Wednesday, March 23, 2011

March 22: ..Far called, our armies melt away...

A hush has descended on New Brunswick. We have our budget. It's exactly what we might have expected. Large corporations have been exempted from feeling any of the pain at all - just like the American banks who drove the US into recession, then got rewarded with tax cuts and tax payer dollars.

At no point is there any sign of an examination of exactly what has caused our recession. That's like a doctor doing heart surgery without first finding out if there's anything wrong with the heart.

On of the very few experts quoted said it was good to hold the line on taxes. But the budget didn't hold the line on taxes -and it most particularly did not hold the line for anybody making less than a hundred thousand or so a year. If there is a tax on cigarettes, for example, the poor will pay exactly the same tax as the rich. If the rich should become sinful, then,  and decide to take up smoking, the tax is meaningless. But we must save the poor from sinning. That's the trouble with any flat tax. it increases the already huge gap between the very rich and the other ninety-nine percent of us.

Captialism is very good at creating wealth. It is lousy at sharing it. A flat tax, one in which we all pay no matter what our means is not only unfair and harder on the poor, it also contributes to what destroys many societies - too much money and power held by too few at the top who have too much greed and self-interest. That destroys the fabric of a society, with the results we are now seeing in Egypt and Libya. Canada and the US are both far out of line in their distribution of wealth, with both getting worse every year.

The expert consulted on this doesn't see it. That's because he's an accountant. For example, he does not see the rise in the post-secondary costs as a tax because it isn't called one. But the end result is that those who need an education will have to pay more. Minus 200 a year is a tax, by whatever name you may call it. And it's a tax that makes no difference to the rich - but is a death blow to the ambitions of many of the poor and the middle class.

Simlarly, a slight increase in education budget is not "holding the line" when the budget was far below needs in the first place. Again, it won't bother the rich, who send their children to private schools. But it will certainly harm the rest of us.

Worse, there has been no discussion about what caused the deficit - except for rants about civil servants and unions.  The attitude of the government (which is why corporations finance the major parties) is to make us think that corporations come here only to fling tons of loonies at us. In fact, their main purpose is to take tons of loonies out - and with all the freebies they can get from the governments on their way through.

Well, a brief peace. But we will soon hear more about unions, civil servants and other forms of acne. The real game is 1. get people to accept the budget as a reasonable one - and The Moncton Times did what it was told to do. 2. To cut down on civil servants so the government has to contract out as much as possible to private busines. 3. To revamp the civil service so it will work on the model of a private corporation. You know - like those great corporations that caused the world economic crisis. 4. To break unions in general. That way, the corporations can get rid of silly ideas like mimimum wages, pension plans, health insurance,...

An exaggeration? Not al all. That's what happened all over the western world in the 1930s. We've been here before. Many times.
..................................................................................................................................
As usual, the editorial page has a commentary by a "Fellow" of a far right "think-thank", this time the MacDonald-Laurier Institute. Mr.Wilner talks about counter-terrorism, a subject of which he clearly knows nothing.
1. He recommends deterrence (stiff penalties for terrorism). Brilliant -except when was there a time in human history when we did not use deterrence against terrorists? Didn't he hear Bush's speech on why he bombed and then invaded Afghanistan? (Incidentally, Bush was lying. US officials have long ago admitted publicy they have no reason to believe the Taliban had anything to do with 9/11).

2. He advocates attacks on every govenment that harbours terrorists. That would be interesting. Is he aware that the US has sponsored and provided refuge for terrorists it hired to set bombs and kill people in Cuba? Is he aware the US government sponsored a massacre of 200,000 Maya in Guatemala? Whole families? And that Clinton publicly apologized for it? Is he aware that the US bombed cities in Cambodia, deliberately killing a half million civilians? Does he know that Israel was founded by terrorists? Has he never heard of the Stern gang or Irgun?

3. We should also deny terrorists access to targets. What? Are we just letting them in now? Do we put up signs with an arrow and the words "this way to bomb targets"?

 4.Talk to the community the terrorists come from and convince them terrorism is against their religion. Right. It's also against any  major religion I can think of. And terrorism has been practiced by countries of every religion I can think of.

Wilner does not seem to have heard of a point 5 which was been proposed by the British military some sixty years ago. Stop creating terrists in the first place. Give a clear indication to the people we are there to help them - and so try to avoid making a bad impression by killing them.

He might also give some thought to a point 6. Stop putting dictators into power (like "the royal family of Saudi Arabia, the "president" of Egypt. Stopping using such dictators (like Ghadaffi in Libya) to impoverish the people of the country while western oil and mining companies rip off their resources and pollute their land.

