Friday, June 14, 2013

June 14: World aghast at double disasters.....

.....but the TandT is the one that got the big story of the day - a fish market has opened at the Moncton airport.

In other news, which didn't make the TandT, the US is stepping up its intervention in Syria. It is going to officially supply the rebels with weapons (it has always been supplying them. But now it will say it is.) It also plans to train Syrian rebels. The reason is that Britain and France and the US (all of whom played a part in starting the rebellion in the first place) now say Syria has been using WMDs. Gee! That's just like those awful people in Iraq, the ones who had the WMDs nobody can find.

The WMD in this case is poison gas.The only UN report on this says that the rebels have used it; but there is no evidence the government has. Well. That just shows how much the UN knows. We can trust the US, Britain and France to tell us the truth.

The US has also been supplying the "rebels" with trained soldiers, mercenaries from Latin American armies. Active intervention in that war by the western powers now seems a certainty. Syria can expect a bloodbath with even more, far more, than the 100,000 or so already killed. (And how many orphaned? widowed? crippled? imporverished?)

And it's much, much worse than that. Russia and China see this as a direct and unacceptable attack on their interests. Jihadists will see this as a staging ground for an assault on Israel. Israel sees it as a chance to destroy Palestine, and annex it to Israel.

What we're watching is a giant step to violence throughout at least North Africa and the Middle East with all major powers confronting each other. I shall not even attempt to guess what that will lead to.

But, hey! How about that seafood shop at the Moncton airport? Eh?
_________________________________________________________________________________
The whole world, including friends of the US are aghast at its immense spying programme. It's criminal. It invades the space of every country on earth. (except, according to Mr. Harper, Canada.)
We haven't begun to hear the whole story on this one. ( and we aren't ever going to hear it from the TandT.)

Oh, I know. It defends us against terrorism. Most experts in the field say it doesn't. but it does put information about all of us into the hands of the US government - and into the hands of hundreds of thousands and officials and agents who can use it to attack political enemies, blackmail, coerce, even to murder under Obama's assassination programme.

But not to worry. Harper assures us that Canada is the only country in the world not affected.

This crisis IS even worse than the war in Syria. By spying on them, the US has declared war on every country in the world. That is not an exaggeration. Such intrusion is, by legal definition, an act of war. And within the US, it is the end of democracy. It's hard for us to grasp anything so fundamental and serious, I know. Most people in Hitler's Germany and Mussolini's Italy couldn't grasp it, either. And so they sleep-walked their way into disaster - disaster for them and for everybody else.
_____________________________________________________________________________
Speaking of Harper,  Arthur Porter, he man he appointed watchdog of our spy system, CSIS, is now in a Panamanian prison on charges of stealing millions of dollars from a Montreal hospital project. Way to pick'em, Steve baby.
______________________________________________________________________________
Speaking of local spying, you are, I suppose, aware that the RCMP has admitted to spying on environmentalists (on government orders), AND reporting their findings twice a year to top business leaders.  You see no problem with that?

Okay. Let's tell the RCMP also to spy on top business leaders, and then meet with environmentalists twice a year to share the information with them. Let's see if the TandT wets its pants over that.
________________________________________________________________________________.
The lead story is an over-excited one about Robert Irving who has been, democratically i'm sure, chosen chairman of an Economic Leadership Council. This council of business leaders is going to plan the future development of Moncton.

Screw off, Bobbie, and take your flunkies with you. Y'see, in a democracy, we plan our future. We elect people to carry out our wishes. You and your friends have no more right to plan the future of Moncton than your brother and his flunkies had a right to plan the economic future of province.

Try to understand. In a democracy, we are all equal, and we all have equal rights. That means you have all the rights I do - but no more. You are not a superior being. Nor are your friends superior beings. You and they have no more right to interfere in our public insitutions than anybody else. And pass that word on to the princeling Irving who just got a contract from our snivelling politicians to interfere with our school reading programmes.

Incidentally, get a new speech writer. Your speech, as reported, was nothing but empty buzz-words. Our mayors and councillors were, of course, ecstatic about it -  which proves we have municipal politicians who are much like the lackeys we have in Fredericton.

Oh, and get a dictrionary. This assumption of political power by business leaders is , well, look under  "fascism".
_____________________________________________________________________________________
The cartoon, about flooding in Alberta, misses the point of that story (as the TandT also has). The danger of the flooding was that it seemed likely to cause overspills of the tailingponds, those vast lakes of the toxic waste from oil sands, that surround For McMurray, and poison all the fresh waters of the region.

Any news on how we're going to dispose of our far more toxic fracking waste? Could be a cartoon there - if a cartoonist had editors with guts and integrity.
________________________________________________________________________________
The editorial would be outclassed by the chatter of monkeys at the zoo. It'a a complaint about how politicians are overtaxing us. Yep, it's all the fault of them there politicians. It has nothing to do with the power of big business, with constant interference of big business in government. Yep. We gotta cut billions in spending, and get rid of useless social services so we can continue to give gifts and tax breaks to billionaires.
Incidentally, the US economy is not rebounding as the editorial claims,  not unless you kid yourself about what those official figures mean. Poverty and hunger are rising. Incomes are dropping - except for the rich.  In fact, it is quite likely that the US economy will never rebound to where it was.
________________________________________________________________________
Norbert sticks with what he knows - rantinig ignorance. And our universities would attract huge crowds if their professors gave public presentations in their special fields? Norbert, Norbert....New Brunswickers don't like to attend serious talks - and certainly not if it's a talk that offends an Irving, and someone might see them there and report them.

