institution outside the judicial system, the Senate has given itself the right to declare behaviour illegal and to punish the accused without trial. We're getting more like the US every day.

No commentator thought this worthy of mention. In fact, the only commentary is an excellent letter to the editor by Donald Goodspeed of Bathurst.  It's just too bad the editor can't read.

No,  I'm not defending the behaviour of the three senators. And I can assure you those three are not the only ones worth looking at. But a basic prinicple of a free country is that one cannot be convicted and punished without a trial. So what aren't we seeing one?

We're not - because the central figure responsible for all this is Stephen Harper. He is the man who appointed t hose three and, quite correctly, he is the one now looking bad and with a re-election in trouble. Best to appear to take action (with all the blame on the senators).  But to do that in a court of law  would almost certainly bring out further evidence about Harper's complicity. Thus the Senate suspension. But, oh, there are dangers.

Senators do not appoint themselves. So where to they get the right to fire each other? The dangers of that in a roomful of political enemies should be obvious. Even worse, the precedent could logically extend to the House of Commons, the ones WE elect, as the governing party suspends opponents to make sure its legislation goes through with little opposition.

That nice nice Mr. Harper wouldn't do such a thing? Oh, yes he would. - there is no prime minister in Canadian history who has ever shown such an utter contempt for democractic practice.

This is a matter for the police, not the Senate. To act as the Senate has is a major break in our democratic tradition. And you can bet that the Conservative senators did not act without orders from Harper.

Boy. Good thing we have an MP like Goguen to stand up for the rights of the people.
________________________________________________________________________
Even when he's (mostly) right Norbert cannot help insinuating and sneering with his choice of words. In just one sentence, native opponents to shale gas are "radical" (Norbert - you don't know what tradical means, do you?); They are agitators (actually most of othe agitating here has been done by a lying and manipulating government supported by a lying and maniputlating press); and they're just "grandstanding". (The word grandstanding, by the way, would mean that they're not serious. Really, Norbert, you should get a good dictionary.)

By contrast, p. A7 has a quite professional report by Shawn Berry on the shale gas protest at the legislature yesterday.
_____________________________________________________________________________

Most notably, this newspaper has not yet had a word about the most serious and immediate crisis facing the whole world - the rapid collapse of the US, and the bungling that has taken it there.


It begins with American governments that have been bought and paid for for years by big business. It's right out in the open. Representatives of big business are a major part of the scenery in Washington. They are there to get legislation their bosses want - and they pay well for it. I don't even know of anybody who denies that. The result is that politicians and influential people in Washington become very, very wealthy.

It's become even more open in the last fifteen years as big business has taken over complete control of American government. That's was obvious when Dick Cheney, a very high profile oil executive, became VP under George Bush. (and both George and his daddy became ultra wealthy out of politics.)

Big business took open, direct, obvious and total control of American economic and foreign policy. (This is Norbert's idea of heaven.) American democracy is dead - much deader than it was under King George IV.

And American economy and foreign affairs are a disaster. Of course they are. Big business is hopelessly incompetent to run any country. It is way too short-sighted, and way too much focussed on its own greed.

In just over a dozen years, it has made the United States the most hated country in the world. It has utterly destroyed any confidence in the US as a world leader or partner. Even it's steadiest supporters like Britain, France and Germany are backing off.

Its power and influence are so reduced, it now goes meekly and apologetically even to small nations which depend on it for their very existence - as Israel and Saudi Arabia. (Now there's a mixed bag of friends).

It is distrusted for its massive spying programme, much of which has nothing to do with terrorists, but with spying out secrets to benefit American (and Canadian) big busines.

Everybody in politics knows that the US is  financially a disaster, that it is not going to recover, and that it's debt is so huge it can never be paid. They know that within a very short time the American dollar will collapse. That's why dozens of countries that once scampered to please the US now give it the finger.

It has not sunk in to us - though it has certainlysink in to many Americans. The American empire that began with the conquest of native lands is collapsing, and collapsing fast. It now faces nations like China, Russia, Brazil, India, South Africa that are eclipsing its economic power. Even Australia and Japan, both heavily dependent on the US to now, are shirting their focus to China, and have abandoned their use of the US dollar for much of their trade.

While Norbert babbles about the brilliance of big business, it has destroyed American power and prosperity - forever, and destroyed it by its own greed and incompetence. Democracy works better, Norbert, it really does.

Now, as  Africa and the middle east seem near to explosion, American big business has to face a huge decision. The longer it waits, the more it loses to the rising powers, especially.China. So -

when does it decide that a war to save the power of the rich is now or never. When does it decide it has to use its nuclear arseanl - now or never.

Is big business arrogant enough and dumb enough to do that? It has certainly shown it has the makings.

Tuesday, November 5, 2013

Nov. 5: The light brigade in the valley of death....

