In the section News Today (a humorous title?), The Moncton Times carries the story of the how the American government might run out of money on Saturday. Right on the ball, kids. except -
That was yesterday's news in The New York Times - which means the story was known to news media two days ago.
At that, it's a pretty shallow report with little sense of just how serious this is. If the budget is not approved, most government services will have to shut down or be seriously reduced. That includes everything from support for autistic children, food for a large part of the US population, law services, and pay for the military, including for troops in Afghanistan. All that will be enormously damaging at home, and even worse in terms of world standing for the US.
Nor does the arcticle make it clear what has caused this crisis. Big business is determined that the cost of the recession (which big business caused) will be borne by the poorest and most vulnderable in American society. Republicans are fighting to save money by cutting off the poor, the sick, the unemployed - while cutting taxes for the very, very rich - large numbers of whom don't pay taxes at all, anyway.
Why such a badly written (and late) story? That's because the T@T gets most of its news outside the metropolis of "greater Moncton" from Post Media, a news agency whose purpose is to play down the greed and social irresponsibility of large corporations and their political flunkies.
The other piece of junk news is the decision of Moncton council to ask Canadian taxpayers to put up 25 million for a glorified hockey rink. The rest of the hundred million or so is expect to come from NB and , especially, from Moncton taxpayers.
Wasn't it just very recently that the editorial writer was foaming at the mouth over a pay raise for city workers that was too high by a few hundred a year?
The undertaking would, of course, be a "partnership" between government and business.However, in this partnership there appears to be no mention of the business partners putting up any money. What a clover patch this is going to be for rich bees. Yeah, we're partners, see?
The hockey team owner (and prime beneficiary of this project) has generously agreed to terms. In a badly written sentence, the story seems to say that the hockey team will be the anchor tenant, and as payment will contribute 2.5 million - spread over ten years - to HELP with maintenance costs. In other words, maintenance alone will cost over a quarter million a year, and the main beneficiary only has to pay part of the maintenance to get a hundred million dollar stadiusm. Zippo on the loans because we'll be paying them, How would you like to live in a nice, big house on those terms?
No wonder Moncton attracts so many scam artists - not just from the "better sort" of people, but also from common thieves. That's the trouble with common thieves. They aren't smart enough to incorporate themselves, set up their own news medium, and to finance elections.
The editorial, which gleefully bashes anybody who isn't rich - teachers,city workers, etc. has not a word to say on these two, major stories. Instead, we get the usual bilge that the whole world is watching Moncton.
Luckily, there are two, good columns of comment on the editorial page. (The cartoon, as usual is trivial; it's about the rise in the price of coffee at Tim's).
Except for those two, solid columns on the editorial page, the paper isn't worth reading unless you really,really want to know which celebrities you never heard of are having a birthday today.
A critical review of local and world news. This blog originally commented on the Moncton Times and Transcript but has enlarged its scope.
Thursday, April 7, 2011
Wednesday, April 6, 2011
Apri l6: footnote
For Moncton readers, my current events group April meeting at the Moncton library will be held on Thursday, April 7. 2 to 3 pm.
April 6: A concise guide to the federal election
Since the Moncton Times has said close to nothing of any intelligence about the election, here's a short guide to your choices.
To begin, forget the words liberal, conservative, socialist, left, and right. Very few people have the faintest idea what those words mean - with the result that they are used as a sort of shorthand for various prejudices. The Conservatave party isn't conservative. The Liberal party isn't liberal. And the NDP isn't socialist. Those labels are used to build hatreds or fears and confusion; and to conjure up cartoon figures for political bigots.. But they really don't mean anything to most people who use them or to most people who hear them.
As well, people who claim to be capitalist and anti-welfare state can actually be very pro-welfare state when it comes to get government grants, easing of regulations, cutting of their taxes. You soon learn that they are against welfare only when it doesn't go to them. In that sense, some of the biggest welfare families in Canada come from New Brunswick.
The two biggest parties in this election are really both the big business party. Both the so-called Liberals and Conservatives disguise the reality of who funds them and who they work for. But they may disguise it in various ways. For years, the Liberals disguised who they worked for by introducing social programmes, but doing as little as possible and a slowly as possible. (That technique was actually first introduced by a Conservative prime minister, R.B. Bennett, in the election of 1935.
Another way is to appeal to special interest groups and by appealing to fears. Harper is appealing to fears by promisiing more jails and longer sentences. (If that worked, then the US with the world's largest prison population would also be the world's most crime-free country.) He also works to satisfy evangelical Chistians and Zionists because these are highly organized groups that can get their voters to the polls.
It's the same with his promise to end gun registration. In the range of serious problems that face us, whether guns should be registered is a piddling issue. But Harper knows there are hundreds of thousands of Canadians who are foolish enough to vote for him on the basis of that one issue alone.
For at least twenty years, the Liberals have lost any sense of what even their phony appeal would be. Mackenzie King, who delayed social legislation for years in this country, was a smart enough politician to pretend he was leading the way. In reality, King was always a servant of big business while pretending to be for the "common people". Ignatieff's problem is that doesn't even know how to fake having principles.
The NDP is not a socialist party. There was a time when it was moderately socialist. That was when it was called the CCF. But those days ended when the unions became its major source of funding. Unions, generally, are not enthusiastic about socialism. In fact, their general outlook is more like that of big business than they are prepared to admit. But it is not until we arrive at the NDP that we come to a party that is not owned by big business.
The Bloc Quebecois is less dependent than the liberals and conservatives on big business for its financing. But it is a party that has no interest even in the existence of Canada. It also relies heavily for support on bigotry in Quebec. (I am not, by the way, at all anti-French. I am anti-bigot. I am, therefore, equally anti those bigots in New Brunswick who speak English.)