I gave public talks on current events in a Montreal suburb smaller than Moncton every month for fourteen years. And for all those fourteen years, the audiences were 200 to 300 (maximum capacity).
You can check. I gave them at Eleanor London Library in Cote St. Luc. I also averaged some 60 talks a year in churches, at conventions, all sorts of topics to all sorts of audiences. A hundred would have been a small audience. The biggest was over 2,000.

I've given the same talks at the Moncton  library for two years. I'm lucky to get three people. Why the difference? Are Moncton audiences too sophisticated?

I see no evidence they are. After all, they turn out in droves to hear Robert Irving talk in buzz words.
No - two things are happening.
1. Monctonians are deliberately trained by the Irving press (and most of the private media) to be interested only in the trivial. (Wow! a new fish shop at the airport! Wow! University registrars don't just collect fees!
2. Monctonians are scared of the people who hold the real power in this province.

That's why this is the first province in Canada to go openly fascist.
________________________________________________________________________________
Alec Bruce's column is brilliant. I had no idea he was so well-informed about education. This is a must read.

I will just add one point (which in no way changes or criticizes what Bruce has written.) Education Minister Jody Carr is wasting money by putting it on "outcomes" in the form of tests at higher levels. But he is going to continue doing it because that is what his real boss wants. And the real boss thinks education is something like manufactutinig toilet paper.

I have written to the honorable minister to ask who is supplying the administration for the "outcome" tests. Is it the schools? Is it an outside agency? Who? He hasn't answered yet but, of course, it's somplicated question, and he's a very busy man.
________________________________________________________________________
Michael Sullvan has excellent ideas on beautifying Moncton - but loses it when he advocates that the development of downtown ideas should be done in meetings with the big money players and developers.

That kind of "cooperation" is a large part of the hearings into corruption in Montreal's city government.

Anyway, these money people can meet with the mayor and the council whenever they want to. And I'm quite sure they do - maybe too often.

Should,for example, Robert Irving be in on the planning for the "events" centre? Isn't it possible that his ownership of the Wildcats might affect his judgement? And the owners of Highfield Square have every interest in selling off that land -whether it makes sense or not. They just want to make money out of a piece of useless land.

Isn't inviting these people to help plan urban growth rather like asking bank robbers to help police in designing burglar-proof banks?
____________________________________________________________________

Jody Dallaire's column is first-rate. The answer to the exploitation of women in the sex trade is not in punishing the women - or even their pimps (though pimps almost never get punished, anyway). The answer is in criminalizing the johns, the men who pay for sex. They are the cause of the problem.
_____________________________________________________________________________
And - the last letter on the last page by nine-year old Ira Reinhart-Smith of Alma, NB, is a delight. Read it. This is one, smart little girl.
 

Thursday, June 13, 2013

June 13: Ignorance? Lying? Corrupted?

These three are a running theme for today's blog.

First, a public policy expert is NOT an expert on what public policy should be. He or she is an expert on how a policy should be carried out once it has been decided on by experts in economics, urban planning,environmental matters, politicians, etc.

Do you see the difference Mr. Editor? Norbert? Do you see it Dr. Savoie? And if you all do, why did the TandT publish Dr. Savoie's series on the virtues of shale gas? And why did Dr. Savoie agree to write it?

If Dr. Savoie ever does a seies on public policy (how to apply a policy once it has been decided on,) I shall be delighted to read it. I have no interest in his opinons about economics or environment. I am an historian. I don't use that as a basis for me to make public pronouncements on the nature of tap dancing.
(Good thing I don't. If I did, Norbert would write "expert historian says tap dancing   causes toenail damage. Alward government must act on this.")
__________________________________________________________________________________

Then there are the inflammatory pieces by the editorial writer and by Norbert. I'm inclined to put these two down to a combination of ignorance and lying with a hint of corruption.

Both take up the problem of our provincial debt and the state of the economy in general.It's really hard to know where to start on these lumps of slime.

To the editorial writer - Yes. We are in an economic crisis. No. It was not caused by New Brunswick doctors; and penalizing them will not cure it.

1. We are in a world wide recession. It was triggered by the criminal bechaviour of western bankers, none of whom was ever called to account for it, and none of whom have ever been criticized by the TandT. It was made even worse, far worse, when governments rewarded criminal bankers by giving them bailouts. In one stroke, this was a far bigger bank robbery than all the deeds of Bonnie and Clyde, and Jessie James and Pretty Boy Floyd and all bank robbers in history put together.
2. It was made worse by a redistribution of wealth from almost everybody to the very rich. This has been going on for decades, and has brought parts of Europe - and maybe not just Europe - to the edge of very serious violence. In the process, much of the middle class has been destroyed - and the proportion of the poor dramatically incrreased - and our traditional markets savagely weakened.
3. It has been made even worse by the ease with which, under free trade, our very rich can destroy jobs here by exporting them. Free trade has also opened up even greater opportunities for the very rich to avoid taxes, and to hide money in foreign banks. (A large company is building a factory in Haiti. It will pay no taxes for fifteen years, and will pay workers two dollars a day.)
Breaking a contract with New Brunswick doctors will have no effect on that.
4.The government has been dishonest about the health situation from the start.
a)Though it has claimed to be seeking cuts in order to improve efficiency, in fact it annouinced the cuts and the cost BEFORE it had the report it commissioned to find out where efficiency was a factor. It had already decided the amount to be cut. It had also planned the size of the cuts BEFORE they settled a contract with the doctors. In short, the government was dishonest in the whole process.
b) It is hard to see how the handling of this could have been handed over to overweight, blustering, bullying, cabinet minister like Mr. Flemming.

