Tuesday, March 15, 2011

March 15: Will the Moncton Times please stop selling us lies?

In 1998, the Abitibibowater paper mill operation in Newfoundland was taken over by the provincial government; so the company lost all its forest land and water rights. And the government took it over just to punish the company. Now, the taxpaers of Canada have to pay compensation to those poor shareholders at Abitibibowarter - just because of that theft by Newfoundland.

That's the story on the editorial page of today's Moncton Times and Transcript. It comes from yet another of the "non-partisan" think-tanks, this one the Macdonald-Laurier Institute. Like most of the other propaganda mills that are regular features of the Moncton TandT, this one is distributed by schlock specialist Troy Media.

Just a few bits of information might be helpful, here.

1. Abitibibowater never owned those timber and water (hydro power) rights in the first place. It was given free use of them so long as it remained in business in Newfoundland. (Close your eyes; think hard; see if you can think of a comany like this in New Brunswick.) This happened way back when Newfoundland was still a colony. But it went out of business in Newfoundland; it closed its mill and sacked its employees; so the land and water rights reverted to the province. It wasn't even a very big deal because all that Abitibibowater left behind is badly damaged forest. Abitibibowater has sucked the province as much as it can. Now, it demands to get paid for the garbage it left behind.

2. Abitibibowater took its case to NAFTA. Normally, it would not have a case at all - except under NAFTA rules which were created to benefit corporations like Abitibibowater. But the Canadian company Abitibibowater has its head office in Detroit (which qualifies it for big tax breaks.). That Detroit head office is what gave Abitibibowater the claim to being a US company so it could make this a NAFTA case.

3. Once it became a NAFTA case, that put Stephen Harper in the decision seat. That's like allowing a cat to decide whether a fish should be swimming in a bowl or chopped up and served on a plate. Harper quickly offered $130 million to Abitibibowater in return for something that never belonged to it in the first place.

This is what Brian Lee Crowley, Managing Director ofThe Macdonald-Laurier Institute (a non-partisan "think-tank"), doesn't tell us.

My goodness, he says, this could do damage to Canadian democracy. Right. Canadian corporations are very concerned about democracy. Just ask the New Brunswick billionaire who recently named himself a member of the New Brunswick government - without bothering to get elected.

And get ready for the day when he doesn't need you any more than Abitibibowater needs the people of Newfoundland.

Monday, March 14, 2011

March 14: Propaganda is welcome at The Moncton Times and Transcript.

It wouldn't be The Moncton Times without its daily dose of propaganda from  neo-conservative "think-tanks." Today's is from one of the seedier outfits, even by Moncton Times standards, the Frontier Centre for Public Policy. The source is Troy Media, an organization that specializes in distributing propaganda for big business. The writer, Cam Dahl, is what journalists call a flack, someone whose job it is to get big business propaganda into the media. Good journalists treat this sort of thing with caution. The Moncton Times doesn't have many good journalists.

Mr. Dahl opens with a line that is both trite and meaningless. "We owe our envious lifestyles to science."
Well,  lifestyle is a word so vague nobody knows quite what it means. Roughly, it seems to mean the way we live. That includes war, corruption, millions in Canada living below the poverty line (tens of billions around the world), a love for display, and piling up wealth based on cheap labour and the poverty all that causes. Is this entirely enviable? And who is us? Obviously, it's not most of the people around the world. It may not mean even most in Canada.

It seems to me that much of what is enviable in our "lifestyles" has nothing to do with science. Science did not invent "Though shalt not kill" or "Thouw shalt not steal", Nor "love they neighbour". But I think moral standards have a good deal to do with creating an envious "Lifestyle) - whatever that means. Indeed, there have been many successful societies in history that survived with very little science. I cannot think of one that has survived with some code of morality  (and most those codes remarkably similat to each other.)

The thrust of his his commentary is that people like David Suzuki don't know what they're talking about. (Mr. Dahl has an Master's degree in science. (Whoopee! That, and a dollar fifty will get you a coffee.) That's kind of a tricky argument because thousands of scientists around the world agree with Suzuki  - and Dahl's whole point is that it is dangerous and foolhardy  to turn our backs on science. In fact, his real point is we should turn our backs on science.

I don't know what Dahl learned in his science degrees; but it cerrtainly wasn't logic.