The Green Party has, by its nature, a very narrow platform. However, they don't really need a broader one because they know they aren't going to form a government. They are also the party big business is least likely to contribute to because big business doesn't give a damn for the environment.. As a result, Canada is notorious for having done the least in the whole, developed world to improve the environment. A vote for the Green Party has mixed results. It may do something to get Canada to move a little bit on environmental issues. But the certainty is that a vote for it is one that probably splits the riding vote enough to improve the chances for Liberals (or maybe Conservatives) to win.
And don't rely on The Moncton Times for any helpful information. I don't think they have yet published the information, from excellent sources, that the new fighter plane Harper intends to buy will not cost $39 billion for a squadron, but something approaching 150 billion. It is also the opinion of military experts in Canada and the US that it is, even by the standards of today, not a very good aircraft - and this is something we would have to use for twenty years and more.
So - what will happen if the Conservatives win? Big business will be popping champagne corks as its taxes get cut, and the middle class and poor are made to pay the price of the recession. We will also continue to be so subservient to the US we can expect to spend at least a generation - if the world lasts that long - fighting American wars.
What will happen in the Liberals win? Not a whole lot different. We would try, at least, to get out of that disastrous fighter plane deal. And we probably wouldn't be spending billions on prisons that would create even more crime. Otherwise - hey, it will still be the same bosses.
In either case, our democracy will continue to decline - and it barely exists, now.
Any majority government could be only Liberal or Conservative. Either one would be immensely destructive of Canadian society.
Some people complain at the idea of a coalition. In fact, some of our best governments of the last fifty years have been near-coalitions. A coalition has the virtue of disarming the extremists on both sides.
Given the current choices, we would be wise to pray for a coalition. Our situation is very dangerous. I don't think we begin to understand the forces that are so rapidly changing the world. Democracy is in serious danger. The concept of societies organized in nation states is on shaky ground. (Globalism has aspects to it that we have not even begun to understand; and it has crippling features to it that endanger the existence of even the concept of democratic and/or national government.
A coalition would buy us time to realize just how dangerous our position is. A majority government would almost certainly put an end to anything we know as Canada.
To begin, forget the words liberal, conservative, socialist, left, and right. Very few people have the faintest idea what those words mean - with the result that they are used as a sort of shorthand for various prejudices. The Conservatave party isn't conservative. The Liberal party isn't liberal. And the NDP isn't socialist. Those labels are used to build hatreds or fears and confusion; and to conjure up cartoon figures for political bigots.. But they really don't mean anything to most people who use them or to most people who hear them.
As well, people who claim to be capitalist and anti-welfare state can actually be very pro-welfare state when it comes to get government grants, easing of regulations, cutting of their taxes. You soon learn that they are against welfare only when it doesn't go to them. In that sense, some of the biggest welfare families in Canada come from New Brunswick.
The two biggest parties in this election are really both the big business party. Both the so-called Liberals and Conservatives disguise the reality of who funds them and who they work for. But they may disguise it in various ways. For years, the Liberals disguised who they worked for by introducing social programmes, but doing as little as possible and a slowly as possible. (That technique was actually first introduced by a Conservative prime minister, R.B. Bennett, in the election of 1935.
Another way is to appeal to special interest groups and by appealing to fears. Harper is appealing to fears by promisiing more jails and longer sentences. (If that worked, then the US with the world's largest prison population would also be the world's most crime-free country.) He also works to satisfy evangelical Chistians and Zionists because these are highly organized groups that can get their voters to the polls.
It's the same with his promise to end gun registration. In the range of serious problems that face us, whether guns should be registered is a piddling issue. But Harper knows there are hundreds of thousands of Canadians who are foolish enough to vote for him on the basis of that one issue alone.
For at least twenty years, the Liberals have lost any sense of what even their phony appeal would be. Mackenzie King, who delayed social legislation for years in this country, was a smart enough politician to pretend he was leading the way. In reality, King was always a servant of big business while pretending to be for the "common people". Ignatieff's problem is that doesn't even know how to fake having principles.
The NDP is not a socialist party. There was a time when it was moderately socialist. That was when it was called the CCF. But those days ended when the unions became its major source of funding. Unions, generally, are not enthusiastic about socialism. In fact, their general outlook is more like that of big business than they are prepared to admit. But it is not until we arrive at the NDP that we come to a party that is not owned by big business.
The Bloc Quebecois is less dependent than the liberals and conservatives on big business for its financing. But it is a party that has no interest even in the existence of Canada. It also relies heavily for support on bigotry in Quebec. (I am not, by the way, at all anti-French. I am anti-bigot. I am, therefore, equally anti those bigots in New Brunswick who speak English.)
The Green Party has, by its nature, a very narrow platform. However, they don't really need a broader one because they know they aren't going to form a government. They are also the party big business is least likely to contribute to because big business doesn't give a damn for the environment.. As a result, Canada is notorious for having done the least in the whole, developed world to improve the environment. A vote for the Green Party has mixed results. It may do something to get Canada to move a little bit on environmental issues. But the certainty is that a vote for it is one that probably splits the riding vote enough to improve the chances for Liberals (or maybe Conservatives) to win.
And don't rely on The Moncton Times for any helpful information. I don't think they have yet published the information, from excellent sources, that the new fighter plane Harper intends to buy will not cost $39 billion for a squadron, but something approaching 150 billion. It is also the opinion of military experts in Canada and the US that it is, even by the standards of today, not a very good aircraft - and this is something we would have to use for twenty years and more.