I taught a course on military history for some years. This is without question the most childish writing on the subject I have even seen. Editors of military journals would burst into helpless laughter just at the headline "Deterrence making a comeback in counter-terrorism".

Only in The Moncton Times&Transcript. And probably The Gleaner and the Telegraph..

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

march 21: same old, same old...

The Moncton Times Standard did the same propaganda hack job for its fourth report (attack) on NB civil servants and unions. Who are they writing it for? It certainly isn't for Premier Alward or his Minister of Finance. They both had their marching orders before the budget even came up for public discussion. These are two dogs who know their master.

They're writing the reports for you. They want to kill any criticism of the budget because it's the kind of budget corporations want. (which suggests that one editor, at least, must have been improperly informed about some contents of the budget.)

As usual, the report has a front page headline about the horrors of the civil service followed by a dash - and then the word "experts". As usual, the"experts" were chosen by the editors. It reminds me of my working days in China when I would wake up to news from The New China News Agency

There really isn't much of anything in this final "report". Well, it does have a touch of accidental humour. One of the "experts" says that if the civil service grows at the rate it has since 1990, it will reach 63,000 by the year. Wow! I have a kitten that has doubled its size in the past year. That means that if it continues growing at that rate, it will need the hockey arena to hold it by 2300. Something to think about.

other points....
1. the top headline is that a business group has rasied 2.5 million for a an events centre  (which will cost far more that will\ have to come out of tax money, the same tax money we save by cutting the civil service and lose by lowering taxes on corporations.)

Well, the business group hasn't actually raised the money, though the headline and the first two paragraphs give the impression they have. They've promised to raise it.

The story doesn't doesn't say so but, since the cost is estimated at 72 million dollars, that probably includes the hockey rink. So, New Brunswick can't possibly maintain its present education budget or its government services - but $72 mil for a hockey rink and convention centre. No problemo.

2, The editorial is the usual piece of self-righeous dim-wittedness. The WE SAY of this one, though, is hilarious."We must legislate a solution to public sector growth and greed." (The greed, it seems, refers to unions.)

Tell you what (Mr Cunningham?). See if you can develop the courage, professionalism and integrity to write a column on a legislative solution to private sector growth and greed. Have the integrity to examine just how much the the private sector takes from this province compared to what it gives back.

3.Viktor Pivarov, a photographer at the T&T got nominated for a national award for an excellent picture he got -one that took some courage as well as being on the spot. But read how the news is presented. It's at the bottom of the page with a big picture which I learned, to my relief, was not the nominated photo but a picture of somebody named Robert Warner who wrote the story.

Usually, a news story begins with a statement of what the news is. This one begins as the life story of Robert Warner (I have no idea why),then becomes a hymn of praise for New Brunswick's anglo newspapers. Victor Pivarov doesn't get a mention until paragraph seven. The rest of the story returns to the theme of the superb quality of the Irving press.

Get used to it, Pikarov. All news media work that way. I've won a half dozen or so awards for best of the year for Central Canada and for Canada as a whole for editorials on radio, and commentaries in print. I never even got to touch the awards. They were sent to the radio station or the newspaper with only the name of the media company on the award. The only way I could tell they were for me was the title of the winning item. In all cases, the award was to the station or the newspaper -and those awards still hang on their walls. I never got them.

Any time it was mentioned by the newspaper or radio station, it was always to show what a high class act THEY were. That's why the article by Robert Warner talks mostly about him and the Irving press. That's why the picture on the front page is of Robert Warner, and not of you or of the great picture you took.

Get used to it in the world of journalism.
.

Monday, March 21, 2011

March21: A new low for The Moncton Times&Tribune

    The heanline on the front page is  "Rise of union power fuels wage gap."

1. This is not, in fact, what the story says. Much of it comes from interviewees chosen by the newspaper who spin the usual propaganda line of the The Moncton Times. But there are also interviews with well-qualified scholars from New Brunswick's universities who disagree. (However, their comments are hidden well down in the story because editors know few readers go that far.)

2. "Wage gap" is a term with emotional punch because it is usually used to describe the huge gap between the very rich few and the poorer rest of us. Here is it designed to take our attention away from the rich entirely, and pretend that people who get decent salaries are the very rich.

It's the same stunt that was pulled in criticizing Moncton works who got raises of something over 2% a week, while ingnoring years of increases by corporate executives or 10% or a hundred percent or even more a year. (Meanwhile, the middle class and the poor in Canada and the US have actually been getting poorer.)

