Saturday, April 16, 2011

April 16: A pleasant surprise in The Moncton Times and Transcript

My pleasant suprise was confined to two pages. Most of the paper was its usual, blah self. There was little on the federal election - and nothing of any significance. "Bill" Beliveau wrote a much too blatantly Liberal commentary. Evidently, politics in New Brunswick are rather like religious faiths in which one believes without knowing a whole lot about them - doesn't know what they mean, but jumps for joy and shouts Hosanna in the highest for (whatever) party.

But, oh, check out pages F2 and F3 in the Whatever section.

There you will find eight commentaries, all intelligent, well-written, and interesting to read. All of them are by students in our public schools - the same ones the The Times and Transcript has so unethically (and unintelligently) poured its venom on.

One of the commentators is Jana Giles, a grade seven student. I taught grade seven students for several years. I never in those years saw a piece of writing that came close to this one. Indeed, I have had university students, more than a few, whose writing was below Jana's level.

I disagreed only with one commentary. It was well-written. It was intelligent. On first reading, I quite agreed with it. This is the column by the Whatever Editor who is, like the other writers, a public school student. But I felt uneasy about it on second thought.

This is the item headed "One-size-fits-all approach to teaching. It is a complaint that the schools seem to be shifting shifting away from streaming courses which puts gifted students in a certain subject in one class, and and those who have difficulties in another.

The problem here is that to note the shift, and even to voice an opinion about it would be quite legitimate. To mention nothing of the other side of the story - and to blame the school disctrict for it - well these are not legitimate. What have here is a case of editorial disease. Luckily, we have caught it early, and the patient's mind seems unusually healthy. So, it can be cured.

1. I would start such an editorial with a statement that the teachers I have seen in Moncton have worked very hard, harder than I have known in other provinces (and countries) to help those students who need coaching.They freely give up their lunch hours, and they give up periods set for other duties, to help students. That is voluntary effort; and it deserves recognition and credit.
2. As a student who was educated in streamed-class schools, I know their failings. Students in the "bobo" class know damned well that they've been slotted as dummies. It can happen way too early in life that a person is, in effect, taught he is of low intellectual quality. And so it happens that Selective classes can convince children they lack ability - at an age when it is far too early to make such judgements.

Beware of anything that "brands" children - either with inferiority or with superiority. The errors you make can affect a child for life.

I feel a little stongly about that because I was branded as  hopeless loss, and was told by the principle to leave school in the last year of high school. So I became an office boy which, he had told me, was all I would ever be good for.

Ten years later, he still  had his BA.. I never got a high school certificate. But I did get a Ph.D.

3. Then there are the questions of cost and use of resources. Were they factors in the decision?
Did the editor ask those questions? I see no evidence she even thought of them.

Beware of modelling yourself on editors. For the most part, editors are hired hands whose job it is to sell papers, and to be the owner's mouthpiece. That can be true even of quite prestigious ones. The result is generations of editors who have written editorials (often inflammatory ones) on subjects they know nothing about - except that such is what the boss wants.

The editor of The Moncton TandT once wrote furiously about the illegality of coalitions in our political system. This was the official line adopted at the time by the Conservative leadership in Ottawa. In fact, there is nothing wrong with coalitions, a piece of information easily determined by reading those pages of any History of Canada which mentions the First World War. It can also be determined by a reading of the history of the Conservative party since 1867. Harper lied. The editor who believed him was either a hack or an ignoramus. Perhaps both.

Before writing an editorial with the judgemental tone of yours, it would have wise to ask some questions and, even then, to avoid assigning the blame.

(Oh, Shakespeare would never write "shoe-in". The expression is an old one going back to the fifteenth century, and perhaps dating back to Latin. It had various spellings such a showe-in and schowe-in.  Today, it is spelled shoo-in. It has nothing to do with the feet -( unless you swat at a fly, and say "shoo"..)

