Monday, August 20, 2012

August 20: Another empty day in the Moncton Times

For the third day, there is a front page story about people flying kites - along with one and a half pages of pictures of kites for those who don't know what one looks like. D1 has the big news that Rihanna still misses her ex-boyfriend. This is a newspaper that almost screams, "My readers are fools. My purpose is to feed them trivia so they will have no idea what is happening in the province or the world, and so they will think "corporation boss" means "philanthropist".

For more trivia, check out the editorial, and the op ed page.

There are only two sections worth reading. There is Alec Bruce's column, light but well written; and which really does have a point. Then there is a letters to the editor page that is the best I have ever seen in this paper. Obviously, New Brunswickers have more brains than the Times and Transcript gives them credit for.

Then there is the main headline, the inevitable bilge about the raid on Dieppe. It was indeed a tragic event, and we really should know a great deal more about who died there, and why they died. But I also think we should learn from history, not just babble platititudes about it.

The sacrifice did not preserve freedom of any sort in Canada. Freedom in North American was never threatened in World War Two  (or One, or the Boer War, or by any other war since 1812.) There has been damage to our freedom over the years. But it's been caused by our governments, and by news media that withhold essential information from us.

And be careful about the story that we learned crucial German codes at Dieppe. Harper will play that tune for the kind of people who support him. But that's a story that needs a lot of testing and historical debate before being accepted.

What we do know about the causes of Dieppe are these.
1. Churchill needed some spectacular event for morale.
2. British troops were already stretched pretty thin.
3. Canadian troops were available, were well trained after two years in Britain, and had seen no action.
4. They had seen no action because Prime Minister Mackenzie King didn't want them to. He didn't care about lives. He was afraid that any losses would force him to introduce conscription - and he feared that would cost him the next election.
5. He was assured by Churchill that any losses at Dieppe would be small. So he agreed to release the Canadian troops.
6. Lord Louis Mountbatten, planner of the raid, had no experience or competence to plan such a raid. Already promoted way over his head because he was a Lord and was closely related to the Royal Family (he was Prince Phillip's uncle), he was a disastrous choice to plan a raid. (But this would not prevent him from  getting even greater promotions later one.)
7. The raiding force was detected by the Germans before it got to Dieppe. There was a fire-fight, and the German garrison was alerted. When the Canadians landed on a narrow beach funneled by cliffs, every piece of that beach was already covered by machine guns and artillery. Planners should have realized that - and the raid should have been called off as soon as the force was spotted.

This is certainly an event we should remember and should mourn. But we could do without the babbling of the usual speakers at our remembrances. Those who died at Dieppe deserve, at the least, to be remembered for  how and why they died.

In the absence of anything in the Times and Transcript to comment on, the following points are some jottings I made yesterday.

1. Probably the most honest newspaper available in the English language (and one of the most intelligent) is the Israeli paper, Haaretz. You can get it on Google.

According to Haaretz, polls show that a large majority of Israelis is opposed to any attack on Iran. Many don't believe that Iran is developing a nuclear bomb (it almost certainly isn't); and they believe the attack is planned for other reasons. (And they're right.) The Israel military leaders agree with the majority, some even of the opinion that Netanyahu is mentally unbalanced.

So why is this very minor leader able to lead Obama (and Harper) around by the nose? Because there is a very powerful and well-funded Israeli lobby in North America, that's why. Say a word against Israeli policy, and that lobby accuses you of being an anti-Semite. Many of my friends who are Jewish and Zionist have been accused of being anti-semites because they oppose Netanyahu.

Thanks to Netanyahu, the Middle East may, at any time, become chaos with the potential to touch off World War Three.

2. What is the western policy in Africa and the Middle East? To bring democracy? Get real.
Most countries in the middle east are bits of patchwork drawn onto maps by the western powers a hundred years and more ago. Syria, Libya, Lebanon, Iraq have all been, at best, fragile. The purpose of the West is to make sure they don't become real and united countries. If they did, they would have the strength to resists western intrusions and exploitation. Breaking them up keeps them weak. That's why Libya still doesn't have a functioning government - and it won't. That's why the west happily supports non-democratic groups in Syria and Lebanon.

3. Watch for an extremely low election turnout in the US. The possibility of a Romney/Ryan victory inspires terror - as it should. But Romney has immense funding from the corporate world.  (With a hundred million Americans on some form of welfare, John Ryan says the answer is to further cut taxes for the rich who are already enjoying their greatest profits in history.)

But Obama has been a dreadful disappointment - and he's funded by much the same people as Romney. And there is no, realistic third choice.

A record low turnout would almost certainly have terrible consequences for the US. On the other hand, it's hard to see a turnout that would offer anything useful.

