Yesterday, I drove past Frank Clair Stadium in Ottawa, and remembered games I had seen there. Greater Ottawa has struggled for years to re-establish a CFL team. Even with its population of 1.3 million, even with its high income levels, even with its backing of wealthy investors, the team is going to have to seek financial support from the Ottawa city government - forever.
The reason I had gone to see an Ottawa game was that my own Alouettes in Montreal had gone broke. Greater Montreal has a population of well over three and a half million.
When I told people in Monttreal and Toronto that Greater Moncton, population about 160,000. was talking of getting a CFL team, they laughed. Now, I pick up The MonctonTimes and Transcript to find most of the first page, plus two more pages in Section A, devoted to Touchdown Atlantic. (followed closely by a story about orphaned kittens - the second time in a week that story has made the front page.)
Most of the reportage and commentary is just fatuous. The CFL commissioner is quoted as raving about the mood of the crowd at last year's game. "People were really enthusiastic about showing off their pride in their city."
What on earth does going to a football game and cheering for teams from two, distant cities have to do with showing pride in Moncton?
At first, I thought this was the old New Brunswick scheme of some influential people getting into our tax money to make a quick buck, and then getting out before people realize what a financial hole they've been sucked into. However, I'm not sure that is the case - if only because we may be even deeper into financial crisis long before a team could take the field.
What this may reflect, instead, is the primary mission of BrunswickMedia - to keep New Brunswickers in the dark about what is going on in this province (or anywhere else).; and to divert them with trivia - ooh - look at those cute. little kittens.
I know of few papers that would run a cute kitten story on the front page. And very few that would do it twice in five days. And those very few are the same type that carry headlines like "Oprah diaries tell shocking story.:
The NewsToday section remains without any sense of focus or planning. The war in Libya - which we were told almost a month ago is over - is still going on. What does this mean? A story from PostMedia tells us we might be heading into a recesssion. Might be? The world has been in a recession which is not yet officially a depression only because the super rich contiue to get richer. In the US, with fifty million living on food stamps and with tent cities springing up across the country, the poor and the middle class are not a recession. It's a depression.
The spotty bits of news in this section serve only to fill a few pages that they had no ads for. There is no hint this section has any editor or guiding plan..
There are solid columns by Alec Bruce and David Suzuki. The only other reason to buy today's Moncton Times and Transcript is to look for sales on 2011 cars.
The problem is not simply that BrunwickMedia newspapers are used hide what is going on, and to spread propaganda for the owners. It's even worse than that. They are quite deliberately intended to keep the thinking of New Brunswickers trivial and irrelevant so they can be more easily ripped off. And it works. Just look at the people we've voted for in the last two provincial elections.
A critical review of local and world news. This blog originally commented on the Moncton Times and Transcript but has enlarged its scope.
Friday, September 23, 2011
Wednesday, September 21, 2011
sept. 21: This is the darkest day in the History of New Brunswick.
You won't find the story on the front page of the TandT. That is reserved for a football story - again.
The big story buried on page 6 of Section A. And it is nothing less than a takeover of our elected government. This is not the fascism of Mussolini. It actually goes further. This is a revolution - a real one.
Democacy is over. That should an extreme statement. Believe me; I wish it were. But the government of this province, and the welfare of you and your family, has been handed over to a gang of self-appointed coroporate bosses.
The story began in mid-December, when Mr. Irving announced in his papers that he had formed a coalition with the government. I wrote at the time that any such move would be contrary to Canadian practice and, indeed, to democracy. In a democracy, you can join a coalition only if your have been elected. And, as I wrote at the time that you have to be invited by government to join.
Mr. Irving's statement was breathtakingly arrogant and anti-democratic. (I say arrogant because it would certainly be arrogant if any of us were to make such a statement. But Mr. Irving seems to think he is not down here with us as a common citizen.He is a person of speical privilege.)
But Mr. Alward, perhaps the wimpiest premier in New Brunswick history, just stood there with his face hanging out. Can you ifmainge what he would have said if you had published a statement that you had declared yourself a member of hie government?)
Then Mr. Irving met with Mr. Alward to inform him he had formed.a gang of buddies from corporate offices ( I expect they will later include a couple of university presidents as potted plants) who would plan the economic future of New Brunswick.
Now, the economic plan is the essential basis off evething else in a province - health, education, roads, social services, everything. The role of the minister of finance is so important that in Britain it carries the lofty title "Cancellor of the Exchequer"' The position is so important that it is not much of an exaggeration to say the minister of finance IS the government.
The premier should have told Mr. Irving that this a a job we elected him and his government to do. But he wimped out again, and approved it.
Now, we have the formal plan Actually, it's not much of a plan - more a PR outline for the cameras. It's full of corporate bullshit that it will apppoint "the best" people, the "most highly skilled". etc. (Ever hear of a company bragging it would hire the worst and least skilled people? Essentially, the new group which will plan our economy and will report to the minister of finance will be made up of private bsuiness honchos. It will be organized as a private company. BUT IT'S WORK WILL BE PAID FOR BY OUR TAXES.We pay for these intruders to rob us.
It will in no way be under the authority of the minister of finance - and there is no provision for any control or evaluation of it. There will be regular reviews of whether it is meeting its goals - But not by any outsider. That fat cats thsemselves will decide how good they are. They will effectively control who gets tax breaks, who gets subsidies, and all the other goodies. This is hiring foxes to guard the henhouse.
The plan promises to bring the "discipline" of the private sector to government. I presume that means the discipline to get cheaper electricity, lower taxes for the rich, cash subsidies, easy regulations, etc.
Given the arrogance and the overthrow of democracy in this document, it is the most important New Brunswick story we shall ever see. It means that whatever whimpering democracy there ever was in New Burnswick is done with. It means we are all going to get ripped off as never before.
So why is it on page A6, sharing space with an ad for wieght loss.? If this is good and sensational,, why isn't the whole front page a photo of Mr. Alward taking bows. Why just a photo of him standing there, perhaps listening. Wasn't he allowed even to hold a corner of the sheet with the logo on it?
I never thought such a thing would ever happen in Canada. I retired here because it was beautiful, and the people were nice. I knew that the business leaders were greedy and uncaring, and the politicians were rag dolls.But I never thought such a thing could happen in Canada.
Now, I see this. And I see a people who, however nice, have never had the courage or, perhaps, the interest to take a stand against the humiliations that are poured on them.
