Saturday, June 8, 2013

June 8: Words, words, words....

Us human types are forever using words we don't understand - and, worse, we speak them to other people who don't understand them either, but whose misunderstanding is a different one from hours.. And so we get into hopeless shouting messages so meaningless that one of us could be speaking in Dutch and the other in Swahili for all it matters.

One writer in the TandT said that conservatives are people who are sober and careful in spending. But that's not what the word means.I have no idea whether conservatives are particularly sober - but, as an historian, I do know they have a record in both Canada and the US for big spending. (However, spending, whether big or small, has nothing to do with the meaning of conservative.

When I was a child I thought of myself as a Liberal because it sounded - you know - generous, broad-minded. And I thought conservative meant old-fashioned, backwards, fat and cranky.

It wasn't until I began studying history that I realized that Liberals were just skinny Conservatives. And that Liberals weren't liberal at all, and Conseratives weren't conservative. But it really doesn't matter, because very few have the faintest idea what either word means, so we have these tremendous debates with both sides using words they don't understand, and each side have different meanings for them.

I thought of this as I read a note from a reader who wrote in to disagree with me (see comments under yesterday's post). He ended on a huffy and righteous note, saying he refused to carry on discussion with a person who invoked the name of Hitler.

I had mentioned Hitler. But mentioning is not the same as invoking. To invoke means to refer to a person AS AN AUTHORITY. But I didn't. I said there were some people who referred to Hitler as an authority - people prominent in American and Canadian business and politics. THEY invoked him. I didn't. Understanding words is important.

But it doesn't matter. My correspondent probably feels he has scored the killing hit. And plenty of semi-literates will agree with him.
______________________________________________________________________________
Words...take a look at a story on P. 1, "SWN praised in the US". Now, the headline is supposed to tell us what the story is about. Okay. Now look at the sub head "Despite assurances of safety and good practices, industry is still controversial and divisive south of the border". The head and the subhead contradict each other. (Don't blame the reporter. An editor writes the head and sub-head; and this editor must be a gem.)

The opening paragraphs give us a mild "some say this, some say that". But most of the story is about those who approve of SWN. Significantly, there is no quotation from anyone who's an authority on the long term damage that can be expected.

The big, lead story on the same page, is that the Alberta premier is in favour of a pipeline for her province's oil, the dirtiest in the world, to go through New Brunswick. Well, yeah. She's gotta move that stuff that most of the world won't touch. BC has turned her down for a line to the West coast which could export the stuff to China - a country that couldn't care less what happens to the environment. And she's run into heavy opposition all through the US all the way down to Texas.

Actually, piplines do spill oil - and they can spill an awful lot because the oil moves through them at very high speed. But they don't have to worry about government opposition in New Brunswick, or about newspapers that tell the truth.

Also on the front page, Donald Savoie opens his column with the usual words that look impressive but say nothing. Then he gets to his real point. We should develop shale gas. What a surprse!

Now, people will say Donald Savoie is an authority. And, within his limits, I'm sure he is. However, studying public policy does not make one an authority on medical or environmental issues. People who are authorities in those fields say that shale gas is harmful. Isn't it just a trifle arrogant of young Donald to ignore the opinions of those people?

That willingness to ignore the opinions of people who have expertise he doesn't have is why I wrote yesterday that he is a pimp for the shale gas industry. Today's column confirms that.
______________________________________________________________________________
Today's Faith column is beneath contempt. No wonder church attendance is going down if this is the sort of pablum people are forced to listen to. The message is that we shouldn't worry if the world is going to hell. It's all part of God's great plan.

Yep. We killed over a hundred million people in Iraq just to steal their oil. Don't sweat it. It's all part of God's great plan. I cannot believe that anyone who could write such drivel can have understood or even read the message of Jesus.
___________________________________________________________________________
In the youth section, Jana Giles writes about a book she enjoyed, and recommends people read it. that is the sort of thing that encourages literacy. This is the sort of thing that should be a regular feature of the TandT for adults - but isn't. The only book I have seen seen even mentioned in any deal was about a book they were trying to dump on an unsuspecting public. It was the autobiography of a retired editor. 

 (There's quite a bit of good stuff in the Whatever section. Too bad the rest of the paper doesn't meet those standards.)
_________________________________________________________________________________
There's a story on a shale gas protest yesterday. What causes these protests?

Well, you can start with a lying press that has made no attempt to give both sides of the shale gas debate. You can blame shale gas companies who manipulate a press and a government to favour them. You can blame a government that claims to listen, but never hears. They are the ones who have provoked this situation.

The protesters are not forcing themselves onto people's property. They are not pumping toxic chemicals into the ground. They are not refusing to listen to the advice of the chief medical officer. They are not planning to pump billions of gallons of heavily polluted water into the Bay of Fundy. They are not doing it to make a pile of money for themselves, and then skip the mess.

All of that is being done by shale gas companies, and by a government - and opposition - that is submissive (even cowardly), ignorant and morally corrupt to an almost unimaginable degree. Those are our troublemakers. Unfortunately, they are also the ones who will decide who the police will be used against - and it won't be them.
_____________________________________________________________________________
The editorial, as always, deals with the great questions of our age. This time it's the compelling question of whether streets should be repaired at night.

Bill Belliveau has nothing new, original, or thought-provoking to say about the "events" centre. But he says it anyway.

Norbert argues that politicians always pander to the public. Get real, Norbert. They will pander on small points to the most ignorant and bigoted of the electorate. (See Harper, for example.) But if you read any Canadian history at all from 1867 and even earlier, every national government we have ever had pandered mostly to big business. Harper does. Apart from the sops he throws to racists, and monomaniacs, all of his decisions are effectively made by the Canadian Council of CEOs. Alward is even worse.

Brent Mazerolle tells a pointless story.

Gwynne Dyer is the only one who has something intelligent and informed to say.
_______________________________________________________________________
Then there's all the news that didn't appear.