4. There has been a wave of murders of American trainers by Afghan troops and police. Some news sources say these are Taliban who join the training programmes to steal weapons. Those sources should listen to the American generals who said yesterday that they are not Taliban. They are from the tribes who are, supposedly, on our side. This is where multi-trillion dollars, over ten years of war, and tens of thousands of dead have taken us. And the people behind this disaster are still influential - and see nothing wrong with their policies.

And there is still no reason to believe that anybody in Afghanistan had anything to do with 9/11.

9/11 has led to at least eight wars, only two of them officially declared. It has killed well over a million people,and driven uncounted millions of Americans into hopeless debt for generation to come. So what's it all about?

Google- Project for the New American Century. They said it. Not me.

5. Harper promised a year of intense scientific study before approving the Northern Gateway Pipeline. Scientists said it would take more time. But Harper insisted on one year. Now, just to make sure, he has gutted the budget for research on the project.

6. Ever read Paul Craig Roberts? You really should.

http://www.paulcraigroberts.org/2012/08/16/is-washington-deaf-as-well-criminal/

No, he is not a terrorist front. In fact, his credentials are pretty good, and very much pro-American in the best sense of that term.

He's been a high official in the Department of Finance, and a very respected journalist for The Wall Street Journal (which is not a terrorist front, either.)

7. The Moncton Times and Transcript does not seem interested in the Quebec election. that's too bad, because this is one that could have a serious impact on all of us. This one is really dangerous.

But this post is too long already. I'll save it for tomorrow.

oh, some will read this post and say I'm anti-American. I suppose they might also say I'm anti-Canadian for criticizing Harper, or anti-New Brunswick for criticizing Alward.

But the fact is, it is not Americans or Canadians or Quebeckers or New Brunswickers who are doing wrong. It is American and Canadian and Quebec and New Brunswick corporations and politicians that are doing
wrong.

And if you think that makes me anti some corporations and some politicians - you're damn right I am.

Saturday, August 18, 2012

August 18: A very mixed bag....

There's everything from excellent to puerile in today's Moncton Times and Transcript. So let's get the crap out of the way to go on to what's worth talking about.
1. There is no news whatever on anything of importance to Moncton or the province. (Unless, of course, you    just can't get enough of pictures of kites, and stories about dogs coming home.)
There is, to be fair, a picture and brief story about Roy McMullen who is running for leadership of the Green Party. But there is not a hint - and never has been - about why anybody in New Brunswick would be interested in green issues. After all, we all know that there are no problems whatever with shale gas; and New Brunswick has the toughest standards for shale gas drilling in the whole world. So what could possibly go wrong?

2. Reuters' account of the diplomatic crisis over Julian Assange and Wikkileaks is almost incoherent. It didn't even have a mention of what must be Assange's greatest concern for what could happen to him. An army private who is alleged to have helped him with the  Wikkileaks, private Bradley Manning, was imprisoned by the US government over a year ago without charge or trial.  He has suffered over a year of solitary confinement and torture - with UN rights officials not permitted to see him. He is now being tried before a military court (which accepts evidence gathered by torture, and whose rules are so loose that the accused is almost invariably found guilty.) Private Manning can expect to spend the rest of his life in prison for the crime of showing that US presidents have consistently lied about the reasons for Iraq and Afghanistan - as well as many other things.  But don't worry your head about it. It's not a story you are likely to see in the TandT. There are too many kites to report on.

3. (Bill) Belliveau lectures lobster fishermen that they, as independent businessmen have to learn that the market dictates the price of goods. So they shouldn't expect government help.

Bill, I would have a hell of a lot more respect for  you if you were to write a lecture like that for the billionaire who owns the newspaper you write for. Meanwhile, I can only assume that the words "in depth" under your name indicate you are prepared to sink very low, indeed.

So much for the crap.

There is a superb column by Gwynne Dyer on what this hot and dry summer is going to mean as millions are going to starve for want of the price of a meal. (Perhaps we can send Bill Belliveau among the starving to spread the comforting, Holy writ that "Market dictates price of food commodities".

There's a good column by Brent Mazerolle on the Dieppe raid and, on p. B1, a fascinating news story about it.

I can add a little bit to Brent's column (not a correction, just a footnote.)

One of my professors (and the supervisor of my doctoral dissertation) was a brilliant man who was the leading authority on Mackenzie King (prime minister in World War 2). He was also close to King for many years. He is relatively unknown because he published very little of what he knew. But he shared his knowledge generously with scholars who gained fame as a result. And he shared it with us students.

Mackenzie King approved of the disastrous Dieppe raid. He also approved of the even more terrible sending of two thousand Canadian troops to Hong Kong, an indefensible colony where those 2000 Canadians would die in the fighting, or of disease and abuse and starvation in prison camps - or would return to Canada forever shattered in body and mind.  Why did King do that?