Remember the fuss over the singing of our national anthem in the schools of New Brunswick? Anybody who now can sing O Canada while accepting a plan to destroy all the anthem stands for is nothing more than a lout. making a mockery of our flag and our country, and all the values our anthem represents..
Remember - no blog tomorrow because I'll be in Ottawa having lunch with the secstat Perhaps he'ss ask about democracy in NB. But I doubt it.
The big story buried on page 6 of Section A. And it is nothing less than a takeover of our elected government. This is not the fascism of Mussolini. It actually goes further. This is a revolution - a real one.
Democacy is over. That should an extreme statement. Believe me; I wish it were. But the government of this province, and the welfare of you and your family, has been handed over to a gang of self-appointed coroporate bosses.
The story began in mid-December, when Mr. Irving announced in his papers that he had formed a coalition with the government. I wrote at the time that any such move would be contrary to Canadian practice and, indeed, to democracy. In a democracy, you can join a coalition only if your have been elected. And, as I wrote at the time that you have to be invited by government to join.
Mr. Irving's statement was breathtakingly arrogant and anti-democratic. (I say arrogant because it would certainly be arrogant if any of us were to make such a statement. But Mr. Irving seems to think he is not down here with us as a common citizen.He is a person of speical privilege.)
But Mr. Alward, perhaps the wimpiest premier in New Brunswick history, just stood there with his face hanging out. Can you ifmainge what he would have said if you had published a statement that you had declared yourself a member of hie government?)
Then Mr. Irving met with Mr. Alward to inform him he had formed.a gang of buddies from corporate offices ( I expect they will later include a couple of university presidents as potted plants) who would plan the economic future of New Brunswick.
Now, the economic plan is the essential basis off evething else in a province - health, education, roads, social services, everything. The role of the minister of finance is so important that in Britain it carries the lofty title "Cancellor of the Exchequer"' The position is so important that it is not much of an exaggeration to say the minister of finance IS the government.
The premier should have told Mr. Irving that this a a job we elected him and his government to do. But he wimped out again, and approved it.
Now, we have the formal plan Actually, it's not much of a plan - more a PR outline for the cameras. It's full of corporate bullshit that it will apppoint "the best" people, the "most highly skilled". etc. (Ever hear of a company bragging it would hire the worst and least skilled people? Essentially, the new group which will plan our economy and will report to the minister of finance will be made up of private bsuiness honchos. It will be organized as a private company. BUT IT'S WORK WILL BE PAID FOR BY OUR TAXES.We pay for these intruders to rob us.
It will in no way be under the authority of the minister of finance - and there is no provision for any control or evaluation of it. There will be regular reviews of whether it is meeting its goals - But not by any outsider. That fat cats thsemselves will decide how good they are. They will effectively control who gets tax breaks, who gets subsidies, and all the other goodies. This is hiring foxes to guard the henhouse.
The plan promises to bring the "discipline" of the private sector to government. I presume that means the discipline to get cheaper electricity, lower taxes for the rich, cash subsidies, easy regulations, etc.
Given the arrogance and the overthrow of democracy in this document, it is the most important New Brunswick story we shall ever see. It means that whatever whimpering democracy there ever was in New Burnswick is done with. It means we are all going to get ripped off as never before.
So why is it on page A6, sharing space with an ad for wieght loss.? If this is good and sensational,, why isn't the whole front page a photo of Mr. Alward taking bows. Why just a photo of him standing there, perhaps listening. Wasn't he allowed even to hold a corner of the sheet with the logo on it?
I never thought such a thing would ever happen in Canada. I retired here because it was beautiful, and the people were nice. I knew that the business leaders were greedy and uncaring, and the politicians were rag dolls.But I never thought such a thing could happen in Canada.
Now, I see this. And I see a people who, however nice, have never had the courage or, perhaps, the interest to take a stand against the humiliations that are poured on them.
Remember the fuss over the singing of our national anthem in the schools of New Brunswick? Anybody who now can sing O Canada while accepting a plan to destroy all the anthem stands for is nothing more than a lout. making a mockery of our flag and our country, and all the values our anthem represents..
Remember - no blog tomorrow because I'll be in Ottawa having lunch with the secstat Perhaps he'ss ask about democracy in NB. But I doubt it.
Tuesday, September 20, 2011
Sept. 20: News for a firightened province.
There is a fear that runs down through every level of New Brunswick society. The people of New Brunswick are cheated and lied to. They know it. They know it; but they don't want to hear it. And they certainly aren't going to talk out loud about it.
They're afraid. They're afraid the big ones might hear about it.
In Israel, tens fo thousands are camped in protest against their government that has encouraged enormous wealth for a few at the cost of low living standards for everybody else. As the protestors camp out in the streets, they also form dozens of lecture and discussion groups to familiarize themselves with the causes of the problem. Openly. Publicly.
Can you imagine anyone in this province gathering in public for open and honest talks about our political and economic leadership?
(Hey! How about that football game, eh?)
The Moncton Times &Transcript exists to sell ads, and to keep people thinking only of trivialities. That's why section A has over a page on football games, five pages of ads and obituaries, and a geegollywhiz story about a rabiit that is looking after kittens..
The big story in NewsToday is the Harper budget. It comes from PostMedia, of course. That's why it didn't carry important news that was easily avaiable.
1, Our cost-cutting government is committing itself to a prison-building, sentence lengthening prograemme that:
a)is estremely expensive.
b) American authroities, who have tried it for years say it doesn't work and indeed, makes crime worse at huge cost. That is also the opinion of Canadians who have studied it. It is far cheaper and more effective to use crime prevention and rehabilitation services.
c) this comes at a time when the Canadian crime rate is at its lowest level in almost forty years.
So why is Harper doing it? To appeal to that very large part of the public that doesn not get honest news from its news media. . Why not? It worked for Alward.
Norrdoes Postmedia mention a rather important point relatied to the crime bill. . Harper has contracted economic consultants to suggest where bugets should be cut. The contract is for $90,000 - PER DAY for as much as TWO YEARS. That's right folks. We are going to spend billions on correction services that aren't needed and don't work; and then spend another $500,000 on tips to save money. Funny how Polstmedia missed that. There was, of course, no call for tenders. Happy times are here again foro Harper buddies.