The Whatever Editor should take this as kindly advice. She's good. She can write. She's intelligent. She is much to good to waste her talents by imitating newspaper editors.

This is really an oustanding section of The Moncton Times&Trnscript. Today, certainly is was the best section.

Friday, April 15, 2011

April 15: The Singular Incident of the dog in the night....

Fans of Sherlock Holmes will remember the mystery "Silver Blaze", of a racehorse taken from its stable one night to be crippled. Toward the end of the story, Holmes tells his faithful Dr. Watson that the answer to the mystery is in "the singular incident of the dog in the night."

Watson, baffled as always, said, "But the dog did nothing in the night."

"That," said Holmes, "is the singular inicident."

Moncton has a dog that has done nothing in the election. Today, The Moncton Times and Transcript had just one story on the federal election - and a largely irrelevant one, at that. Nor was there an editorial on it. On the same page, Norbert Cunningham confined himself to a commentary so esoteric and irrelevant that few are likely to read it.

The editorial comments have recently had more federal politics in them than the paper as a whole has. Well-drawn (if with pretty juvenile wit), the cartoons tells what the paper's bias is.  This is a cartoonist who seems to have built his career on knowing what the bosses want.

But there's nothing in the paper....except...maybe... the editorial "Canadians fed up with prison system". That could be our singular incident of the dog in the night. This is a story about a dangerous murderer who was rejected by the parole board, but given a daily (supervised) work release by the Correctional Sevice of Canada. I quite agree with what the editorial says, but... if I were the editorial page editor, I would have called the editorial writer in for a chat.

"You can't use that headline."

"Why not, chief? It's true."

"It is also true that you really would be more presentable if you made proper use of tissue paper in caring for your nose. And you may write an editorial on that if you so wish. But I would not label that one, either, "Canadians fed up with prison system."

" In fact, your editorial contains no evidence whatever that Canadians are fed up with their correctional system, and no evidence that they even know much about it. A headline is supposed to reflect the message of the story. The message of this story is that we object to the release, even supervised, of such a dangerous person. It is not about the attitude of the Canadian people toward pir prison system - of which most people, in fact, know close to nothing."

Obviously, this conversation never took place. Why not?

A paper like The Moncton Times and Transcript chooses its side in an election long before any election is called. But to show that too early turns people off. So they do what they did to the public schools. Any story, however trivial, that generates negative feelings about public schools was published. Any that was positive got ignored or attacked.  When ten or so paents objected to the closing of Moncton High, they go full media coverage. The more than a thousand who didn't object got scarcely a mention.

Remember the time New Brunswick was praised nationally for its high school completion rate? The Times responded by attacking the schools bitterly, even accusing them of not teaching ALL the students - whatever that means. Then there was the story of a girl in elementary school who wasn't allowed to go to the bathroom in time -and so wet her pants. That was a big item of the day in hack newspapers and radio stations.

It's a simple propaganda device. Use information to spread a general sense that somebody or some thing is hateful. Don't say it directly because that betrays prejudice. Make it appear like you're just telling irt as it is.

In the case of today's "singular incident", it may not suprise you to remember that Harper has made "getting tough on crime" a major issue.

Editorial heads are usually written by the editorial page editor. The editor who let that head blow by is either unethical or as thick as the proverbial brick. Alas! I think he's actually quite clever. Give the Moncton Times Credit. It may be trivial, uninformative and even misinformative. But it knows something about propaganda.

Expect The Moncton Times and Transcript to keep us uniformed on the election. It many then, the day before the election, give us its thoroughly nonpartisan advice.

As for the cartoon, I still wait to see one making fun of either Stephen Harper or James Irving.  Talk about lacking integrity.....

Thursday, April 14, 2011

April 14: What election?

There was, again, only one story on the federal election in today's Moncton Times and Transcript. And it was the unavoidable story of last night's debate. At that, the Today'sNews section was topped by a bizarre article asking why Republicanism has not taken root in Canada. This is a crucial issue facing Canada? Must be. It not only led the NewsToday section; it was a longer story than the debate was.