In fact, for a really interesting report on real wage gap, The Moncton Times should have published the cost to us (Yes, us. All money comes from the same place.) of corporate executives. It would have to count wages, bonusses, paid golf club memberships, meals at lush restaurants, free interest on mortgage payments, lavish separation benefits.... Perhaps it might also include years of tax cuts for the rich since that's a loss the rest of us have to pay for from our taxes and from cuts in services.

3. The sub head of the "story" is "Experts say salaries, benefits of public sector employees need to be reined in."   In fact, some of the experts (the ones hidden at the bottom of the "report") did not say that at all. That sub-head is a blatant lie.

4. On page A4, there is a chart which claims to give a picture of public and private sector pay scales. In fact, it shows two ways to use charts to give a false impression
A bar for each year since 1998 shows private and public sector wages. The lower part, in light blue, is private sector. The upper part is darker blue. Making the public sector darker and placing it on top as a extension of the private sector bar make the difference look more prominent and greater than it really is.
(I remember learning that somewhere around grade six.) And it may be even more misleading than it seems.

We are told the comparison is of average salaries in both sectors. That assumes a perfectly matching set of requirements for skills, labour and reponsibilites in both sectors. But there is no evidence to show that there is such a matching set.

Finally, the "report" does not even consider another possibility - that corporations may be responsible for this wage gap which may or may not exist. It is possible, even likely, that corporations have been more successful in cutting out unions so that greedy bosses can have more money for their million dollar bonuses and golf club memberships.

That would suggest that it is corporations, not unions, that have too much power in New Brunswick. After all, can you imagine a minimum wage Walmart employee declaring himself a member of the government - without bothering to get elected? Mr. Irving did it.

This will be an interesting budget, with good news for millionaires and bad news for the rest of us, for The Moncton Times to make so much effort to ensure we cheer at the prospect of getting ripped off to make the rich even richer.

Saturday, March 19, 2011

March 19:The Moncton T&T is playing its usual game.

The Monton times produced its second report on the "problem" of the civil service. This time, it is an interview with Donald Savoie of U do Moncton. Savoie certainly does have a distinguished reputation - particularly among neo-conservatives and industrialists.  He is a longtime friend and admirer of the Irving family and its interests. I am happy to see a deserving family get all the friendship and admiration that is lavished on them. But it does give a hint that Donald Savoie is not what one might call an independent.

In his interview, Professor Savoie comes down hard on the civil service of New Brnswick. In particular, he says its bureaucracy is the real power in the province; and that is the real problem that must be addressed.

And that is such nonsense that only a professor could take it seriously. If he can keep up the writing nonsense like that, he'll become a university president and get the Order of Canada in no time.

Civil service bureaucrats do not appoint themselves. If they did, I would certainly join in the attack on them. But they don't appoint themselves. Politicians appoint them. Politicians also have the power to overrule them, fire them, demote them. Doesn't that suggest we should be looking at the politicians as the source of at least part of our problem?

The politicians of New Brunswick are themselves the products of two forces.

One force is the failure of most of the news media in this province to tell the truth. Instead, they publish propaganda lightened by trivia. All the English papers are owned by one family which also has a strong interest in who gets into power. How can the public make a sensible choice on the basis of that?

It costs money to get elected. It costs so much that most of it comes from private sources. And that means the most of it is not be be found in the ten dollar bills we peasants have to spare. Most of it comes from the wealthy and large corporations. And that goes to the Liberals and Conservatives - two parties that give no indication of even understanding the words liberal and conservative. Both understand, though, the importance of money, and of keeping big donors happy.

That might help to explain Awlard's choice of Minister of Finance. Yep. Premier Alward listens to people. It's just that he listens to some peoplle more than others.

If bureaucrats have too much power, the problem does not start with the civil service. It starts with biased and servile journalists, with politicians bankrupt of  political ethics and of any political philosophy, and as servile as The Moncton Times is.

Yes, there is a problem with the civil service, Professor Savoie. But it isn't caused by civil servants. It's caused because politicians, press and voters all bow to where the real problem lies - the monopoly of power and influence by a very tiny group of people who are not elected.

The problem is that New Brunswick is a "just pretend" democracy. And you are its most distinguished "just pretend" expert.

Friday, March 18, 2011

March 18: Propaganda as news that treats as readers as brainless

The Moncton T&T has just begun a new series of economic "studies" on the NB budget. It's all about the faults of the civil service and the unions. That seems odd. If you study a problem, don't you begin by looking at all the elements in the problem? How can one decide the cause of a crisis without looking at business practice, for example, or political corruption, or the impact of big spending on elections?