For some years, I taught Canadian military history. I taught about, for example, the destruction of the Royal Newfoundland Regiment. I spoke of their order to charge across a long, open field swept by the fire of hidden, German machine guns. They rose obediently, and began a "charge" which, for men weighted down with  packs and ammunition and weapons could only be a slow trudge.

Not one made it to the German line. In fact, it is likely that not one even fired  his rifle. And across Newfoundland, in most of the outports in which every eligible man, fathers and husbands and sons, had volunteered and gone with the regiment,  not one returned.

It was horrribly sad. It's a story of terrible suffering both at the front and at home. It was courage.

What it bloody well was not was glory.

It's an old game.You  take a disaser of suffering and death (and killing), and tart it up as the next thing to sainthood. When the British Light Brigade charged into the mouths of cannon in the Crimean War they did it because of ignorance and clumsiness at the command level. And there was nothing glorious as the survivors fled in panic through a valley lined with Russian gunners. And most of them stayed in that valley, never to run anywhere again. It was one of the greatest defeats of the British army.

But to the propagandists, even a disastrous defeat can be made into a victory. And so the poet, Tennyson, wrote of it:

"When can their glory fade?
O the wild charge they made."

A Canadian clergyman, without the benefit of poetic talent, told Canadian troops in  Afghanistan they were doing an important job. Onward Christian soldiers. I have no idea what he can possibly have meant by that. And, if is was so damned important, why were most Canadians pulled out in the middle of the war?

I suppose there were chaplains like that with the Canadian "peacekeepers" who went to Haiti to destroy the only democratic government that country had ever had, and to replace him with an American puppet. And there must have been some with the Canadian airmen who bombed a Libya that couldn't shoot back.

Glory. Glory.

On p. 1.is a news item "Project teaches youths about military glory". It's about a veterans' association that lobbies schools to include Canada's war history (especially its glory in the history curriculuum.)


Sure. And will we teach about the reputation of Canadians as killers of prisoners in World War One? Will we talk about torture? (Oh, of course. Canadians never do that.) Will we talk about the glory of bombing hundreds of thousands of civilians to death?

And, to be fair, we'd have to include the glory of the Japanese who captured over a thousand Canadians at Hong Kong, and sent them into camps that destroyed the health and the lives of most of them.

And then there's the courage and glory of the German soldiers who killed so many Canadians in Italy, France, The Netherlands and Germany.

Then there was Bertie who played with me though he was sixteen and I was only nine. Bertie was severely retarded, and had left school in grade four. He was big for sixteen. So it was easy to lie about his age and join the army. He just loved those army boots that made a clicking sound on the pavement. His parents could have stopped him. But they were too drunken and irresponsible to bother.

Bertie was still sixteen when he saw his first action - or as well as it could be seen with his face in the mud and him shaking with terror  as a machine gun sprayed the air above him. Suddenly, he leaped to  his feet, screaming for this mother. And the machine gun cut him in half.  Glory, glory.

I taught military history to officers in the reserves, and even to a few in the regulars, including a Lieutenant-Colonel. I spoke of suffering, of murder of civilians, of torture, of the killing of prisoners (yes, we did that), of courage amounting heroism. But never of glory - and my students would not have bought it for a minute if I had. Some of them had seen action. They knew there was no glory.

"Onward, the Light Brigade"

Schools don't teach military history because they have to teach the truth. And if they taught the whole truth about war, they'd have to talk about the base motives - on both sides - for war, about the horrors we have committed as well as those our enemies have. And if schools told the the whole truth, then they'd have the whole "O Canada" super patriot crowd banging on the doors in fury.

But whatever the "O Canada"s might think, school is not the place to teach propaganda.


Even the news story was written as propaganda. Its opening sentence reads, "When British Prime Minister David Cameron visited the Canadian Parliament.....he praised Canada's efforts in the Second World War as being the main reason England is a free country today. Sure.

And if I ever visit a home with a new baby, I shall look at that ugly and squawking blot on the decor, and say, "What a lovely baby."

Canada's role was important - but scarcely decisive. One can safely say the entry of Russia and the US had far more to do with saving British freedom (so that the British, for a time, at least, could continue to deny freedom to people in Africa, India, Malaya, Iran....)

We owe our veterans. We owe them big time. They owe us the right to tell the truth and nothing but the truth. Isn't that what the wars were all about?

Nov. 11 is not about glory. It's about remembering sacrifice, unspeakable brutality and cruelty on all sides, about synicism. It's about mothers who had to cope, alone, for years while their husbands were away, some women whose husbands had joined because the family had to eat, or because they were patriotic, or because they just wanted to dump the old woman and the kids - and have fun. (I had an uncle who was one of those. He was at Dieppe, too.)

Nov. 11 is about remembering all of that. All of it. It's remembering that war is about courage; it's about the fullest measure of evil, it's about remembering suffering and sacrifice; it's about children who lost their fathers - some for years and some forever.