The TandT also missed what was surely the oustanding story to come out of the first debate. Harper was caught in an obvious and blatant lie in the first debate. When charged with making it difficult for refugees trying to flee to Canada in fear of their lives,and also of making it difficult to immigrants to come to Canada with their families, Harper said it was not true. He said  that, in fact, immigration has been rising.

Reporters who do research (hint - not from Brunswick Press) dug out the real figures. Immigration and acceptance of refugees has beein decllining dramatically for years - and as a direct result of government policy.

It is not possible the prime minister would not know that. He's a proven liar, and not for the first time. But The Moncton Times had no space for that story because they had a hot one on the burning issue of whether Canada should become a republic. (Hint to editor - republicanism is now more commonly used to refer to the Rebpublican party in the US. That's a confusing head.)

So far, I have seen nothing about the "greater Moncton" candidates.Nor have I heard of any political party meetings. Nor can I get the slightest sense of the general issues facing Canada and, in particular, New Brunswick from reading the Brunswick Press.

It's not as though the issues aren't pretty obvious.
1. Canada is militarily and politically tied, and in a subordinate position, to a nation that is in serious and rapid decline. It is a relationship that will draw Canada into an endless series of wars in Asia,  Africa and South America - exactly as it drew us into a war in Afghanistan, and is now pulling us into one in Libya.
2. Our reliance on the US to buy our exports has, as most business leaders have recognized, become a handicap. We need to get into the great market places that seem to be developing in India, China, Brazil. But what are we going to sell them? Computers? Television sets? Cars?
  The problem for large corporations is not such a pressing one. They can simply move their investment money from here to Brazil, India, and China. Lucky them.
   But what about the rest of us? Do we all go back to the old days of selling off our natural resources for low wages?
3. We have a dangerous problem with the spreading gap between rich and poor. That is quite likely to lead to civil violence in both Canada and the US. (Harper and Obama both know that. That's why they've been working on a deal to use American and Canadian troops interchangeably in both countries, just in case the ordinary folks get restless.)

This is the most important election in the history of this country. It is also the most trivialized one. Except for a quick visit by Harper (in which he said nothng), one could easily get the impression that nothing is happening in New Brunswick. And, in that respect, The Moncton Times is an accurate reflection of the political indolence of this province.

That's what makes it so easy to plunder New Brunswick.

But,  hey,I just bet the whole world is pretty excited about the talk of a new hockey rink.

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

April 13: Not with a bang, but a whimper...

Today, in the midst of a frederal election, and probably the most important one in Canadian history, The Moncton Times and Transcript carried one story (count them, folks, one) on the election. At that,it was the unavoidable story of the leaders' debate.

Most Canadians still have almost no idea of what the election is about. Nor has the debate made much difference. TV is a terrible medium for the transmission of ideas. Ask anybody who has ever worked in the firld. People's  minds are active and concentrating when they listen to radio. But TV puts the brain to sleep. It's all pictures. As a general rule, the winner of a TV debate is the one who stays calm and doesn't move much. That's why Trudeau was so effective on TV.

Harper was short on any clarification of what his plans are. He dodged most questions and charges. He had nothing of import (or even of truth) to say. But I would guess he won the TV  debate because TV is being a picture,not a thinker. Harper undoubtedly has strengthened his hold on the functionally illiterate vote; and that alone can take him a good part of the way to a majority.

Speaking of functional illiteracy, the Moncton Times has its predictable editorial "Tax cuts defensible", defending tax cuts for corporations and the wealthy. Making the rich richer helps us all, it says, because the rich then invest it, and create jobs. I connect that with illiteracy because illiteracy must be the only excuse for not knowing what nonsense that is.

After decades of tax cuts for the rich and corporations, the US is deep into a recession CAUSED by the rich and corporations. In that period, way of half of all the wealth of more than 300,000,00 Anericans is  held by 400 families. Almost none of those families pay anything close to even the low taxes assigned to them. That's because the tax laws are full of loopholes for the rich.