 Pamela Wallin has made over three million dollars as a board member of various companies since being appointed to the Senate. The fuss is that she charged trips to many of those meetings to the Senate. The bigger fuss should be is that there are surely conflicts of interest here. Forget separation of church and state. What about separation of big business and state? Reading the story of Pamela Wallin might help Norbert to understand that the real pandering of government is not to the people - but to big business.

According to a CBC report, NB's general income tax for corporations, rising from 10% to 12% , will generate 17 million additional dollars for the province in 2013-2014.

Huh?

That means 17 million is a fifth of what they have been paying. So that would be a total of $85 million in taxes they have been paying to now.

The provincial budget is  8.5 BILLION. The tobacco tax alone is far more than all of the corporation taxes collected in all of this province. Considering all the money corporations make out of this province, considering the gifts and loans and grants and other favours they expect from us, corporations must be paying far below their share. And there must be stunning loopholes in our tax laws. And corporate bosses must be laughing all the way to their (offshore) banks.

Could the TandT spare a reporter to tell us how much major corporations make out of us? And how that compares with these ludicrous budget figures?

So much for Norbert's dream that politicians pander to the voters. In fact, we seem to be getting robbed blind.

Then there is the scandal sweeping the US. The National Security Agency has, illegally and without warrant, been checking the private phone calls, computer messages, credit card spending of uncounted millions of Americans. The idea is to compile massive files of information on everybody. And that's not just in the land of the free and the home of the brave. They are also doing it to foreign nationals (read British and Canadian.) That means British and Canadian companies and the British government and the Canadian government have been complicit.

This is the biggest domestic spying operation in history, far biggert than anything undertaken by Hitler, Stalin or Mao. This is an agency of government giving itself enormous powers of blackmail, coercion and threats to political opponents. And doing it all illegally.

This is what a police state looks like. This is what the end of democracy looks like. Now you can understand why countries like Germany, Italy, Spain accepted this sort of behaviour in the 1930s. They accepted it because they never even noticed what has happening. And even the nicest people went fascist. And why didn't they notice?

Because they had news media just like the Irving press.
___________________________________________________________________________






 

Friday, June 7, 2013

June 7: It's hard to read this crap every day....

I've just noticed that Donald Savoie, at the head of his columns, is referred to as a policy expert. As a description. that is absurd. They never referred to Dr. Cleary as a medical expert. In fact, no critic of shale gas or of the Irvings, has ever been referred to as an expert. Nor is an editor qualified to make any such statement about anybody. No editor has the ability to judge who is an expert in history or economics or chemistry because no editor has the training to make such a judgement. Nor would it mean anything if they did.

To call someone expert implies that person is correct. And to think that betrays a profound ignorance of what advanced study is about. In the time of Gallileo, the "leading" astonomers and scholars of his day believed that the sun went around the earth. And they were the experts.

In Darwin's time, experts of all sorts believed that the earth was created in six days - and that man as a species had no ancestors. There are still serious scholars, influenced by religion, who claim that. Experts of all sorts are influenced by religious beliefs, moral values. social values.... There are even some - quite a few actually - who are influenced by the fame or money or both to be gained by thinking the "right" way.

There is no such thing as a polcy expert who can point the way to what is the right policy. Quite apart from all t he limitations of human understanding, our notion of what is the right policy is influenced by all sorts of factors, moral and social. It also requires a knowledge of what the future will be like - something Professor Savoie has not demonstrated.

I have seen no evidence that the editors of Irving press  have any understanding of the above. But Professor Savoie should.

He closes by once again telling us to put our shoulders to the wheel. Why is he bothering with us? What influence do we have on all this? The gas companies don't care what we think. They have given us no information - and certainly not a word on any dangers in the process. Ditto for the Tand T. Ditto for the government.

Anyway, why waste advice on us who have nothing to do with the running of this province? The government doesn't run it,, either. As professor Savoie must know, this province is quite blatantly run by Mr. Irving and his buddies. Mr. Savoie, why not give your advice to them?

That would, at least, be more honest than acting as a pimp for them.
_____________________________________________________________________________
In another front page story, a chief of Native Peoples calls for protests to be peaceful.  That's so true. There is nothing worse than violence like, for example, poisoning the land and fresh water, then using the fresh water to flush the poisons and dump them in , say, the Bay of Fundy.

Yep. Nothing worse than violence. Somebody should tell that to SWN and Mr. Alward and Mr. Irving, and all those leeches who cling to tnem.
________________________________________________________________________
Lots of great ads in NewsToday.

Your Business has a story by staffwriter Alan Cochrane., "Pipline project could benefit all of New Brunswick." Young Alan must have skipped some of his journalism classes  A headline isi supposed to tell us what a story is about. This story is NOT about how the pipeline will benefit us. It is not even a statement that it will benefit us. It is about how some people who want shale gas SAY it will benefit us. There's a difference.

Consider, for example, these two headlines.

"Mr. Alward is the most dyaminic a lovable presmier in Canada."
"Mr. Alward says he is the most dynamic and loveable premier in Canada."

See the difference?
_______________________________________________________________________
Roughly half of the editorial and op ed pages are devoted to giving support to shale gas. When was the last time you saw a column on either page that was critical of shale gas?
_____________________________________________________________________________

Michael Sullivan has a good column on reality television shows. But it's a bit much to suggest, as ge does,  that this is because he's a conservative. Most such shows are supported by TV channels that are conservative to the core. And PBS, which he loves, has been under constant attack from American conservatives.

As to reality television shows, these are our equivalent to the old Roman enthusiasm for watching people kill and/or humiliate others in the Coliseum. Worthless and degraded themselves - and knowing it - they hugely enjoyed laughing at people even lower than they were.That's the appeal of Jerry Springer. It's a sign of one hell of a sick society - just like all those scandal mags at supermarket checkout counters.

A suggestion, though, Mr. Sullivan. Get off the conservative/liberal kick. You are talking about things that have nothing to do with either liberalism or conservatism. As well, I'm not convinced you are a conservative - or that there is anything conservative about the conservative party. It's important to know exactly what words mean.