So - what will happen if the Conservatives win? Big business will be popping champagne corks as its taxes get cut, and the middle class and poor are made to pay the price of the recession. We will also continue to be so subservient to the US we can expect to spend at least a generation - if the world lasts that long - fighting American wars.
What will happen in the Liberals win? Not a whole lot different. We would try, at least, to get out of that disastrous fighter plane deal. And we probably wouldn't be spending billions on prisons that would create even more crime. Otherwise - hey, it will still be the same bosses.
In either case, our democracy will continue to decline - and it barely exists, now.
Any majority government could be only Liberal or Conservative. Either one would be immensely destructive of Canadian society.
Some people complain at the idea of a coalition. In fact, some of our best governments of the last fifty years have been near-coalitions. A coalition has the virtue of disarming the extremists on both sides.
Given the current choices, we would be wise to pray for a coalition. Our situation is very dangerous. I don't think we begin to understand the forces that are so rapidly changing the world. Democracy is in serious danger. The concept of societies organized in nation states is on shaky ground. (Globalism has aspects to it that we have not even begun to understand; and it has crippling features to it that endanger the existence of even the concept of democratic and/or national government.
A coalition would buy us time to realize just how dangerous our position is. A majority government would almost certainly put an end to anything we know as Canada.
Tuesday, April 5, 2011
April 5: it's them there poor people what's causin' all the trouble
Read it. "City must hold line on wages" is today's editorial. It seems city workers and their conniving union won an increase in their contract - and it is almost a whole one percent more than the editor thinks it should be.
I would have more respect (though still not much) for that editorial writer if he/she had ever made a similar complaint about out leading people in private business. For at least thirty years, the incomes of the very rich have been skyrocketing, even in the recession. When banks failed in the US due to their own shoddy practices, the government gave them at least hundreds of billions of dollars from the tax payers. The senior executives promptly gave each other bonusses of milions of dollars for the fine work they had done.
The editorial writer rails at people whose raise amounts to a few hundred dollars a year (much of it already gone on new taxes). It makes no mention that Moncton council will happily tax us (with cheers from The Moncton Times and Transcript) to give away money to billionaires - as in the form of a hockey rink and other perks for the right people.
For thirty years, we have been watching a steady growth in poverty in Canada, and a steady and rapid rise in the "wages" of the very rich. Would the editorial writer have the guts, the integrity, or even the wit to write about that?
The very wealthy are using the recession to complete their looting of North America. Their device is the argument that letting them get richer is the road to prosperity. And so it is - for them. If cutting taxes for the rich and cutting social services is what makes a nation prosperous, then Congo, Haiti, Guatemala and others would be the richest countries on earth. Billions of dollars have been taken out of those countries. They have virtually no taxes, no services, no education, no health care. Whatever they have is what it pleases private business to give to them. So it doesn't give them anything.
Cutting taxes for the rich and for corporations will not create prosperity. It never has. It never will. Cutting social services will create more unemployed to join the misery of those who are already unemployed.
When Belgium took over the Congo almost a hundred and fifty years ago, it extracted billions of dollars in natural resources, enslaving, torturing and starving millions of people. (The reason it gave for taking The Congo was that it would Christianize and civilize the people. True enough, that is the way our Christian civilization behaves.) Western countries (including Canada) are still there, and will stay there until it is bled dry. They pay extremely low wages, virtually no taxes. They just loot, and the Congolese live in poverty.
Check the growth of the income gap in Canada and the US. Watch this recession being used to make the gap even bigger by cutting taxes for the rich, breaking unions, cutting government - except for its role in letting big business fill its pockets.
Watch the current budget fight in the US Congress to see what's planned for us.
That, Mr./Ms. editorial writer is what the "real world" is like. That sort of greedy and selfish power has already made democracy close to a farce (thus the spectacle of our current federal election.) At the present pace, even the farce of democracy will soon end.
Remember the day just a few months ago when Mr. James Irving announced in his newspaper that he had formed a coalition? I said at the time that was anti-democratic (since in a democracy you have to be an elected member to join a coalition), and that it was arrogant, and that it was the starting point of corporatism which was a way station on the road to Benito Mussolini's fascism.
I know many readers must have thought I was exaggerating. I wasn't. Such things happen. We're watching it happen. That's the "real world".
I would have more respect (though still not much) for that editorial writer if he/she had ever made a similar complaint about out leading people in private business. For at least thirty years, the incomes of the very rich have been skyrocketing, even in the recession. When banks failed in the US due to their own shoddy practices, the government gave them at least hundreds of billions of dollars from the tax payers. The senior executives promptly gave each other bonusses of milions of dollars for the fine work they had done.
The editorial writer rails at people whose raise amounts to a few hundred dollars a year (much of it already gone on new taxes). It makes no mention that Moncton council will happily tax us (with cheers from The Moncton Times and Transcript) to give away money to billionaires - as in the form of a hockey rink and other perks for the right people.
For thirty years, we have been watching a steady growth in poverty in Canada, and a steady and rapid rise in the "wages" of the very rich. Would the editorial writer have the guts, the integrity, or even the wit to write about that?
The very wealthy are using the recession to complete their looting of North America. Their device is the argument that letting them get richer is the road to prosperity. And so it is - for them. If cutting taxes for the rich and cutting social services is what makes a nation prosperous, then Congo, Haiti, Guatemala and others would be the richest countries on earth. Billions of dollars have been taken out of those countries. They have virtually no taxes, no services, no education, no health care. Whatever they have is what it pleases private business to give to them. So it doesn't give them anything.
Cutting taxes for the rich and for corporations will not create prosperity. It never has. It never will. Cutting social services will create more unemployed to join the misery of those who are already unemployed.