Nov. 11 is not about glory. It's about gratitude and remembering out debt. It's not about glory.

But that's what we've made it into.
____________________________________________________________________
Woooo. That one did go on. But there's not much else in the paper. It doesn't, for example, carry the news that the Transport Safety Board has made it official. The crude oil shipment that hit Lac Megantic was mislabelled -and the blame for that lies with some oil company called Irving. (We'll see if it makes tomorrow's paper.)

It also said that all railway regulations are secret. Gee! I wonder why.
_________________________________________________________________________
Norbert has a good, tough column on Rob Ford. I'll have some respect for him when he writes a similar column about some powerful person in this province.

The editorial is, as usual, pretty brainless.

There's an op ed piece by Brian Gallant, presumably to convince us to vote for him.  His most striking statement is "We need leadership....and we need...a plan"  Wow! Way to blaze it baby. That's laying it one the line. I've never heard a polician say anything so radical before. Yeah. We need leadership.  And a plan. Yeah. A plan. That should do it.

Oh, oh. Not just a plan. "We need goals". Damn right. And the goals have to be realistic. You tell 'em, Brian. No point in unrealistic plans.

Boy, he reminds me of another brilliant politician I know - a guy named Alward.

What young Brian does not tell us in this third of a page of infantile and pointless babbling is on what principles he and his party base themselves. Do they have any common morals or values that they base their "leadership" and "plans" on? What are the responsibilities of a government? What are our obligations to each other?  Do they feel that corporations should be under some sort of control? Or do they share Norbert's view that they should be allowed to do whatever they like?

This guy makes Alward look like a deep thinker.
______________________________________________________________

I had so much more to say for today because the world is in such a dangerous situation, especially regarding Syria and Iran (and then all of us), that it beats the Cuban missile crisis of the sixties. But I guess that will have to wait.

Meanwhile, a warning for this province.

If there is a renewal of the blockade at Rexton - and there should be - violence can help only one side - the side of the government and the gas companies.

Would SWN or the government provoke a crisis? You can bet your very last dollar that they would, and there's a strong possibility they will. They can do something sparked by company security guards, and made to look as though natives started it. They might even be able to buy off a few people on the reserve (just as if they were professors of ecology) to slip a few guns into the encampment.

Remember Alward's hysterical statement that the last encampment was an "armed camp" because they found three guns in it? That's a stunt that still has legs. Just a few guns slipped in would cover any evidence that the government or the company was actually what had caused the trouble. Even a few knives might do it.

I think it almost certain that something like this will be attempted. The company is too brutal to care what damage it might do. And Mr. Alward---ah---Mr. Alward is not intellectually gifted.

A blockade is the only response possible with people who won't listen. But this one will need very, very tight control by native organizers.






 

Monday, November 4, 2013

Nov. 4: Cheap and sloppy Monday...

There really is a pattern to the Irving press. Monday is always something thrown together in a few minutes with almost no news about anything, anywhere, and no news ever for New Brunswick worth reporting.

This one, though, has one, blockbuster news story that New Brunswickers bloody well should think long and hard about. Indeed, it has serious implications that go well beyond New Brunswick and even beyond Canada.

First, just a quick review of stories the Irving press was too lazy and/or ignorant to pick up.
_________________________________________________________________________
1. Polls show four out of five Canadians approve of the Europe trade deal. Sound good?
Well, think of this. Two of five Canadians are functionally illiterate. Of the remaining three, it's a safe best that most don't know what's in the treaty - and wouldn't  have enough training to make a judgement even if they did know.

So much for the wonderful world of statistics - you know, the things we use in Lean Six to make political and business decisions.

2. The rash of train derailmeents involving hazardous goods continues. There have been at least two in the past week, both with explosions and fires. How come the news media aren't asking the obvious questions?
We know that the Lac Megantic crash came after a change in regulations. What changes in regulations have there been in last dozen years or so? Who made them? Why? Who requested them? Why have we seen no results of any research or investigation of this? Have the changes in regulations resulted in lower costs for some shipppers?
These are obvious questions. How come the Irving press doesn't ask them?

3. A recent edition of the Wall Street Journal, a not unrespectable business paper, suggests that shale gas is a flash in the pan. Unlike oil, it is typically found in small "sweet spots" that usually play out within a few years. That means that searching for of drilling new holes is a constant and very expensive business which can made shale gas very expensive. Some recent ones in the US are expected to go dry by 2017. Shale gas, it says, is expensive, and short term.

So much for opening a new era for New Brunswick. So much for risking our health and environment. Duh, it'll create jobs and prosperity for New Brunswick.

No. What it will create is some short term jobs. And quick profits for SWN and the Irvings, etc. before the bubble bursts. We'll be left with the wreckage.