The prime minister wanted only one thing in life - to be prime minister. And, related to that, his greatest fear throughout World War Two was that Canadians would be killed.

No. He didn't care about it for the sake of Canadian soldiers. He did it because in World War One, Canadian losses had forced PM Borden to introduce conscription for military service. That destroyed the Conservative party for the best part of a half century. King was determined to avoid casualties - because casualties could mean conscription. And conscription could mean that he would lose the next election.

He sent troops to Hong Kong because that gave the impression he was helping in the war effort but, since he was assured Hong Kong was a safe place to be, there would be no danger of being forced into conscription.

Brent Mazerolle's account is quite correct. Just add to it King's motivation. He had been assured that casualties would be minimal. So there would be no conscription - and he and the Liberal party would survive. (There is a p.s. to the story. Late in the war, King did have to introduce conscription. But it was so obvious that he had postponed it as long as he could that he didn't suffer for it.)

My attention was caught, as well, by a news story on Dieppe.

The story on p. B1 is about a researcher named O'Keefe who says he has discovered that Dieppe was really  a cover for another raid that was a huge success in breaking German intelligence.

(In fairness and pure ego, I  have to admit it was the name O'Keefe that caught my attention. In my days at Concordia, I taught him military history. He was one of many, excellent students I  had who were officers in the militia. Taken as a group, they were a very bright bunch, people all Canadians can be proud of.)

It's too early yet to be sure of the importance of O'Keefe's theory. But it looks promising.

As to the importance of lessons learned at Dieppe, I disagree with that as I disagreed with O'Keefe so many years ago. You land troops on an open but narrow beach with impossible natural barriers, and manned by an enemy that knows you are coming, and makes the beach a wall of machine-gun fire and blasting shells...you try to run tanks up a steeply sloping beach covered in loose gravel..and they can't do it.....

Any military planner who needed to learn those lessons is a person who shouldn't be allowed to go to the bathroom by himself.

The great problem is that the planner of that raid was Lord Louis Mountbatten, a celebrated war figure, one who would go on to even higher command - but hopelessly out of his league in any military situation.

Friday, August 17, 2012

August 17: The blog I hoped.........

....I would never have to write. It's about a major story that did not appear in The Moncton Times and Transcript. In fact, no major story appeared anywhere in this most trivial and vapid edition of a newspaper I have even seen. The only item of any note is a photo in Section B, p. 1, of Harper showing pride in his pregnancy.

It won't change any reactions to what I'm going to say - but I'll tell this, anyway.

I grew up and lived a member of a minority. Because I was a member of a minority, I was beaten be gangs, denied police protection, denied jobs. I grew up in a hysteria of bigotry, hatred, ignorance, abuse, much of it supported by the politicians, by the education system, and by the Roman Catholic church.

Others, such as Blacks, Chinese, Jews, had it worse - and had it worse from both French and English. Quebec always has been and still is a thoroughly bigoted and racist province in English, in French, and in both official languages. In the 1930s, it had thriving fascist and Nazi movements. The fascist headquarters, Casa d'Italia, was just a few blocks from my home. (Years later, I would drop into the coffee shop owned by the local Il Duce to get matchbooks with a picture of him and Mussolini on the cover.) The Nazi party's Deputy Fuehrer was a  relative of mine. (Check it in google. Dr. Noel Decarie.)

For a dozen years or more, I was on the provincial executive of Alliance Quebec, the anglo rights group, the last several of them as Vice-President and Chairman. I've gone through interviews with a deliberately lying and hate-mongering French press, through riots, through arson of our offices - all of it to the indifference of the Montreal police. It was a province it which it was virtually impossible for an anglo to get a civil service job - not even as a garbageman. Nor would becoming bilingual help. You had to be pur laine - a native born Quebecois of French stock.

If you are the latter in Quebec, you have the right to a job as, say, nurse in an English school - even if  you cannot speak a word of English. I have spoken at a provincial conference of teachers who teach English at  French schools. Many, very many could not carry on a simple conversation in English. At the other extreme, I knew a woman, French born, raised with French as her first language, fluent in English, trained in it, hired to teach English in a French school - then fired because it was discovered she had gone to an English high school. No more pur laine for her.

I grew up as a "honglish pig". Oh, I had the right blood, that of one of the founding families of Montreal. The godfather of the first Decarie born in the new world was Paul de Maisonneuve, the founder of the city. The godmother was Jeanne Mance, a towering figure in Quebec history.

But Quebec nationalism has always been a thoroughly racist movement. It still is. I left Quebec as soon as I retired. All that lingers is a hatred of racisim - and a contempt for the Canada that deserted us.