Even the dolt who writes editorials for this paper must know some of this. And that raises the question of corruption. He behaves and acts like a caricature of a field boss for slave plantations.

Norbert - much the same as above plus -
Norbert still cites Dr. Savoie as an expert on public policy - but invokes his name to defend actions that are not in that field.  Dammit, Norbert. Will you please learn what words mean?

Then he dumps on the politicians as though this were all their fault. It's true that the Liberals and Conservatives of this province are the weakest and most snivelling lot of their breed I have ever seen. But get real, Norbert. They don't run this province. Even am irresponsible ranter like you must know that.

They are owned by the big money in this province. They don't run the province. We all know who is making the record profits in this province. We all know who tells the Minister of Finance what to do. We all know who gets off with light taxes. We all know who gets special deals and big business welfare payments.

And you think the answer to the problem is to make government listen to the people? Norbert - that was the main plank the Alward government ran on. Are you suggesting that Alward has broken that promise and has been lying to us all along? So how come none of the great minds at Irving press have told us this?

And what do the people of this province have to tell the government? How do they know what to say?  They don't get any information out of your ignorant and lying print media to know what to say.

You write of critics "Tell us of a better way that achieves the goal." Bullshit, Norbert. Anyone who suggests a better way doesn't get reported in your press - but gets ranted at by you, anyway. Frankly, Norbert, you are long since too ignorant or too bought to recognize a better way.

Ditto for the editorial cartoon. It carries on the TandT theme that the economy is in trouble - and it's all, duh, because of the doctors. Duh, it's all those poor people. Duh, it's the politicians. Duh, it's all these social programmes, duh, duh...and it's just happening in New Brunswick, duh.

Actually, it's happening all over the world. And it's happening because big business so corrupts our government and feeds us propganda that it has been able to loot whole nations - the US, Britain, Greece, Spain, Ireland......, to destroy millions of jobs,..to create hunger where there was none before...Never once has the TandT mentioned any of this.

No,  the TandT blames it all on New Brunswick doctors.

But another no. Calling the Irving press ignorant, lying or corrupt isn't enough. We have to consider the  word "gutless". (Look it up in the dictionary, Norbert.)
______________________________________________________________________________
Alec Bruce's column is a well written defence of the events centre. I can't agree with a word of it. Any research body that issues a report on the economic future and how an events center would draw huge audiences and big profits is - well - questionable.

The whole world is in very serious economic crisis. We have no idea where this is going to go - or how far. In the US, 1 person in six cannot buy enough food. The new  jobs opening up there are almost all at very low salaries. The middle class has been largely destroyed - and we are nowhere near close to the botton. A forecaster might have considered this will have an effect on our economic future.

An events centre would draw between 317,000 and 396.000 people a year? Really? Not 315,000 to 397,000? That's quite a precise guess, especially for a world that's still hitting early days of a world recession that shows no sign of easing, early days in the which the middle class that can afford to travel to shows and stay in hotels and eat at restaurants is melting.It also ignores all the cases in which this scenario has not worked out - even in better times than we are facing.

And we, who live in a province that cannot afford enough books or teachers for its schools, and cannot afford health care, are being urged to borrow $500 million - probably more - at a time when major American cities are going bankrupt.

Oh, and we just gotta get a CFL team. Duh.
____________________________________________________________________________
Rod Allen again demonstrates his general lack of knowledge. But this time he discusses a specific topic in the news. Alas! I think he must get all his news from the Irving press.

He discusses shale gas, but with the sort of glib comment that used to be called  "old wives' tales". That is a sexist term, of course. So we'll call them "old assistant managers' tales."
________________________________________________________________________________
The savinig grace in the whole paper is the other column on the op ed page. It's by Doctor Robert Desjardin, president of the New Brunswick Medical Society. This shows first-rate knowledge of the subject laid out in remarkably clear and well-written style.  If  you have already paid for the paper, better read this one because it's the only thing worth reading in the whole paper.
______________________________________________________________________

The headline on page 1 "Book stirs controversy at U de M." hints at an important story - but never really gets into it. The reality is that universities are generally under the heavy-handed control of their boards of governors - typically made up of the very rich or their stooges, all of whom typically know nothing about education of any sort.

They operate in secret, and issue orders that are never explained. I taught at one university at which I knew the president of the university quite well - a very capable and honest person. After just months, the  board of governors fired the president - a move that cost the university millions of dollars. No explanation was ever given.My guess?

Well, I served as facultry representative on many a board committee. My guess is that the president's sin was something like refusing to appoint some millionaire's son to a major position.

Some board members are decent. I worked with a chairman of our board who was super-rich (the head of the family that is probably the oldest super-rich family in Canada). I liked him very much as a thoroughly decent and intelligent man.

More common, though, was the born-rich lout who assumed that his family name meant he had a right to rule, was entitled to live high at public expense, and who had nothing but contempt for us commoners.
______________________________________________________________________________
I was wrong in my appendix yesterday when I said what a hash the TandT would make of yesterday's anti-fracking protest at City Hall. The report is actually well done, and quite honest.

Mea culpa.
______________________________________________________________________________


What   wasn't in the paper?

