The Moncton T&T has just begun a new series of economic "studies" on the NB budget. It's all about the faults of the civil service and the unions. That seems odd. If you study a problem, don't you begin by looking at all the elements in the problem? How can one decide the cause of a crisis without looking at business practice, for example, or political corruption, or the impact of big spending on elections?
And shouldn't a sober study of the subject avoid emotionally evocative words like "worst crisis", "soaring" and inexorable?"
And when we're looking for information, shouldn't we look at other sources besides big business propaganda agencies like AIMS, Canadian Taxpayers' Federation, and The Frontier Insitute?
There is a particularly cheap shot at Moncton workers who got 2.75% raise a year. Did the reporter bother to ask about the incredible rises of pay and bonuses, sometimes at hundreds of percentage points a year - and for companies that are being driven broke - but will be okay because our "nanny" governments step in to bail them out with low interest loans, grants, low electricity rates and other goodies?
How much is the growth in the public service is there to serve big business?
There is a very sensible comment by Professor Hudon of the department of Public Administration at U. de Moncton. But it is so deep in the story that few people will ever read that far. And editors know that.
And if anybody at The Moncton Times and Transcript knows poop about economics, why was the paper campaigning to borrow even more millions for a hockey rink and a CFL franchise just weeks ago?
Then, a reporter, writes two, full pages on an interview with the Minister of Finance,
Then there is a massive two-page interview with Blaine Higgs, and with no fewer than five pictures of him. Now, I admire Mr. Higgs' face as much as all New Brunswickers do. But I think I can get the idea with one picture.
And Mr. Higgs has spent his life as an executive with Irving's. Wow! What a concidence! Is that the same Irving's that owns the The Moncton Times and Transcript and the Fredericton Gleaner and the St. John Telegraph?
In that whole two pages Mr. Higgs says close to nothing. He's encouraged to because the reporter asks close to nothing. Here's a sample passage.
"T&T: "...with a wife and four daughters, I wonder how you manage to adjust the household testosterone level. I am permitted a tom-cat for the household pet."
B:H: "I have a male dog. but he likes his wife more than me.
T&T: "Ha! Are the children all grown up, and are any living in New Brunswick?"
And there's much more. All of it just as good. Look for the part about how much Mr. Higgs enjoyed holidaying in Hawaii and going on an African safari. Then ask yourself - How many Moncton city workers get to spend holidays in Hawaii and to go on African safaris? And did Mr. Higgs average less than 2.75% a year in pay raises?
Very, very few are going to read all this drivel. Editors know that very well. This is not a study of the civil service at all. It is a study in how the editors of TheMoncton Times twist propaganda so it looks like news. A quick read of bits of this will produce what the editors want - a public pushed toward panic at a time of crisis - and a public that believes the whole problem is caused by the civil service and by unions. This has nothing to do with informing the public. It was everything to do with protecting private corporations from paying their share. When we cut budgets for our children's education, or for social help, or for medical care, we aren't harming the families of billionaires or even millionaires. We, who built these corporations, often with our tax money and low wages, are the ones to suffer.
If the Moncton Times and Transcript wanted to do a real study of the causes of this crisis, it would do a study of how much corporations cost us in grants, gifts,subsidies, insider contracts. What is the average annual pay raise plus bonusses for a senior corporate executive? How quickly has that been going up in the last quarter century? If we were getting good service from them at their old payrates, why is it necessary to pay so much more now?
But I don't think testosterone levels at The Moncton Times and Transcript are anywhere close to being enough for the challenge.
And this godawful crap is just the beginning of a four part series.
A critical review of local and world news. This blog originally commented on the Moncton Times and Transcript but has enlarged its scope.
Friday, March 18, 2011
Thursday, March 17, 2011
March 16: columns tied - one good and one bad.
I should explain where I started from on the issue of feminism.
When I became a university teacher, the feminist move was past the trot and moving to the charge among women professors. I was on their side though, truth to tell, I found them more than a little self-righteous.
One year, when I was department chairman, I had a senior (male) professor who, despite repeated warnings, bullied a young secretary into a nervour breakdown, pretty effectively destroying her life. I demanded the dean (a woman and an ardent feminist) discipline the professor severely, and that the secretary be offered all help and support possible.