I should add that I had also come to understand that Quebec nationalism is a combination of ignorance, bigotry - and hypocrisy. The French working class got nothing from it. The ones who did get something - a lot - were the wealthy French. And that's what the nationalist movement was all about in the first place.

I came to New Brunswick because - I liked it. The people are universally polite; the cities are a handy size; and the wilderness is next door. It's true that some of the English are dreadful bigots - and there's an undercurrent of that bigotry that I find bothersome - but those English have nothing like the influence of Quebec's nationalists.

I like the Acadians. Hell, as a member of a minority I know what it's like to be in a minority. And I remember well the intolerance and the bullying by the English in Moncton of forty years ago. As well, I get the impression that Acadians are more intellectually active and involved  and progressive than anglos are.)

So what got me on to this rant? It began with the news story (one of many) that is not in the TandT. The Parti Quebecois has announced a policy of banning religious symbols in the work place. Significantly, all the religious symbols mentioned are non-Christian ones, the moslem head scarf, the Sikh turban, the Jewish yarmulke. (Of course. I mean, who could object to a cross with a dead Jesus on it?)

It's against the Charter of Rights. But that's no problem. The PQ will just use the notwithstanding clause - as it did with the English. It's purpose? Obvious. It's to stir up a sort of race hatred in the name of protecting a culture, while really further enriching a wealthy elite class of Quebecois. The PQ is as intellectually and morally corrupt as Jean Charest's Liberals.

So why should I care? Because I have noticed that the language of political discussion among Acadians is often the language of Quebec nationalism. I guess that's not surprising, given the influence of Quebec media, as well as Quebec professors and students at l'U de M.

It's a language that encourages hatreds and extremism. It's language that makes our case a struggle of language when it is really a struggle of majority and minority. That's not the same (though it would take another unreadable blog to explain that.) The situation in NB would be the same if the majority spoke a Mongolian dialect, and the minority spoke Fiji.


When you say the problem is French against English, then you necessarily typecast the French and victims and the English. (What you typecast them as depends on which side you're on.) Ultimately, that makes the debate personal, ugly, and damned stupid, with the morons on each side the only possible winners.)

I hear "The English in Quebec are the best treated minority in Canada." That is very much a statement from Quebec - and it is disgusting nonsense from people who can't even name all the minorities in Canada, and have no idea of how they are treated.

New Brunswick has a way to go, it's true. But it is leagues ahead of Quebec in its treatment of minorities. New Brunswick can have a French premier. Quebec has NEVER had an English premier (and only one, Protestant one). Moncton has a French Mayor. Montreal, despite its large English population, has not had an English mayor in over a century. And you would have to go back almost a century to find an anglo police chief. And if you want to see an anglo or a Black or a Jew or a moslem or a Sikh don't waste your time searching through the ranks of the Quebec provincial police.

Then I hear babble about preserving a culture. There is no such thing a preserving a culture. In fact, no culture has ever been defined, not even in Quebec. And, whatever it may be, no two people on earth share exactly the same culture.

What bothers me is that this influence is damaging to Acadians. It sends them out on false trails. It pushes them into losing fights. Worse - it sets them up to be used by the Parti Quebecois and its rich friends as they are also trying to use franco-Ontarians.

I know. Both sides will hate me for this. Well, it's try.








Thursday, August 16, 2012

August 16: the absence of good and evil

I'm actually writing this on the night of August 15 because I had an interesting note from a reader. (You can check it at the end of the column for August 15.) He says  he doesn't like western imperialism, but might it not be better for Syria than rule by Assad? Now, that goes right to the heart of understanding political and economic affairs because the use of the word better means there must be a good and a bad, one on each side of better.

We are taught from childhood to see all behaviour as good or bad. I guess the first words I remember are, "No, Graeme. Bad boy." or, more rarely, "That's a good boy." But good and bad only sometimes have anything to do with decision making in the world of politics or of corporations. Usually, they are irrelevant.

The more common motive for political and corporate behaviour is like that of the lion who jumps on an animal, and eats it. The lion is being neither good nor bad. He's just hungry.

When Britain conquered an empire, it was praised, even in the churches, as being good for bringing blessing to the heathens. But British governments didn't build an empire to scatter blessings - however good that might have been. They did it to satisfy the hunger of the lions of British capitalism.

When the US invaded Iraq and killed over a million people, it had nothing to do with 9/11 or with Saddam being a bad man. It had to do with the hungry lions of the oil industry.

When shale gas companies explore New Brunswick, it has nothing to do with being good for the province. And when they cause damage, even death, they aren't being bad. They just don't give a damn about those things. They are hungry lions.