In foreign News, there is no mention of a story which has been receiving coverage from reputable news sources for weeks. The rebel forces in Libya have been on a spree for weeks raping, murdering, torturing, beating, starving to death in prisons anybody who is Black. Most of the victims are migrant workers brought in to do the dirtiest and worst paid jobs in Libya.
Weren't we told that we were going to Libya to prevent just such a slaughter? How come NATO hasn't 'made a peep? How come the TandT has yet to carry a story on Canadians fighting in Libya? How come Harper hasn't said anything? He's the one who sent our flyers there.
(Oh, and what kinds of bombs are they dropping? They wouldn't be cluster bombs, would they?)
I have a long list of easily available and important news that is not in the the TandT.And it comes from sources a lot more reliable than PostMedia. But I'll save it for another day.
In fairness, we do have half a page by a staff writer on how you're never too old to rock. (When all the old TandT staffers fade from this world, they're going to have to open a new care centre in the idiot section of the New Jeursalem).
There are two must-reads in the paper.- Alec Bruce on the Editorial Page, and Ed Graham on the Op Ed.
Meanwhile, a reminder. I shall have a blog for Wednesday. But on Thursday, I have to be in Ottawa to meet for an hour or so with the Secretary of State.. But I'm a poor man; so the Secstat will pick up the tab. Thanks to all you taxpayers. And I hav a feeling the TandT isn't going to report it. Not unless secstat gives me a free ticket to the football game - or wants me to be a mother to orphaned kittens.
They're afraid. They're afraid the big ones might hear about it.
In Israel, tens fo thousands are camped in protest against their government that has encouraged enormous wealth for a few at the cost of low living standards for everybody else. As the protestors camp out in the streets, they also form dozens of lecture and discussion groups to familiarize themselves with the causes of the problem. Openly. Publicly.
Can you imagine anyone in this province gathering in public for open and honest talks about our political and economic leadership?
(Hey! How about that football game, eh?)
The Moncton Times &Transcript exists to sell ads, and to keep people thinking only of trivialities. That's why section A has over a page on football games, five pages of ads and obituaries, and a geegollywhiz story about a rabiit that is looking after kittens..
The big story in NewsToday is the Harper budget. It comes from PostMedia, of course. That's why it didn't carry important news that was easily avaiable.
1, Our cost-cutting government is committing itself to a prison-building, sentence lengthening prograemme that:
a)is estremely expensive.
b) American authroities, who have tried it for years say it doesn't work and indeed, makes crime worse at huge cost. That is also the opinion of Canadians who have studied it. It is far cheaper and more effective to use crime prevention and rehabilitation services.
c) this comes at a time when the Canadian crime rate is at its lowest level in almost forty years.
So why is Harper doing it? To appeal to that very large part of the public that doesn not get honest news from its news media. . Why not? It worked for Alward.
Norrdoes Postmedia mention a rather important point relatied to the crime bill. . Harper has contracted economic consultants to suggest where bugets should be cut. The contract is for $90,000 - PER DAY for as much as TWO YEARS. That's right folks. We are going to spend billions on correction services that aren't needed and don't work; and then spend another $500,000 on tips to save money. Funny how Polstmedia missed that. There was, of course, no call for tenders. Happy times are here again foro Harper buddies.
In foreign News, there is no mention of a story which has been receiving coverage from reputable news sources for weeks. The rebel forces in Libya have been on a spree for weeks raping, murdering, torturing, beating, starving to death in prisons anybody who is Black. Most of the victims are migrant workers brought in to do the dirtiest and worst paid jobs in Libya.
Weren't we told that we were going to Libya to prevent just such a slaughter? How come NATO hasn't 'made a peep? How come the TandT has yet to carry a story on Canadians fighting in Libya? How come Harper hasn't said anything? He's the one who sent our flyers there.
(Oh, and what kinds of bombs are they dropping? They wouldn't be cluster bombs, would they?)
I have a long list of easily available and important news that is not in the the TandT.And it comes from sources a lot more reliable than PostMedia. But I'll save it for another day.
In fairness, we do have half a page by a staff writer on how you're never too old to rock. (When all the old TandT staffers fade from this world, they're going to have to open a new care centre in the idiot section of the New Jeursalem).
There are two must-reads in the paper.- Alec Bruce on the Editorial Page, and Ed Graham on the Op Ed.
Meanwhile, a reminder. I shall have a blog for Wednesday. But on Thursday, I have to be in Ottawa to meet for an hour or so with the Secretary of State.. But I'm a poor man; so the Secstat will pick up the tab. Thanks to all you taxpayers. And I hav a feeling the TandT isn't going to report it. Not unless secstat gives me a free ticket to the football game - or wants me to be a mother to orphaned kittens.
Monday, September 19, 2011
Sept. 19: Where to start?
1. Let's go with the editorial, easily the most inane I have seen since News of the World closed down. It gave Alward an A+ for his political brilliance in appearing before TV cameras in a show to get the Bay of Fundy named one of the world's seven natural wonders.
a). Premiers almost always show up for such photo ops. To congratulate him for doing what politicians do every day is like saying he deserves an A+ for remembering to zip his fly on formal occasions.
b) Then it says the Hopewell Rocks are world famous! Oh? If they're already world famous, why are we campaigning to make them world famous? (In fact, they aren't even nationally famous.)
c) How does a picture of Alward doing naughty things to sardines do anything to create interest in the Bay of Fundy?
d) Are the rock formations at Hopewell the only point of interest in the bay? I don't think they are. But the TandT seems to think so. At least, that's the only thing that it has photographed or spoken of throughout this campaign. (In fact, it hasn't shown that it knows much even about the rocks.)
So far, the NB campaign to sell the Bay of Fundy region as a top wonder of the world looks pretty feeble and amateurish. Too bad, because it does deserve serious consideration.
2. The anti-fracking demonstration was reported fairly in some respects. (Indeed, how could a newspaper ignore it?) But there were oddities. Such a demonstration is rare in New Brunswick. New Brunswick is, in political terms, an extraordinarily passive place. Open and public discussion of public affairs is probably less common here than it is in China. This demonstration was so unusual for this society that a report on it should not have been on page 3. It would have been an easy matter to dump the daily, front page Special Report (which is seldom worth reading, anyway) to make room for such an exceptional event. As it was, the demonstration got less coverage than yet another story about how the whole world is watching Moncton because of the CFL game.