What I got was endless hearings and meetings that went on with no action for months. As it went on, I wondered, "Where the hell are all those feminists who had been swaggering the halls for the last dozen years?" Then I realized a truth that should have been obvious. When they spoke of feminine equality, they meant it for feminist professors, not for the lower classes like secretaries.
The bad column on the subject today is at the bottom of the editorial page. It's from Troy Media, of course. The only women the writer (Catherine Ford) appears to know are career women like herself. (She also trumpets her concern for third world women - of whom she seems to know none at all.) But that's okay. They're far away, so she can just send the odd donation, and feel good playing fairy godmother.
For contrast, turn to a superb column on the next page by Elsie Hambrook. She points out that for a great many women right here in Canada, the feminist crusade did nothing at all - notably nothing for women who were native peoples or poor or victims within the criminal world. Elsie Hambrook shows an awareness of all women, and what it is they have to deal with.
The Troy Media writer, like so many womren professors I worked with knows only her own, seemingly priviliged, class.
Elsie Hambrook is worth following.
Troy Media is just schlock.
When I became a university teacher, the feminist move was past the trot and moving to the charge among women professors. I was on their side though, truth to tell, I found them more than a little self-righteous.
One year, when I was department chairman, I had a senior (male) professor who, despite repeated warnings, bullied a young secretary into a nervour breakdown, pretty effectively destroying her life. I demanded the dean (a woman and an ardent feminist) discipline the professor severely, and that the secretary be offered all help and support possible.
What I got was endless hearings and meetings that went on with no action for months. As it went on, I wondered, "Where the hell are all those feminists who had been swaggering the halls for the last dozen years?" Then I realized a truth that should have been obvious. When they spoke of feminine equality, they meant it for feminist professors, not for the lower classes like secretaries.
The bad column on the subject today is at the bottom of the editorial page. It's from Troy Media, of course. The only women the writer (Catherine Ford) appears to know are career women like herself. (She also trumpets her concern for third world women - of whom she seems to know none at all.) But that's okay. They're far away, so she can just send the odd donation, and feel good playing fairy godmother.
For contrast, turn to a superb column on the next page by Elsie Hambrook. She points out that for a great many women right here in Canada, the feminist crusade did nothing at all - notably nothing for women who were native peoples or poor or victims within the criminal world. Elsie Hambrook shows an awareness of all women, and what it is they have to deal with.
The Troy Media writer, like so many womren professors I worked with knows only her own, seemingly priviliged, class.
Elsie Hambrook is worth following.
Troy Media is just schlock.
Wednesday, March 16, 2011
March 16: A disgusting and ignorant editorial - but now I think I know who writes that type.
"Higher taxation harms economy" shouts the head of the editorial. And it's all them there nanny social programmes. I've rarely seen a headline so disgusting on an editorial so reeking of ignorance of economics and even obvious facts and well known history.
This is meant, of course, to build up support for a budget that will let the rich off the hook again. And it gives the usual reason. It's private capital that creates wealth.
Well, yes, private capital can be very good at creating wealth - for the rich. But it does a terrible job of distributing wealth across the society. That's why the whole world is now in an economic crisis.
Check out Guatemala, Haiti, Congo, Ivory Coast, Egypt. What do they all have in common? Low taxes on corporations and wealthy people -and dreadful poverty for most people. Haiti has been living under a very pure form of capitalism with almost no taxes or regulations for the whole century it has been under American control. The result? It is the poorest country in the western hemisphere.
Check out the US ever since St. Ronald Regan began lowering taxes for the rich and de-regulation of big business. Lots of wealth has been produced - at the top. But there has also developed an enormous gap between a small number of very rich and hundreds of millions of poor.
There are now just one hundred supremely wealthy families in the US. They have more wealth than over 300,000,000 Americans all put together. That's a major reason why the US is in recession - and shows no sign of coming out of it. Wealthy Americans have looted their own country. The result is that many millions of people cannot earn enough to buy their products. That only way out of our crisis is to distribute wealth, not to give even more to the rich.
Canada has gone much the same route with a gap between a few rich and millions of poor so great that it will soon rival the US. The world is in an economic crisis? Good. This is a great time to go into the whole to for thirty billion or more for a handful of fighter planes that are of no use to defend Canada? (Also a great time to borrow money for a hockey rink and a CFL franchise.)