Understanding that is fundamental to understanding political and corporate behaviour. It's hard to remember it because we are raised to see only good and bad; and we miss that terrible other motive, self-interest, the human equivalent of a lion's unreasoning hunger.

In the same context, it's important no to waste time being pro or anti any nation. Most people in nations all over the world have no control over what there governments do. Most people are kept in complete ignorance of what their leaders are doing and why.

Decisions in the US, for example, are made by business and political leaders. The major function of the news media is to spread propaganda to support what the leaders do, and to keep people in ignorance of what is going on. The Moncton Times and Transcipt exemplifies this well.

Remembering that, let's consider whether Syria might be better off under western imperialism.

Congo was under western imperialism for 75 years. Nobody can even guess how many millions were murdered, tortured, mutilated, starved and enslaved in that time. Earlier, all of black Africa had suffered under western imperialism as 60 million died just in transit to the horrors of slavery in the US.

Lincoln freed the slaves. But that had nothing to do with being good. He didn't give a damn about them. The war to "free the slaves" was really to satisfy the hungers of rising industrial lions in the North. The slaves were just the propaganda cover that every war needs.

US imperialism has ruled Haiti for the best part of a century. That has created excellent profits for American and European factory and land owners, but left Haitians the poorest and most miserable people in the western world.

US imperialism overthrew the elected government of Guatemala, and installed a dictator. Then it systematically slaughtered a quarter million native peoples. Most news media didn't even report it.

Western imperialism supported Chiang-Kai Shek against Mao in China. Chiang, a Christian, was a puppet of the world's biggest drug dealer, and the killer of so many millions of Chinese that his score may rival that of even Mao.

But a Canadian government would never do that? We've done it. Often. In the Boer War, to our own native peoples, to Vietnam (where our "observers" acted as spies for the US army), to Libya. We did it to satisfy the hunger of our corporate lions. And we're going to do it again, soon.

Yes, Assad is a bad man.

But if  you are ever in the tropical wilds, and get sick and feel faint - it really won't matter much to you whether the first hungry creature to come along is a lion or a tiger or a python.

No. Western imperialism would not be better for Syria.

Over the years, many countries - Spain, France, Britain, and now the US - have assumed the right to tell other nations how to run their affairs. They have all turned out to be just hungry lions.

I was raised to see things in terms of good and bad. But there is little use in arguing with a Harper or an Obama or even an Alward on those terms. Their masters are corporate bosses. And corporate bosses are forever hungry lions.

If there's something particularly interesting in the August 16 Moncton Times, I might add to this.

(It's next morning. The Tand T is so trivial and vapid - except for Alec Bruce and Jody Dallaire, it's not worth commenting on. Or reading.)

Wednesday, August 15, 2012

August 15: lies, damn lies, and boring lies.

Today's report on Syria is a gem of an example of bad reporting. You know, if you read every report on Syria that ever appeared in the Irving Press, you would still have no idea what has been going on there. In papers around the world, it's long been recognized that the war was created by the western powers, and by Arab powers closely connected to them.

It's widely recognized that few of the rebels could be called freedom fighters. Many are mercenaries who will kill anybody for a buck. A large number are Islamic Jihadists. Many of the mass killings attributed by Reuters to Assad we now know to have been carred out by rebels - who are particularly interested in murdering the Christian population of Syria.

Norbert said several days ago that Assad would lose. Yes, Norbert, he will lose. So will we. So will most of the people of Syria. That policy document prepared by far right wingers, Project for the New American Century, the plan to establish american world economic dominance through mlitary power, has led us into slaughter, disaster and economic collapse.  But don't tell Reuters. Or Norbert.

For misleading use of language, check out paragraph four in column 3. This one claims Assad is facing deeper isolation by being expelled from the Organization of Islamic Cooperation. (Wow! Even the OIC is turning against him.) Well, actually, the OIC is controlled by Saudi Arabia which has been financing the rebels from the start, and which had a good deal to do with starting the rebellion. It's hard to see how getting expelled from it MORE DEEPLY isolates Syria.

The next paragraph says splits between the big powers, and between Saudi Arabia and Iran, have stymied diplomatic efforts to halt the bloodshed. Yeah. That's it. We just want to bring peace and motherhood back to Syria. It's them there Russians and I-ranis what's causin' the trouble. We just want to halt the bloodshed. Yeah.

Well, if we really wanted to halt bloodshed, we wouldn't have set it up in the first place; and we wouldn't be the major suppliers of weapons to the whole world.  (Canada, on a per capita basis, is right up there.) From Algeria to Vietnam to Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Somalia, Yemen, Pakistan, - and Syria, the west has happily slaughtered millions.

For figures on war dead, Reuters still uses the grandly titled Syrian Oservatory of Human Rights, a one-man operation run by a haberdasher in England who gets his information from the rebels.