Nor does the report estimate the size of the crowd. It refers simply to hundreds. Now, I have covered a lot of demonstrations. I have never even heard of a newspaper not giving an estimated crowd size. In this case, a count was easy because the crowd was very orderly and always within a defined space. Since I have had, at times, to estimate crowds in the thousands (and once at a hundred thousand), it was no difficulty to estimate this one at 600+. That's very strong for a normally passive society.
Given the limits of space (an editorial decision) and the failure to estimate crowd size (almost certainly an editorial decision), the story is still an example of fair and objective reporting by Yvon Gauvin. (The reporter.)
3. I give up on the NewsToday section. I have no idea what standards are used to judge what appears. There are two stories on legislation coming up in the new, federal parliament. Both are stories that have been known for months. The lead story is that a university president is appealing for more federal money. This isn't old news. This is ancient news. Every university president in Canada has always appealed for more money.
There is no mention, never has been, of the serious unrest in Israel, where thousands of people have been camping in the streets in a protest against the huge gap between rich and poor, the declining standard of living, the excessive political power of minority groups. This has been going on for weeks without a mention in the TandT. Why?
Nor has there been any mention of the spread of shanty towns and tent cities in the US. There are even some on vacant lots within cities. The US is in a recession only in abstract terms. In reality, it's in a depression - with no sign of recovery. (But I didn't figure that out from the so-called business page of the TandT.)
The final page of NewsToday is the only one worth reading. It's about the heavily (and badly) reported war in Libya. Most of the TandT reports have come from Reuters; and they have all been text book examples of why we should not trust war correspondents, none of them.
To now, the reports have all been of heroic and smiling rebels as they pushed back Ghadaffi forces. We were assured the population supported the rebels. Those reports were never credible. Such popular support coupled with NATOs massive air power as well as British, French and American special ops on the ground would have ended the war in a couple of months.
The frequent reports of "fierce" battles using bombs, rockets and artillery, and with only two or three dead, never made sense.
Now, with only a few fragments of Ghadaffi's army left, and those bottled up in just a few locations, the rebels have suffered one humiliating defeat after another in their attacks. This is the war that was supposed to be over three weeks ago. Why do I hear echos of Bush's premature "Mission Accomplished" in Iraq?
As well, Reuters now informs us that the rebel leadership and the rebel army are so divided they can't even begiin to form a government. This, too, has been known for a long time. Why didn't Reuters tell us this months ago when it was already obvious?
Never trust war correspondents.
a). Premiers almost always show up for such photo ops. To congratulate him for doing what politicians do every day is like saying he deserves an A+ for remembering to zip his fly on formal occasions.
b) Then it says the Hopewell Rocks are world famous! Oh? If they're already world famous, why are we campaigning to make them world famous? (In fact, they aren't even nationally famous.)
c) How does a picture of Alward doing naughty things to sardines do anything to create interest in the Bay of Fundy?
d) Are the rock formations at Hopewell the only point of interest in the bay? I don't think they are. But the TandT seems to think so. At least, that's the only thing that it has photographed or spoken of throughout this campaign. (In fact, it hasn't shown that it knows much even about the rocks.)
So far, the NB campaign to sell the Bay of Fundy region as a top wonder of the world looks pretty feeble and amateurish. Too bad, because it does deserve serious consideration.
2. The anti-fracking demonstration was reported fairly in some respects. (Indeed, how could a newspaper ignore it?) But there were oddities. Such a demonstration is rare in New Brunswick. New Brunswick is, in political terms, an extraordinarily passive place. Open and public discussion of public affairs is probably less common here than it is in China. This demonstration was so unusual for this society that a report on it should not have been on page 3. It would have been an easy matter to dump the daily, front page Special Report (which is seldom worth reading, anyway) to make room for such an exceptional event. As it was, the demonstration got less coverage than yet another story about how the whole world is watching Moncton because of the CFL game.
Nor does the report estimate the size of the crowd. It refers simply to hundreds. Now, I have covered a lot of demonstrations. I have never even heard of a newspaper not giving an estimated crowd size. In this case, a count was easy because the crowd was very orderly and always within a defined space. Since I have had, at times, to estimate crowds in the thousands (and once at a hundred thousand), it was no difficulty to estimate this one at 600+. That's very strong for a normally passive society.
Given the limits of space (an editorial decision) and the failure to estimate crowd size (almost certainly an editorial decision), the story is still an example of fair and objective reporting by Yvon Gauvin. (The reporter.)
3. I give up on the NewsToday section. I have no idea what standards are used to judge what appears. There are two stories on legislation coming up in the new, federal parliament. Both are stories that have been known for months. The lead story is that a university president is appealing for more federal money. This isn't old news. This is ancient news. Every university president in Canada has always appealed for more money.
There is no mention, never has been, of the serious unrest in Israel, where thousands of people have been camping in the streets in a protest against the huge gap between rich and poor, the declining standard of living, the excessive political power of minority groups. This has been going on for weeks without a mention in the TandT. Why?
Nor has there been any mention of the spread of shanty towns and tent cities in the US. There are even some on vacant lots within cities. The US is in a recession only in abstract terms. In reality, it's in a depression - with no sign of recovery. (But I didn't figure that out from the so-called business page of the TandT.)
The final page of NewsToday is the only one worth reading. It's about the heavily (and badly) reported war in Libya. Most of the TandT reports have come from Reuters; and they have all been text book examples of why we should not trust war correspondents, none of them.
To now, the reports have all been of heroic and smiling rebels as they pushed back Ghadaffi forces. We were assured the population supported the rebels. Those reports were never credible. Such popular support coupled with NATOs massive air power as well as British, French and American special ops on the ground would have ended the war in a couple of months.
The frequent reports of "fierce" battles using bombs, rockets and artillery, and with only two or three dead, never made sense.
Now, with only a few fragments of Ghadaffi's army left, and those bottled up in just a few locations, the rebels have suffered one humiliating defeat after another in their attacks. This is the war that was supposed to be over three weeks ago. Why do I hear echos of Bush's premature "Mission Accomplished" in Iraq?
As well, Reuters now informs us that the rebel leadership and the rebel army are so divided they can't even begiin to form a government. This, too, has been known for a long time. Why didn't Reuters tell us this months ago when it was already obvious?
Never trust war correspondents.