What is also happening now is that wealthy Americans have so thoroughly looted their own country, they are runniing out of places to invest their money. Thus the crisis. Why did they do that. Are they crazy?
No. They aren't crazy They're arrogant. They're greedy. And they can buy news media and politicians to spread their absurd ideas. Capitalism is destroying itself just as communism destroyed itself. That's what much of the violence in the middle east is about. Too many people have been exploited for too long by western corporations and their hired "kings" and "presidents". It might well happen here, too.
If it comes here, it will likely come in the form of a fascism combined with some variation of racism. Many of the signs of that are already showing.
Look - of course rich people play a role in creating wealth. But an even bigger part is played by the rest of us. Britain got rich in the industrial revolution because of appallingly cheap labour in Britain, and some of the worst living conditions on record. It also got rich by killing Boers in South Africa, and killing, torturing and using as cheap labour Blacks and Orientals all over the world.The capital that British corporations invested to build early twentieth century Canada came largely from gold, diamonds, farmland, oil looted from all over the world. It grew poppies on estates stolen from India, then forced China to buy a mimimum tonnage of it each year. That same pattern has been followed by the US, France, Belgium.
New Brunswick has been built largely by its own people whose governments gave away or sold their forests at bargain prices, who loaned money to the rich at low rates, who guaranteed their bonds, and who paid to subsidize electricity for corporations. Oh, and who often had to work for very low wages.
Capitalism has done something to develop New Brunswick. It also took out a hell of a lot more than it put in.
I don't favour any economic system - capitalist, socialist, communist - in its pure form. All of them, in that pure form, will break down under human greed and corruption and stupidity. As in everything else, there has to be a balance of many elements within any successful economy; and that balance has to change as conditions change.
The editorial is right on only one point. New Brunswick has a nanny government. And that is a problem because it nannies the rich while doing very little for the common good.
The world is facing a crisis probably beyond our ability to understand. Societies are falling apart. The American empire and its economy are collapsing. New Brunswick is not immune to what is happening to the whole world. If we're to survive, we have to act in the interests of our whole society, not just those of the richest families. And time is very short.
But the editorial writer is on safe ground. The budget almost certainly will benefit the rich and punish the rest or us. But, at least, it's now possible from style and choice of words to figure out who writes these shameless editorials.
My guess, and I suggest it with regret, is Norbert Cunningham.
This is meant, of course, to build up support for a budget that will let the rich off the hook again. And it gives the usual reason. It's private capital that creates wealth.
Well, yes, private capital can be very good at creating wealth - for the rich. But it does a terrible job of distributing wealth across the society. That's why the whole world is now in an economic crisis.
Check out Guatemala, Haiti, Congo, Ivory Coast, Egypt. What do they all have in common? Low taxes on corporations and wealthy people -and dreadful poverty for most people. Haiti has been living under a very pure form of capitalism with almost no taxes or regulations for the whole century it has been under American control. The result? It is the poorest country in the western hemisphere.
Check out the US ever since St. Ronald Regan began lowering taxes for the rich and de-regulation of big business. Lots of wealth has been produced - at the top. But there has also developed an enormous gap between a small number of very rich and hundreds of millions of poor.
There are now just one hundred supremely wealthy families in the US. They have more wealth than over 300,000,000 Americans all put together. That's a major reason why the US is in recession - and shows no sign of coming out of it. Wealthy Americans have looted their own country. The result is that many millions of people cannot earn enough to buy their products. That only way out of our crisis is to distribute wealth, not to give even more to the rich.
Canada has gone much the same route with a gap between a few rich and millions of poor so great that it will soon rival the US. The world is in an economic crisis? Good. This is a great time to go into the whole to for thirty billion or more for a handful of fighter planes that are of no use to defend Canada? (Also a great time to borrow money for a hockey rink and a CFL franchise.)
What is also happening now is that wealthy Americans have so thoroughly looted their own country, they are runniing out of places to invest their money. Thus the crisis. Why did they do that. Are they crazy?