You have a good mind. Let it free of those meaningless labels.
___________________________________________________________________________
Alec Bruce has a column that could be a springboard ro develop some ideas. I don't agrree with the implications of what he says. But he does touch on points that need a lot more thought.

This province has economic problems that are, many of them, unique to it. The only reponses I've seen to those problems have been get-rich-quick schemes - usually promoted by the wealthy and benefitting only them.

New Brunswick needs long term planning based on realistic assumptions of what North America will be like twenty years from now - and even more. I have seen no hint of such thinking going on. We need that before we spend a cent more on wildly optimisiic and costly boondoggles like a thirteen thousand seat hockey rink.

We have to invest a lot more in education - and we have to get the interfering noses of big business out of education and, for that matter, out of government. We have to get far more active in redesigning the whole population distribution in this province - and the public transportation system. Similarly, we cannot cut medical services until we first solve the problems that make the services costly.  That's where redistribution of population and reorgnization of public transport come into it.

What's wrong with Mr. Flemming on hospitals is that he listens only to Mr. Irving. And Mr. Irving doesn't give a damn about human needs. He just wants to cut costs with wild swings of a blunt axe. And there is no blunter axe than Mr. Flemming.

We need planning. What we're getting is short term scams from brains of low wattage.
__________________________________________________________________________

To the writer of the letter "Aggressive rhetoric thwarts our right to know", I would suggest he buy a good dictionary. Look up words like cohesive and facts. (He obviously have no idea what they mean.)  I applaud his demand that we have a right to know. So how come hehas not complained to the Irving press that is has hidden information concerning one side of the debate. He might also, when involking the word "rhetoric' , to mean (wrongly) ranting speech - well, he might also want to tone down his own language.

I see no evidence in the letter that he has  made any attempt to find out what the dangers of shale gas might be. Doesn't that make it unwise of him to accuse those who disagree with him of "burying their heads in the sand'?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am more than a bit dismayed by the failure of t his paper to cover much of anything outside local trivia. In Quebec, a province which has driven over half a million people out because they do not speak French, the provincial soccer association, with the support of the government, has forbidden Sikh children who where turbans from playing on public fields - and from playing in any league.

There is no suggeston or evidence that turbans constitute a danger. They are illegal purely because they are not "Quebecois". This is pure racism, and more is coming. In a few months, the Quebec government will dictate laws defining how people must act in conformity with Quebec "culture." More racism.

This is not happening because Quebec is French. It's happening because Quebec is intensely racist. Not is it the only part of Canada that is racist. Harper's Conservatives are running a campaign against Native People to appeal to the large body of racist voters across Canada. BC had a viciously racist policy to Japanese and Indian Canadians. Anti-semitism in Canada was a powerful force well into the 1960s. New Brunswick was notorious for its racist treatment of African-Canadians. Nova Scotia still is.

We are and always have been racist people in this country. Funny how it has almost never made the news.

Thursday, June 6, 2013

June 6: police hold seminar on cargo thefts; council to vote on land purchase....

..and even more of the news YOU need to know.  On p. 1. A Moncton man is happy with his job in film... Oh, and Donald Savoie says "Province must put shoulder to the wheel". My, that man has a gift for le mot juste and the original, colourful phrase. I should love to attend one of his lectures - with a blanket, pillow and teddy bear.
_____________________________________________________________________________

Two days ago, all news media were informed there would be an anti-shale gas demonstration near St.-Louis de Kent. Yesterdayafternoon, as promised, it was  held. It blockaded SWN trucks that were there to begin gas exploration. It was quite peaceful. Nonetheless, thirty or forty police arrived; the highway was closed to all traffic; and there were some arrests.

But there is not a word about it on the front page or any other page of the Moncton TandT.

Well, on A4 there is a long story that everything is going just fine in the St.-Louis de Kent region, and SWN is continuing its peacful and harmless work. At the bottom of the story is a sentence that anti-shale gas groups had planned a protest, but had cancelled it. (In fact, the protest began about noon, which mean it was well in advance of press time.

There really are times when it's hard to tell whether TandT editors are chosen for their ability to lie or for their utter incompetence as journalists.
________________________________________________________________________________
Professor Savoie's second part of his grande oeuvre on the province's finances is as empty as his first one - and with all the pomposity of the first one.

He discusses the need for us to cut back - without a single mention of the role of big business in creating this situation. No, apparently, all this trouble was caused by us wasting money on child advocates, schools, medical care, and other frills.

There is no mention of how much Mr. Irving and friends suck out of this province in gifts, tax reductions,grants, special favours. And it's all the fault of t he politicians. Are you aware, Professor Savoie, that James Irving is a part of the government? He announced it himself. He appointed those who have been the official financial advisors to the government for the last two or three years.
He and his loved ones have forced their way into the schools, getting contracts they have no competence to carry out. It is almost certain the last two budgets were written by Irving flunkies.

But who has caused all this economic  trouble? Why, it's them there sick people and poor peop[le. And now, they gotta put their shoulder to the wheel. (brilliant phrase; what a gift that man has!)

Never mind that Mr. Irving has been making record profits for decades while most of the rest of us get poorer. Damn right. It's the fault of the poor. Cut off their medical service. Cut off child help. Close schools. Fire teachers. (We already show the way to save by spending the least in Canada on public and school libraries. But that's okay. Hell, the kids get astroturf fields to walk on.What more to they want?)

Mr. Irving and friends already put their shoulders to the wheel. The send their children to private schools to ease the cost to the public purse - and they probably have private doctors for the same reason.

Apparently, there are points "one of Canada's most respected" academics is unaware of.
1. The whole, western world is in recession. That is not entirely the fault of New Brunswick voters or of our wasting money on services to children.
2. It is well established that austerity is exactly the wrong way to go in this situation. Cutting spending will create the far worse situation we are seeing in Europe where it has increased suffering while sill delivering record profits to the very rich.
3. If you want to improve the economy, you have to get the noses of the Irvings of this world out of it. He has, outragerously, named himself a member of the government, stuffed it with his people, forced it to adopt his half-wit ideas on how a civil service should be run, and has demanded that everybody make sacrifices - everybody except him and his buddies.;

And Savoie disgraces the whole, academic world by acting as his yelping prophet.