Saturday, September 17, 2011
sept. 17: Man cleared at fight in bar....
I yawned. A man getting cleared of starting a fight is front page stuff in Moncton. Then I noticed a real story. "School district chief praised." And there was a picture of Harry Doyle, Chairman of School District 2 Education Council. It was just a year ago I had dealings with him. I wanted to present to the council my views on the interference of Atlantic Institute of Marketing Studies in New Brunswick schools. I wanted to explain why AIMS was utterly incompetent to give advice on public education, and was really acting as one of the propaganda agencies for corporations across North America who want to get our tax money into their pockets.
Doyle played it absolutely straight. He gave me my allotted time - to the second. At no point did he indicate agreement or disagreement with me. I still don't know what he thought. And that's the way it should be. He did exactly what a chariman should do, and did it with exemplary impartiality. As I waited to speak, I had a chance to see he conducted the whole meeting that way. I've been to a lot of executive meetings, too many.Tthough many of those meetings had some pretty eminent chairmen, I have never seen one as impartial and effective as Harry Doyle.
The editorial picks up the theme - but in a disgustingly partisan way that Doyle would never permit. It dumps all the blame for in the Moncton High closing, for example, on the administrators of District 2, saying they were at fault for not maintaining the school. That's what's called a lie because whichever village idiot employed by the TandT to write editorials knows, or should know, that the responsillibity lay with New Brunswick governments, includinig the current one led by "I'm all ears" Alward - the same man who completely failed in his reponsibilities to inform the electorate on the shale gas issue.
As well, I remember how The Moncton Times and Tribune for months carried a series of vicious and lying attacks on the whole school system, including our District Education Council. I Iwas reminded of that when I saw the name of the reporter who wrote today's story for Doyle. It was Brent Mazerolle who once wrote reports of a much different kind. That was when The TandT ran the most unethical and lying smear campaign against public schools that I have even seen.
The objective was private/ public "partnerships", scheme by corporations to get tax money away from children and put into corporate pockets. This has already done so much damage in the US that its public education system now ranks the worst in the developed world. But that will not discourage New Brunswick's corporate bosses - who don't give a damn what happens to us or our children. Forming a partnership with them is like offering to be a target for pickpockets.
The TandT's praise for Harry Doyle is deserved. And it would be welcome if the TandT would apologize for its many slanders. But it hasn't. And it won't. And the smear campaign will be coming back.
On Libya, we have been told for months that most of Libya is on the side of the rebels. We were also told the war (which is lastiing well over twice as long as it was supposed to) ended two weeks ago. We are also given to understand only a small fraction of the Ghadaffi loyalists are left. And, course, we are told our bombs don't kill civilians.
1. If the war is over, how come it's still going on?
2. If Ghadaffi was widely hated, how come some regions are still holding on?
How come the whole rebel army with massive air support plus weaponry supplied by NATO plus troops supplied by NATO is having such a hard time?
3. We are told the cities and towns holding out are being bombed, and hit with rocket fire and artillery.
Never in history has that kind of power failed to kill very large numbers of civilians. Never. So how come we aren't hearing anything about civilian deaths? Other, reputable news sources put the number of civilian deaths at as much as 50,000. And that was two weeks ago.
4. The African Union has publicly protested that Blacks in Libya. many of them migrant workers, are being slaughtered by the rebels. How come Reuters hasn't reported that?
Then there's Bill Belliveau's column. I used to like his columns because he seemed to put so much research into them. Unfortunately, that's all his puts into them. The thinking part is a trifle weak - and a lot biased.
Today, he says the Liberals were right to want to sell NBEnergy because it's real accounting figures were so bad, we would be lucky to get 50% of it's estimated value in the sale. So it's better just to let it go. Otherwise, the debt just gets worse.
Okay. we sell it - which, at the loss, raises our debt right there. Presumably, somebody buys it. And then? They charge us at least what he have been paying (probably more to bring the balance up) AND more to make a profit. They also use their control to get even lower electric rates for their businesses in the province - which means we have to pay even more to cover that.
Great thinking, Bill. For your next column, how about a study of privatization of power that has resulted in lower rates? Good luck on finding one. (Did you know that electricity supply was taken over in the first place because privately owned energy was too expensive? Ever read any history?)
On the op ed page, Brent Mazerolle contributes the thought-piece of the day. It's about
Scarlett Johansson's naked bum.
Doyle played it absolutely straight. He gave me my allotted time - to the second. At no point did he indicate agreement or disagreement with me. I still don't know what he thought. And that's the way it should be. He did exactly what a chariman should do, and did it with exemplary impartiality. As I waited to speak, I had a chance to see he conducted the whole meeting that way. I've been to a lot of executive meetings, too many.Tthough many of those meetings had some pretty eminent chairmen, I have never seen one as impartial and effective as Harry Doyle.
The editorial picks up the theme - but in a disgustingly partisan way that Doyle would never permit. It dumps all the blame for in the Moncton High closing, for example, on the administrators of District 2, saying they were at fault for not maintaining the school. That's what's called a lie because whichever village idiot employed by the TandT to write editorials knows, or should know, that the responsillibity lay with New Brunswick governments, includinig the current one led by "I'm all ears" Alward - the same man who completely failed in his reponsibilities to inform the electorate on the shale gas issue.
As well, I remember how The Moncton Times and Tribune for months carried a series of vicious and lying attacks on the whole school system, including our District Education Council. I Iwas reminded of that when I saw the name of the reporter who wrote today's story for Doyle. It was Brent Mazerolle who once wrote reports of a much different kind. That was when The TandT ran the most unethical and lying smear campaign against public schools that I have even seen.
The objective was private/ public "partnerships", scheme by corporations to get tax money away from children and put into corporate pockets. This has already done so much damage in the US that its public education system now ranks the worst in the developed world. But that will not discourage New Brunswick's corporate bosses - who don't give a damn what happens to us or our children. Forming a partnership with them is like offering to be a target for pickpockets.
The TandT's praise for Harry Doyle is deserved. And it would be welcome if the TandT would apologize for its many slanders. But it hasn't. And it won't. And the smear campaign will be coming back.
On Libya, we have been told for months that most of Libya is on the side of the rebels. We were also told the war (which is lastiing well over twice as long as it was supposed to) ended two weeks ago. We are also given to understand only a small fraction of the Ghadaffi loyalists are left. And, course, we are told our bombs don't kill civilians.