When Belgium took over the Congo almost a hundred and fifty years ago, it extracted billions of dollars in natural resources, enslaving, torturing and starving millions of people. (The reason it gave for taking The Congo was that it would Christianize and civilize the people. True enough, that is the way our Christian civilization behaves.) Western countries (including Canada) are still there, and will stay there until it is bled dry. They pay extremely low wages, virtually no taxes. They just loot, and the Congolese live in poverty.
Check the growth of the income gap in Canada and the US. Watch this recession being used to make the gap even bigger by cutting taxes for the rich, breaking unions, cutting government - except for its role in letting big business fill its pockets.
Watch the current budget fight in the US Congress to see what's planned for us.
That, Mr./Ms. editorial writer is what the "real world" is like. That sort of greedy and selfish power has already made democracy close to a farce (thus the spectacle of our current federal election.) At the present pace, even the farce of democracy will soon end.
Remember the day just a few months ago when Mr. James Irving announced in his newspaper that he had formed a coalition? I said at the time that was anti-democratic (since in a democracy you have to be an elected member to join a coalition), and that it was arrogant, and that it was the starting point of corporatism which was a way station on the road to Benito Mussolini's fascism.
I know many readers must have thought I was exaggerating. I wasn't. Such things happen. We're watching it happen. That's the "real world".
Monday, April 4, 2011
April 4: What are the real election issues?
You won't find out what the real issues are in The Moncton Times&Transcript or any other news medium. The Times is not alone in being vacant today. Almost all of our news media have vacant days. New Brunswick takes it a step further. Vacant is its normal, basic stage of New Brunswick papers, usually followed by vacuous and then vitriolic.
So what are the real issues?
Forget about the economy. We're heavily linked with economies all over the world; and we're one of the smaller players. If the rest of the world picks up, so will we. If if doesn't, we won't. We survived the his the US took - not because our corporations are better run, but because we have used government to regulate them so that it's harder for them to pull off giant scams.
Simlarly, we are committed to military alliances and promises (US, NATO, Israel). If any of those sinks deeper into wars and debt, so will we. If economies get really bad, and there is civil unrest, we are already well on the way to committing Canadian troops to put down rioting in the US, and the US is reciprocating.
Of all the things we can deal with, only one is likely to receive much attention in the news media - proportional representation. I think it's a good idea. Unfortunately, it won't solve the major problems of our political system.
The major problem is that most ordinary people have no real control over who gets elected.
1. Elections cost big money. The only parties that can get themselves significant media space are ones that are obedient to the sources of big money - large corporations and the very wealthy. Harper has promised to make it even worse by cutting off government funding for parties.
2. The news media of Canada keep Canadians largely ignorant of what is going on in the world, and what our choices are. That's because most big news media, like print, radio or TV, are owned by very wealthy people who want the news to carry what they want us to think.
Result, most people haven't the faintest idea what the elections are about. That's why the last New Brunswick election was inane. Remember how the Liberals lost because Shawn Graham and his Liberals were discredited by the energy proposal with Quebec?
Come on, folks. Do you seriously think the energy deal was Shawn's idea? Did he ever give the impression of being a daring and inventive person who would push through a piece of legislation with tremendous implications for manufacturing costs - and without being told by corporate leaders to do it? If you do, get real. Like Premier Alward, Shawn Graham is a pet dog. The boss throws the ball, and Alward and Graham chase it. It's like that in most provinces, and federally.
Canadians cannot cast an informed vote because they have no information.
Have you ever seen any figures on how much large corporations cost us taxpayers per year? Taking into account all grants, subisides, contracts, reduced taxes, civic works, etc. carried out for private benefit? Do you know how much tax of the total of all taxes is paid by large corporations? So you know that there are a great many large corporations in both Canada and the US that pay no income tax at all? Despite doing well for their executives and shareholders? And that takes us into another, related issue.
3.The US now has the largest gap between a few wealthy and millions of poor in all of the developed world. Canada is moving in the same way. The giant corporations that fight a rise of a buck fifty or so for minimum wage, give 20%, even 100 %, increases to their senior execs (plus all the perks of club memberships, diners' cards, paid holidays, massive severance pay, etc.) Right through the recent, bad years, their share of national wealth has been increasing dramatically, while poverty has risen.
What they are doing - and doing on a national and international scale - is not only a perversion of the principles of capitalism. It is a destructive force that can destroy our society just as it is now destroying Libya and Egypt.
Greed and excessive ambition will destroy our society as surely as they have destroyed so many societies in the past. The only way to prevent that is to ensure that business is intelligently regulated, and that wealth is widely distributed, both as money and as services.
4. Then there is the question of our foreign policy - which mostly means our relations with the US. No matter who is president, the US faces years of war and a declining economy as its inlfuence is challenged all over the world. That's what the middle east rioting in about. That's what much of the civil warring in Africa is about. That's what Afghanistan is about. It looks very likely to be repeated in Central and South America where the price of US dominance is being seriously challenged.
Do we want to join those wars? The Canadian Council of CEOs will want us to, just as it wanted to send troops to Afghanistan. (Some members of the council so rather well out of cheap labour and lack of regulation in Central and South America. Canadian mining companies are particularly notorious.) Do we want a generation and more of those wars? All other considerations aside, can you imagine the impact that would have on our society?
As oil gets more expensive, will we be allowed to sell it wherever we wish? Will we be allowed to regulate (and enforce regulations) on oil drilling in the high Arctic?
As inland water levels drop (check out Hoover Dam), will we be allowed to control our own fresh water?
Where is this being debated for the public in this election? Where is the informed commentary?
No. We won't see it. Mr. Harper was here and in PEI, presumably because of the election. He said nothing of substance here, and ditto while serving up coffee in PEI.