Well, UN peacekeepers all pulling out of the Golan Heights. right between Syria and Israel. That means an almost certain war no matter which side wins in Syria or even before either side wins. And that could spark one hell of conflict in the whole region. And Stephen Harper has pledged in public that Canada will participate in any war Israel fights, no matter who starts it.

The scandal of the US spying on its own citizens? Well, the reporter who broke the original story says that there is much, must more to tell. The more part is, I would guess, that the spying is aimed at covering EVERYBODY in the US - and in other countries. And that is the end of the personal freedom and privacy that is the foundation of democracy. It means we are all living in Germany about 1932.

And the spy system is immense. Almost all spying in the US has been contracted to private companies. And those companies have something over a million employees. Many of them are not Americans - but are given top secret clearance, anyway.

It is the biggest espionage system in history, the most expensive, and with equipment so advanced that we cannot imagine its abilities. And it's all aimed at everybody.  (Well, Harper says it doesn't operate on Canadians. Harper is almost certainly lying.)

Ever wonder how ordinary German could simply walk placidly down Hitler's path of invasion, torture and murder? Wonder no more. We've been taking the same walk for some years, now.
____________________________________________________________________________

Sorry to be late today. I had to go for a blood test t his morning. Apparently, I still have some.


 

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

A brief appendix for the blog of June 12....

It is still June 12. I have just returned from several hours of being cold and wet. I did not see a reporter from the Times and Transcript there - though I did look and ask. But it doesn't matter since Tand T reporters are trained to see only what they are told to see. And I know what they're told to see: so I think I can write tomorrow's (July 13) front page story for them. Something like this....

Yesterday, a crowd of durnken and cocaine ravaged dissolutes terrified children at Edith Cavell school when they gathered in Victoria Park to urinate on the flower gardens before surging through the streets to Moncton City Hall, leaving not a virgin intacto in that whole district of the city.

As they passed the offices of the TandT, they were served best wishes and cups of hot chocolate by a beaming Norbert Cunningham assisted by managing editor Al Hogan, both dressed in fetching tu-tus and standing, as we say in ballet, au point.

That's when we learned they had no reporter to cover the anti-fracking march. All of them had been  assigned to cover an inspirational prayer meeting of fracking CEOs being held at the Irving Chapel. The service was led by one of the clergy who writes for the TandT Faith page. The message was from Matthew 7:7 "Ask and it shall be given unto you."

Then, God and His/Her angels were named to join Mr. Irving in the New Brunswick Business Hall of Fame.

The closing hymn was that old favourite,
"And did those feet in ancient time
Walk upon NB's fracking slime...."

(It was really a good and spirited turnout on such an utterly miserable day. But, oh, I shall never feel warm and dry again.)

 

June 12: best letters to the editor - ever....

The letters to day, are really the best of the TandT. They are full of the   material we should be reading on the op ed page and editorial page - we should be reading it, but with few exceptions, we don't. Start reading today's paper with the letters to the editor. Then the bozo quality of the rest of the paper really shows up.

Page 1 has a big story - a big, big, long story - "Recruitment strategies help keep universities competitive". Trouble is that very few readers are going to plough through all that verbiage. Nor should they.

Most of this story  is gobbledegook put out by the universities. It will have very little meaning to the average reader. And there are stacks of statistics which mean nothing at all to anybody.

The only item worth reading in Section A is on p. 7, "Dismissed DEC member gets a hearing in court". This is a bizarre story. Mr. Crossman was elected to serve on the DEC. But at the urging of the DEC's chairwoman, he was dismissed from the DEC.

Huh? The council can fire a member elected by the voting public?

 Then it replaced him.

Huh? The council can not only fire an elected member, but can replace him without election?

Democracy in action. This one is worth following.
____________________________________________________________________________

For proof of a serious plague of infectious ignorance at the TandT, turn to NewsToday.  The big story is that New Brunswick has stiffer regulations on shale gas than any other jurisdiction. Then it shows it ignorance of the meaning of words by saying they're similar to the regulations of Alberta. (How can they be the stiffest if another province has regulations just as stiff?) But that's nit-picking.

The big story is that the TandTeditors apparently didn't read yesterday's news from Alberta.

The closely related regulations for shale gas in Alberta are drawn from those for oilsands, particularly on the issue of disposing of highly toxic waste material. In Alberta, these wastes are deposited in vast, gooey lakes called tailing ponds. They are regulated to meet a target date for cleanup. The regulations were laid down in in 2009. Yesterday, it was reported no company has yet conformed to the regulations.

Worse, they couldn't if they wanted to. The technology to meet those standards does not exist, despite years of intense resarch to find it. The result - lakes of toxic waters that kill bird and animal life in huge numbers and that kill vegetation, and that poison the soil (and the people) around them forever.

But the eagle-eye editors at the TandT didn't notice that story. Nor did the auditing firm of Deloitte that carried out its "impartial" survery for the very impartial New Brunswick Business Council.

(Mind you, I'm flattering them by saying they're ignorant. Some people might call them liars.)

Now, let's chat about our tough regulations for disposing of highly  toxic water in the billions of gallons. What is our proposed technology for disposing of it? Does such a technology exist? Where, exactly, are we going to put this stuff? Could we just deliver it to the offices and homes of Deloitte? Or those of the New Brunswick Business Council?

The reality is that there are some things we cannot yet do. We may never  be able to do them. And to produce vast dumps of toxic materials in the hope that someday, maybe, we hope, we will find a miracle answer......well, that's just plain greed, stupidity and irresponsility. (and that's why I have to hurry this blog so I can join the march on city hall and the offices of SWN Poisoning Inc.)_______________________________________________________________________________

The editorial is the usual propaganda. Norbert's column the usual ignorance with, this time, personal slanders built into it.