And shouldn't a sober study of the subject  avoid emotionally evocative words like "worst crisis", "soaring" and inexorable?"

And when we're looking for information, shouldn't we look at other sources besides big business propaganda agencies like AIMS, Canadian Taxpayers' Federation, and The Frontier Insitute?

There is a particularly cheap shot at Moncton workers who got 2.75% raise a year. Did the reporter bother to ask about the incredible rises of pay and bonuses, sometimes at hundreds of percentage points a year - and for companies that are being driven broke - but will be okay because our "nanny" governments step in to bail them out with low interest loans, grants, low electricity rates and other goodies?

How much is the growth in the public service is there to serve big business?

There is a very sensible comment by Professor Hudon of the department of Public Administration at U. de Moncton. But it is so deep in the story that few people will ever read that far. And editors know that.

And if anybody at The Moncton Times and Transcript knows poop about economics, why was the paper campaigning to borrow even more millions for a hockey rink and a CFL franchise just weeks ago?

Then, a reporter, writes two, full pages on an interview with the Minister of Finance,

Then there is a massive two-page interview with Blaine Higgs, and with no fewer than five pictures of him. Now, I admire Mr. Higgs' face as much as all New Brunswickers do. But I think I can get the idea with one picture.

And Mr. Higgs has spent his life as an executive with Irving's. Wow! What a concidence! Is that the same Irving's that owns the The Moncton Times and Transcript and the Fredericton Gleaner and the St. John Telegraph?

In that whole two pages Mr. Higgs says close to nothing. He's encouraged to because the reporter asks close to nothing. Here's a sample passage.
"T&T: "...with a wife and four daughters, I wonder how you manage to adjust the household testosterone level. I am permitted a tom-cat for the household pet."
B:H: "I have a male dog. but he likes his wife more than me.
T&T: "Ha! Are the children all grown up, and are any living in New Brunswick?"

And there's much more. All of it just as good. Look for the part about how much Mr. Higgs enjoyed holidaying in Hawaii and going on an African safari.  Then ask yourself - How many Moncton city workers get to spend holidays in Hawaii and to go on African safaris?  And did Mr. Higgs average less than 2.75%  a year in pay raises?

Very, very few are going to read all this drivel. Editors know that very well. This is not a study of the civil service at all. It is a study in how the editors of TheMoncton Times twist propaganda so it looks like news. A quick read of bits of this will produce what the editors want - a public pushed toward panic at a time of crisis - and a public that believes the whole problem is caused by the civil service and by unions. This has nothing to do with informing the public. It was everything to do with protecting private corporations from paying their share. When we cut budgets for our children's education, or for social help, or for medical care, we aren't harming the families of billionaires or even millionaires. We, who built these corporations, often with our tax money and low wages, are the ones to suffer.

If the Moncton Times and Transcript wanted to do a real study of the causes of this crisis, it would do a study of how much corporations cost us in grants, gifts,subsidies, insider contracts. What is the average annual pay raise plus bonusses for a senior corporate executive? How quickly has that been going up in the last quarter century? If we were getting good service from them at their old payrates, why is it necessary to pay so much more now?

But I don't think testosterone levels at The Moncton Times and Transcript are anywhere close to being enough for the challenge.

And this godawful crap is just the beginning of a four part series.

Thursday, March 17, 2011

March 16: columns tied - one good and one bad.

I should explain where I started from on the issue of feminism.

When I became a university teacher, the feminist move was past the trot and moving to the charge among women professors. I was on their side though, truth to tell, I found them more than a little self-righteous.

One year, when I was department chairman, I had a senior (male) professor who, despite repeated warnings, bullied a young secretary into a nervour breakdown, pretty effectively destroying her life. I demanded  the dean (a woman and an ardent feminist) discipline the professor severely, and that the secretary be offered all help and support possible.

What I got was endless hearings and meetings that went on with no action for months. As it went on, I wondered, "Where the hell are all those feminists who  had been swaggering the halls for the last dozen years?" Then I realized a truth that should have been obvious. When they spoke of feminine equality, they meant it for feminist professors, not for the lower classes like secretaries.

The bad column on the subject today is at the bottom of the editorial page. It's from Troy Media, of course. The only women the writer (Catherine Ford)   appears to know are career women like herself. (She also trumpets her concern for third world women - of whom she seems to know none at all.) But that's okay. They're far away, so she can just send the odd donation, and feel good playing fairy godmother.