Where the hell are the universities of this province? I'm sure there must be hundreds of professors who are not the sucks for Mr. Irving that Savoie is. But I'm never heard a word from any of them. Where are the economists who know Savoie is talking pompous nonsense? The scholars of Education who know that the Irvings are damaging the schools and our children? Where are the professors of Journalism who know what an incompetent, irrelevant and lying outfit the Irving Press is?

Those are the crises we face. The pillaging, destructive, anti-democratic interfering Irvings and their friends whose kiss-up political and academic servants remind me of the "democracies" of the Soviet Union and China.
_________________________________________________________________________________
NewsToday has a sample of bad (and possibly unethical) journalism, read the first paragraph of the story "Health workers confront premier". It says that Alward tried to convince an angry crowd of health workers "that his Tory government is taking a responsible approach to managing the costly system."

What's wrong with it? One word that a journalist should have been aware of and, certainly, that an editor should have caught.  Costly.

A news story is supposed to report fact, not opinion. One can say that Alward is a Tory - because he certainly is, and would never deny it. But whether the health system is costly is a judgement. Worse, it implies that it is too costly - and that word sets the reader's attitude for the rest of the story. It's a small thng. But It has a tremendous impact.
___________________________________________________________________________
The editorial is the usual ignorant rant. It offers its view - with no evidence whatever - that most of the hue and cry over health cuts is coming from interest groups. Actually, Mr. Editor, it's allowed to come from interest groups. That's called freedom of speech. It's called democracy. Politicians do not have an exclusive right to discuss political issues. We're all allowed to. After all, Mr. Editor, you represent a speical interest group, don't you?

It offers the advice that 750,000 people do not need 22 hospitals. That's a remarkably dumb statement. If the 750,000 lived in Toronto, then they certainly would not need 22 hospitals. But I suggest the editor take a drive around this province. It is somewhat more spread out than Toronto. And it doesn't have a subway system. In fact, it has little in the way of any public transit at all.

Generally, this is pretty brainless stuff, written to support Mr. Irving's grand design for the future of our social services - and anything else that hasn't been privatized yet.
_______________________________________________________________________________

Alec Bruce, Norbert Cunningham and Beth Lyons are worth reading. Rod Allen...well...you can see why he's an editor for Irving Press.
________________________________________________________________________
As a footnote for the day, there's a magazine called Literary Review of Canada (LRC). The edition for June, 2013, has a brilliant article on education - and one that has a special meaning for New Brunswick.

Though few Canadians know it, Canada has long had one of the best education systems in the world  in methods, teachers, and results. Though there is still work to be done, of course. But Canadian schools lead in closing the gap between successful and poor students And it consistently produces high results in international testing programmes. (You would never know that from reading the TandT.)

Our system is based on the public education system pioneered in Scotland, and has now spread around the world. It, more than anything else, accounts for the tremendous rise in knowledge and prosperity through most of the twentieth century.

But big business is not happy with it. It wants to impose business methods on the schools. It wants them to run on statistics, and just loves to impose tests that rank schools (tests that, in reality, are quite invalid and tell us nothing.) In Atlantic Canada, the pet dog for this thinking is Atlantic Institute for Market Studies which has been used by the Irvings to get their noses into the school system.

But the Irvings, as always, want more. They want to get their hands on our education tax money. Thus the gift of a two and half million dollar contract to an Irving to run a teaching programme he has no qualifications whatever for. In the long run, they want privatization of education - a step that would take us back at least three centuries.

It's already been tried on a large scale in Britain and the US with a gradual privatization of schools and the introduction of lots and lots of statistical measurement. And it has been a disaster wherever it has been tried. In the US, the quality of education has dropped to the lowest level in the developed world - and even below some in the undeveloped world. Britain is going through a similar drop.

Of course, that won't deter the Irvings. After all, they want profits and, getting them, they want more profits. And if that destroys our children for generations to come, who gives a damn?

So let's put our shoulders to the wheel and roll it over education and health to make the Irvings happy.

If you can't find LRC on a magazine rack, try the library. It's also possible Chapters would have it.
_____________________________________________________________________________

LRC also has a review of a book that is a true horror story about NB. The reviewer, a retired professor of the History Department at UNB says this is a wonderful read.

It's a true story set in the Shediac of 1805. Amos Babcock, in front of his wife and nine children, scalped his sister, then disembowelled her. (On learning this, I immiedately cancelled plans to visit the beach at Shediac. However, a check of my phone book reassured me that there are no longer any Babcocks in Shediac.)

It's "The Ballad of Jacob Peck" by Debra Komar. Try chapters. Try the library.

Too bad that the TandT, which constantly expresses its concern about literacy, never has a book review section to interest Monctonians in books like this.
_________________________________________________________________________




 

Wednesday, June 5, 2013

May 5: special edition - by idiots - for idiots...

Let's start with the editorial. Predictably, it's a hymn of praise to the Native "firm" which SWN has contracted to check its safety procedures in fracking.

Obviously, these are eight people of unusual insight. They can tell without ever having met them that the many, many thousands of New Brunswickers who oppose fracking for shale gas are "liars". Obviously, these are people who can see around corners.

So how come we haven't been told all about their superb training and their work experience? How many such contracts have they had? From whom?

Monitoring for toxic materials and dangerous procedures in pretty sophisticated work, calling for very advanced training. Can we be given some idea of their advanced training in chemistry? Engineering? The distinguished universities they attended?

And if they are so highly educated, how come they don't talk gooder?

Does the hiring of this firm mean we can't trust government regulators to do the job? But aren't you the one who earlier said we could? And if it's true that there's a danger of cheating in the process, then that would mean the cheating would originate with SWN. So why on earth would SWN contract a company to see if it's guilty of cheating? And why should we trust a company (which seems low on brains in the first place) to report cheating by the people who pay its bills?