Eric Lewis' message from the mountain top is that we have to be patient during summer roadwork season.  Gee! And all Moses could  come down with is ten, lousy tablets.
_____________________________________________________________________________

Alec Bruce's column is excellent.

Brian Cormier at last shows he has some great stuff in him with a column on what Harper is planning to do to the CBC. I would only urge him to take it a step further. Harper intends to get government control of CBC so he can control the news. This legislation is already prepared, and will be tabled in the very near future. His next step, also already prepared, is to cut off all funding of CBC, and turn it into a privately owned network. That will have two effects.
1. Canada will lose the only world-class news gathering system it has.
2. Canada will be heavily dosed with American programming and American news services with the result that Canadians will lose their sense of identity, and see the world only in American terms. This is exactly what another Conservative, R.B.Bennett of New Brunswick, (and of considerably more brains than Harper) was trying to prevent in his development of CBC.
_______________________________________________________________________________
Yesterday, the TandT carried a story that the schools will be introducing target dates to reach target standards in our public schools. They (or the government) are doing this at exactly the same time they are cutting school budgets. So -

1. Who is setting the target dates and standards?
2. Who will administer the exams?
3. Will this, by any chance, involve a private contractor? Perhaps a propaganda think tank like Atlantic Institute of Market Studies. (Intellectual prostitutes at reasonable prices?)

Curiously, the TandT made no mention of these points. So I have written to Education Minister Jody Carr for further information.

We'll see.
______________________________________________________________________________
And now, off to the march.


______________________________________________________________________________

 

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

June 11: Liars

Page one of the TandT has the headline "Report touts shale gas". It is a hymn of praise to shale gas prepared by (surprise, surprise) the New Brunswick Business Council. It is reported in great detail.
 
Of course, being the professional journalists that the TandT people are, they also include criticism of it. You'll find it toward the end of the report (where few people read). You'll also find that it chose selections that say nothing. As a public service then, here is the whole response to today's report on the praise the Lord glories of shale gas. This is the real report that the TandT deliberately garbled.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
For Immediate Release                        PRESS RELEASE                                       June 10, 2013

First Response to NB Business Council Report on Shale Gas

Fredericton NB - The communications committee for the alliance of community groups opposed to shale gas asked Jim Emberger for a first response to the NB Business Council Report on Shale Gas. 

 

Jim Emberger, a resident of Taymouth NB and a retired software developer says: “The most striking point is that this report proves that if you pay a consulting firm they will produce a positive report for you regardless of how weak and conditional the conclusions are.” “ Below are my first comments to the questionnaire that was used, the supporting data they used, the conclusions that were drawn, and their review of current regulations and their lack of assessment of costs incurred by road damage”  Mr. Emberger continues.

 

On the questionnaire and subsequent conclusions:

Right off the bat, there was a response rate on their questionnaire of 16% and they calculate the report has an 11% margin of error on those few points where the report can even make a comment, because of the small response rate.  I’m not a pollster or statistician, but I wouldn’t want to bet the farm on that foundation.

 

On the supporting data:

The report uses some outdated data to support some of its statements.  On the outlook of unproven technically recoverable gas, it cites a 2010 EIA report showing 1,931 trillion cubic feet in North America – the source of the famous 100 years of natural gas comment.  However, the EIA recently revised that figure downward by 42% in the US, meaning at best a 24-year supply.  I don’t have figures on Canada itself, but it is undoubtedly similar. The revisions mirror the actual production figures recently calculated for 65,000 shale wells by Canadian energy analyst David Hughes (Drill, Baby, Drill Can Unconventional Fuels Usher in a New Era of Energy Abundance – David Hughes, 2/13)

 

The real life accounting of wells by David Hughes, (also Deborah Rogers and Art Berman and others) show that existing shale plays peak in about 4 years on average, with individual wells depleting by 79% to 95% in three years.  Entire plays deplete at an annual average of 30% to 50%.  So despite drilling thousands of new wells, terminal decline starts rather quickly and it is inconceivable that shale plays will last anywhere near the 25- 60 years mentioned in the report.   Remember that shale gas is barely a decade old, and that the figures used for longevity are based on conventional gas wells.  Virtually all plays older than 5 years are in decline.

 

The report also cites consulting firm IHS CERA for predictions about how much royalty money will flow by the year 2030.  Unfortunately, IHS CERA has one of the worst records of long term predictions anywhere.  It’s long term predictions for oil from their reports of the early 2000’s stated that oil production would soar to millions of more barrels a day, and that we would now be paying between $30 and $40 a barrel.  Instead, the price has been $100 a barrel or more for many years, and supply has not increased since 2005.

 

The use of GDP as a measure of benefits is flawed as things like road repair, environmental clean-up and legal action would all increase GDP, while actually illustrating negative consequences for NB citizens.

The Conclusions:

The figures for Full time equivalent jobs (FTE) per well based on a One Well model can be misinterpreted.  One cannot simply take the figure of 21.5 FTE jobs per well and multiply it by the number of wells to get how many people will be employed. Most jobs are portable, meaning that a few drilling crews go from well to well, thus not increasing the number of employees, only the FTE statistics.  Since they did not explain the one-well model in the paper, I may have misinterpreted it, but it is something that the press should question.