4. Over the next four years, the US plans to downsize its military by 1.2 million. I'm not at all sure that's going to be possible but, if it is done, 1.2 million veterans, many of them disoriented by their experience, will be one hell of a load to drop on a society in which poverty is at record levels. I wonder how many will be returning to live in Detroit where the real unemployment level (not the official one) is probably well over 50%. And how will they react to the cut in food stamps - which tens of millions of Americans rely on to (barely) stay alive - a cut made to spend more billions on weapons.

As well, many of them will be former special-ops troops. I have known a few of them. I worked with one for thirty years. Psychiatrists say many of them are in special ops because they like violence and they like killing. They aren't patriots. They're seriously disturbed people. That was certainly my experience of the ones I knew. That opinion has been echoed in a number of US publications including USA Today - which may not be a great publication, but is certainly not a left-wing, liberal, ignorant,communist, anti-Norbert Cunningham publication.

Discharged veterans could be a very interesting addition the US population in these troubled times.

But don't worry. None of this will ever appear in the Irving press.

______________________________________________________________________
The big story is on p. 1 (a rarity). "Another blockade possible in shale gas protest".

Alward, of course, calls for law and order. Of course. He (and Irving) made the laws, and they'll give the orders.  Besides, "law and order' sounds good. It sounds proper. It sounds respectable, very Christian - though Jesus was crucified because some powerful people say him as a threat to law and order. (We can be sure, though, that nobody will ever make that accusation against his wimpy churches.)

Anyway, Alward doesn't even know what law and order means..

When Hitler rounded up millions of Jews and blacks and gays and Romas, that was the law at work. And when these people lined up to get on the freight trains that would take them to death camps, they were being orderly.

By Alward's declared standards, this was law and order.

When the Americans and the the French took up arms in revolutions to establish republics, they were being unlawful and disorderly. Mr. Alward would have been on the other side.

Law and order don't usually break down just becaue of rebellion. They break down because of government that uses law and order in an abusive way. Alward refuses to speak with one native leader because that leader has already decided against shale gas. Has it not occured to  him (or the TandT), that the reverse is also true, that there is no point to native discussion with Alward because he has already decided For shale gas.

Mr. Alward has lied and manipulated on this issue from the start. So I think we should be able to understand why native peoples are not eager to line up to get on the freight cars for the death camps.

 If the government were to order you to do something which you were convinced would damage you, your land and water, with a damage that would last for your life, your children's lives and their children's lives, would you do it?

Surely,  the law requires us to protect our land, ourselves and our children. So if we do it, shouldn't the RCMP be surrounding the offices of SWN with armed police and "paramilitary" snipers? And shouldn't they be arresting Mr. Alward for causing disorderly behaviour?

What has now developed is an extremely dangerous situation. It was created by Mr. Alward who tried to force native peoples to allow themselves to be abused.. SWN is ruthless and powerful; there is no evidence it gives a damn for human life.

It is quite possible that blood will be shed this time. And no matter who 'starts it' and whose blood is shed, that blood will be on Mr. Alward's hands for having created this situation as he lied and manipulated and crawled to please his bosses.

The Irving press won't notice that. The Norbert Cunningham bigot club won't notice it. All of those people who thought that Mr. Harper's racist pamphlet on native peoples (thoughtfully distributed by smirker Goguen) won't notice it.

But the rest of the world will. And Canada will suffer one hell of a loss in reputation, one that will cost us,  - as well as more bloodshed across this country and, quite possibly, the US.

As to native peoples, their guiding point has to be that they cannot win an exchange of violence. Whether violence is justified or not has nothing to do with it. The reality is that if there is violence, the government will win the fight every time. Those opposed to shale gas have to be on the receiving end of violence to win. So it's important to keep a lid on the nutbars. Make sure it's clear that all the nutbars are in the government and the shale gas companies.

As to Mr. Alward, stop lying on your back, waiting for Mr. Irving to scratch your unattractive belly. Start acting as though you really are the premier. Starting acting as though this province actually belongs to us, and not to any pirate company that comes through. In the name of human life and basic decency, tell SWN to get the hell out. That's what real law and order would be.

Do you have the courage to do that, Mr. Alward? Do you have the courage to kneel on the road with a feather of peace in your hand?

 

Sunday, November 3, 2013

Nov. 3: Just a few Sunday thoughts - with a special for university students on getting As.

But first -

There are few things more annoying that political arguments. And the annoyance is caused by those people whose discussion style is formed by their prejudices.  Such people will pick a side based entirely on their prejudices. And they generally have two approaches to the discussion.

One is to wander through the whole forest of opinions on the subject to look for one that is obviously wrong. And you will always find such wrong arguments on either side of any issue. They will then ignore the bulk of the discussion, and wave that one error as though it proves the other side is entirely wrong.