This is an editorial that shows utter contempt for the common sense of the whole population of New Brunswick.

Either that or the editorialist is so thick he needs a sheet of instructions to zip his fly.
_________________________________________________________________________________
Then we have the first of Prof. Savoie's series on the economic future of New Brunswick. (sound of trumpets, curtains open to reveal parade of elephants, each with a trumpeter seated on its head.)

It's an interesting view of the economic future as one might have seen it in 1950, but perhaps a bit dated for 2013. It's also, to put it kindly, a string of mindless platitudes tarted up to sound like scholarly wisdom. He also completely ignores the impact that Irving and other big business have on the province - the enormous costs they thrust on us, the enormous ripping off they have subjected us to as they get richer every year to the degree that they make us poorer, their de facto control of our government.

We all, says Prof Savoie, should be involved in the planning of our future. Come off it. The government doesn't give a damn what we plan. The government IS Irving. You're a professor. Do you know what the word coalition means? Irving has publicly said he is in coalition with the government. He also appointed the official advisors to the Minister of Finance. Close your eyes tight, and really think hard, Prof. What does that tell you about who makes the decisions in this province?

Incidentally, there are citizens who are trying to play a role - the anti-shale gas movement. I'm suprised you don't praise them for their efforts. (Well, no, I'm not suprised. You praise only those whose role is kissing Mr. Irving's rear end.)

As to my suggestion that Prof Savoie writes as if this were the 1950s, he writes as if the future will be much like today - but just getting better and better at doing more of the same. But this is not 1950.
1. The western economies are in collapse. The "recovery" has been mainly by the very, very wealthy. For the rest, there has been no recovery. Even those jobs that reopen are now at lower salaries.
2. For 500 years, western economies have depended on their military dominance of the world and its trade. That is almost certainly over. That dominance, despite American and British and French attempts to turn back the clock, is done.
3. Big business has, through free trade, freed itself of any need to give a damn about loyalty to its own countries - including Canada.
4. Big business has assumed almost complete dominance over elected governments in the US, Canada, Britain, France, and Germany. They, not we, control our governments.
5.It is aiming at complete privatization of everything - schools, medical care, prisons, police forces, everything. So much for our role. (Such privatization, incidentally, has proven both enormously expensive and socially disastrous.)
6.Our growth of the past half-century has come at tremendous cost in resources, many of which are running out - at tremendous damage to the environment with effects we already feel in climate changes which will become much - and often fatally - worse in the very near future.
7. Big business is pillaging what is left of the wealth of the western world. As US companies post bigger profits every  year, the number of Americans who now cannot afford enough food is one in six. (And the US government is cutting down on food stamps.) Banks in the US and Britain have criminally looted the state of hundred of billions of dollars - at least. In Canada, the very rich have been getting richer as everybody else gets poorer - and that has been going on for at least twenty years.
8. Cutting government social programmes to balance the budget will not make things better. It will make them worse. That was one of the great lessons of the 1930s. Indeed, the looting of Europe, coupled with the cutting of budgets, has turned Spain, Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece - at least those - into breeding grounds for violence and revolution. These hardly seem like good models for us to follow.

None of these problems can be solved by a pipeline or developing shale gas or by building an "events' centre. We are facing the need to make fundamental changes to a society based on materialism. We are going to need to rethink fundamentals like the way he house people and the way we move about in cities. We are going to have to re-establish governments that once were democratic but which now fit the dictionary definition of fascist. The people who really govern us are greedy, short-sighted - and really not very bright.

But none of that will be discussed by a professor who has shown all the signs of being Mr. Irving's court jester.

_________________________________________________________________________________
Another good column by Norbert on the Senate.

Alec Bruce is certainly the most knowledgeable person at that paper. But in today's column - as in many others - he stops short of seeing reality.

Eric Lewis warns about the dangers of a  moment of stupidity. It's about the dangers of lighting bush fires. He's right. But this is scarcely the stuff of an opinion column. A news interview with a fire chief would have been quite adequate.

Brian Cormier talks about how pretty flowers are.

Way to speak out and tell it like it is, Brian.

 

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

June 4: the fix is in....down and dirty

 Lead story - "Policy expert calls for debate"

The expert is Donald Savoie who never met an Irving or an fossil fuel executive he didn't like. He is writing a special four-part series, a challenge for the looming crisis (as opposed to an unlooming one) that threatens New Brunswick. He is challenging our economic and political leaders to a debate on the subject.
(Why should they debate? The economic leaders know what they want. What's to debate? The Liberal and Conservative leaders don't need a debate. They've been told what to do, and they're scampering to do it. And the TandT has shown not the slightest interest in a debate. It's been printing nothing but propaganda for years.)

"This is not the time for conflicting messages says Mr. Savoie." Oh. Well, that kind of kills the debate, doesn't it? I mean, if you don't have conflicting messages, you don't really have a debate. Do you?"

Then the blurb says this is to be an exceptionally honest review. Hint - if you have to say it's honest, then that sort of implies it really isn't. Indeed, I have never before seen a news story that had to say that a statement (which hasn't appeared yet) is honest.

We are told that the TandT wants to encourage a debate.  How nice! So why have they spent so many years either dodging the subject or lying?

And the final essay in the series?  "Saying yes to development".  Of course.
_________________________________________________________________________________
Double whammy Front page!  "First Nations group backs SWN." The group turns out to be eight people who developed their superior knowledge of fracking from talking to SWN execs. Called the Chief to Chief Consulting Group, they will be  checking to make sure the environment is safe. Yep.

Eight people get front page. eight people whose knowledge comes entirely from shale gas execs. Gee. And who paid for their visits with these kind-hearted execs? And who's paying them to do the monitoring?

And what training do they have to do that monitoring? There is no evidence to suggest these are well educated people. Read the article, and take a close look at sentences quoted from their leader.

"I think it can be working side by side with someBODY and making sure THEY are following..."