No. They aren't crazy They're arrogant. They're greedy. And they can buy news media and politicians to spread their absurd ideas. Capitalism is destroying itself just as communism destroyed itself. That's what much of the violence in the middle east is about. Too many people have been exploited for too long by western corporations and their hired "kings" and "presidents". It might well happen here, too.
If it comes here, it will likely come in the form of a fascism combined with some variation of racism. Many of the signs of that are already showing.
Look - of course rich people play a role in creating wealth. But an even bigger part is played by the rest of us. Britain got rich in the industrial revolution because of appallingly cheap labour in Britain, and some of the worst living conditions on record. It also got rich by killing Boers in South Africa, and killing, torturing and using as cheap labour Blacks and Orientals all over the world.The capital that British corporations invested to build early twentieth century Canada came largely from gold, diamonds, farmland, oil looted from all over the world. It grew poppies on estates stolen from India, then forced China to buy a mimimum tonnage of it each year. That same pattern has been followed by the US, France, Belgium.
New Brunswick has been built largely by its own people whose governments gave away or sold their forests at bargain prices, who loaned money to the rich at low rates, who guaranteed their bonds, and who paid to subsidize electricity for corporations. Oh, and who often had to work for very low wages.
Capitalism has done something to develop New Brunswick. It also took out a hell of a lot more than it put in.
I don't favour any economic system - capitalist, socialist, communist - in its pure form. All of them, in that pure form, will break down under human greed and corruption and stupidity. As in everything else, there has to be a balance of many elements within any successful economy; and that balance has to change as conditions change.
The editorial is right on only one point. New Brunswick has a nanny government. And that is a problem because it nannies the rich while doing very little for the common good.
The world is facing a crisis probably beyond our ability to understand. Societies are falling apart. The American empire and its economy are collapsing. New Brunswick is not immune to what is happening to the whole world. If we're to survive, we have to act in the interests of our whole society, not just those of the richest families. And time is very short.
But the editorial writer is on safe ground. The budget almost certainly will benefit the rich and punish the rest or us. But, at least, it's now possible from style and choice of words to figure out who writes these shameless editorials.
My guess, and I suggest it with regret, is Norbert Cunningham.
Tuesday, March 15, 2011
March 15: Will the Moncton Times please stop selling us lies?
In 1998, the Abitibibowater paper mill operation in Newfoundland was taken over by the provincial government; so the company lost all its forest land and water rights. And the government took it over just to punish the company. Now, the taxpaers of Canada have to pay compensation to those poor shareholders at Abitibibowarter - just because of that theft by Newfoundland.
That's the story on the editorial page of today's Moncton Times and Transcript. It comes from yet another of the "non-partisan" think-tanks, this one the Macdonald-Laurier Institute. Like most of the other propaganda mills that are regular features of the Moncton TandT, this one is distributed by schlock specialist Troy Media.
Just a few bits of information might be helpful, here.
1. Abitibibowater never owned those timber and water (hydro power) rights in the first place. It was given free use of them so long as it remained in business in Newfoundland. (Close your eyes; think hard; see if you can think of a comany like this in New Brunswick.) This happened way back when Newfoundland was still a colony. But it went out of business in Newfoundland; it closed its mill and sacked its employees; so the land and water rights reverted to the province. It wasn't even a very big deal because all that Abitibibowater left behind is badly damaged forest. Abitibibowater has sucked the province as much as it can. Now, it demands to get paid for the garbage it left behind.
2. Abitibibowater took its case to NAFTA. Normally, it would not have a case at all - except under NAFTA rules which were created to benefit corporations like Abitibibowater. But the Canadian company Abitibibowater has its head office in Detroit (which qualifies it for big tax breaks.). That Detroit head office is what gave Abitibibowater the claim to being a US company so it could make this a NAFTA case.
3. Once it became a NAFTA case, that put Stephen Harper in the decision seat. That's like allowing a cat to decide whether a fish should be swimming in a bowl or chopped up and served on a plate. Harper quickly offered $130 million to Abitibibowater in return for something that never belonged to it in the first place.
This is what Brian Lee Crowley, Managing Director ofThe Macdonald-Laurier Institute (a non-partisan "think-tank"), doesn't tell us.
My goodness, he says, this could do damage to Canadian democracy. Right. Canadian corporations are very concerned about democracy. Just ask the New Brunswick billionaire who recently named himself a member of the New Brunswick government - without bothering to get elected.