 

The report also supports our contention that except for a few geologist type jobs, most jobs for NB’ers would be truck driving and security type jobs.

 

The conclusions note that gas companies have many existing relationships with existing suppliers and trained employees.  This confirms what we have been saying about the benefits to NB.

 

Regulatory review:

They compared NB to BC, Alberta, Colorado and Arkansas.  First, BC and Alberta’s gas plays are in the boondocks generally – many miles from anywhere.  Alberta, as noted by the report, is new to shale and is only now addressing new regulations for it. For example, they do not currently require testing of water wells for a frack.

 

Arkansas, one of the first shale plays, has been playing catch-up, as production started with few regs.  Correspondents from there have told us to stop shale before it starts, because regulations always lag damages.

 

Colorado – the only long-term health study from the Univ. of Colorado showed the states regs to be inadequate to protecting public health. As extraction moves into populated areas, friction between local governments and state government is increasing.

 

Geologically, none of these areas resemble NB.  Pennsylvania is probably the closest analogue, but was not considered.  The main point continues to be that all those areas continue to have widespread problems despite a variety of regs.

 

Road repair paid for by companies?

It is interesting to note that the report claims the cost estimate for road damage cannot be determined yet, but that the government regulations “contemplate” that companies will be responsible for these costs.  We haven’t found any direct reference to this in the new government rules.  Furthermore, shale oil and gas income from royalties have been shown in other jurisdictions to be way less than the costs incurred by accompanying road damage. 

For example, since 2009, Arkansas has taken in approximately $182M in royalties but estimates its road damage from drilling to be $450M.   This is not surprising, as it takes over 1,000 loaded trucks to bring one gas well into production, plus 350 loaded trucks per year for maintenance, and another 1,000 loaded trucks for each additional frack. 
________________________________________________________________________________  
_______________________________________________________________________________
-There is yet more pimping from the Tand T at the top of page 1. This time it's for the events centre, This is a bizarre report. it gives enthusiastic reports of how Moncton will become a boom town when it gets its new hockey rink. But there is not a word of what this is all based on. Where are the studies? Where are the figures? This "report" is nothing more than painting pictures on clouds.  Why on earth would any newspaper use this for a lead story? (Well, we know why.)
___________________________________________________________________________________
In NewsToday, the TandT has at last noticed the government spying scandal in the US in which the government has been massiverly spying on just about everybody, and collecting information - which could and will be used to deal with political enemies and anybody who criticizes the wrong people.  Peter MacKay, our defence minister, is assuring us that this is not being applied to Canadians. Mr. MacKay is full of it. Almost all Canadian communications systems are routed through US jurisdictions.
_______________________________________________________________________________
The editorial page is back to a topic the editorial writer can (almost) understand - the question of whether our cars need one licence plate or two. Way to come to grips with the big questions of the day....
 
At that, he beats staffwriter Alan Cochrane on op ed who has a  remarkably unintelligent column on how hard it is to be a dad. Well, at least it wasn't about motorcycles going vroom, vroom.
 
Norbert is still on yesterday's rant - and it's as ignorant as yesterday's.
 
He begins by heaping blame for our our debt on the government. Come off it, Norbert. Even a person of your barely flickering perception must know that our politicians do not run this province. Irving  delcared himself a member of the government in Norbert's very own paper - on a page facing  Norbert's column. He then appointed the official advisors to the Minister of Finance who is, by conincidence, a former irving employee.
 
Alward and the boys had nothing to do with our budgets. It was Irving.
 
I suspect the same is true of a very suspicious looking plan to set educational targets for our schools. (There's a good laugh in there, though. Mr. Alward says he wants the schools to train students to be leaders. In the many years I taught, every school claimed to be training for leadership. But any teacher who tried to do any such thing would get stomped by parents, administrators, and school boards. The same is largely true of universities. They train obedient followers. And that's the way the Irvings of this world like it.)
 
In today's rant, Norbert takes out his bile on the poor and their sense of 'entitlement'. That's right. It's the poor who have caused the massive debt of our governments, and the great crash of western economies. Make them iggerant, loafin' poor pay.
 
In the first place, Norbert, we are all of us 'entitled' to a share of what this province and this country produce.
 
In the second place, the big spending and the big raking in of wealth and of govrnment favours is not being done by the poor. You want to see entitlement? You want to see welfarism? You want to see greed? You want to see indifference to the damage these are causing in this province?
 
Then have the guts to check out your boss and his corporate friends. Norbert says so in his own column  (read the second to last paragraph). But he doesn't have to wit to understand what he wrote.
 
Our economies are in trouble because the great corporations have been looting us the same way they have looted third-world countries for generations.  We are being looted by tax breaks, by hidden profits, by massive corruption, all helped along by "free" trade.
 
Norbert - you know nothing about economics, nothing about government, and damn little about people. And you're a cheap stoolie for big business. Go away.
 
Alec Bruce begins well in his column on the reasons for the anger in New Brunswick - mostly, but not entirely, over shale gas. But it dwindles away from any useful conclusion in its final paragraph.
 
Yes, there is a lot of rage in New Brunswick. But there's no mystery about what's causing it. The economic bosses of this province are ramming a project down our throats. They are doing it with the full cooperation of lying newspapers.  This is a province that has been bullied and looted throughout its history. And many people have become angry.
 
Gee. go figure....
____________________________________________________________________________
A reader sent me the following site. It's the story the TandT isn't going to tell  you about the very brave young man who blew the whistle on how the US is spying on its own citizens. What will happen to him? Well, my guess is that he will be assassinated (and the body will disappear.)