In a badly informed country, this province and PEI are probably the worst informed, and the least open to serious public discussion.
There's a price for that.
So what are the real issues?
Forget about the economy. We're heavily linked with economies all over the world; and we're one of the smaller players. If the rest of the world picks up, so will we. If if doesn't, we won't. We survived the his the US took - not because our corporations are better run, but because we have used government to regulate them so that it's harder for them to pull off giant scams.
Simlarly, we are committed to military alliances and promises (US, NATO, Israel). If any of those sinks deeper into wars and debt, so will we. If economies get really bad, and there is civil unrest, we are already well on the way to committing Canadian troops to put down rioting in the US, and the US is reciprocating.
Of all the things we can deal with, only one is likely to receive much attention in the news media - proportional representation. I think it's a good idea. Unfortunately, it won't solve the major problems of our political system.
The major problem is that most ordinary people have no real control over who gets elected.
1. Elections cost big money. The only parties that can get themselves significant media space are ones that are obedient to the sources of big money - large corporations and the very wealthy. Harper has promised to make it even worse by cutting off government funding for parties.
2. The news media of Canada keep Canadians largely ignorant of what is going on in the world, and what our choices are. That's because most big news media, like print, radio or TV, are owned by very wealthy people who want the news to carry what they want us to think.
Result, most people haven't the faintest idea what the elections are about. That's why the last New Brunswick election was inane. Remember how the Liberals lost because Shawn Graham and his Liberals were discredited by the energy proposal with Quebec?
Come on, folks. Do you seriously think the energy deal was Shawn's idea? Did he ever give the impression of being a daring and inventive person who would push through a piece of legislation with tremendous implications for manufacturing costs - and without being told by corporate leaders to do it? If you do, get real. Like Premier Alward, Shawn Graham is a pet dog. The boss throws the ball, and Alward and Graham chase it. It's like that in most provinces, and federally.
Canadians cannot cast an informed vote because they have no information.
Have you ever seen any figures on how much large corporations cost us taxpayers per year? Taking into account all grants, subisides, contracts, reduced taxes, civic works, etc. carried out for private benefit? Do you know how much tax of the total of all taxes is paid by large corporations? So you know that there are a great many large corporations in both Canada and the US that pay no income tax at all? Despite doing well for their executives and shareholders? And that takes us into another, related issue.
3.The US now has the largest gap between a few wealthy and millions of poor in all of the developed world. Canada is moving in the same way. The giant corporations that fight a rise of a buck fifty or so for minimum wage, give 20%, even 100 %, increases to their senior execs (plus all the perks of club memberships, diners' cards, paid holidays, massive severance pay, etc.) Right through the recent, bad years, their share of national wealth has been increasing dramatically, while poverty has risen.
What they are doing - and doing on a national and international scale - is not only a perversion of the principles of capitalism. It is a destructive force that can destroy our society just as it is now destroying Libya and Egypt.
Greed and excessive ambition will destroy our society as surely as they have destroyed so many societies in the past. The only way to prevent that is to ensure that business is intelligently regulated, and that wealth is widely distributed, both as money and as services.
4. Then there is the question of our foreign policy - which mostly means our relations with the US. No matter who is president, the US faces years of war and a declining economy as its inlfuence is challenged all over the world. That's what the middle east rioting in about. That's what much of the civil warring in Africa is about. That's what Afghanistan is about. It looks very likely to be repeated in Central and South America where the price of US dominance is being seriously challenged.
Do we want to join those wars? The Canadian Council of CEOs will want us to, just as it wanted to send troops to Afghanistan. (Some members of the council so rather well out of cheap labour and lack of regulation in Central and South America. Canadian mining companies are particularly notorious.) Do we want a generation and more of those wars? All other considerations aside, can you imagine the impact that would have on our society?
As oil gets more expensive, will we be allowed to sell it wherever we wish? Will we be allowed to regulate (and enforce regulations) on oil drilling in the high Arctic?
As inland water levels drop (check out Hoover Dam), will we be allowed to control our own fresh water?
Where is this being debated for the public in this election? Where is the informed commentary?
No. We won't see it. Mr. Harper was here and in PEI, presumably because of the election. He said nothing of substance here, and ditto while serving up coffee in PEI.
In a badly informed country, this province and PEI are probably the worst informed, and the least open to serious public discussion.
There's a price for that.
Saturday, April 2, 2011
April 2: It's official. The Moncton Times will kiss up to Harper
The election stance of the The Moncton Times was never in doubt. Today, it was made obvious from the editorial cartoon, a sketch of Ignatieff dancing on an empty toothpaste tube. (The cartoonist draws well, but has neither depth nor independence in his art. The cartoon commonly - almost always - supports the position of the editors who support whoever they're told to support.)
The editorial, itself, follows the Harper formula for the election. It's an attack ad. There is no mention of any major issue, no mention of any policy except for one item in the Liberal platform - subsidized day care.
Nor is there any attempt at balance. Not a single reason is given in favour of it And the editorial writer is personally insulting to millions of Canadians.
I am no admirer of Ignatieff. I have only nce voted Liberal in my life -and that was because the candidate was a friend who I greatly admire for his abilities and his social conscience. According the the editorial writer, daycare is a subsidy for two-income Yuppies driving expensive SUVs in Canada's biggest cities.
Dear editor, you supercilious, sneering, servile ass...How about those two-income families that work at minimum wage in Walmart or gas stations, or fast food outlets and all the other cheapy jobs which are found in the biggest cities and the smallest villages right across Canada. What about those millions of two-income families who can't even afford their basic needs, and can be fired at a moment's notice?
Have you ever lived like that? You who spends his life wiping the boss' nose with your bare hands?