And get ready for the day when he doesn't need you any more than Abitibibowater needs the people of Newfoundland.
That's the story on the editorial page of today's Moncton Times and Transcript. It comes from yet another of the "non-partisan" think-tanks, this one the Macdonald-Laurier Institute. Like most of the other propaganda mills that are regular features of the Moncton TandT, this one is distributed by schlock specialist Troy Media.
Just a few bits of information might be helpful, here.
1. Abitibibowater never owned those timber and water (hydro power) rights in the first place. It was given free use of them so long as it remained in business in Newfoundland. (Close your eyes; think hard; see if you can think of a comany like this in New Brunswick.) This happened way back when Newfoundland was still a colony. But it went out of business in Newfoundland; it closed its mill and sacked its employees; so the land and water rights reverted to the province. It wasn't even a very big deal because all that Abitibibowater left behind is badly damaged forest. Abitibibowater has sucked the province as much as it can. Now, it demands to get paid for the garbage it left behind.
2. Abitibibowater took its case to NAFTA. Normally, it would not have a case at all - except under NAFTA rules which were created to benefit corporations like Abitibibowater. But the Canadian company Abitibibowater has its head office in Detroit (which qualifies it for big tax breaks.). That Detroit head office is what gave Abitibibowater the claim to being a US company so it could make this a NAFTA case.
3. Once it became a NAFTA case, that put Stephen Harper in the decision seat. That's like allowing a cat to decide whether a fish should be swimming in a bowl or chopped up and served on a plate. Harper quickly offered $130 million to Abitibibowater in return for something that never belonged to it in the first place.
This is what Brian Lee Crowley, Managing Director ofThe Macdonald-Laurier Institute (a non-partisan "think-tank"), doesn't tell us.
My goodness, he says, this could do damage to Canadian democracy. Right. Canadian corporations are very concerned about democracy. Just ask the New Brunswick billionaire who recently named himself a member of the New Brunswick government - without bothering to get elected.
And get ready for the day when he doesn't need you any more than Abitibibowater needs the people of Newfoundland.
Monday, March 14, 2011
March 14: Propaganda is welcome at The Moncton Times and Transcript.
It wouldn't be The Moncton Times without its daily dose of propaganda from neo-conservative "think-tanks." Today's is from one of the seedier outfits, even by Moncton Times standards, the Frontier Centre for Public Policy. The source is Troy Media, an organization that specializes in distributing propaganda for big business. The writer, Cam Dahl, is what journalists call a flack, someone whose job it is to get big business propaganda into the media. Good journalists treat this sort of thing with caution. The Moncton Times doesn't have many good journalists.
Mr. Dahl opens with a line that is both trite and meaningless. "We owe our envious lifestyles to science."
Well, lifestyle is a word so vague nobody knows quite what it means. Roughly, it seems to mean the way we live. That includes war, corruption, millions in Canada living below the poverty line (tens of billions around the world), a love for display, and piling up wealth based on cheap labour and the poverty all that causes. Is this entirely enviable? And who is us? Obviously, it's not most of the people around the world. It may not mean even most in Canada.
It seems to me that much of what is enviable in our "lifestyles" has nothing to do with science. Science did not invent "Though shalt not kill" or "Thouw shalt not steal", Nor "love they neighbour". But I think moral standards have a good deal to do with creating an envious "Lifestyle) - whatever that means. Indeed, there have been many successful societies in history that survived with very little science. I cannot think of one that has survived with some code of morality (and most those codes remarkably similat to each other.)
The thrust of his his commentary is that people like David Suzuki don't know what they're talking about. (Mr. Dahl has an Master's degree in science. (Whoopee! That, and a dollar fifty will get you a coffee.) That's kind of a tricky argument because thousands of scientists around the world agree with Suzuki - and Dahl's whole point is that it is dangerous and foolhardy to turn our backs on science. In fact, his real point is we should turn our backs on science.
I don't know what Dahl learned in his science degrees; but it cerrtainly wasn't logic.
His main concern is genetic engineering of crops. He says this is the way for the future to feed the poor,etc. Well, feediing the poor is not entirely what he is about. Genetic engineering can produce bigger crops. But it's a private business; and you have to buy fresh seed from each year. See what that means to a farmer in a poor region?