On the final column of the story (p. B7, paragraph 2, Reuters coyly hints that Saudi Arabia and Quatar are believed to be supplying money and weapons to the rebels.

Believed to be? This has been common knowledge from the start. And not only money and weapons, but training, and imported mercenaries. As well, Obama recently admitted openly what he was been doing secretly from the start - supplying money, weapons, military advisors, intelligence. So has Britain. Even medical aid is highly politicized, and often has nothing to do with medicine. Canada has recently shifted its medical aid from Red Crescent to a Syrian-Canadian group nobody has ever heard of, but is almost certainly a rebel front, just like the Syrian Observatory of Human Rights.

The story finishes by saying the end is near. Yes. It is. And the only result will be  further chaos in the Middle East, a chaos that will be felt even in the streets of Moncton. It also, quite possibly, opens the way to World War Three.

This has not been a golden age for western forieign policy. And it's been a dreadfully decadent one for North American Journalism.

I regret to read that the editorial writer is ignorant of the causes of the Acadian deportation. It had very little to do with "imperial interests far from our shores." The deportation was wanted, decided on, and largely carried out by the northeastern colonies of what is now the US. The colonial government at Halifax was largely controlled by them. They were the land-hungry ones. For the same reason, the states further inland would demand the invasion of Canada just 200 years ago. (See how it all fits together, Mr. Editor?)

There is a powerful tongue-in-cheek column by Alec Bruce.

The whole op ed page is a waste of time.

Gee! The story about Enbridge spilling 25 million litres of oil in accidents still hasn't appeared. They must be saving it for a special, all about shale gas,  edition.

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

August 14: catching up...

Congratulations to the Moncton Times and Transcript for giving prompt and prominent space (p.1) to the story of how four citizens confronted the provincial government on its refusal to explain why the site for a new Moncton High was chosen. The government says it doesn't have to. The court says, "Oh, yes, you do."

Alward will still twist and squirm and delay, of course. But this is something City Council should have been leading the way on. Maybe we need more people like the fighting four to ask City Council what the pollutants are under Highfield Square. How bad are they? Do they affect commercial and residential properties near the square?

For an example of a useless news story, go to the bottom of p. 2 to read how Harper has directed some 10 million dollars in humanitarian aid for Syria away from Red Crescent- because some group we have never heard of says that Red Crescent is biased against the government side. That's what happens you're PostMedia or BrunswickMedia and you insist that your rerporters know nothing, see nothing, speak nothing; and simply take notes. What on earth is the point of this story? What does it really tell us.

First, the idea that any western leader gives a damn about the suffering of any Syrians on either side is laughable. If they didn't want Syrians to suffer, all they had to do was to not start a war in the first place.  Here's the story.

It began as a simple plan along the lines of Libya. Provoke a civil war to overthrow a Syrian government that is an ally of Iran. Supply money, weapons, organizers, special ops, intelligence to the rebels. Install a new government friendly to the West. Then hit an isolated Iran, and take over the oil fields.

That was the plan. But the wheels came off.

It turns out that a high proportion of the rebels, especially those supplied and hired by Saudi Arabia and the Emirates, are Moslem Jihadists, the ones we're fighting against everywhere else. So the US is now  rallying its NORAD team just in case they have to intervene to make sure the right "good" guys win.

The Canadian shift in humanitarian aid is just a small sign of that. The US has gone much further. It is ensuring that its money and weapons go only to those rebels it wants to win. But the clock is running down.

While the Syrian government seems sure to loose, timing could be everything. The American election is close - and Obama is in the lead. Israel's Netanyahu may decide he has to attack Iran now before Obama, with the election behind him, might nix an invasion. (I think Netanyahu considers Obama a more honest man that I do.) An attack now, with Syria still in chaos, could touch off wars all over the Middle East - and well beyond it.

That's why it's important for a reporter to ask questions, and to know which questions to ask.

While in hospital, I had the good luck to see a real reporter in action. (I don't watch TV at home; but a hospital room can get pretty lonely, especially without an appendix to talk to). I flipped through the usual, awful channels that are the reason I don't watch TV. Then I hit a programme called Power and Politics. It's on CBC (6 to 8p.m., I believe). The host was Evan Solomon, who was well-informed, sharp, and knew how to keep asking why and how even after his guests tried to the usual, long-winded answers that tried to hide the lying in a fog of words.

Wow! This guy is an experience. He's knowledgeable; he's tough; he has a powerful sense and use of drama.  The Canadian ministers of Finance and of Natural Resources never did tell the truth, of course. But by the end of the show, Evan Solomon's questions had made it clear to viewers how lacking they were in any quality of statesmanship or trust. Like aging, scrawny hookers they stripped themselves bare with everything they said.