1. If the war is over, how come it's still going on?
2. If Ghadaffi was widely hated, how come some regions are still holding on?
How come the whole rebel army with massive air support plus weaponry supplied by NATO plus troops supplied by NATO is having such a hard time?
3. We are told the cities and towns holding out are being bombed, and hit with rocket fire and artillery.
Never in history has that kind of power failed to kill very large numbers of civilians. Never. So how come we aren't hearing anything about civilian deaths? Other, reputable news sources put the number of civilian deaths at as much as 50,000. And that was two weeks ago.
4. The African Union has publicly protested that Blacks in Libya. many of them migrant workers, are being slaughtered by the rebels. How come Reuters hasn't reported that?
Then there's Bill Belliveau's column. I used to like his columns because he seemed to put so much research into them. Unfortunately, that's all his puts into them. The thinking part is a trifle weak - and a lot biased.
Today, he says the Liberals were right to want to sell NBEnergy because it's real accounting figures were so bad, we would be lucky to get 50% of it's estimated value in the sale. So it's better just to let it go. Otherwise, the debt just gets worse.
Okay. we sell it - which, at the loss, raises our debt right there. Presumably, somebody buys it. And then? They charge us at least what he have been paying (probably more to bring the balance up) AND more to make a profit. They also use their control to get even lower electric rates for their businesses in the province - which means we have to pay even more to cover that.
Great thinking, Bill. For your next column, how about a study of privatization of power that has resulted in lower rates? Good luck on finding one. (Did you know that electricity supply was taken over in the first place because privately owned energy was too expensive? Ever read any history?)
On the op ed page, Brent Mazerolle contributes the thought-piece of the day. It's about
Scarlett Johansson's naked bum.
Friday, September 16, 2011
Sept. 16: Journalists and "personalities"
Today's is a thoroughly annoying edition of The Moncton Times and Transcript. There is nothing really disgusting about it. It is just shoddy and amateurish and a waste of good trees.
Let's start with a point that is small, but illustrates the hicktown boosterism that characterizes so much of this paper..
The front page lead story is about a national TV programme doing a show at Hopewell Cape. It refers to the host of the show as a 'personality'. Look, Mr. editor; check with Norbert Cunningham on this. A person in not a personality. Not ever. Not any more than a fish is a fishality or a tree a treeality.
A person, even a TV host, is a person. Such a person may HAVE a personality, just as he may have a great haircut without BEING a great haircut. Get it, Mr. editor? (And Mr. Mazerolle?)
We are told that a crowd of a hundred turned out to watch. A hundred watching a national TV shoot is not very many. I have often seen far more turned out for a live radio broadcast - including at least one occasion here in Moncton..
They were there "to show their pride in the Bay of Fundy". Oh? A reporter is supposed to report what he sees. I doubt very much that Mr. Mazerolle has any evidence that the hundred were there for that reason. There's nothing small about that. TandT reporters have a habit of making up things as they go along - anything that sounds good and boosterish.
Even as PR, this story is amateurish. It's supposed to be the bay that's in the national spotlight. I hope the TV show gave more play to this than the story did. The news story is all about trivia like the premier packing sardines. I can just see a family in Toronto sitting around the TV, "Mummy, daddy, we want to go the the Bay of Fundy to see premier Alward pack sardines."
(Actually, if you look closely at the picture, he's not packing sardines. He seems to be listening to them.)
NewsToday has its usual story on Libya. Like all the others, it came from Reuters. So we still have no idea how many were killed in this humanitarian mission. Nor do we have any idea what form the government will take. We do know, though, that the NATO countries who supported the rebels will get preferential treatment in taking over the Libyan oil industry. Gee! Who would have guessed?
The day's editorial is its usual, half-wit self. It advocates saving money by giving free flu shots only to those who qualify under a means test. The obivous idiocy is that the cost of administering the means test would equal or come close to the cost of the shots. It would also mean that many people would not get the shot, especially children whose parents would not take the extra offort to apply for the means test. As a consequence, we could face heightened medicare costs if this flu proves to be a deadly one.
Read some history, Mr. editor. The great flu epidemic of 1919 killed more people than World War One did.
How come this government is so eager to save fifteen bucks on a flu shot - but gives gas companies a gift of no taxes until 2016?
Alec Bruce's column is, to say the least, disappointing. He practically foams at the mouth about shale gas protestors who demanded that the mayor of Fredericton write and sign a promise to keep shale gas exploration out of the city region. He asserts that such a signed document would have no legally binding worth for anyone.
Thus far, Bruce is quite right. But he goes on to suggest that protestors are not fully aware of all the laws (neither are most lawyers; that's why some specialize). Then he says protestors are deliberately kept uninformed by their leaders. Does he have any evidence of that? Most of the protestors I have met seem to be far better informed of the issues than is the paper Mr. Bruce writes for. Indeed, the TandT has worked very hard for years to keep people uninformed.
Then he compare the protesters to the Tea Party movement in the US. Why didn't he go all the way and compare it to Mao's cultural revolution?
The rage of the protestors is incoherent? I'm not surprised. They live in a province in which most of the news media treat them like idiots, helps big business rip them off, and even lies to them. And they have governments that for a hundred and fifty years and more have served the interests of economic bosses instead of the people who elected them.
Protestors cheapen the quality of the debate? What debate? What are you babbling about? Until very recently, thanks to our governments and most of our news media, we didn't even know there was anything to debate. And Brunswick Media has certainly done nothing to encourage or even inform a debate at any time.
Mr. Bruce say, "Protesting is not a lifestyle choice....., it's a somber duty." Do you have evidence that those who protest are simply making a lifetstyle choice? Was George Washington making a lifestle choice? Martin Luther King? The protestors against slavery? Women who demanded the vote?
I'm sorry to write this. Alec Bruce is one of the best columnists I have ever read. But this time - its just a grade nine rant.
Let's start with a point that is small, but illustrates the hicktown boosterism that characterizes so much of this paper..
The front page lead story is about a national TV programme doing a show at Hopewell Cape. It refers to the host of the show as a 'personality'. Look, Mr. editor; check with Norbert Cunningham on this. A person in not a personality. Not ever. Not any more than a fish is a fishality or a tree a treeality.
A person, even a TV host, is a person. Such a person may HAVE a personality, just as he may have a great haircut without BEING a great haircut. Get it, Mr. editor? (And Mr. Mazerolle?)