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/09/edward-snowden-nsa-whistleblower-surveillance

Monday, June 10, 2013

June 10: N.B. won't drop front licence plate"

Wow! Talk about a game changer! How do you like them apples, Mr. Irving? You'll need to get a front licence plate - if you ever come back to live in New Brunswick. Take that from the gutsiest government we've ever seen.

What half-wit assignment editor ever thought this was a story worth covering? And for the front page? Is it possible any reporter thought that this story made all those hours and months of study in journalism school worth it?

In other, riveting front page stories, three new schools will be opening - so some school boundaries may change a bit. And "Weather predictions too slow for Metro?"  Be still, my heart.

And the big, big headline, "Health networds want end to medicare disputre". Gee. What a suprise! and here I thought they would want it to go on forever.

There's even more inside. Did you know that the RCMP calls tow trucks when there's an accident? That fast-breaking story was covered by Craig Babstock

Nor does it stop even there.

The lead story for NewsToday is that a former US ambassador died.

 There is no mention that Israel was (and still is)close to an invasion of Syria. I'm afraid even to guess at the consequences of that. Among those consequences is the fact that our prime minister has publicly (and unconstitutionally) declared that Canada will be at Israel's side in any war - even if Israel starts it.

On the page for business news (Your Investments), the big story is that landscapers are rushing to get their spring jobs done. I needed to know that. There is no mention of the ludicrously low taxes being paid by corporations in this province - though the figures are easily available.

This is Disneyland with a vengeance. Then we come to the main course - the editorial and op ed pages.
________________________________________________________________________________
Norbert begins his column with several paragraphs of the most nauseating, ass-kissing prose I have ever seen outside certain fanatical churches or nazi rallies.

Donald Savoie, it seems, is highly respected and, get this, impartial. Other adjectives or non-partisan, non-ideological, We are lucky to have him.

Norbert, you are taking pure bullshit - and I doubt whether you even understand the meanings of  words like ideological.

As a person supporting one side in a debate, he is highly partisan. That's what the word partisan means, Norbert. And I doubt very much whether you know what the term "public policy expert" means. In fact, it is a fancy term largely used to by right wing propaganda tanks to make their selfish ideas sound respectable.

And whatever Dr. Savoie may be expert in, he is not an expert on medicine or environment. If you are too dumb to understand that, Dr. Savoie is certainly not that dumb. 

The expert in medicine in this case is the Provincial Health Office, Dr. Cleary- and the whole medical profession. Their expertise is essential when you're talking of pumping toxic chemicals into our ground and flushing it out with fresh water. But your paper completely ignored her. And you have never reffered to her as an expert. Admittedly, there's enough evidence of stupidity in the Irving press to make it possible none of you understand that.

However, Dr. Savoie must know he was giving advice which, at its heart, involved a topic he knows nothing about it. And the word for that is not wise or respected. The word for that is unethical. That is one hell of a serious charge in the academic world. Luckily for Dr. Savoie, most of the academic world doesn't care much about ethics.

Nor does Dr. Savoie know poop about environmental threats. Yet these threats, too, are central to the debate. Dr. Savoie knows that as well.

Dr. Savoie has no significant knowledge of what regulations are necessary to control fracking. Indeed, he doesn't even know what toxic chemicals are being used because SWN and the rest of the boys won't tell us. Nor does he have the faintest idea how that wastewater will be disposed of - or what the dangers are in that.

What Dr. Savoie wrote was a very simple and superficial report that we need to encourage job growth in New Brunswick. That's not a brilliant insight. But it's reasonable.

But he wrote - and he knew he was writing - to encourage a project on which he is quite unqualified to speak. Norbert may be too dumb to know the difference. Dr. Savoie cannot be that dumb, not if he walk upright and can zip his fly without assistance.

Then Norbert goes off on a tirade about something he knows nothing about. (Nothing is the only subject he's a respected authority on.) He attacks teachers for not wanting their numbers cut. Too bad Norbert knows nothing about either education or economics.

1. The education system in this province is understaffed. Fewer pupils give us a chance to catch up. Norbert wants to use it as an excuse to keep us down.
2. He says we don't have enough money. Oh? Then how come he and the village idiots who surround him are so hot on a hundred million dollar hockey rink?
3. He cites Greece and Spain as examples of what can happen when when a government spends too much. In fact, Greece and Spain are examples of what happens when criminal bankers throughout the western world destroy national economies (and get away with it - with bonusses for being so smart.)
4. Greece and Spain HAVE drastically cut spending, quite savagely. And, as many economists have known for over seventy years, cutting spending does not work. On the contrary, it has made the situation in Greece and Spain worse, much worse.
5.Why don't you look at the tax money we (don't) get from corporations. We have the lowest corporation taxes around - and there's massive cheating and reductions even on that. That does us a hell of a lot more damage than the salaries of forty teachers.

Norbert - you really should be careful about accusing others of pandering, being spineless. And very, very careful about accusing others of being ignorant ranters. Today's column by you is not a bad one. Bad doesn't come close to what is really ignorant and ass-kissing.
________________________________________________________________________________

The editorial,  though somewhat better than Norbert's column, still stinks. Times are tough for corporations? The days of easy money are over? Are you crazy, Mr. Editor?

Corporatons around the world have been making their biggest profits in history. It was the same in the 1930s. They get richer as we get poorer. North American manufacturers are not losing money. They're moving their money - and their jobs - to cheap labour supplies. Irving isn't losing money. Canadian mining isn't losing money. Bombardier isn't losing money.