His country is poor. The World Bank generously offers it aid money. But there is a little catch. It has to spend the money in a rich country to buy seed - every year - forever. The World Bank (which really represents western business) is happy. Private suppliers are happy. But....
Before, the farmer was able to get seed from one year's crop to plant the next year's crop. Now, he can grow more, but at such a greater cost than he and his family are poorer than ever.Meanwhile, his extra food can be exported to maintain our envious lifestyle.
He also attacks scientists who claim no technology should be used until it is proven safe. "This," he says "is a ridiculous and dangerous interpretation." Really? Perhaps The Moncton Times and Transcript should alert the Japanese government about this so they can stop worrying about radiation from nuclear plants.
(By the way, ever wonder why Somalia fishermen suddently became nororious pirates, holding ships for ransom? It might have somoething to do with their fish disappearing. And the fish disappeared - and people started dying - because western companies and governments were dumping shiploads of nuclear and chemical waste along the waters and the shores of Somalia. Simlarly polluted shores can be found in much of Africa.)
This is a silly, uninformed and illogical article which says we shouldn't turn our backs on science, then says we should - which makes most money for billionaires. And the editors of the Moncton Times make sure that commentaries like this appear frequently.
Let's learn a new word today. In yiddish,, a commentary like this is called schlock. Good word, schlock.
Mr. Dahl opens with a line that is both trite and meaningless. "We owe our envious lifestyles to science."
Well, lifestyle is a word so vague nobody knows quite what it means. Roughly, it seems to mean the way we live. That includes war, corruption, millions in Canada living below the poverty line (tens of billions around the world), a love for display, and piling up wealth based on cheap labour and the poverty all that causes. Is this entirely enviable? And who is us? Obviously, it's not most of the people around the world. It may not mean even most in Canada.
It seems to me that much of what is enviable in our "lifestyles" has nothing to do with science. Science did not invent "Though shalt not kill" or "Thouw shalt not steal", Nor "love they neighbour". But I think moral standards have a good deal to do with creating an envious "Lifestyle) - whatever that means. Indeed, there have been many successful societies in history that survived with very little science. I cannot think of one that has survived with some code of morality (and most those codes remarkably similat to each other.)
The thrust of his his commentary is that people like David Suzuki don't know what they're talking about. (Mr. Dahl has an Master's degree in science. (Whoopee! That, and a dollar fifty will get you a coffee.) That's kind of a tricky argument because thousands of scientists around the world agree with Suzuki - and Dahl's whole point is that it is dangerous and foolhardy to turn our backs on science. In fact, his real point is we should turn our backs on science.
I don't know what Dahl learned in his science degrees; but it cerrtainly wasn't logic.
His main concern is genetic engineering of crops. He says this is the way for the future to feed the poor,etc. Well, feediing the poor is not entirely what he is about. Genetic engineering can produce bigger crops. But it's a private business; and you have to buy fresh seed from each year. See what that means to a farmer in a poor region?
His country is poor. The World Bank generously offers it aid money. But there is a little catch. It has to spend the money in a rich country to buy seed - every year - forever. The World Bank (which really represents western business) is happy. Private suppliers are happy. But....
Before, the farmer was able to get seed from one year's crop to plant the next year's crop. Now, he can grow more, but at such a greater cost than he and his family are poorer than ever.Meanwhile, his extra food can be exported to maintain our envious lifestyle.
He also attacks scientists who claim no technology should be used until it is proven safe. "This," he says "is a ridiculous and dangerous interpretation." Really? Perhaps The Moncton Times and Transcript should alert the Japanese government about this so they can stop worrying about radiation from nuclear plants.
(By the way, ever wonder why Somalia fishermen suddently became nororious pirates, holding ships for ransom? It might have somoething to do with their fish disappearing. And the fish disappeared - and people started dying - because western companies and governments were dumping shiploads of nuclear and chemical waste along the waters and the shores of Somalia. Simlarly polluted shores can be found in much of Africa.)
This is a silly, uninformed and illogical article which says we shouldn't turn our backs on science, then says we should - which makes most money for billionaires. And the editors of the Moncton Times make sure that commentaries like this appear frequently.