We are told that a crowd of a hundred turned out to watch. A hundred watching a national TV shoot is not very many. I have often seen far more turned out for a live radio broadcast - including at least one occasion here in Moncton..
They were there "to show their pride in the Bay of Fundy". Oh? A reporter is supposed to report what he sees. I doubt very much that Mr. Mazerolle has any evidence that the hundred were there for that reason. There's nothing small about that. TandT reporters have a habit of making up things as they go along - anything that sounds good and boosterish.
Even as PR, this story is amateurish. It's supposed to be the bay that's in the national spotlight. I hope the TV show gave more play to this than the story did. The news story is all about trivia like the premier packing sardines. I can just see a family in Toronto sitting around the TV, "Mummy, daddy, we want to go the the Bay of Fundy to see premier Alward pack sardines."
(Actually, if you look closely at the picture, he's not packing sardines. He seems to be listening to them.)
NewsToday has its usual story on Libya. Like all the others, it came from Reuters. So we still have no idea how many were killed in this humanitarian mission. Nor do we have any idea what form the government will take. We do know, though, that the NATO countries who supported the rebels will get preferential treatment in taking over the Libyan oil industry. Gee! Who would have guessed?
The day's editorial is its usual, half-wit self. It advocates saving money by giving free flu shots only to those who qualify under a means test. The obivous idiocy is that the cost of administering the means test would equal or come close to the cost of the shots. It would also mean that many people would not get the shot, especially children whose parents would not take the extra offort to apply for the means test. As a consequence, we could face heightened medicare costs if this flu proves to be a deadly one.
Read some history, Mr. editor. The great flu epidemic of 1919 killed more people than World War One did.
How come this government is so eager to save fifteen bucks on a flu shot - but gives gas companies a gift of no taxes until 2016?
Alec Bruce's column is, to say the least, disappointing. He practically foams at the mouth about shale gas protestors who demanded that the mayor of Fredericton write and sign a promise to keep shale gas exploration out of the city region. He asserts that such a signed document would have no legally binding worth for anyone.
Thus far, Bruce is quite right. But he goes on to suggest that protestors are not fully aware of all the laws (neither are most lawyers; that's why some specialize). Then he says protestors are deliberately kept uninformed by their leaders. Does he have any evidence of that? Most of the protestors I have met seem to be far better informed of the issues than is the paper Mr. Bruce writes for. Indeed, the TandT has worked very hard for years to keep people uninformed.
Then he compare the protesters to the Tea Party movement in the US. Why didn't he go all the way and compare it to Mao's cultural revolution?
The rage of the protestors is incoherent? I'm not surprised. They live in a province in which most of the news media treat them like idiots, helps big business rip them off, and even lies to them. And they have governments that for a hundred and fifty years and more have served the interests of economic bosses instead of the people who elected them.
Protestors cheapen the quality of the debate? What debate? What are you babbling about? Until very recently, thanks to our governments and most of our news media, we didn't even know there was anything to debate. And Brunswick Media has certainly done nothing to encourage or even inform a debate at any time.
Mr. Bruce say, "Protesting is not a lifestyle choice....., it's a somber duty." Do you have evidence that those who protest are simply making a lifetstyle choice? Was George Washington making a lifestle choice? Martin Luther King? The protestors against slavery? Women who demanded the vote?
I'm sorry to write this. Alec Bruce is one of the best columnists I have ever read. But this time - its just a grade nine rant.
Thursday, September 15, 2011
Sept. 15: headlines and and "special reports" as propaganda
"Metro backs shale gas: poll" That's the head that blasts in the middle of page 1 in today's Moncton Times and Transcript. Wow! So all the protestors are wrong. But, wait a minute....
When you read the story, it says 41 percent in Moncton support shale gas exploration.. Since when has 41% been most? Those who oppose it are 36%, a number within the margin of error for such a poll which means the poll shows no significant difference between the two sides. Fully 20% have no opinion at all. How could they? They haven't had any information about it. That whole story is a lie.
When the story continues on p. A6, the headline is "Poll finds support for shale gas exploration". Well, yes. If it can find one person who supports shale gas exploration and thousands against it, then it has found support - I suppose. Not much support. But some. I imagine similar polls could also find support for Stalin, for farting in public, and for spitting on restaurant floors. The headline is true. But it gives a false impression - and that's lying.
In fact, shale glass exploration means fracking. And, when you call it fracking, the 41% support drops to 29%. In other words, when the meaning of the poll is made clear, then the real issue, fracking, has very, very little support.
And this was in an urban poll. Expect the shale gas option to do much, much worse in a rural poll.
This whole story is a classic example of how to slant the news to give the impression it says something different from what it does say.
Right below this story on the front page is a SPECIAL REPORT. Why is it called a SPECIAL REPORT? After all, it's really quite a minor news story, Well, that's another, old news game. It's called a SPECIAL REPORT because that gives it an air of authority and excitement.
The head is "Students get shale gas experience". It's simply a story of NB students who worked in the shale gas industry this summer. It's a feel good story. SWN resources took them on for summer jobs in the southern US. The real messages?
1. Students loved the experience. Have positive feelings about fracking.
2, SWN cares about New Brunswickers, and is looking after their children and their children's futures.
3. SWN will provide jobs for New Brunswickers.
This is soft sell propaganda - and pretty sleazy stuff for a newspaper to run.
Oh, there is still no story about the serious fracking accidents in Pennsylvania, no story about the law companies making money out of law suits for fracking damage, no stories about other countries who are banning fracking.
Nor have we yet had any of the impartial evidence we have many times been promised by Alward, by Brunswick Media, and by the shale gas industry. What we're getting instead is some pretty crude propaganda. The industry is going to have to find a better propaganda writer than Brent Mazerolle..
The editorial is a booster speech, something like Shakespeare would have written for Henry V rallying his troops - if Shakespeare had been a really bad writer.
Interesting column by Norbert Cunningham on multi-culturism. One of the key problems is that so few people understand what culture means. There is no such thing as a Moslem culture or a Christian culture or a French or English... We each have a culture - a way we react to the world. There are many ways in which I react to the world in much the way a Moslem or an Acadian does. There are many ways I don't react as my parents did. Our children will not have the same culture as us. Cultures, as reactions to the world, also change constantly as the world changes. Good luck to anyone who tries to define something that no two people completely share, and that is constantly changing, anyway.