In any given year, as many as 20% of the richest and the largest corporations in the US will pay no taxes at all. For others, the real rate of income tax paid is commonly something like ten percent or less of profits. The situation in Canada is the same, and will get worse under a Harper majority.

Nor is there any reason to believe that tax cuts for the rich will be used to invest in Canadian or New Brunswick jobs. Investors are not agents of charity. They invest money where it will make money.Increasingly, that money is being invested in the new economic powers -China, Brazil, India... We hand over gifts in the shape of saved taxes to coroporations. But we have no control over how or where they spend it.

With the cutting of taxes for corporations, the middle class and the poor have not gained. In fact, they have both lost ground. The wealth of the very rich has rocketed out of sight. If all New Brunswickers from birth to death were to work at the average New Brunswick wage, and to carry that on for a full century and to save every penny of it, then the whole province of nearly a million paople all put together would still not match the wealth of the Irvings. Somebody is making big money out of this. But it isn't  you or me.

All over the world, there are countries that have low to zero taxing for corporations (largely for corporations owned by western investors, including large numbers of Canadians.) This has been going on for centuries. Almost all those countries  are in wretched poverty with no services and, often, death-dealing pollution  - Haiti, Guatemala, most of Central America, Congo and, indeed, most of Africa. In every case, nothing of the investment has gone back to the country. As the British looted South Africa and Iran and Iraq, and Libya and India, they left behind them mostly poverty, disease, ignorance and despair.

Now, North American corporations are completing the looting of the US and Canada as they move on to newer empires.

That editorial is not only ignorant of the basics of economics, but is childish in its ignorance. (To be fair, we have to consider the possiblity that the editorial writer is really a skilled economist, but is lying. Hard to tell with TheMoncton Times and Transcript.)

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

April 12: No. Today, I can't blame the Moncton T&T

Today's paper had virtually nothing about the federal election in it. There was a poll showing Harper is close to Majority territory. That other story, quite reasonably so, is that Harper has been caught in another scandalous case of boondoggling to go with his choices of convicted thieves in his entourage, his manipulation of audiences at election speeches, and his flagrant lies to parliament. None of this matters.

As they go into what will be, I think, the most important  federal election in the history of this country, most Canadians must don't give a damn. The parties were quite right to pospone their French debate when it conflicted with the time of a hockey game. If they had gone ahead with the debate, they would have had no viewers.

I have never seen Canadians (and Americans) behave with such indifference to an election. Perhaps it's an understandable disillusionment with democracy. Perhaps it's the growing interest in trivia that we see reflected so often in our news media and in those absurd tabloids we see in supermarkets - that seem to outsell the regular newspapers on any given day. Perhaps it's just a stunned fatalism.

It is rare to find anyone who knows what the party platforms are, let alone what pressing issues are not even mentioned in the news media.

The world is going through a change as big as the fall of the Roman Empire; and Canada, despite its relatively stable financial position, is not at all prepared the economic and military changes that are coming - and coming soon. The changes are many but, admittedly; hard to predict. For example, the continued growth of China would have a severe impact on us. If it doesn't grow -  if for example, the Chinese government loses its iron control - and it is at least possible that it will - then we shall all have reason to fear a nuclear power in a state of collapse.

The Moncton Times carries two columnists who are among the best you will find anywhere -and I do mean anywhere. Check out Alec Bruce and Gwynn Dyer. (I think I'm being neutral. I've never even met Alex Bruce, and I knew Gwynn, but it was many years ago on radio. Read their columns on the editorial page today. You may find yourself thinking we really do have bigger issues than what a nuisance it is to register a gun.