Or, they will simply pick up a report that says no gas company has ever been found guilty of poisoning land. Well, yeah. But that might have something to do with the fact that gas companies spend billions to keep such cases out of court in the first place.

In a variation which is even worse, a friend argued with me that today's Swedish socialism is based on Nazi Germany which was also socialist. Well - Sweden is not socialist. Never has been. A socialist country is not simply one that imployment insurance. It's a state in which most industry is owned by the government.

Most industry in Sweden is owned by private business.

And, in fact, Hitler's Germany was not socialist, either - though Hitler called his system National Socialism. Most industry in Nazi  Germany, by far, was owned by private business, including people like Henry Ford.

The other argument is the Norbert Cunningham strategy. Just let your prejudice be your guide - and call people names..

So let's be clear - and stick with facts that we really know..

The only medical report ever commissioned on shale gas in New Brunswick.was the one by our chief medical officer, Dr. Cleary. She, with the support of the whole, medical community advised that developing shale gas in New Brunswick was a highly risky thing to do.

She did NOT say that the strictest regulations in the world would prevent that. She said it was too risky to go ahead.

The Irving press gave  her report one day - and spent much of even that day's story in quoting people who were not experts but who said it was safe. Then, when medical opinion across Canada endorsed her view, the Irving press didn't bother to report it.

The Cleary report has NEVER been shown to be wrong by anyone who is an authority on medecine. NEVER.

You cannot make a report wrong by ignoring it or by making vague references to tougher regulations. You have to prove it wrong. Nobody has done that.

There has been no other study reported, so far as I know, not on health, not on financial benefits, not on environmental impace that has been made by any other group that is both authoritative and impartial. None. (And, no, don't trust the word an ex-politician, now a very rich man, who is everybody's friend who knows nothing of the subject, but who gets big coverage in the Irving press when he says shale gas is good for you.)

All we have, apart from the Cleary report,  is a farcical report by an academic fraud who is, apparently, a dear friend of Mr. Irvng, and who gathered his information from a few meetings with ordinary citizens who knew even less than he did about the subject.

In this latter case, the evidence at least suggests that Prof. Lapierre was bought. And, if so, it would seem most unlikely he was bought by the anti-shale gas side.

After a decade or so, our government has still not fully developed regulations. It has still not conducted an impartial and expert study of the effect on our land and water. It has not given us much information of any sort - and none at all that suggests any criticism of shale gas.

And the only impartial and expert report we have so far is the one the government and the industry simply ignored.

Anyone who can't put two and two together to make a flatulent four in this case must be mighty thick. All the above can prove is that we have been massively betrayed by this Conservative government, and by those who like to think of themselves as our economic leadership, and by the Liberal party which we all know will support shale gas once it gets elected.

Then there's the new argument that shale gas is less destructive than other fuels, and so will give us time to prepare for renewable energy that is non-polluting.

Sure.

I'm glad to see they at least recognizing that the world is warming, and we need new forms of energy. It's pretty hard to deny now that Arctic ice is disappearing and the eastern Arctic (the part above us) is now warmer than it's been in 140,000 years. And at some point, maybe soon, that warming becomes irreversible.

That means that even if shale is (which I doubt) less damaging than other fossil fuels, we still can't afford to let it happen We don't need damage that's growing more slowly. We need damage stopped - and time is limited.

And what are our business and political leaders doing about that?

Nothing.

Harper has cancelled almost all environmental research. He has destroyed almost all environmental protection, particularly where that is convenient for resource companies. We will not meet our emissions goals - and we're not even going to try to. The whole drive is to push the extraction of fossil fuels as hard as possible, to sell as much of the stuff as possible.

The TandT seems to think the European trade deal is about selling fish. And the pipeline is to transport fish from the west coast to St. John for export. The European deal is to throw the door wide open for European business to take what it wants without any, fussy environmental controls in the way (especially in resource extraction) and to use our fresh water as they like - just as they do in poor countries in Central America, Congo, and all over the world.

And what then? There is no what then. Business doesn't think that way. There is no future beyond the next bonus day. If our business leaders had been on the Titanic, they would all have gathered in the dining room to eat as much as possibly before the ship sank.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Now, just a quick note on studying for university students. I was reminded of it by Mike Elliot's excellent column in yesterday's Whatever section. Here's how to study in university.

Most teaching in university is by rote. That is, it's memory work. That's a pretty poor form of learning, but professors aren't real teachers, so most of them don't know any better. Anyway, that's what you have to do. Study a lot for memorization.

After I got a terrible BA, Acadia University (bless them) gave me a second chance. If I would do a full undergraduate year and get straight As, they would admit me to an MA programme.

It was just about that time that I read somewhere that if you study in a certain way, you can memorize better - and with less work. So that's what I did.