Superb column by Jody Dallaire. Well worth a read.
Interesting letter by M. Sullivan in "Direct efforts to right place". It 's a well deserved jab at those who confuse self-righteousness and finger-pointing with religious faith.
A p.s. to this blog. The US SAT scores for reading skill at high school graduation have hit the lowest level in the long history of these scores. This comes at the same time as other tests have shown US education to have declined shaprtly, putting it far below standards in the rest of the developed world.
This is a result of the massive shift in the US to statistical ratings of public schools, and to crereping privatization. This has all come at the urging of "think-tanks" eager to make it possible for private business to get control of public education, and to run it on a "for profit" basis.
The Atlantic Institute for Market Studies and other think-tanks like The Fraser Institute have been publishing their pseudo-scientific studies to duplicate in Canada what has happened in the US. That's why New Brunswick now has school raings, administered by the people at The Atlantic Institute who are quite ignorant of education, but very well-informed on greed and self-interest, and who really runs New Brusnwick.
That's why the T and T last year ran a crude and unethical campaign to vilify the public shools, to destroy confidence in them, and to call for more intrusions by the private interests who have done so much to destroy american public schools. I have to assume that the TandT's boss, who is also affiliated with AIMS, wants the public schools to be discredited and, as much as possible, run by a public/private partnership.like the one that destroyed education in the US. (We currently have a system that ranks in the top ten in the world. (No thanks to AIMS or to our puppet ministers of education or to the political and economic bosses of New Brunwick.)
There is a small group who have our forests. The dominate the provincial economy. They get handsome tax breaks that we have to pay for. They get subsidized electricity that we have to pay for. Now, they want our children. If we go along with this, we're on a downward road that has no end except in poverty and hopelessness. And our children and grandchildren will live to curse us for what we allowed to happen.
When you read the story, it says 41 percent in Moncton support shale gas exploration.. Since when has 41% been most? Those who oppose it are 36%, a number within the margin of error for such a poll which means the poll shows no significant difference between the two sides. Fully 20% have no opinion at all. How could they? They haven't had any information about it. That whole story is a lie.
When the story continues on p. A6, the headline is "Poll finds support for shale gas exploration". Well, yes. If it can find one person who supports shale gas exploration and thousands against it, then it has found support - I suppose. Not much support. But some. I imagine similar polls could also find support for Stalin, for farting in public, and for spitting on restaurant floors. The headline is true. But it gives a false impression - and that's lying.
In fact, shale glass exploration means fracking. And, when you call it fracking, the 41% support drops to 29%. In other words, when the meaning of the poll is made clear, then the real issue, fracking, has very, very little support.
And this was in an urban poll. Expect the shale gas option to do much, much worse in a rural poll.
This whole story is a classic example of how to slant the news to give the impression it says something different from what it does say.
Right below this story on the front page is a SPECIAL REPORT. Why is it called a SPECIAL REPORT? After all, it's really quite a minor news story, Well, that's another, old news game. It's called a SPECIAL REPORT because that gives it an air of authority and excitement.
The head is "Students get shale gas experience". It's simply a story of NB students who worked in the shale gas industry this summer. It's a feel good story. SWN resources took them on for summer jobs in the southern US. The real messages?
1. Students loved the experience. Have positive feelings about fracking.
2, SWN cares about New Brunswickers, and is looking after their children and their children's futures.
3. SWN will provide jobs for New Brunswickers.
This is soft sell propaganda - and pretty sleazy stuff for a newspaper to run.
Oh, there is still no story about the serious fracking accidents in Pennsylvania, no story about the law companies making money out of law suits for fracking damage, no stories about other countries who are banning fracking.
Nor have we yet had any of the impartial evidence we have many times been promised by Alward, by Brunswick Media, and by the shale gas industry. What we're getting instead is some pretty crude propaganda. The industry is going to have to find a better propaganda writer than Brent Mazerolle..
The editorial is a booster speech, something like Shakespeare would have written for Henry V rallying his troops - if Shakespeare had been a really bad writer.
Interesting column by Norbert Cunningham on multi-culturism. One of the key problems is that so few people understand what culture means. There is no such thing as a Moslem culture or a Christian culture or a French or English... We each have a culture - a way we react to the world. There are many ways in which I react to the world in much the way a Moslem or an Acadian does. There are many ways I don't react as my parents did. Our children will not have the same culture as us. Cultures, as reactions to the world, also change constantly as the world changes. Good luck to anyone who tries to define something that no two people completely share, and that is constantly changing, anyway.
Superb column by Jody Dallaire. Well worth a read.
Interesting letter by M. Sullivan in "Direct efforts to right place". It 's a well deserved jab at those who confuse self-righteousness and finger-pointing with religious faith.
A p.s. to this blog. The US SAT scores for reading skill at high school graduation have hit the lowest level in the long history of these scores. This comes at the same time as other tests have shown US education to have declined shaprtly, putting it far below standards in the rest of the developed world.
This is a result of the massive shift in the US to statistical ratings of public schools, and to crereping privatization. This has all come at the urging of "think-tanks" eager to make it possible for private business to get control of public education, and to run it on a "for profit" basis.
The Atlantic Institute for Market Studies and other think-tanks like The Fraser Institute have been publishing their pseudo-scientific studies to duplicate in Canada what has happened in the US. That's why New Brunswick now has school raings, administered by the people at The Atlantic Institute who are quite ignorant of education, but very well-informed on greed and self-interest, and who really runs New Brusnwick.
That's why the T and T last year ran a crude and unethical campaign to vilify the public shools, to destroy confidence in them, and to call for more intrusions by the private interests who have done so much to destroy american public schools. I have to assume that the TandT's boss, who is also affiliated with AIMS, wants the public schools to be discredited and, as much as possible, run by a public/private partnership.like the one that destroyed education in the US. (We currently have a system that ranks in the top ten in the world. (No thanks to AIMS or to our puppet ministers of education or to the political and economic bosses of New Brunwick.)
There is a small group who have our forests. The dominate the provincial economy. They get handsome tax breaks that we have to pay for. They get subsidized electricity that we have to pay for. Now, they want our children. If we go along with this, we're on a downward road that has no end except in poverty and hopelessness. And our children and grandchildren will live to curse us for what we allowed to happen.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)