Instead, Canadians will, if they vote at all, vote on knee-jerk reactions as in - 'Conservatives are good at handling an economy' (even a glance at Canadian history will show they have the worst record of bad and excessive spending); the 'Liberals are too deep into social spending' (a myth that goes back some sixty years. In fact, Liberals have done just enough social spending to avoid civil unrest, and to get re-elected).' The NDP is socialist.' (I might wish it were, at least a little bit. In fact, it has not been socialist since it was formed out of the old and only partly socialist CCF).

How will it turn out?

My guess is a great many won't even vote. The ones with special interests will vote because Harper has played to them. Most of us will ignore the profound military and economic consequences that face our children and, probably, most of those who read this. The special interests will turn out strong for Harper because they think the big issues of the day are gun registration, unconditional support for Israel, unconditional support for an American empire in its last, desparate years, privatization of everything, and more prisons.

That's how Harper will win, and we all will lose. Not with a bang, but a whimper.

Oh, and read the letter to the editor by M.P.Martin. it's excellent. I congratulate the T&T not only for publishing it, but for naming it The Letter of the Day.

Saturday, April 9, 2011

April 9: Nothing in the The Moncton Times day, so Obama

Much of what happens in political life is quite obvious. But we don't see it. That's because we don't want to. It was surely obvious from the start that Prime Minister Brian Mulroney was a slick opportunist, and a man of no political principle. We ignored it, and elected him, anyway. Even as some of the truth came out, we have refused to see and to take action on his behaviour. Nor have we considered the obvious implications. Surely, Mulroney's lobbyist was not the only one in Ottawa. And surely other politicians have received offers either of personal bribes or of party funding.

We see. But we refuse to allow ourselves to believe what we see. That's why most of will refuse to believe this post.

Obama, who spent a record 750,000,000 on his last presidential campaign, announced a few days ago he will raise a billion dollars for the next one. That could have been a politically damaging announcement for him. Obama would look a fool if he failed now to raise that money. But Obama  is not a fool. That means the money is almost sertainly in the bag already.

Who is it being raised from?

Is it coming from the unemployed? From the poor and the ill and the homeless whose help is being cut in order to lavish hundreds of billions on failed millionaires in banking and the automotive industry? And on a hugely profitable defense industry?

Will herraise it from single or deserted mothers struggling to live on the minimum wage paid by a big box store? From the millions who lost their homes to a Wall St. scam? Certainly not.

He will get a billion dollars from the same corporations and wealthy individuals who gave him his campaign funding the last time. That's not speculation. The figures are public. Look at them. Look at them, and see what's there. (looking and seeing what is really there is not, alas, the same thing.)

Obviously, Obama has been a good boy for his funders. He has followed almost exactly the same policies as George Bush - who was also financed by the same sort of people, often exactly the same people, who financed Obama. The people elected Obama. Obama sold them on the illusion that change was possible within the American political system.

Blame him or blame the system. It doesn't matter which is to blame. What we can see, if we will look and really see what is there, is that change is not possible within the American political system. With at least three to six lobbyists lobbyists for each congressman, with corporations paying the bulk of election costs, it is no longer possible even to imagine change happening through the present system.

People will take a great deal of punishment so long as they hold illusion they can change things. What they will do if they realize they can't is unpredictable, but almost invariably destructive.

The significance of Obama's announcement is that it is a statement that change will not happen. I don't think Obama ever was more than an illusionist. But he has destroyed even his own illusion. What rule the US now are the forces of personal interest and a greed so obsessive as to be suicidal.

Look at it. See the reality. But don't,if you're a Canadian, feel smug.

We are well along in the same direction. Only two parties (plus, possibly, the Bloc) can raise enough money to put on a successful campaign in the face of the corporate funding available to the Conservatives and, still, to the Liberals. Corporations do not give millions to political parties to enourage the democratic process. Indeed, they make sure that some parties get no funds from them at all.

The US Supreme Court has recently decided that corporations are jes' folks like the rest of us, so it lifted the few retrictions there were in corporate funding of parties. Harper has made it clear he will do his bit by withdrawing government help for parties that cannot tap the corporate piggy bank.