His main concern is genetic engineering of crops. He says this is the way for the future to feed the poor,etc. Well, feediing the poor is not entirely what he is about. Genetic engineering can produce bigger crops. But it's a private business; and you have to buy fresh seed from each year. See what that means to a farmer in a poor region?

His country is poor. The World Bank generously offers it aid money. But there is a little catch. It has to spend the money in a rich country to buy seed - every year - forever. The World Bank (which really represents western business) is happy. Private suppliers are happy. But....

Before, the farmer was able to get seed from one year's crop to plant the next year's crop. Now, he can grow more, but at such a greater cost than he and his family are poorer than ever.Meanwhile, his extra food can be exported to maintain our envious lifestyle.

He also attacks scientists who claim no technology should be used until it is proven safe. "This," he says "is a ridiculous and dangerous interpretation."  Really? Perhaps The Moncton Times and Transcript should alert the Japanese government about this so they can stop worrying about radiation from nuclear plants.

(By the way, ever wonder why Somalia fishermen suddently became nororious pirates, holding ships for ransom? It might have somoething to do with their fish disappearing. And the fish disappeared - and people started dying - because western companies and governments were dumping shiploads of nuclear and chemical waste along the waters and the shores of Somalia. Simlarly polluted shores can be found in much of Africa.)

This is a silly, uninformed and illogical article which says we shouldn't turn our backs on science, then says we should - which makes most money for billionaires. And the editors of the Moncton Times make sure that commentaries like this appear frequently.

Let's  learn a new word today. In yiddish,, a commentary like this is called schlock. Good word, schlock.

Saturday, March 12, 2011

March 11: re previous blog for this date.

The rules of British rugby also explain why hockey has blue lines.
But that's another story.

March 12: Nothing terrible in The Moncton Times today - but an interesting comment by Brent Mazerolle

"Fewer and fewer kids and parents think hockey is worth playing." That's the headline on an intriguing op ed piece by Brent Mazerolle in which he argues that fighting is destroying the game. He's right. But  hockey will never clean itself up because the owners won't let it. Fighting is what the commercial game is about. So let's take a look at why it happened, and why owners won't change it.

Modern hockey was invented in Montreal in the 1870s.  Yes, I know there is a picture of a Haligonian skating with a hockey stick before that. Yes, I know that a Nova Scotia school had a "hockey" team before that.  For that matter, there are paintings of Dutch children with skates and sticks playing on the canal ice in the 1700s.

They even sometimes called it hockey - a corruption of "hoquet", the French word for the curved stick. For that matter, I'm sure playful cavemen knocked enemy skulls along the ice with their clubs. But none of this was really hockey. More properly, the English called such a game "shinty", meaning a pickup game with no standard rules. (From that, we got the "shinny" I played on the street as a kid.) In fact, virtually all modern games have roots that go back to ancient times.

But a game is not invented until it has a standard set of rules which are the same in Toronto as they are in Moncton as they are in Moscow. That happened in Montreal. And the rules most certainly did not make allowances for fighting.

Organized sports in those days were almost exclusively for "gentlemen", a word that meant the wealthier classes like business families. They regarded it as their class right to provide national leadership in all areas of life  (not unlike modern New Brunswick). The purpose of organized sport lay in its supposed ability to make them leaders over the lower classes.

But, alas! Clubs soon learned that the wealthy often couldn't produce the quality of player that was needed. So they lowered themselves to allow free club memberships for gifted poor people.

It got worse. Within a generation, the railway had made it possible to transport teams, and so to develop leagues and professionalism. But Canada was still a small country, too small to support a pro hockey league. Owners had to tap the US market (notably New York, Detroit, Chicago, and Boston). But people in those places who understood hockey were too few. The answer was to offer them something they could understand - speed.

The original game copied most of its rules from British rugby (another game of the rich and the aristocracy). Rugby didn't allow substitution. So early hockey didn't, either. That meant some spretty straggly games by the third period. So the owners changed the rules to allow substition so they could offer speed. And the Americans bought it.

Professionalism also put paid to the job of creating gentlemen because gentlemen were losers at the box office. Fighting appeared (though usually less of it and less vicious than today.) By the 1940s, though, as Maurice Richard was being prepared for the NHL, he was given boxing lessons. Trust me on t his one. His boxing coach was my uncle.