I grew up in a two-income family in one of Canada's biggest cities. We didn't have an SUV. We had no car at all until we got rich and could afford a used one when I was sixteen. When his employer cut his salary, my father shoveled snow at less than a dollar a day. My mother worked for the same low wages doing manual work at a big newspaper edited by flunkies like you. (Until we started school, my mother stayed home. But that meant we had to hope my father got lucky at the charity food dispensary.)
There's plenty of poverty in Moncton, Dieppe and Riverview And you have insulted everyone who is poor or who has any sense of decency. Ignatieff is out of touch with the real world? I don't doubt he his But you are scarcely the one to say so.
When you think, if you think, imagine a world without two-family incomes. All mothers would have to stay home. So we could all say goodbye to much of the underpaid commercial staff who make shopping so cheap for us. We would have to close down half of our schools (and you probably think that would be a good idea.) Our hospitals would cease to function. So would most of our restaurants. Even for those above the poverty level, they need two salaries to support the casinos, hockey teams, football teams, extra booze , and expensive SUVs that your paper daily urges on us.
You hypocritic lout! You probably know that we subsidize energy costs for billionaires, we subidize the oil sands project, you want to subsidize the hockey team (owned by guess who), we subsidize a wide range or rich people for billions of dollars per year. Meanwhile, we also subsidize the rich my letting them off taxes. But God forbid we should subsidize chldren.
It is really quite impossible to express the contempt you deserve.
You remind me of the poen by Alexander Pope who was a frequent visitor to the king of England's residence of the time in a village called Kew. There he was disgusted by the noble flunkies who spent their day flattering the king and publcly making a fuss and saying "who's 'ittle dog are you?" to the pet dog that the king adored. So Pope engraved on the dog's collar;
I am His Highness' dog at Kew.
Pray tell me, sir,
Who's dog are you?
I urge readers and the editor to read the editorial "Out of Touch with Canadians". Then read the commentary next to to it, "Hypocrisies of electioneering" by (Bill) Belliveau. It is reasoned and offers evidence for its claims. It is unbiased, It does not make hysterical rantings.
It is also well-researched, including points that should have appeared in the news stories of The Moncton Times and Transcript but, like most real news items, never made them.
I was surprised to read that Harper actually said, "Only the party with the most seats can form a government in a democracy?" Oh, so the Canadian government of 1917 was illegal. All the minority governments were illegal. The government of Israel is illegal. If that's true, then Harper has committed us to go to war in defense of an illegal government. I shall have to alert B"Nai Brith.
It's not possible that a prime minister of Canada would not know all this. He has to be lying. We also know that he proposed a coalition to the Bloc. He lied about that, too.
But let's not waste time stating the obvious.
The important thing to do is to read the editorial that is on a level of ignorance, lying, ranting that is surely unacceptable even in one of Canada's smallest cities. Look at the editorial cartoon that assumes we enjoy seeing a "me too" suck up to a bully.
Then read "Bill" Belliveau's column to see what an intelligent commentary looks like.
(No, I don't always agree with Belliveau. But I respect him as a person worth arguing with. And I respect him for his independence.)
The editorial, itself, follows the Harper formula for the election. It's an attack ad. There is no mention of any major issue, no mention of any policy except for one item in the Liberal platform - subsidized day care.
Nor is there any attempt at balance. Not a single reason is given in favour of it And the editorial writer is personally insulting to millions of Canadians.
I am no admirer of Ignatieff. I have only nce voted Liberal in my life -and that was because the candidate was a friend who I greatly admire for his abilities and his social conscience. According the the editorial writer, daycare is a subsidy for two-income Yuppies driving expensive SUVs in Canada's biggest cities.
Dear editor, you supercilious, sneering, servile ass...How about those two-income families that work at minimum wage in Walmart or gas stations, or fast food outlets and all the other cheapy jobs which are found in the biggest cities and the smallest villages right across Canada. What about those millions of two-income families who can't even afford their basic needs, and can be fired at a moment's notice?
Have you ever lived like that? You who spends his life wiping the boss' nose with your bare hands?
I grew up in a two-income family in one of Canada's biggest cities. We didn't have an SUV. We had no car at all until we got rich and could afford a used one when I was sixteen. When his employer cut his salary, my father shoveled snow at less than a dollar a day. My mother worked for the same low wages doing manual work at a big newspaper edited by flunkies like you. (Until we started school, my mother stayed home. But that meant we had to hope my father got lucky at the charity food dispensary.)
There's plenty of poverty in Moncton, Dieppe and Riverview And you have insulted everyone who is poor or who has any sense of decency. Ignatieff is out of touch with the real world? I don't doubt he his But you are scarcely the one to say so.
When you think, if you think, imagine a world without two-family incomes. All mothers would have to stay home. So we could all say goodbye to much of the underpaid commercial staff who make shopping so cheap for us. We would have to close down half of our schools (and you probably think that would be a good idea.) Our hospitals would cease to function. So would most of our restaurants. Even for those above the poverty level, they need two salaries to support the casinos, hockey teams, football teams, extra booze , and expensive SUVs that your paper daily urges on us.
You hypocritic lout! You probably know that we subsidize energy costs for billionaires, we subidize the oil sands project, you want to subsidize the hockey team (owned by guess who), we subsidize a wide range or rich people for billions of dollars per year. Meanwhile, we also subsidize the rich my letting them off taxes. But God forbid we should subsidize chldren.
It is really quite impossible to express the contempt you deserve.