To add to that, neither Canada nor the US has news media that are non-partisan, and that keep us fully informed on what is going on. That includes the most prestigious outlets in both Canada and the US. They are all owned by much the same people who control the corporations. Even the CBC, certainly the best of the lot in ethics and honesty, has to pull its punches for fear that a leader like Harper will slash its budget or, most likely, sell it.

We do not have the information to even understand what the issues are. Our news media don't inform us. They manipulate us.New Brunswick newspapers are not different from other North American newspapers. Their only distinctions are that their ethics are even lower than most of the others, and the quality of their editing and reporting are in journalism's toilet.

Nobody in New Brunswick, surely, has any serious doubts about who runs this province. Everybody knows that no party will get adequate funding or publicity unless it can be pleasing to those who run the province.

We are well through a period of rapid and fundamental change. That creates fear and hysteria -both already manifest with the creation of the Tea Party.

Democracy is, for all practical purposes, gone from North America. Soon enough, it will be impossible even for the most optimistic among to kid ourselves that we can still see it.

Friday, April 8, 2011

April 8: an offensive commentary -and a missing story.

Norbert Cunnngham has a "To the contrary column" that is  (quite unintentionally, I'm sure) offensive. I quite agree with his view that people who invite us to commercial lectures on how to get motivated talks are taking the gullible for a ride. Where we part company is the notion that fierce drive and energy are the essentials to becoming rich.

In fact, most rich people are the children of rich parents. George Bush II at no time in his life was either intelligent or hard-working. Much of his youth was lost in drugs and booze. His university grades were too low to get into a good MBA programme: but daddy fixed that and got him in, anyway. Miraculously, the drunken druggie who couldn't perform up to standard in a BA, did well and got an MBA.

Then,with Daddy's help, he dodged the raft for Vietnam. Only then, at long last, did he get his first job. It was a job as CEO of an oil company. Talk about working hard to get ahead! (I'm sure it was just a coincidence that the share holders of the oil company were daddy's friends.) The company went broke.

So George was invited by become head honcho of another company that needed connections to pull off a big deal involving a baseball team. George's father, by then, was president; and had just finished using his influence to get his son out of a fraud charge arising from the oil company failure. George became a multimillionaire out of that one. He also got a "thank you" bonus of twelve million dollars that was delivered to him after he got his third job - governor of Texas.

Sam Bronfman, who founded Canadian Distilleries and a family dynasty, founded his fortune in prohibition days as a booze smuggler. So did Joe Kennedy, the father President Kennedy.

What it takes to be rich is fully explained in a book that is a big favourite of rich people. It's called "Atlas Shrugged", by Ayn Rand. That book has become The Bible of the very rich. It's argument is that greed, self-interest, lack of concern for others, are all good; that these are the qualities that make you rich. These are the qualities that the rich, themselves, tell us we should admire.

As a professonal speaker, I met a good many multi-millionaires, some of whom I quite liked. But I would characterize few of them as hard working, not when they had ample spare time for exclusive clubs with long and expensive suppers with guest speakers. They also had lots of spare time for golf and travel to exotic places.

There are people in this world who work very hard, indeed. You will find many of them struggling to survive on minimum wage. I don't think I have ever met a rich person who worked nearly so hard as any deserted mother struggling to raise a child on a job at Walmart. Even a couple, working at average wages, find it hard to make ends meet in this province. I have never met a rich person who worked nearly as hard as a single mother on minimum wage, or as hard as a lineman working on second-storey wires on a -20 day in a blizzard, or as hard as an average elementary school teacher.

Working hard has nothing to do with getting rich. What counts is greed, towering ego, a sense of entitlement, and a rich daddy.

Meanwhile, all the news media missed the significance of the most important news story of the week. President Obama has publicly stated he intends to raise one billion dollars to fight the next American election. That's a story that tells you all you need to know about the reality of where the US is, and where it is going. Maybe I'll try that one tomorrow.