"As far as our group,we've educated ourselves...." (not only is that an ignorant choice of words; the idea that eight people of no special training have made themselves experts on a subject requiring a high degree of training is absurd.)

"...to be quite honest with you...." Anyone who says this is almost certainly lying. It was a favourite phrase among the mafia kids I grew up with.

Then he says the anti-shale gas people are telling "flat out lies". That's a serious charge to make against people most (perhaps all) of whom he has never met.

Then, in a subtle shift to reverse racism, he implies the anti-shale gas group should be ignored because it's non-native.

Amazing it never seems to have occured the reporter to ask about any of this. Here we are presented with eight people taking a highly unusual position, whose contact appears to have been solely with SWN, whose source of funding is unknown, and whose pattern of speech suggests limited education.

And it didn't occur to either the reporter or the assignement editor that there were questions to be asked here.
_____________________________________________________________________________
Then there is the story that we don't have.

SWN cancelled its meeting in St.-Louis de Kent because, it said, it received a threat.

1. What was the threat? Do they have an evidence of it? This "threat" has been used to slander a large group of people. Surely, the company has an obligation to say what the threat was, and how it was received.

2. Did SWN notify the police? Isn't it required by law to report such threats? Are they too scared to hold a meeting? And also too scared to tell the police?

My guess is that there probably was no threat. The cancellation of the meeting was done to create divisions in NB. Watch next for an 'incident'. It's not hard to set one up. You know, hire a couple of thugs to do damage to company property. Then demand that the police be called in to protect those nice folks at SWN from those terrible protesters.
_______________________________________________________________________________
There is a desperate game being played here. The fuels from oilsands and from shale gas have to be sold soon. Oil sands fuel is deadly to our future. Shale gas may be somewhat better - BUT - at the present rate of increase of fuel, the poisoning of our atmosphere and the changes to our climate will increase even if we use nothing but shale gas.

People in the fossil fuel business have always been too short-sighted, too greedy, and too indifferent to recognize that. But even they realize that the roof is going to fall in - and soon. That's why they - and Harper - are in a desperate hurry to sell this stuff as fast as they can. Expect lots of dirty tricks.
_____________________________________________________________________________
In NewsToday, the "Hospital union fears big health cuts". They're right.
"Efficiency" was just a buzz word in reorganizing our hospitals. It was always about cuts in budget - and in service. Does Flemming understand that? I don't know. He gives no outward sign of human intelligence. But he's a good lapdog for Irving.

There are at least three issues here to consider.

1. We are going to see cuts to our hospital services. Given our scattered and aging population, our medical services have to cost more than other provinces.   Bringing the spending to average can be done, then, only by cutting the services.

2. In the next round, the TandT will be obeying the boss' orders to push for privatization - which will give us the American situation in which millions get no medical care at all, and in which the largest cause of bankruptcy among the elderly is medical bills.

3. Budget-cutting in a recession does not work. It never has in human history. Making even more people poor will not bring back the good times. That was the lesson of the 1930s. And right now we're watching a Europe which is sinking into unspeakable poverty - and certainly into very serious violence - because of budget cuts.

4. sorry - forgot this one. The province that can't afford library books for its schools or adequate medical care for its citizens can afford astroturf for school playing fields, and a hundred million plus for a hockey rink.

In the US, budget cuts in social services have done nothing to ease the recession for anybody except billionaires who are now wealthier than ever. Meanwhile, and as the government makes cuts in food stamps, one in six Americans goes hungry. So far as we know, the rich are eating regularly.
______________________________________________________________________________

The editorial is the usual piece of idiocy, using the word efficiency to cover the reality of budget cuts and less service for those who need it. Amazing how no editor in the history of Brunswick news has ever written to suggest that a better answer might be to get Irvings and friends pay their share of taxes.

Good column by Norbert. Good column by Alec Bruce.

Alan Cochrane continues his adolescence with a vroom-vroom column about a motorcyle parade.

And Gwynne Dyer shocked the pants off me. I knew Gwynne many years ago when we were in our early radio days. I liked him. I had a lot of respect for his views on foreign affairs.  But today's column by him is bizarre. He argues that the world is more at peace than it looks. Well, maybe such an argument can be made - but much of his evidence is just plain wrong.

There are not "just two wars" going on in the world. The US is killing people in Afghanistan, and supplying  the "civil" war in Syria. But it is also killing people in Pakistan, Somalia, and Yemen. Using your army to kill people is called war. Whether it is actually declared doesn't matter.

Incidentally, an embargo is also an act of war - so that means war against Iran and Cuba. And, in the case of Iran, people are dying - adult scientists by assassination, and young children for lack of medicines cut off by the embargo.

Then there's the war in  Mali - inspired by the French who want Mali's resources.

Oh, an a thousand were killed in fighting last month in Iraq. It's getting worse. But I think a thousand dead in a month sounds like a civil war now.

The war in Syria is being fought with money and weapons from Britain, the US, Saudi Arabia and Qatar, with mercenaries from a dozen countries. That means all of them are at war, too. The US is also active in encouraging revolutions in uncooperative countries in Latin America. And it has recently killed several hundred thousand in Guatemala.

Oh, and to slip back to Africa, there was war in Libya with the war largely financed, organized and supplied by the US - and with Libya now hopelessly ungovernable and wracked by a hundred small wars.

Then he says "only" a million have been killed in the 21st century. That's nonsense. The Iraq war alone killed well over a million - and it is largely the cause of the violence and killing now springing up between Islamic sects throughout Africa.

Meanwhile, it is almost certain wars can be expected involviing Israel, Iran, Lebanon, the US, Britain, As well, American expansionism (to put it kindly) is forcing China and Russia to confront it.

And, oh, yes, the world has 17,000 nuclear weapons.

Oh, Gwynne, Gwynne.....
________________________________________________________________________________

Tonight at 7 pm at the library, I shall meet with the current events group. Though you would never guess it from the Brunswick Press, we are living through a time of the greatest change since the fall of Rome - and maybe a good deal greater than that. So I'll be talking about where that change comes from - and the real issues we have to face.