1. Study every day for a least a  half hour, starting with your notes for that day. Then go on to prepare any papers you owe.
2. It must be at an "official" time every day. if the timing of classes makes it possible, it should be the same time every day - including weekends.
3. The first time you read notes, the information will stay with you only a short time. On the next reading, it will last longer - and so on. So, for each day, I had an index card.

On it was the date - and the note pages I had to study (plus any other work I had to get started. Don't put off starting on papers.) So let's say the index card was for classes on Nov. 1. Then, the other study dates would follow - Nov. 3, Nov. 10, Nov. 30. The first day, third day, seventh day and 30th day.

So, every day I would go through my cards to see what I had to study for that day. In the last two weeks before final exams, I would every day go through the whole term's notes - perhaps only once a day.

At end of a year, Mr. D (and I don't mean Decarie) had straight As.

I don't suggest this is a good way to learn. What I am saying is that most university teachers know little about education, so their lectures are simply talking text-books. Most can think only of passing on information because they have little idea of  how to teach more important things like how to read with meaning, how to think, how to organize ideas, how to arrive at judgements.

Anyway, my system worked for me. I actually spent less time studying - and greatly reduced the stress of studying by using this method.

Try it. You, too, can get rich and retire to beautiful Moncton on the Peticodiac - "where every prospect pleases and only man is vile."
































 

Saturday, November 2, 2013

Nov. 2: It's a wonderful, wacky world..

Check out p. 1, "New Store prepares for World's End. It's a survival store - and I can see it all now. It's not only possible but probable that there will soon be drastic food shortages around the world, and dramatically reduced crop yields even in our favoured land. So now we have a store dedicated to supplying us with survival equipment. Yes, as climate goes wild, you can survive by hunting and....and......, well, anyway that's how we'll deal with the problems of all those hundreds of thousands of you and millions of Canadians and hundreds of millions of Americans.

It'll be fun. And I'm sure that all Canadians will cooperate and help each other in the context of the collapse of government and the difficulties of hunting for a livng in downtown Toronto - or even Moncton.

Nor is faith neglected.

The owner of the store also owns The Faithful Servant book store, with literature for the soul to guide you through those trying days to come.  But......

Wouldn't it be cheaper and more practical to stop all that from happening in the first place?

If you think this store is wacky, what do you think of Harper destroying almost all environmental protection rules in Canada, cutting off funds for climate change research, enouraging use of the fossil fuels that are causing climate change, and refusing to meet our promised renewable energy objectives?

Better stock up on those religious books. They might be all you have to eat.
_________________________________________________________________________

P. A6 has an important story, "Union protests cuts to hospital laundry". The union claims that privatizing the hospital laundry services will not save money. The union is almost certainly right.

Even if the centralization saves money, the saving is something that could as well have been done by government, rather than by offering it to private business which must, in addition  to regular costs, provide a profit - and very, very high bonuses for senior executives. Remember the recent ice breaker contract in which we got zinged with massive overcharges - and Nova Scotia got zinged for a couple of hundred million in taxpayers' money as a gift to Mr. Irving for being so kind as to build the ships in Nova Scotia? Were they afraid he was going to build them in Alberta?

Two things are going on here. One is the regular moves of private business to muscle in on government work, almost invariably at higher cost.

The other is the gradual privatization of health care so we can have a wonderful system like the US -Where the poor die much sooner than the rich - thus saving a lot of government pension money.

____________________________________________________________________

Then, on p. A 11, we have an ad for Alward, disguised as a news story. "Leaner civil service saves millions." This is all about how Alward has saved 11 million dollars by adopting a business model for the civil service.

But the reporter never bothered to check the shortcomings of this new system called Lean Six. He just wrote down whatever Alward babbled.

To begin, it's typical of many schemes of the big business world in that much of it is pretentious gobbeldygook. Then there's the problem that it doesn't encourage innovation. In fact, it gets in the way of innovation. And it relies heavily on statistics, something that's always dangerous because statistics can be twisted to say almost anything you want them to. And the list goes on.

Lean Six is the flavour of the month  right now in big business. It's very heavily advertised in google. But it's actually been in decline for some years now. However, it's still big news for mr. Irving, so Alward is all for it.

Has he saved 11 million dollars by it? That's another question the reporter might have raised. You see, how much is raised (or lost) depends on how you're doing you're accounting - and that's a messy a field as statistics.

Hint to reporters - read Harvard Business Review before you interview Alward on a story like this.
___________________________________________________________________

Your Business page continues to baffle me. Today's big story is on how Mount Allison is again rated by MacLean's as Canada's top undergrad university.

First, the MacLean's rankings are a crock. In training background,  in teaching, in methods there is no significant difference between any two universities in Canada. This whole thing is a scam to sell magazines. But it has sucked the universities into it because of their desperation for students - and so we have magazine editors now telling universities how to teach.