You remind me of the poen by Alexander Pope who was a frequent visitor to the king of England's residence of the time in a village called Kew. There he was disgusted by the noble flunkies who spent their day flattering the king and publcly making a fuss and saying "who's 'ittle dog are you?" to the pet dog that the king adored. So Pope engraved on the dog's collar;
I am His Highness' dog at Kew.
Pray tell me, sir,
Who's dog are you?
I urge readers and the editor to read the editorial "Out of Touch with Canadians". Then read the commentary next to to it, "Hypocrisies of electioneering" by (Bill) Belliveau. It is reasoned and offers evidence for its claims. It is unbiased, It does not make hysterical rantings.
It is also well-researched, including points that should have appeared in the news stories of The Moncton Times and Transcript but, like most real news items, never made them.
I was surprised to read that Harper actually said, "Only the party with the most seats can form a government in a democracy?" Oh, so the Canadian government of 1917 was illegal. All the minority governments were illegal. The government of Israel is illegal. If that's true, then Harper has committed us to go to war in defense of an illegal government. I shall have to alert B"Nai Brith.
It's not possible that a prime minister of Canada would not know all this. He has to be lying. We also know that he proposed a coalition to the Bloc. He lied about that, too.
But let's not waste time stating the obvious.
The important thing to do is to read the editorial that is on a level of ignorance, lying, ranting that is surely unacceptable even in one of Canada's smallest cities. Look at the editorial cartoon that assumes we enjoy seeing a "me too" suck up to a bully.
Then read "Bill" Belliveau's column to see what an intelligent commentary looks like.
(No, I don't always agree with Belliveau. But I respect him as a person worth arguing with. And I respect him for his independence.)
Friday, April 1, 2011
April 1: I wish I could agree....
"Stop complaining and taste what's on the political menu!" says the header on today's op ed page of The Moncton Time and Transcript. Lynda McGibbon, the writer, is a good writer. I wish I could agree with her this time. I really do. but I can't.
She compares an election to a sort of smorgasbord of tasty delights. I wish it were. I wish I could urge people to read the menu. I wish I could say I'm proud of Canadian democracy. But none of that is possible.
The smorgasbord has some tasty delights, I'm sure. It also has some fatal poisons. And the menu (our news media), give us no indication which is which.
For example, Harper intends to cut subisidies for political parties. Sound like a sensible measure? It's not. Putting parties on their own to raise all their money is a guarantee that the only parties ever to win another Canadian election will be parties financed as agents of corporations. They will be the only source, and we shall forever be governed by a Liberal Pary which is not Liberal, or a Conservative Party which is not conservative.
American democracy ceased to exist in any real sense years ago. President Obama is pretty much like President Bush because both have been finannced by the same billionaires. The same is true of the whole congress. There's a reason why the US government spent perhaps a trillion dollars to bail out bankers and other investors who pulled a monster scam by deliberately creating a housing bubble. There's a reason why they are not showing no rush to help the people who lost their homes, or the unemployed. There's a reason why the poverty gap in the US, growing for years, is now the biggest in the developed world.
Canada is going the same way. We don't elect governments. It's partly because we don't have enough information to do so. We just had a provincial election with no serious debate. The big parties didn't even have something that looked like a platform. One of them one, anyway. Of course. They're the only ones who have money. Guess where they get it. Guess who they really represent.
The same is true for most of Canada. The Conservatives are rolling in money. Guess where it comes from. Guess who the Conservatives govern for. (Hint -the same people the liberals government for.) Guess how much easier it will all be if we stop giving third parties at least a chance to get their message out. '
Who do you think will tell us about new parties or about parties that don't have enough money to buy the PR needed for a showing in an election? The Moncton Times and Tribune? Get real. Indeed, you won't find it in private newspapers, radio or TV anywhere in Canada. You might catch a bit on CBC; but it's pretty much muzzled by fear of Harper doing away with the system.
There are issues, very serious ones, that should be issues in this campaign. The severe limitations and the decline of Canadian democracy are serious issues. The dramatic crash in Canada's reputation around the world over the past decade or so has been stunning. From our international role to our human rights record to our very humble servitude to US policies, we have almost no international respect left. Nor do we deserve it. The gap between rich an poor in Canada is growing almost as fast as the one in the US.
Our military has been rebuilt to be nothing more than an auxiliary to the American military - which is now almost equally made up of serving Americans, and hired mercenaries from all over the gutters of the world.
When, recently, an American murdered two Pakistanis in public, the US paid a large sum of money and put on other pressure to get him out - though there was no legal basis to let him return to the US. When the US captures or kidnaps Canadian citizens, Canada doesn't say a word. In fact, the federal police assist the US in the kidnapping and, when the Canadian is sent to a foreign country for torture, the CSIS goes along to help out the torturers. When a Canadian juvenile was captured and imprisoned at Guantanamo Bay (illegally), Canada said nothing. It continued to say nothing through years of torture and they trial by an illegally military court, illegally using testimoney obtained by torture. Canada has the shame of being the only country with a national captured in Afghanistan to do nothing whatever for its own citizen. (Oh, I know. You think the kid should rot in jail. let me know when it's your turn.)
Yeah. I'm real proud to be a Canadian.
If we're going to be a democracy, we need to know what's going on. We need honest news media. Media with brains would be a big help, too. We need to develop politicians, real ones, not just the hired hacks of corporations. It's never been easy to get political ideas off the ground without having big money. Harper plans to make it impossible.
Why did 40% of Canadians not vote the last time around? It's probably largely because of what I wrote above. And it's a pattern you can see in most western democracies. When George Bush first got elected president, he did it with the votes of something like 30% of the total American electorate.
I'm sorry to say it. But a Canadian election is not a smorgasbord of taste treats. It's a pig's wallow. We don't have the luxury of a democracy. Who will win elections in this country is decided by a handful of multimillionaires and billionaires, and by the newspapers and radio and TV stations they own.