And that doesn't even count the trillions of dollars in secret bank accounts.

And the idea that the snivelling wretches we call Liberals and Conservtives would stand aside, and turn down corporate requests for grants and loans and other favours, is absurd.
_____________________________________________________________________________
Alec Bruce has an excellent column on US spying on millions of its own citizens - all with the connivance of telephone companies, computer servers, credit card companies .... They're doing it with the connivance of Canadian companies and, almost certainly with the connivance of Harper. Oh, and Britain is also a part of it.

The excuse, like all the excuses for the destruction of civil liberties, of due legal process, of illegal invasions with murders by the millions, is the "war on terror". And plenty of fools will believe that. The TandT, a notch lower than your average run of fools, doesn't even h ave an editor who realizes this is an important story.

The real reason for it is, of course, power - power over all of us. You're critical of the government? You're on the list. The fundamental concepts of democracy and freedom have been destroyed over the last dozen years. We are well into the world 1984 and 'big brother'.

When Obama first ran for president, I said - on CBC - that I did not have much hope for his abilities. I thought he was a glib talker, and nothing more. I saw nothing of substance in his speeches. I wish I could take credit for that: but the fact is I overrated him.

He is even more destructive and vicious and corrupt than Bush. There was some excuse for Bush. He was seriously retarded. (Son of rich man gets master's degree from prestige university even though functionally illiterate and lacking entry requirements.) There's no excuse for Obama.

We are watching a man of intelligence who following the same policies as Bush did. We are getting back to back and in double terms the two worst presidents in American history. And we have a prime minister who thinks in the same slot they do. (So does Britain.)

In this time of overwhelming issues, Craig Babstock discusses the pressing problem of crosswalks in Moncton.

Steve Malloy takes almost the same topic - but does something original and thought-provoking with it.
___________________________________________________________________________

Sorry to be late with today's blog. I had to run an errand, and got delayed by celebrants at the Moncton Springtime Street-repair Festival.








 

Sunday, June 9, 2013

June 9: What to do?

There is a reader's comment at the bottom of yesterday's post. It asks what we should do to stop Shale gas exploration.

First - can it be stopped?

Yes, it can be stopped. It has been stopped, even turned back after it began, in parts of the US and Canada and Europe.

What will not stop it is violence. The people behind shale gas would love to see violence (and I suspect they will see it in parts of Canada and the US this summer.) Violence gives them, with the help of the scum of the journalism world, the chance to drive public support away from the protestors; and to call in the police. Violence gives them a chance to call in a violence that the protestors cannot match.

I'm quite sure that the recent decision to call off an "information" meeting because there had been a threat of violence was a setup.  I don't believe they would call off a meeting without a serious and very credible threat. But SWN has presented no evidence of such a threat. And it would be very naive to think that SWN would keep such a threat so secret. On the contrary, it would splash its information all over the news media because of the damage it would do to the anti-shale gas movement.

It was a setup. and the Irving press played along with it.

It is quite possible, even likely, that SWN will create violence with mysterious attacks on its own people and equipment. These people act exactly like mafia - because they are exactly like mafia. And, in such a case, depend on the Irving Press to follow their lead without question.

All of that will easily convince the people of New Brunswick that the protestors are in the wrong. This is a province that has been government by fear of the rich and powerful going back well over a century and a half. We have further been numbed by a lying a frivolous press - the only provincial press I know of that has routinely been condemned in federal studies.

The chances of violence across Canada are going to be especially strong this summer now that Harper has stirred up racism among his supporters to carry out a war against native peoples. He wants them out of his way. He wants the treaties out of his way. He wants that to get uncontrolled access to resources - like shale gas. As part of his campaign, he is starving reserves of money that is owing to them for decent housing and sanitation. And he is spending rumours that the reserves are corrupt. Talk about the pot calling the kettle black!

What makes these tactics possible on the shale gas issue is that the anti-shale gas movement is still too small, and it demonstrations too small. So long as that is the case, private news media of all sorts will play down the credibility of the movement. (Journalists are as  sheep-like as they come.) Even the CBC, which has been far the best source of news about this issue) may well lose its independence within weeks as Harper has prepared legislation to destroy it.

All this means the movement has to be even more active in recruiting members, and in ensuring that demonstrations are large. It has to encourage people to read the only alternative print media we have,
The Monctron Free Press.

That won't be easy. Getting New Brunswickers to publicly take stands and to think independemtly and without fear makes walking on water look easy. (It  might even be useful - and easier - to get people to demonstrate against the Moncton TandT.)

We need more  (and more open) opponents to shale gas. We need t o reveal the Irving press for the manipulative and lying work it does.

And, in the very near future, we must get rid the Liberals and the Conservatives who suck at the Irving teats. Admittedly, some of them can be forgiven on the grounds of stupidity (Mr. Flemming springs to mind). But as long as those two, wretched parties remain in power, this province will sink ever deeper into poverty to make billionaires richer.

As it is, we are destroying our own people, owu children - and now our own lands and waters. (Incidentatlly, where are they going to put the toxic waste water from the wells?)

The fundamental problem of New Brunswick is an aristocracy of wealth that has looted this province for generations. They can get away with it only so long as New Brunswickers act like sheep.

With large, active and open opposition in public, with our votes in provincial elections (and municipal ones), we can, for ourselves and our children, beat these greedy, thieving and destructive bastards.

Yes. They can be stopped.