Among the gems:
1. The Minister of Natural Resources, trying to seem neutral buy really supporting the oil pipline industry, said that pipelines can be very safe with Enbridge, for example, suffering only three, minor accidents in recent years. Solomon shot him a look that pinned him to the wall like an insect.

"I have official figures here showing that Enbridge has had uncounted spills in that period with a total spillage of over 25 million litres. That's not just a few spills. That's not just minor damage."
(The minister muttered something about Solomon changing the subject.)

By the way, did the BrunswickNews tell you about that rate of spillage by Enbridge, a company that has wide shale gas rights in New Brunswick? Did Premier Alward mention it after his promise to inform us more fully about shale gas?

2.The Minister of Finance was asked about his intention to investigate tax evasion by the Italian mob that controls the construction industry. (Montreal has multi cultural mobs. There used to be a Jewish mob that controlled gambling, until the government mob took over; the Irish mob controls the waterfront. And so it goes....) The minister replied that they are investigating it but had only recently learned of the construction scandal in Quebec.

I was stunned to hear that. I grew up just a few blocks from the heart of the Italian mob district. My neighbour was a small time hood for the mob. (He died young from a bad case of being wrapped up in a chain and dropped into a lake.) Some of my best friends in school were from mob families. By grade seven, I knew all about the Italian mob, the construction industry, and their corrupt ties with governments. And the Canadian government just found out?

Then he dropped a real clanger. I think it was because Solomon had rattled him with his magisterial questoning style.  He said that Stephen Harper was already preparing tough legislation to investigate the massive scandal of the Quebec construction industry. Okay. But the minister knew he had to say more with those eyes locked on him. So he said Harper was preparing it to investigate other notorious hotbeds of corruption and thievery - like environmentalists, and unions who take hard-earned money from workers.

We look at Quebec; and we see the worst corruption and criminal scandal in Canadian history. Mr. Harper looks at it; and he sees a chance to strike at those who have dared to criticize him and his government.

Power and Politics. This programme is what reporting should be about. It's on CBC.

Norbert has a column, snarly but vague, on the martime bus transit crisis. Actually, it's a crisis that goes far beyond busses , and that takes in the need to drastically reorganize the rural maritimes. Pumping grants to dying villages isn't going to cut it. And maybe busses won't cut it. Anyway, we know what the government is going to do. Indeed, the fix is probably already in.

A new company will appear to take over the service. The government will agree to give it tax deductions and grant money. And it will be specified that the company may hire non-union workers.

Problem solved.

There are the usual good columns by Alec Bruce and Gwynne Dyer.

Alan Cochrane's column proves once again that there is nobody on that editorial staff capable of writing serious and informed comment about anything.

The editorial ponders what the federal government can do to ease such problems as the lobster fishery. Ponder no more. Harper has decided. He will allow the fishery on the East coast to destroy itself. Meanwhile, he will open the Arctic to commercial fishing. That step will pretty quickly destroy the last fishery in Canadian waters. But by then, Mr. Harper will have left politics to accept his reward in the form of a dozen or so directorships. So it won't be his problem.

That, in the corporate world, is called long-term planning.


Monday, August 13, 2012

August13: Apologies

The last thing I remember of Wednesday night was lying helpless on my back with a masked man standing over me.  He had a knife. Then all went black. When I came to, many hours later, a young woman was prodding me in a normally no trespassing area, while another was doing something with a long, plastic tube that I should have preferred not to  have done to me, not even with a short, plastic tube.

However, I'm now home, and short by an appendix. By the way, if  you ever suffer a sharp pain in your lower, right abdomen,  don't waste your time taking it out on an angry blog. Go to emergency right away. Luckily, they were able to have me in an operating room within 90 minutes.

I won't write a regular blog right now because I've barely looked at today's paper - and because I have a pile of other jobs backed up. I'll start as, I think, my last blog said I would, with Norbert's column of last Wednesday on the Mars landing.

Norbert sees it as a magnificent triumph, an exciting moment in our knowledge of the universe - and so it is. But the US Congress does not give billions to NASA simply to provide us with show biz thrills. At root, space science is a military project; and NASA serves military purposes.

NASA research gave the US the ability to put spy stations into space, to keep them there; and it developed the technology to see a situation better and with more information than an agent on the spot could. The drone, a robot aircraft. can now be flown any place on earth to get information - or to kill, with the dead always reported as 'militants'. Maybe they are. But, if so, there must be a large number of children, even infants, women and elderly who are militants.

Drones are used to carry out assassinations, to attack countries with whom we are not at war, and which are no military threat to us. Best of all, there are usually no western witnesses to such attacks. Nor have our news media shown any eagerness to get the facts. The drone is very much a product of NASA research.