You can make kids in school sing O Canada till they turn blue. It won't stop the cancers of our servility to big business and the US. It won't stop the steady growth of poverty we're watching, or the looting of both Canada and the US by a few hundred families.
I'll be happy someday to sing about a true north strong and free. But I'll wait until I see it.
P.S. Once again, Harper is in town on a campaign swing. Ever notice he never says it's mice to be back in the province his parents came from? Ever notice the news media never mention it? Ever notice we never hear of him visiting his parent's old home in Port Elgin, or perhaps drop in on the development called Harper Heights? (actually, there are no heights. it's dead flat - something like the Liberal and Conservative parties.)
Why doesn't he mention somethiing that could be worth more than a few votes in NB?
One possibility seems obvious. He's an arrogant snob. He doesn't want it generally known where his family comes from.
She compares an election to a sort of smorgasbord of tasty delights. I wish it were. I wish I could urge people to read the menu. I wish I could say I'm proud of Canadian democracy. But none of that is possible.
The smorgasbord has some tasty delights, I'm sure. It also has some fatal poisons. And the menu (our news media), give us no indication which is which.
For example, Harper intends to cut subisidies for political parties. Sound like a sensible measure? It's not. Putting parties on their own to raise all their money is a guarantee that the only parties ever to win another Canadian election will be parties financed as agents of corporations. They will be the only source, and we shall forever be governed by a Liberal Pary which is not Liberal, or a Conservative Party which is not conservative.
American democracy ceased to exist in any real sense years ago. President Obama is pretty much like President Bush because both have been finannced by the same billionaires. The same is true of the whole congress. There's a reason why the US government spent perhaps a trillion dollars to bail out bankers and other investors who pulled a monster scam by deliberately creating a housing bubble. There's a reason why they are not showing no rush to help the people who lost their homes, or the unemployed. There's a reason why the poverty gap in the US, growing for years, is now the biggest in the developed world.
Canada is going the same way. We don't elect governments. It's partly because we don't have enough information to do so. We just had a provincial election with no serious debate. The big parties didn't even have something that looked like a platform. One of them one, anyway. Of course. They're the only ones who have money. Guess where they get it. Guess who they really represent.
The same is true for most of Canada. The Conservatives are rolling in money. Guess where it comes from. Guess who the Conservatives govern for. (Hint -the same people the liberals government for.) Guess how much easier it will all be if we stop giving third parties at least a chance to get their message out. '
Who do you think will tell us about new parties or about parties that don't have enough money to buy the PR needed for a showing in an election? The Moncton Times and Tribune? Get real. Indeed, you won't find it in private newspapers, radio or TV anywhere in Canada. You might catch a bit on CBC; but it's pretty much muzzled by fear of Harper doing away with the system.
There are issues, very serious ones, that should be issues in this campaign. The severe limitations and the decline of Canadian democracy are serious issues. The dramatic crash in Canada's reputation around the world over the past decade or so has been stunning. From our international role to our human rights record to our very humble servitude to US policies, we have almost no international respect left. Nor do we deserve it. The gap between rich an poor in Canada is growing almost as fast as the one in the US.
Our military has been rebuilt to be nothing more than an auxiliary to the American military - which is now almost equally made up of serving Americans, and hired mercenaries from all over the gutters of the world.
When, recently, an American murdered two Pakistanis in public, the US paid a large sum of money and put on other pressure to get him out - though there was no legal basis to let him return to the US. When the US captures or kidnaps Canadian citizens, Canada doesn't say a word. In fact, the federal police assist the US in the kidnapping and, when the Canadian is sent to a foreign country for torture, the CSIS goes along to help out the torturers. When a Canadian juvenile was captured and imprisoned at Guantanamo Bay (illegally), Canada said nothing. It continued to say nothing through years of torture and they trial by an illegally military court, illegally using testimoney obtained by torture. Canada has the shame of being the only country with a national captured in Afghanistan to do nothing whatever for its own citizen. (Oh, I know. You think the kid should rot in jail. let me know when it's your turn.)
Yeah. I'm real proud to be a Canadian.
If we're going to be a democracy, we need to know what's going on. We need honest news media. Media with brains would be a big help, too. We need to develop politicians, real ones, not just the hired hacks of corporations. It's never been easy to get political ideas off the ground without having big money. Harper plans to make it impossible.
Why did 40% of Canadians not vote the last time around? It's probably largely because of what I wrote above. And it's a pattern you can see in most western democracies. When George Bush first got elected president, he did it with the votes of something like 30% of the total American electorate.
I'm sorry to say it. But a Canadian election is not a smorgasbord of taste treats. It's a pig's wallow. We don't have the luxury of a democracy. Who will win elections in this country is decided by a handful of multimillionaires and billionaires, and by the newspapers and radio and TV stations they own.
You can make kids in school sing O Canada till they turn blue. It won't stop the cancers of our servility to big business and the US. It won't stop the steady growth of poverty we're watching, or the looting of both Canada and the US by a few hundred families.
I'll be happy someday to sing about a true north strong and free. But I'll wait until I see it.
P.S. Once again, Harper is in town on a campaign swing. Ever notice he never says it's mice to be back in the province his parents came from? Ever notice the news media never mention it? Ever notice we never hear of him visiting his parent's old home in Port Elgin, or perhaps drop in on the development called Harper Heights? (actually, there are no heights. it's dead flat - something like the Liberal and Conservative parties.)
Why doesn't he mention somethiing that could be worth more than a few votes in NB?
One possibility seems obvious. He's an arrogant snob. He doesn't want it generally known where his family comes from.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)