But television was an even bigger challenge for hockey. For NHL owners, the game promised possibilities for huge profit from advertisers. But TV took us all the way to Florida and California where even speed wasn't enough to pull them in. That was when the owners decided to make fighting and injuring (the two are not necessarily the same) the central attraction of the game. The owners could put a stop to hockey goons in just one game. But it would cost them. That's why they have never done it. Remember, big profits don't mean providing hockey for experts on the game. Big profits mean pulling in people who think Don Cherry  is an intellectual.  It means drawing fans who think the WWF is for real. They love watching people get injured. Fighting in hockey, like the "sport" of extreme fighting, might be telling something upsetting about our society.

The common people of ancient Rome (usually referred to as the "mob") were among the most useless people in the world. They were given enough food by their rulers to stay alive (food that came from conquered peoples), enough housing to shelter them in filth and disease, and great pits their bodies would be thrown into when they died. They were contemptible people. They knew they were contemptible and useless.

But the emperor and the aristocracy had to keep them quiet or they might turn to riot and looting. So it diverted free with free shows at various stadia. The shows were not only free,but designed to keep them from thinking - the same sort of job The Moncton Times does. But it charges.

As the humour of farting elephants and human freaks waned, the ruling class introduced increasing brutality - sham battles in which hundreds died; and then, even further down the scale, just watching people getting ripped to pieces by wild animals.

An historian of Rome has argued that they enjoyed this because they knew they were contemptible and deserved punishment. They loved watching others die because somebody else was getting the punishment they deserved, and because the shows gave them a sense of somebody who was inferior even to them. (It's  something like the reason we watch Judge Judy on TV.)

That is the direction we are going with pro hockey. On balance, then, maybe it's a good sign if both parents and kids are losing interest in hockey

Friday, March 11, 2011

March 11: Whoa, baby! Norbert goes wild.

This is my second attempt to write this article. I had thought I could write it as a humorous piece. but there's really nothing funny about it. I regret that I have to name Mr. Cunningham. I really do. I had thought it possible he was one of the few intelligent and ethical people working for The Moncton Times. I'm sorry I have to say what I do. But I don't apologize for it.

Mr. Cunningham's smears of whole groups of people, and his bias amounting to bigotry make it justifiable and necessary to name him. As I recall it, this is also the editor who accused the Liberals, NDP, and Bloc of acting illegally when they considered forming a coalition. I thought then it was either a stunning ingorance of Canadian parliamentary practice and Canadian history or a lie. I think I can now elimimate one of those possibilities.
Headed "Looking for something that's fresh, with a vision for Canada", the commentary begins well with a criticism of the failure of the Liberals to come up with a vision for Canada. All too true. The Liberal party needs to go back to the 1940s when opinion polls and the rise of the old CCF forced Mackenzie-King to recognize that the nineteenth century was over.

He could have mentioned that the federal Conservatives don't seem to have a vision, either. Instead, they rely heavily on the advice of the Canadian Council of CEOs to develop a relationship with the US that is very similar to our old, colonial relationship to Britain.  Well, I guess one could say Harper does have a policy. He wants to be governor of the colony of Canada, one with the need for democratic practices reduced to zero.

Then, Cunningham rants at the "knee-jerk ideological devotion to expensive nanny social programmes backed primarily by special interest groups."  (Good thing he doesn't seem to know that this knee jerk ideological  devotion began with a Prime Minister from New Brunswick, a Conservative named R.B.Bennett, way back in the federal election of 1935. The Liberals didn't get into the game until 1945.

As for the speical insterest groups who supported these "nanny" state solutions, the only speccial interest group that supported them was the voters of Canada. Do you have a problem with that, Norbert?

The ones we would usually call special interest groups were things like insurance companies, major employers, etc.  And they did not support social programmes. In fact, heavily opposed social spending.

As well, the word "ideology" is not only used incorrectly but, like "nanny", is used as a loaded word to suggest denigration. Does one have to be an ideologue to believe people should help each other? So far as I know, mutual compassion and help is a principle of every major religion in the world. That's one reason why democracies are formed in the first place. Democracy is a way of a society coming together to help each other.

"Nanny" social programmes are expensive? Yep. So are "nanny" giveaways of crown timberland, and "nanny" spending of $84,000,000 for a hockey rink. So are "nanny" tax cuts to the rich. I would feel somewhat less contempt for Mr. Cunningham if he were occasionally to write in such a derogatory manner of his masters. There are few things so distasteful and so dishonest as the sneer of a Uriah Heep.

