Friday, March 11, 2011

March 11: Whoa, baby! Norbert goes wild.

This is my second attempt to write this article. I had thought I could write it as a humorous piece. but there's really nothing funny about it. I regret that I have to name Mr. Cunningham. I really do. I had thought it possible he was one of the few intelligent and ethical people working for The Moncton Times. I'm sorry I have to say what I do. But I don't apologize for it.

Mr. Cunningham's smears of whole groups of people, and his bias amounting to bigotry make it justifiable and necessary to name him. As I recall it, this is also the editor who accused the Liberals, NDP, and Bloc of acting illegally when they considered forming a coalition. I thought then it was either a stunning ingorance of Canadian parliamentary practice and Canadian history or a lie. I think I can now elimimate one of those possibilities.
Headed "Looking for something that's fresh, with a vision for Canada", the commentary begins well with a criticism of the failure of the Liberals to come up with a vision for Canada. All too true. The Liberal party needs to go back to the 1940s when opinion polls and the rise of the old CCF forced Mackenzie-King to recognize that the nineteenth century was over.

He could have mentioned that the federal Conservatives don't seem to have a vision, either. Instead, they rely heavily on the advice of the Canadian Council of CEOs to develop a relationship with the US that is very similar to our old, colonial relationship to Britain.  Well, I guess one could say Harper does have a policy. He wants to be governor of the colony of Canada, one with the need for democratic practices reduced to zero.

Then, Cunningham rants at the "knee-jerk ideological devotion to expensive nanny social programmes backed primarily by special interest groups."  (Good thing he doesn't seem to know that this knee jerk ideological  devotion began with a Prime Minister from New Brunswick, a Conservative named R.B.Bennett, way back in the federal election of 1935. The Liberals didn't get into the game until 1945.

As for the speical insterest groups who supported these "nanny" state solutions, the only speccial interest group that supported them was the voters of Canada. Do you have a problem with that, Norbert?

The ones we would usually call special interest groups were things like insurance companies, major employers, etc.  And they did not support social programmes. In fact, heavily opposed social spending.

As well, the word "ideology" is not only used incorrectly but, like "nanny", is used as a loaded word to suggest denigration. Does one have to be an ideologue to believe people should help each other? So far as I know, mutual compassion and help is a principle of every major religion in the world. That's one reason why democracies are formed in the first place. Democracy is a way of a society coming together to help each other.

"Nanny" social programmes are expensive? Yep. So are "nanny" giveaways of crown timberland, and "nanny" spending of $84,000,000 for a hockey rink. So are "nanny" tax cuts to the rich. I would feel somewhat less contempt for Mr. Cunningham if he were occasionally to write in such a derogatory manner of his masters. There are few things so distasteful and so dishonest as the sneer of a Uriah Heep.

He also says there are lots of good approaches and ideas to be found in "solid, non-partisan expert studies".  But he doesn't name even one of these experts. I would dearly like to know what such a partisan editor would think is non-partisan, and what is expert.

Note, by the way, he scorns wasting money on arenas for NHL franchises - but does not seem to see any problem with spending it on minor league hockey or CFL franchises. I wonder why.

Then he has the gall to say to we should copy those right wingers who say we should not subsidize private business. I agree we shouldn't. But I haven't ever seen anybody on the right who has conducted any serious campaign against such happenings. Perhaps Mr. Cunningham could get the debate rolling with, say, an example of a company getting reduced rates for electricity. Perhaps he could even find one in New Brunswick.

Following that, he has the nerve to denounce any criticism of the US as "silly anti-Americanism". Do you approve of torture, Mr. Cunningham? Do you approve of mass killing of civilians? Do you approve of imprisonment without trial or even charge? Do you approve of the US consistently ignoring Canadian claims to the Arctic? Gee. I must be a silly anti-American. Perhaps I need to listen to O Canada till I turn blue so I can be a good Canadian like Mr. Cunningham, and approve of everything the US does.

Then - get this - he accuses people who want to control or in any way limit competition in Canada as "fraidy cats". Right on, kid. Now, write an editorial on how New Brunsick newspapers need competition;  and call on the owners to break up their monopoly on the English speaking part of the population. I don't accuse Mr. Cunningham of being a hypocrite, though. I don't think he sees any contradiction is advising more competition in every business except his own.