The old ways are dying (or being killed) before our eyes. And there is no plan for the future.

I invite all the wise folk of the TandT - Rod Allen, Al Hogan, to challenge any point they like.

In fact, I even invite Mr. Irving. After all, he is, by his own declaration, a member of the government - and the department of Finance's official advisors are his appointees. I'm sure he'll want to report to the people on what he's been doing in government, and seeking our approval.


______________________________________________________________________________

Monday, June 3, 2013

June 3: A very mixed bag...

Just back from a couple of days in PEI. Quite a revelation. I lived there for three years in my early teaching days - and hated it. This time, as I drove along its roads, I was quite taken by the high standard maintenance of its houses and grounds. Even the bits of forest looked neat and cared for. The neatness, the cleanliness, the sense of colour were a remarkable contrast to the shabbiness of much of rural (and urban) New Brunswick.

I was also struck by the initiatives of small business in setting up tourist attractions. We could learn a great deal from PEI.

I also picked up a copy of The Globe for Saturday. (The island newspapers, though superior to those of New Brunswick, are nothing wonderful.) The Globe has serious weak points but, oh, it's a journalistic paradise compared to the Irving Press.

For example, The Globe carried the story about BC saying no to a pipeline from the oilsands to the west coast. As well, native peoples along the route said no. They're worried, and rightly so about oil spills.

Harper is desperate to get that oil to the China market while such polluting oil is still permitted - which won't be long. That's why he launched a racist campaign against native peoples. (He was going to make them there native peoples accountable to Ottawa for their spending and, particularly, make their chief's salaries public. This nicely ignores the fact that most of the chief's salaries already are public - and  they're low; that the money native people get from Ottawa is theirs by right of treaty - and a damn cheap price we pay for the getting all this land; that, in fact, we have not been paying nearly as much as we're supposed to under the treaties.)

You don't think this is racist? Okay. What if it read "We're going to crack down on them there Jews" or "them there Koreans", or "them there African Canadians."?

Harper wants control of native peoples because he wants to pollute and destroy their lands to make a quick buck for his friends. And if they resist, well, then they're trouble-makers, and he'll send in police or even the army. And it will be all the fault of them there native peoples.

He'll even win votes on it. There are far more racists and bigots in this country that we are prepared to admit.  I could give you a couple of shocking examples of racism and bigotry here in New Brunswick. But, like much racism, it flies under that radar so we con't notice it, even when we share it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Globe also had a major column "The shale revolution and its unintended climate side effects". When was the last time you saw something critical of shale gas in the Irving press?

There were also two, full pages by experts giving each side of the shale gas debate. When was the last time you saw that in the Irving Press?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
That latter point reminded me of SWN's bizarre cancellation of an "information" meeting in New Brunswick a few days ago on the claim they feared for the safety of their employees. That theme was emphasized in Saturday's TandT.

I think we're being set up. Consider these points.

1. Why do the press and SWN refer to the anti-shale gas people as protesters? These are people on opposite sides in a debate - rather like Liberals and Conservatives. Ever see the paper refer to Liberals or Conservatives as protesters? So why use the word here?
Because the word 'protesters' implies violence and trouble-making?
2. Why did SWN cancel the meeting? If it's an information meeting so of course people of both sides would be there. Supposedly, that's why such meetings are held. So why cancel? Nobody had made any threat of violence.  And we can be quite sure that the bosses at SWN don't give a damn for the safety of their employees. In fact, an attack on them would suit SWN perfectly, giving it an excuse to call for police suppression of the anti-shale gas movement. So why did they cancel?
a)The may have been worried that the antis at the meeting would be more numerous than the pros. turning into a meeting that would make SWN look bad.
b) They may be looking to build an image of the anti-shale gas people as being violent and revolutionary. That would make it easier for SWN to stage an incident, and demand that the police be called in.

The shale gas companies, like the oilsands people, are desparate. They know this stuff is severely damaging to the climate. They know that this truth will soon be unavoidable. So they have to get it out and sell it now.

It's short-sighted because even the CEOs will have to live in the severely damaged world they are creating. But short-sightedness is the occupational disease of big business.
_____________________________________________________________________________
And I have'nt even got to today's TandT.

Section A is, as usual, a zero. The major story in it is propaganda for Health Minister Ted "Me Tarzan" Flemming. "N.B. hospitals could cut costs  by $236m:report".

Of course, they could. The study was assigned to a company with the understanding it would come up with savings. So, of course it did. And isn't it interesting that the report wasn't submitted until AFTER Me Tarzan had already announced cuts? How convenient it should support what he had said!

And why must the costs come to equal the Canadian average? We don't have the average conditions of other provinces. This is all just statistical babble. So why do we have to meet the average for provinces when our province has more elderly and a more widely scattered population to contend with? Why not the US average. (that would give us a huge budget increase), or the Afghanistan average (we could bomb all the hospitals.)

This story is not a story at all. A news story would tell us more about the credentials and affiliations of the company that did the study. It would ask for the reaction of people like the medical associations and the Chief Medical Officer.

This really isn't a news story. It's a propaganda spread for a man in a loincloth  (44" waist) swinging on a vine. And there's another man way up in the tree who swings it the way he wants Mr. Flemming to go.
_______________________________________________________________________________
NewsToday is really "AdsToday".
________________________________________________________________________________
The editorial is bizarre. It's a call for saving "Castle Manor", a tall and skinny, stone building with standard size windows going sideways and upwards in a stunning show of boredom. The roof has obviously phony crenelations in the worst possible imitation of those late nineteenth century mansions that were dreadful copies of medieval architecture. It's unspeakably ugly and tasteless.

This newspaper, which supported the closing of a high school which is architecturally impressive and whose outward appearance, unlike "Castle Manor" does not pretend to be something it is not, now wants us to spend public money on a useless pile of ugly rock.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This a rare occasion. I don't agree with a word of Alec Bruce's column. To suggest that change can come only conferences and actions by big business, that government doesn't make change, is absurd. Big business did not create health care. Big business did not create our social safety net - not here, not in Britain, not in the US, not in anywhere I ever heard of.