Let's learn a new word today. In yiddish,, a commentary like this is called schlock. Good word, schlock.
Saturday, March 12, 2011
March 11: re previous blog for this date.
The rules of British rugby also explain why hockey has blue lines.
But that's another story.
But that's another story.
March 12: Nothing terrible in The Moncton Times today - but an interesting comment by Brent Mazerolle
"Fewer and fewer kids and parents think hockey is worth playing." That's the headline on an intriguing op ed piece by Brent Mazerolle in which he argues that fighting is destroying the game. He's right. But hockey will never clean itself up because the owners won't let it. Fighting is what the commercial game is about. So let's take a look at why it happened, and why owners won't change it.
Modern hockey was invented in Montreal in the 1870s. Yes, I know there is a picture of a Haligonian skating with a hockey stick before that. Yes, I know that a Nova Scotia school had a "hockey" team before that. For that matter, there are paintings of Dutch children with skates and sticks playing on the canal ice in the 1700s.
They even sometimes called it hockey - a corruption of "hoquet", the French word for the curved stick. For that matter, I'm sure playful cavemen knocked enemy skulls along the ice with their clubs. But none of this was really hockey. More properly, the English called such a game "shinty", meaning a pickup game with no standard rules. (From that, we got the "shinny" I played on the street as a kid.) In fact, virtually all modern games have roots that go back to ancient times.
But a game is not invented until it has a standard set of rules which are the same in Toronto as they are in Moncton as they are in Moscow. That happened in Montreal. And the rules most certainly did not make allowances for fighting.
Organized sports in those days were almost exclusively for "gentlemen", a word that meant the wealthier classes like business families. They regarded it as their class right to provide national leadership in all areas of life (not unlike modern New Brunswick). The purpose of organized sport lay in its supposed ability to make them leaders over the lower classes.
But, alas! Clubs soon learned that the wealthy often couldn't produce the quality of player that was needed. So they lowered themselves to allow free club memberships for gifted poor people.
It got worse. Within a generation, the railway had made it possible to transport teams, and so to develop leagues and professionalism. But Canada was still a small country, too small to support a pro hockey league. Owners had to tap the US market (notably New York, Detroit, Chicago, and Boston). But people in those places who understood hockey were too few. The answer was to offer them something they could understand - speed.
The original game copied most of its rules from British rugby (another game of the rich and the aristocracy). Rugby didn't allow substitution. So early hockey didn't, either. That meant some spretty straggly games by the third period. So the owners changed the rules to allow substition so they could offer speed. And the Americans bought it.
Professionalism also put paid to the job of creating gentlemen because gentlemen were losers at the box office. Fighting appeared (though usually less of it and less vicious than today.) By the 1940s, though, as Maurice Richard was being prepared for the NHL, he was given boxing lessons. Trust me on t his one. His boxing coach was my uncle.
But television was an even bigger challenge for hockey. For NHL owners, the game promised possibilities for huge profit from advertisers. But TV took us all the way to Florida and California where even speed wasn't enough to pull them in. That was when the owners decided to make fighting and injuring (the two are not necessarily the same) the central attraction of the game. The owners could put a stop to hockey goons in just one game. But it would cost them. That's why they have never done it. Remember, big profits don't mean providing hockey for experts on the game. Big profits mean pulling in people who think Don Cherry is an intellectual. It means drawing fans who think the WWF is for real. They love watching people get injured. Fighting in hockey, like the "sport" of extreme fighting, might be telling something upsetting about our society.
The common people of ancient Rome (usually referred to as the "mob") were among the most useless people in the world. They were given enough food by their rulers to stay alive (food that came from conquered peoples), enough housing to shelter them in filth and disease, and great pits their bodies would be thrown into when they died. They were contemptible people. They knew they were contemptible and useless.
But the emperor and the aristocracy had to keep them quiet or they might turn to riot and looting. So it diverted free with free shows at various stadia. The shows were not only free,but designed to keep them from thinking - the same sort of job The Moncton Times does. But it charges.
As the humour of farting elephants and human freaks waned, the ruling class introduced increasing brutality - sham battles in which hundreds died; and then, even further down the scale, just watching people getting ripped to pieces by wild animals.