Anyway, he'll never write such a column. The only "fraidy cat" I see is Mr. Cunningham.

Oh, yes, he also slurs environmental activists who parrot the latest fad "solutions" for the environment.  His big suggestion, undoubtedly from "non-partisan experts"? Well, we could have bicycle paths, safe walking routes. Boy, that'll fix everything in a few days. The mind boggles.

And we gotta beat down the national debt. Yep. And if Mr. Cunningham knew any history, he would know that the big spenders in  Canada and the US have been Conservatives and Republicans at every level of government. It's true. Check it out. The current world economic crisis began with the policies of Ronald Reagan -  a very conservative Republican. And it came crashing in on us with the neo-conservative George Bush.

Oh, and of course, Mr. Cunningham sees the real fat and waste in the public service. If he meant by this Harper going into the hole for 29 billion for fighter planes of no possible Canadian use, then he would be right. But he doesn't mean that. He means those stupid social workers who want to "nanny" unsafe families. He means those regulators who interfere with honest billionaires to make sure they don't pollute. He means those do gooders who think all families should have food.

Fat and waste mean money taken from us in excess of what is needed. If Mr. Cunningham takes the trouble to look at the shameful distribution of wealth in Canada and the US, he will see that most of the waste and fat are part of the wealth of the 100 or so wealthiest families in North America. Private business when it has few controls or regulations and when it can buy governments is a great producer of wealth. But it is a lousy distributor of it. The inevitable result of that sort of fat and wasteis what we are watching in the middle east and Africa - and possibly in the US this summer.

Cunningham concludes by saying that all we see in our political system is power lust and mud. Well, there is a lot of that going around and, in New Brunswick, it's encouraged by Brunswick Media. People are not well informed by most media of the issues. They are not only uninformed but fed with a constant diet of propaganda bolstered, I now realize, by an almost complete ignorance of politics encouraged by the newspapers.

In the recent provincial election, neither the Liberals nor the Conservatives had anything that could be called a platform. The Conservatives won simply because the Liberals were unpopular and Alward said he would listen to the people. Nobody at The Moncton Times had the honesty - or perhaps the wit - to point out that the great democratic leaders of the past century have been great not because they listened (you can rent a recording device to do that). The great leaders like Churchill and Roosevelt were elected because they said what they were goingn to do, people liked what they heard. A democracy does not vote for a "nanny" listener. It votes for a person of principles and vision and a vision that sounds sensible. But they can't do that in New Brunswick because the newspapers keep people in ignorance of what the issues are.

New Brunswick, thanks largely to its English newspapers, can only barely be called a democracy. Mr. Cunningham's column is a good illustration of how that has happened.

Thursday, March 10, 2011

March 10. How to write propaganda that looks like news.

"Urgent changes needed in N.B. budget: : experts"
That seems clear enough. It suggests this is a news report in which a number of experts (with all that word's hint of impartiality) say that budget changes are necessary. That is reinforced in the sub-head which refers to "some" advocates - though that sub head is not quite so clear. We still have a range of experts, it seems. But they're also advocates. Advocates of what?

It turns out the experts are just two people. Count them - two. Are there experts who disagree with them? The report doesn't mention any.

One of the experts is genuine enough. Donald Savoie of U de Moncton. He certainly seems a man whose opinions are worth paying attention to. But I taught in  unversities for forty years. I know the word expert is not so reassuring as it sounds. Virtually all profs, including me, have biases that affect their opinion at least as much as their studies affect them. Professor Savoie is certainly an expert. But hundreds of experts in his field will not only disaggree with him, but will be all over the map in their own opinions. There have even been some so rude as to disagree with me.

Perhaps the most notorious departments for bias in universities are Political Science and Economics. In this case, Professor Savoie is a political scientist writing on economics. Both fields are notorious for their wide range of biases. So what we have here is an opinion, not a judgement.

Professor Savoie's view is that we need an HST tax. That is a tax which hits low incomes the hardest. It hits the wealthy and corporations the least. I know lots of scholars who would disagree with that. They are experts, too.  Apparently, though, the Moncton Times knows only the one at U de Moncton.