He also says there are lots of good approaches and ideas to be found in "solid, non-partisan expert studies".  But he doesn't name even one of these experts. I would dearly like to know what such a partisan editor would think is non-partisan, and what is expert.

Note, by the way, he scorns wasting money on arenas for NHL franchises - but does not seem to see any problem with spending it on minor league hockey or CFL franchises. I wonder why.

Then he has the gall to say to we should copy those right wingers who say we should not subsidize private business. I agree we shouldn't. But I haven't ever seen anybody on the right who has conducted any serious campaign against such happenings. Perhaps Mr. Cunningham could get the debate rolling with, say, an example of a company getting reduced rates for electricity. Perhaps he could even find one in New Brunswick.

Following that, he has the nerve to denounce any criticism of the US as "silly anti-Americanism". Do you approve of torture, Mr. Cunningham? Do you approve of mass killing of civilians? Do you approve of imprisonment without trial or even charge? Do you approve of the US consistently ignoring Canadian claims to the Arctic? Gee. I must be a silly anti-American. Perhaps I need to listen to O Canada till I turn blue so I can be a good Canadian like Mr. Cunningham, and approve of everything the US does.

Then - get this - he accuses people who want to control or in any way limit competition in Canada as "fraidy cats". Right on, kid. Now, write an editorial on how New Brunsick newspapers need competition;  and call on the owners to break up their monopoly on the English speaking part of the population. I don't accuse Mr. Cunningham of being a hypocrite, though. I don't think he sees any contradiction is advising more competition in every business except his own.

Anyway, he'll never write such a column. The only "fraidy cat" I see is Mr. Cunningham.

Oh, yes, he also slurs environmental activists who parrot the latest fad "solutions" for the environment.  His big suggestion, undoubtedly from "non-partisan experts"? Well, we could have bicycle paths, safe walking routes. Boy, that'll fix everything in a few days. The mind boggles.

And we gotta beat down the national debt. Yep. And if Mr. Cunningham knew any history, he would know that the big spenders in  Canada and the US have been Conservatives and Republicans at every level of government. It's true. Check it out. The current world economic crisis began with the policies of Ronald Reagan -  a very conservative Republican. And it came crashing in on us with the neo-conservative George Bush.

Oh, and of course, Mr. Cunningham sees the real fat and waste in the public service. If he meant by this Harper going into the hole for 29 billion for fighter planes of no possible Canadian use, then he would be right. But he doesn't mean that. He means those stupid social workers who want to "nanny" unsafe families. He means those regulators who interfere with honest billionaires to make sure they don't pollute. He means those do gooders who think all families should have food.

Fat and waste mean money taken from us in excess of what is needed. If Mr. Cunningham takes the trouble to look at the shameful distribution of wealth in Canada and the US, he will see that most of the waste and fat are part of the wealth of the 100 or so wealthiest families in North America. Private business when it has few controls or regulations and when it can buy governments is a great producer of wealth. But it is a lousy distributor of it. The inevitable result of that sort of fat and wasteis what we are watching in the middle east and Africa - and possibly in the US this summer.

Cunningham concludes by saying that all we see in our political system is power lust and mud. Well, there is a lot of that going around and, in New Brunswick, it's encouraged by Brunswick Media. People are not well informed by most media of the issues. They are not only uninformed but fed with a constant diet of propaganda bolstered, I now realize, by an almost complete ignorance of politics encouraged by the newspapers.

In the recent provincial election, neither the Liberals nor the Conservatives had anything that could be called a platform. The Conservatives won simply because the Liberals were unpopular and Alward said he would listen to the people. Nobody at The Moncton Times had the honesty - or perhaps the wit - to point out that the great democratic leaders of the past century have been great not because they listened (you can rent a recording device to do that). The great leaders like Churchill and Roosevelt were elected because they said what they were goingn to do, people liked what they heard. A democracy does not vote for a "nanny" listener. It votes for a person of principles and vision and a vision that sounds sensible. But they can't do that in New Brunswick because the newspapers keep people in ignorance of what the issues are.

New Brunswick, thanks largely to its English newspapers, can only barely be called a democracy. Mr. Cunningham's column is a good illustration of how that has happened.