All the universities are backwards in their teaching. All have the same lack of understanding and of respect for teaching. All still teach asa they taught two hundred years ago - and even a thousand years aago..

As an example of the silliness of the MacLean's ratings, (and no, this is not bragging), I was several times ranked on the five most popular professors at Concordia. Sounds nice. But how the hell do you measure popularity among twenty thousand students? There certainly was no vote. And even if there were, what does popularity have to do with quality of teaching? And if it did, how would students be able to judge teaching qualirty? Most of them have never taught. They don't know any more than MacLean's editors (or their professors) what good teaching is.

You want to know what good teaching is? Ask any teacher who handles grades K to 3. There are the real pros who know what they're doing. The last person you should ask if a magazine editor or a professor.

And, anyway, why is this on a business page?
_______________________________________________________________________

Bad news on B4. The "Syrian" rebels  - most of whom are not Syrians at all but foreign Muslims from groups like Al Quaeda, armed, paid, and trained by Saudi Arabia, the US and a few others, are refusing to attend peace talks with the UN. Saudi Arabia is not helping. It wants Syria destroyed because its Moslems are too moderate. Al Quaeda doesn't want peace talks because it intends to set up an extreme Moslem state in the part of Syria it now controls. Israel doesn't want peace because it wants Syria destroyed. The US Republicans don't want peace because they want to satisfy Israel and Saudi Arabia.

The same people want Iran destroyed, too,  for much the same reasons.

Obama is just about alone on this one. And if the UN cancels the peace meetings because of the "rebel" objections, then Obama is really out of the game.

That will mean a war -and how terrible and how widespread a war, none of us can even guess.
____________________________________________________________________

The editorial is a wine ad.

Norbert writes about raising chickens, manages to accuse 'activists" of talking without knowing what they're talking about. then admits he doesn't know any answers. So why did he write the column. Then he has a "The Last Word" which as usual, is a quotation that has nothing to do with the article.

Bill Belliveau has a well-written and reasonable article on the Senate. Itthink he's right is demanding due process of law before taking any decisions on Duffy and friends - and wrong in suggesting an elected senate. But it's a good column.

Brent Mazerolle is, as usual, irrelevant.

Gwynne Dyer has a perversely amusing column about Georgia (the place formerly under Russian rule, not the Georgia Peach state.) Read it - and see if you can find any similarities to New Brunswick.

________________________________________________________________
There is a section called Focus on Education. It appears to be mostly useless information and sentimental blather. It's really an advertising feature - and it's a waste of time.
_______________________________________________________________________

Then there are the two, faith pages (sigh).

I note the one that carries ads for church services is down to seven churches. That suggests to me the churches must have to pay for these ads. Wow! The blessed saints of the Irving press offer a free ad for a store disgused as a news story on the front page. But churches have to pay.

I usually criticize the church events as focussing more on bellies than on brains. But I note that the Christ in Action Church is holding a three day seminar "The Lord will give you victory over your suffering."

Alas, I shall be busy those three days  (whenever they are).

I have to feed the ducks.

Friday, November 1, 2013

Interesting news....

...but not in any of the Irving papers. So let's start with some interesting stuff.

Yesterday, the TandT carried a front page story on how a young girl went from Halifax to Moncton by Via rail for the first time, and how she even got to blow the whistle. There's a somewhat similar story today (but no in the TandT) about a nine-year old girl who went all the way from Pakistan to Washington. It had been arranged for her to speak to Congress, along with her brother and father. Grandmother couldn't go. She had been blown to pieces while they were all working in their vegetable garden. In fact, her wounds were so terrible that doctors and others refused to let the family look at her body. The children were wounded, too.

US and Canadian news agencies, if they mentioned it at all, called it a strike on militants. One more victory in the war on terror. The pilot of the drone wasn't there, of course. He, like other warriors up in the "blue sky yonder" never left the ground. He drove from his home not far from Washington to a sort of computer game store where he slipped into a mock cockpit, switched on a screen, pushed a few burrons - and an unpiloted airplane took off from a base in Afghanistan.

Then the pilot checked the list of his targets (it is drawn up at the White House every morning.)

The children told congress you can hear the sound of the drones all the time. They describe it as a zung, zung, zung And then the world went dark.

The attack was reported to the press (and published) as the killing of militants. The US has carried out 376 attacks on Pakistan - though not only militants got killed. More reliable estirmates suggest 926 civilians killed, including 200 children.

At the end of the day, the pilot climbs out of his "poane", submits his report, and wonders if he'll get a medal. There really are medals specifically for the heroes of the computer garmes room.

So the Rehman fanily went to Washington for an arranged meeting with both houses of congress.

Five congressmen showed up.
____________________________________________
But this wasn't important enough for the Irving press.