An historian of Rome has argued that they enjoyed this because they knew they were contemptible and deserved punishment. They loved watching others die because somebody else was getting the punishment they deserved, and because the shows gave them a sense of somebody who was inferior even to them. (It's something like the reason we watch Judge Judy on TV.)
That is the direction we are going with pro hockey. On balance, then, maybe it's a good sign if both parents and kids are losing interest in hockey
Modern hockey was invented in Montreal in the 1870s. Yes, I know there is a picture of a Haligonian skating with a hockey stick before that. Yes, I know that a Nova Scotia school had a "hockey" team before that. For that matter, there are paintings of Dutch children with skates and sticks playing on the canal ice in the 1700s.
They even sometimes called it hockey - a corruption of "hoquet", the French word for the curved stick. For that matter, I'm sure playful cavemen knocked enemy skulls along the ice with their clubs. But none of this was really hockey. More properly, the English called such a game "shinty", meaning a pickup game with no standard rules. (From that, we got the "shinny" I played on the street as a kid.) In fact, virtually all modern games have roots that go back to ancient times.
But a game is not invented until it has a standard set of rules which are the same in Toronto as they are in Moncton as they are in Moscow. That happened in Montreal. And the rules most certainly did not make allowances for fighting.
Organized sports in those days were almost exclusively for "gentlemen", a word that meant the wealthier classes like business families. They regarded it as their class right to provide national leadership in all areas of life (not unlike modern New Brunswick). The purpose of organized sport lay in its supposed ability to make them leaders over the lower classes.
But, alas! Clubs soon learned that the wealthy often couldn't produce the quality of player that was needed. So they lowered themselves to allow free club memberships for gifted poor people.
It got worse. Within a generation, the railway had made it possible to transport teams, and so to develop leagues and professionalism. But Canada was still a small country, too small to support a pro hockey league. Owners had to tap the US market (notably New York, Detroit, Chicago, and Boston). But people in those places who understood hockey were too few. The answer was to offer them something they could understand - speed.
The original game copied most of its rules from British rugby (another game of the rich and the aristocracy). Rugby didn't allow substitution. So early hockey didn't, either. That meant some spretty straggly games by the third period. So the owners changed the rules to allow substition so they could offer speed. And the Americans bought it.
Professionalism also put paid to the job of creating gentlemen because gentlemen were losers at the box office. Fighting appeared (though usually less of it and less vicious than today.) By the 1940s, though, as Maurice Richard was being prepared for the NHL, he was given boxing lessons. Trust me on t his one. His boxing coach was my uncle.
But television was an even bigger challenge for hockey. For NHL owners, the game promised possibilities for huge profit from advertisers. But TV took us all the way to Florida and California where even speed wasn't enough to pull them in. That was when the owners decided to make fighting and injuring (the two are not necessarily the same) the central attraction of the game. The owners could put a stop to hockey goons in just one game. But it would cost them. That's why they have never done it. Remember, big profits don't mean providing hockey for experts on the game. Big profits mean pulling in people who think Don Cherry is an intellectual. It means drawing fans who think the WWF is for real. They love watching people get injured. Fighting in hockey, like the "sport" of extreme fighting, might be telling something upsetting about our society.
The common people of ancient Rome (usually referred to as the "mob") were among the most useless people in the world. They were given enough food by their rulers to stay alive (food that came from conquered peoples), enough housing to shelter them in filth and disease, and great pits their bodies would be thrown into when they died. They were contemptible people. They knew they were contemptible and useless.
But the emperor and the aristocracy had to keep them quiet or they might turn to riot and looting. So it diverted free with free shows at various stadia. The shows were not only free,but designed to keep them from thinking - the same sort of job The Moncton Times does. But it charges.
As the humour of farting elephants and human freaks waned, the ruling class introduced increasing brutality - sham battles in which hundreds died; and then, even further down the scale, just watching people getting ripped to pieces by wild animals.
An historian of Rome has argued that they enjoyed this because they knew they were contemptible and deserved punishment. They loved watching others die because somebody else was getting the punishment they deserved, and because the shows gave them a sense of somebody who was inferior even to them. (It's something like the reason we watch Judge Judy on TV.)
That is the direction we are going with pro hockey. On balance, then, maybe it's a good sign if both parents and kids are losing interest in hockey
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)