Thursday, March 10, 2011

March 10. How to write propaganda that looks like news.

"Urgent changes needed in N.B. budget: : experts"
That seems clear enough. It suggests this is a news report in which a number of experts (with all that word's hint of impartiality) say that budget changes are necessary. That is reinforced in the sub-head which refers to "some" advocates - though that sub head is not quite so clear. We still have a range of experts, it seems. But they're also advocates. Advocates of what?

It turns out the experts are just two people. Count them - two. Are there experts who disagree with them? The report doesn't mention any.

One of the experts is genuine enough. Donald Savoie of U de Moncton. He certainly seems a man whose opinions are worth paying attention to. But I taught in  unversities for forty years. I know the word expert is not so reassuring as it sounds. Virtually all profs, including me, have biases that affect their opinion at least as much as their studies affect them. Professor Savoie is certainly an expert. But hundreds of experts in his field will not only disaggree with him, but will be all over the map in their own opinions. There have even been some so rude as to disagree with me.

Perhaps the most notorious departments for bias in universities are Political Science and Economics. In this case, Professor Savoie is a political scientist writing on economics. Both fields are notorious for their wide range of biases. So what we have here is an opinion, not a judgement.

Professor Savoie's view is that we need an HST tax. That is a tax which hits low incomes the hardest. It hits the wealthy and corporations the least. I know lots of scholars who would disagree with that. They are experts, too.  Apparently, though, the Moncton Times knows only the one at U de Moncton.

The other "expert" is less impressive. He is the regional head of The Canadian Taxpayers' Association. Not only is he something less than an expert, he has been closely associated with several "think-tanks" (propaganda agences for corporations).. Of course he's opposed to raising taxes. That's what he's paid to do.

Lacey ends with a bizarre statement. He says the economy in Nova Scotia is suffering as a direct result of higher taxes than New Brunswick. Oh? Where did that cause and effect theory come from? Haiti has had virtually no taxes for a century. Foreign factory and factory farm corporations have certainly prospered under this system. But would Mr. Lacey hold up Haiti as an example of how effective it is to lower taxes?

And just to show that even experts like Professor Savoie and Mr. Lacey cannot agree. Savoie holds Nova Scotia up as an example of what New Brunswick should be doing.

So what was this "news" item really about? It is propaganda following up on a campaign the The Moncton Times and Transcript began a week ago, almost certainly on the orders of its masters. The message has nothing to do with a systematic quiestioning of experts. EVen the use of the word expert in its plural form is misleading. One is certainly expert in his field. But many experts in that same field don't agree with him. The other is not an expert; he's a hired front man for a pressure group.

This is not a news item. This is propaganda to make sure that Premier Alward doesn't do something foolish like raising taxes on coporations. (There's even a hint that if such taxes are raised, messrs Irving and Ganong and the rest will stamp their feet and leave the province - so we'll be the only jurisdiction in North America with no gas stations or boxes of chocolates.)

We should be so lucky.

Wednesday, March 9, 2011

March 9: L'Acadie Nouvelle

Since I get most of my news from the web, the only paper in New Brunswick I have read on a regular basis - with a sort of fascinated horror - is the Times and Tribune. But, today, I took the time to look through L'Acadie Nouvelle.

This is one, fine paper. It's not just that it reports news honestly, and writes editorials intelligently -and does both very well, indeed. .  But even better, as I read page after page, I got a strong sense of a real Acadian community - a community with social attachments, with awareness, with purpose for the common good, and with ambition.  I also got a strong sense that here was a newspaper that had respect for its readers.

In reading The Moncton Times and Transcript, I get no sense at all of an English-speaking community anywhere in New Brunswick. The sense I get is that there are no shared values or aspirations, that the Moncton Times has nothing but contempt for its readers. It sees them as a rabble of morons, much as the later emperors of Rome saw what we still refer to as the Roman "mob".. Like the emperors, it encourages triviality and ignorance. It treats its readers as lower creatures whose only purpose  is to be manipulated and wrung dry by the corporate aristocracy of New Brunswick.

That makes iti pretty much like most of the newspapers in the Maritimes and, indeed, across Canada and the U.S.

Acadians have a newspaper that respects them. New Brunswick anglos have newspapers that are Judas goats.

This is an attractive city full of people who could accomplish a great deal. But English-speaking ones are being sold out by their own major source of news and insight.

Pity.