Since making drones is a very profitable venture for the defence industry, various forms of them are already on sale to countries and police forces around the world. The next step, with some designs already complete, is for drones that will have no pilot in the plane or on the ground. It will make its own decisions about who to kill. (Notice how the Mars vehicle makes some decisions on its own?). Fighter versions of such drones will travel many times are fast as the F-35; and, without the limits of human stress to worry about, will be the most  manoeuverable aircraft ever built. Nor is this in the distant future. Indeed, such a drone is likely to be in service before the F-35, which would make our F-35s, at 40 billion? 50? 80?. the most expensive museum display pieces in history.

Oh - a final touch - plenty of countries can develop such aircaft. And are  developing them. China, Russia, India are examples. As well, they will be, as most other weapons are, available on the open market.

War has, for this child  of World War Two, changed since the days I ran around the schoolyard, my arms outstretched as the wings of a Spitfire shouting ratatat tat as I came up behind a Messerschmitt. (He shouted he was Spitfire, too. But they all try to fool you.)

We were all there. We were all in it. And there was no torture (that we knew of), no deliberate killing of civilians (that we knew of). We didn't  hate, at least, not much. In fact, it was only late in World War Two that armies learned that most soldiers didn't want to kill. That's when psychologists were called in to make soldiers want to kill, even to enjoy it. Not coincidentally, we now have growing rates of mental illness and suicide among soldiers.

The hired killers, the mercenaries. have become so common that the coporations which recruit them have become among the biggest corporations in the world. They also supply police forces for whole countries. Even in a regular army, like that of the US, many soldiers are not citizens of the country they fight for. Foreigners join the US army on the promise they will be given citizenship on discharge. As wars become more brutal, most of us have become increasingly detached.

Partly, that's because with all the possibilies of modern news media, we are getting even less news than we did on World War One. We understood why we sent troops to France in 1914. We knew why we sent troops to Hong Kong in 1941. (It was a bad idea; but we knew what the intent was.)

But why did we bomb Libya? Why did we join the absurd war in Afghanistan? Why did the US and Britain invade Iraq? Why are drones attacking Somalia and Yemen? Why are we preparing to invade Syria to help the rebels defeat the government? After all, the major reason a rebellion exists is because the rebels have been getting money, training, weapons and mercenaries from western and certain Arab powers. As well, many of the rebels are Islamic Jihadists. Aren't we supposed to be against them?

Never before in history has so much money been spent on so many news media - with so little result.

These thoughts of the stunning changes in warfare, the general ignorance of what is going on, and our detachment from it all, were going through my mind on a sleepless night at the hospital. Suddenly, another great change occured to me. Where were the popular war songs?

Going back over a century and a half to the early days of mass popular music, every war produced masses of popular songs. As early as the Napoleonic wars, "Heart of Oak" was a hit in music halls and pubs.  In the American civil war, sheet music popularized, "John Brown's Body".
Nor were such songs necessarily militant. There were more tender songs about the impact of war on home life '"Just Before the Battle,  Mother". In the Boer War, there was "We are Marching to Praetoria." In World War One, there were hundreds of songs in sheet music, music halls, and early records."It's a long way to Tiperarry", "The whole world is waiting for the sunrise". By World War Two, " There'll always be an England"(check this on youtube with Vera Lynn. Magnificent.)

"A nightingale sang in Berkeley Square". "Praise the Lord; and pass the ammunition."  Sometimes defiant, sometimes loving, sometimes nostalgic, sometimes hoping, songs like these dominated the charts through the war years. At the end of the war,there was even a war song that bridged the way to peace. Originally, a Czech song, it was copied the the Germans, then by the Allies as "Lili Marlene".

Then it stopped.

The only hit songs of the Vietnam war were protest songs like "Where have all the flowers gone?"

Then nothing. It's the same with movies. Afghanistan, the longest war the US has ever fought - and at the greatest cost in money - ---care to name a hit movie about it? US studios were making hit movies about World War Two before the US even entered it. It made them throughout the war - and still does.

It's as if we were deliberately detaching ourselves, giving up on any responsiblity, refusing to see what is happening, what has happened to us.....

                                              -------------------------------------

Oh, I did glance at Norbert's column for today. He ranted that all bloggers are vain, attention-seeking, and ignorant. I agree. And it gives me a wonderful idea. Here is a great chance for Norbert to challenge a blogger to a public debate so he can show how ignorant the blogger is.  Modesty forbids me to mention a name....no...I'm not modest. I'm a blogger. I'm vain.

My vanity suggests I should be the blogger for Norbert to challenge. And my attention-seeking side demands that he should be allowed to have his whole editorial staff with him to argue against me.