For contrast, turn to a superb column on the next page by Elsie Hambrook. She points out that for a great many women right here in Canada, the feminist crusade did nothing at all - notably nothing for women who were native peoples or poor or victims within the criminal world. Elsie Hambrook shows an awareness of all women, and what it is they have to deal with.

The Troy Media writer, like so many womren professors I worked with knows only her own, seemingly priviliged, class.

Elsie Hambrook is worth following.

Troy Media is just schlock.

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

March 16: A disgusting and ignorant editorial - but now I think I know who writes that type.

"Higher taxation harms economy"  shouts the head of the editorial. And it's all them there nanny social programmes. I've rarely seen a headline so disgusting on an editorial so reeking of ignorance of economics and even obvious facts and well known history.

This is meant, of course, to build up support for a budget that will let the rich off the hook again. And it gives the usual reason. It's private capital that creates wealth.

Well, yes, private capital can be very good at creating wealth - for the rich. But it does a terrible job of distributing wealth across the society. That's why the whole world is now in an economic crisis.

Check out Guatemala, Haiti, Congo, Ivory Coast, Egypt. What do they all have in common? Low taxes on corporations and wealthy people -and dreadful poverty for most people. Haiti has been living under a very pure form of capitalism with almost no taxes or regulations for the whole century it has been under American control. The result? It is the poorest country in the western hemisphere.

Check out the US ever since St. Ronald Regan began lowering taxes for the rich and de-regulation of big business. Lots of wealth has been produced - at the top. But there has also developed an enormous gap between a small number of very rich and hundreds of millions of poor.

There are now just one hundred supremely wealthy families in the US. They have more wealth than over 300,000,000 Americans all put together. That's a major reason why the US is in recession - and shows no sign of coming out of it. Wealthy Americans have looted their own country. The result is that many millions of people cannot earn enough to buy their products. That only way out of our crisis is to distribute wealth, not to give even more to the rich.

Canada has gone much the same route with a gap between a few rich and millions of poor so great that it will soon rival the US. The world is in an economic crisis? Good. This is a great time to go into the whole to for thirty billion or more for a handful of fighter planes that are of no use to defend Canada? (Also a great time to borrow money for a hockey rink and a CFL franchise.)

What is also happening now is that wealthy Americans have so thoroughly looted their own country, they are runniing out of places to invest their money. Thus the crisis. Why did they do that. Are they crazy?

No. They aren't crazy They're arrogant. They're greedy. And they can buy news media and politicians to spread their absurd ideas. Capitalism is destroying itself just as communism destroyed itself. That's what much of the violence in the middle east is about. Too many people have been exploited for too long by western corporations and their hired "kings" and "presidents". It might well happen here, too.

If it comes here, it will likely come in the form of a fascism combined with some variation of racism. Many of the signs of that are already showing.

Look - of course rich people play a role in creating wealth. But an even bigger part is played by the rest of us. Britain got rich in the industrial revolution because of appallingly cheap labour in Britain, and some of the worst living conditions on record. It also got rich by killing Boers in South Africa, and killing, torturing and using as cheap labour Blacks and Orientals all over the world.The capital that British corporations invested to build early twentieth century Canada came largely from gold, diamonds, farmland, oil looted from all over the world. It grew poppies on estates stolen from India, then forced China to buy a mimimum tonnage of it each year. That same pattern has been followed by the US, France, Belgium.

 New Brunswick has been built largely by its own people whose governments gave away or sold their forests at bargain prices, who loaned money to the rich at low rates, who guaranteed their bonds, and who paid to subsidize electricity for corporations. Oh, and who often had to work for very low wages.

Capitalism has done something to develop New Brunswick. It also took out a hell of a lot more than it put in.

I don't favour any economic system - capitalist, socialist, communist - in its pure form. All of them, in that pure form, will break down under human greed and corruption and stupidity. As in everything else, there has to be a balance of many elements within any successful economy; and that balance has to change as conditions change.

The editorial is right on only one point. New Brunswick has a nanny government. And that is a problem because it nannies the rich while doing very little for the common good.

The world is facing a crisis probably beyond our ability to understand. Societies are falling apart. The American empire and its economy are collapsing. New Brunswick is not immune to what is happening to the whole world. If we're to survive, we have to act in the interests of our whole society, not just those of the richest families. And time is very short.

But the editorial writer is on safe ground. The budget almost certainly will benefit the rich and punish the rest or us. But, at least, it's now possible from style and choice of words to figure out who writes these shameless editorials.

My guess, and I suggest it with regret, is Norbert Cunningham.