Bruce says government is useless because it reflects us - and we don't know what we're doing. I don't believe I have ever seen such a thorough dismissal of democracy. His whole column is a pitch for dictatorship by big business.

He advocates education that would be centred almost entirely on job training. Well, that's good. That'll keep voters stupid so their wishes won't get in the way.

Oh, yeah. And university research should be tied to business wants. Right. That'll  stop creating the Dr. Suzuki's of this world who get in the way of business. It will also do away with fields like philosophy, sociology, history....that teach people to think. I mean, a lion tamer in a circus doesn't teach lions to think. He trains them to do what he says when he cracks a whip. That's what universities should be doing.

Of course, most of them are already doing it - and too damn much of it. The world needs thinking people, not Irving puppets.

"As for governments, their watchwords should be collaboration..." Has he looked at the Liberals and Conservative governments of this province? What does he think they do if not to collaborate. Their lips on permanently attached to the bums of the wealthy.

The conferees say we should start thinking for ourselves. Whoever said that is too dippy to understand that the only way we can express that thinking for ourselves is through democracy, and through education that teaches us to think, not just trains us to serve others.

This is really just the standard TandT line of government bad, big business good.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Craig Babstock has a nothing column, seemingly to tip off pimps and "customers" that there is a court case in Ottawa which might lead to legalizing prostitution. Or it might not. (yawn)

From its title, I thought I would be bored by Steve Malloy's column on hunting for a summer job. But I was quite wrong. In fact, I photocopied it for my two sons.

Finally, a letter to the editor about abortion. I can see reason to agree with both sides on this. But - the reality is that abortion and infanticide have been with us - and on a big scale - for thousands of years. To make it illegal will certainly please the self-righteous - but it will do little about the problem.

How about both sides sitting down, recognizing this is not simply a personal matter and, instead of screaming at each other, discuss how this is a question for our whole society to deal with it in a way that helps both mother and child. As it is, there are evil consequences whichever of two, debated choices. we make. We need to examine this will less self-concious virtue, and rather more practical, common sense.

Saturday, June 1, 2013

June 1: Back in the gutter again...

Whoever writes the editorials for the TandT wrote a sort of respectable one yesterday. It was really propaganda for SWN; and it was written to stir up fear and hatred of shale gas progesters. But at least it wasn't the real down and dirty stuff that the editorials usually are. Today makes up for that lapse.

It repeats the SWN propaganda that it simply could not expose its employees to physical threats by protesters. (Never mind that such threats were never made.) And my goodness, the only protection that the SWN people would  have is all the armed police in the province. Of course, the protesters could fight back, armed with their plastic Stop Shale Gas signs.

Never mind, too, that SWN is used to protesters all over the US and Canada. In any such case, it's the one with muscle on its side. This lying editorial is an attempt to stir up fears, lies and hatreds. It's written to support the propaganda and lies of SWN. That kind of lying and fear-mongering is exactly what creates violence - and the violence usually comes from the billionaires who can rely on the support of political hacks and the full resources of police and even military power.

Then he says the protesters are closing their eyes to the financial benefits of shale gas development. On the contrary, it's the editorial writer who has closed  his eyes to the consequences of it - and who has routinely lied about it.

Incidentally, it is not likely that shale gas will bring prosperity to New Brunswick. Most of the money, by far, will go out of the province.

In a related case, BC has refused to allow a pipeline from the tar sands to cross it. The arguments against it are much the same as those against shale gas. How odd that the TandT didn't bother to report the BC story!

What's really going on here? The age of fossil fuels is coming to an end. Oil and gas moguls - and Harpers - are determined to sell as much of it as possible before the roof caves in. And if that poisons us and impoverishes us for generations to come, so be it. They'll rip what they can out of the province, and leave us to cope with the disasters. Not they're problem. They'll be busy ripping off somebody else in some other part of the world.

Big business lives for now. Its idea of future does not extend more than three months. And it has only one concern - making profits. It couldn't care less about what that does to people. That's why it's fatally dangerous to allow business to corrupt and to interfere with government.

_________________________________________________________________________

In a related story (on p. D1) there was a riot at a Canadian gold mine in Krygyzstan in which 85 people were injured. That's not unusuall. Canadian mining companies have a dreadful reputation all over the world for brutality, bad working conditions, confiscation of land, displacement of people, beatings, murder all over the world.

If the TandT is really concerned about violence, if might want to take a look at that as, for example, in Central America where pollution from Canadian mines runs wild, and where thousands have been killed by police and the army. Gee! How brave of the mining companies to put their executives at risk. Luckily, the armies and police have concentrated their beatings, killings and rapes on the lowly employees, not on the company bosses.
_______________________________________________________________
The rest of editorial and op ed were okay - and Gwynne Dyer was excellent. Brent Mazerolle's column was a little lightweight - all about the naming of a school. But at least is was an opinion column, and not a doggie woggie story.
________________________________________________________________________
Check out Isabelle Agnew's column on p. F3. She responds to pastor Richard Jackson's sermonette on last week's face page. She thought it was a good column - and I agree. But what's most interesting is that his column took a very practical approach to religion - and that is what got a response from Isabelle Agnew.

This wasn't a dozy column about how sweet Jesus is. It was about Christianity as a practical matter - the only such sermonette I have seen on that page. And it made contact. And it stimulated thinking. And it created interest. This is good stuff. But Miss Agnew tells the story a whole lot better than I do - so be sure to read her.
________________________________________________________________________________
A reminder about the gathering of the current events groups this Tuesday at 7 p.m. at the Moncton library. All are welcome. One topic for this session is "The truth about Stephen Harper". I have always thought him an ideologue with fanatical political philosophy with the potential to destroy Canada. I may have been wrong.

I think now that he has no political ideology at all - just a fanatical desire to have power (with the potential to destroy Canada.)