Then there's the case of Detroir. With the export (thanks to free trade) of all its jobs, Detroit has been turned over to its creditors - mostly the banks - to make sure they get their money back. There is no longer a democracy in  Detroit, no longer city elections. The people of Detroit have not a word in the running of their city. They are their simply to be  bled dry by the banks, thanks to free trade over which they had no control.

8,000 retired police, firemen and other city workers have lost they health insurancee. In the US, that's as good as a death warrant. Many others will follow to lose even more.  And this bankruptcy is permanent. It will never end. Detroir will be run by a bank lawyer.

Since Detroit is 80% black, the lawyer is black. It works well to get people to think they've risen to equal rights becauase one of their own is the boss.  You know, the way American blacks in general used to think when they elected Obama.

Other cities will follow. In all of them, democracy will be ended to be replaced by corporate rule.
Of course, many cities have white majorities; so they['ll be run  by white lawyers.

Googbye American democracy. We  hardly even knew ye'.
____________________________________________________________________________

It's tougher to find news to comment on in the Irving Press.

There's an interesting story on P. 1 about how native peoples might have a strong case for control over their own land. Alward and the gas industry had little trouble getting the non-native population to say, "yes sir, yes sir, three bags full". But the native people are proving to be a lot more astute.

What some   (including me) will find disturbing is that for some native peoples it's just a question of getting a better deal - as is, "would you like steak or chciken before your execution."

There's an even more disturbing story on p. A2 that New Brunswick will give substantial sums of money to our universities to support researth. Sounds good? That's how it's supposed to sound.

The research is to be for big business. In other words, out taxes are yet another gifr to big business in the province - you know - big business, the ones that are supposed to be private enterprise, that are out there in the world fighting their own battles with no help from anybody, the ones who are smarter than governments, the ones who think government should be smaller ---except when it's handing tax money over to them.

Funny that a premier who has people starving in his cities has to hand them over the volunteer charities. But he can find big money to hand over millions to billionaires (who pay little tax).

Our universities are a mess. They have been effectively taken over by the very rich. They treat their undergraduate students as though they are they only to pay the bills. They have given virtually no thought to their essentical role in a democratic society (if we still  have such a society), and they can't teach worth a poop.

But, oh, my, they're good for big business.
________________________________________________________________________
Somewhere in the paper, I saw the Senate described as the chamber of "sober, second thught". Apart from the implicationi that the House of Commons is always drunk, that description is just plain wrong.

It doesn't now provide sober second thought; and it was never designed for that purpose. The truth is that our founding fathers were not big fans for democracy. Democracy could elect the wrong kind of people, layabouts who would want things like minnimum wage, health care, etc. The Senate was designed to prevent that.

Senators would be chosen by a thoughtful and  sober man like John A. Macdonald who would make sure it was well staffed with bank and railroad esecutives, people faithful to his principles, who would block any foolish ideas. (John A had no quarrels with big business in politics. In part of his career as prime minister, he was also pesident of a life insurance company.)

Over the years, Senate gradually changed to a body largely of party hacks - especially those from one of the two, safe parties. Senators of "advanced ideas" have been rare. Many have had no training in government or law. At least one was a hockey player. (Nothing wrong with being a hockey player. But can you imagine an NHL team drafting a senator?)

Nor is there any reason why senators should be appointed (or elected) to represent any province. Ours is a government that is supposed to repreresnt people. It is not there to represent mountarn ranges, farmlands, cities, or the power brokers of any province. It represents people - one person, one vote.

The House of Commons does that. We don't need a senate that represents little bunches of people. There are provincial government to look after provincial affairs. NB doesn't have a senate to represent the rest of Canada. Canada does not need senators to represent NB. NB already has its reprentation in the house of Commons as with, God help us, George Goguen.

________________________________________________________________
As to ed and op ed pages, The editorial is one more piece of boosteriem

The edditorial is vague. Again, it's on sprucing up downtown but lacking any ideas on the subject, The writer, in effect, just says' "something must be done". (By the way, he or she seems to think that panhandlers hang out only on poor streets. Nonsense. I've been in a lot of cities on four continents. Panhandlers work the active and fun streets where there's easy money. They'd love a dressed up downtown.)

Norbert does the usual ignorant and sneering piece about native peoples. Well, it's worse than that. It's an embarassing display of ignorance, bigotry and racism. Then, he  goes on to rant in similar style about federal economics, and then on to a third but pointless topic.

So far, as I read Norbert and also read statements by native leaders, Norbert sounds increaingly ignorant and crude.

Alec Bruce has a well-written piece. And it is true that we  are confused about a great many things that call for decisions. Alas. They call for decisions NOW. We can't put them off. - which means that even a columnist cannot forever sit on a limb.

Cole Hobston seems to be followinto into the Rod Allen school of journalism - just shootin' the breeze. That's not what a column is for.

Too bad. Hobston has more talent than that.

Excellent column by Suzuki.