The other "expert" is less impressive. He is the regional head of The Canadian Taxpayers' Association. Not only is he something less than an expert, he has been closely associated with several "think-tanks" (propaganda agences for corporations).. Of course he's opposed to raising taxes. That's what he's paid to do.

Lacey ends with a bizarre statement. He says the economy in Nova Scotia is suffering as a direct result of higher taxes than New Brunswick. Oh? Where did that cause and effect theory come from? Haiti has had virtually no taxes for a century. Foreign factory and factory farm corporations have certainly prospered under this system. But would Mr. Lacey hold up Haiti as an example of how effective it is to lower taxes?

And just to show that even experts like Professor Savoie and Mr. Lacey cannot agree. Savoie holds Nova Scotia up as an example of what New Brunswick should be doing.

So what was this "news" item really about? It is propaganda following up on a campaign the The Moncton Times and Transcript began a week ago, almost certainly on the orders of its masters. The message has nothing to do with a systematic quiestioning of experts. EVen the use of the word expert in its plural form is misleading. One is certainly expert in his field. But many experts in that same field don't agree with him. The other is not an expert; he's a hired front man for a pressure group.

This is not a news item. This is propaganda to make sure that Premier Alward doesn't do something foolish like raising taxes on coporations. (There's even a hint that if such taxes are raised, messrs Irving and Ganong and the rest will stamp their feet and leave the province - so we'll be the only jurisdiction in North America with no gas stations or boxes of chocolates.)

We should be so lucky.

Wednesday, March 9, 2011

March 9: L'Acadie Nouvelle

Since I get most of my news from the web, the only paper in New Brunswick I have read on a regular basis - with a sort of fascinated horror - is the Times and Tribune. But, today, I took the time to look through L'Acadie Nouvelle.

This is one, fine paper. It's not just that it reports news honestly, and writes editorials intelligently -and does both very well, indeed. .  But even better, as I read page after page, I got a strong sense of a real Acadian community - a community with social attachments, with awareness, with purpose for the common good, and with ambition.  I also got a strong sense that here was a newspaper that had respect for its readers.

In reading The Moncton Times and Transcript, I get no sense at all of an English-speaking community anywhere in New Brunswick. The sense I get is that there are no shared values or aspirations, that the Moncton Times has nothing but contempt for its readers. It sees them as a rabble of morons, much as the later emperors of Rome saw what we still refer to as the Roman "mob".. Like the emperors, it encourages triviality and ignorance. It treats its readers as lower creatures whose only purpose  is to be manipulated and wrung dry by the corporate aristocracy of New Brunswick.

That makes iti pretty much like most of the newspapers in the Maritimes and, indeed, across Canada and the U.S.

Acadians have a newspaper that respects them. New Brunswick anglos have newspapers that are Judas goats.

This is an attractive city full of people who could accomplish a great deal. But English-speaking ones are being sold out by their own major source of news and insight.

Pity.

March 9: The rant continues

Today's editorial in The Moncton Times and Transcript is much like its Phil Seeley comment of yesterday - and much like The Fraser Institute commentary and the editorial that preceded it. . "Moncton council failed to hold line".  It attacks the Moncton Council for agreeing to wage increase of 2.7% a year for city workers. This, in the view of the editorial writer is a scandalous waste - and I presume this is the same editorial writer who thought it was a neat idea to borrow $84 million for a hockey rink.

Two point seven percent in just one year?  How shameless!  Of course, it they were deserving people -like senior executives of auto companies who go broke, or of paper mills that want more crown land and maybe a grant or two, or foodpackers who want big tax cuts - raises of a hundred percent or more in a year are so reasonable the paper rarely evens reports on it.

The messsage is simple. As times get tough, pull out all the stops to make the rich richer and dump the rest of us to look after ourselves.

What a wretched excuse for a newspaper! No wonder they accept commentaries from a Phil Seeley.

There will  be another blog today, this time about a good newspaper.

Tuesday, March 8, 2011

March 8: A sequel to March 7 - or - you could see this one coming.

On March 7, The Moncton Times and Transcript ran a commentary by one of its favourite propaganda machines, The Fraser Institute. Disguised as an attack on corporations for taking too much of our money, it was really pitch for us to give them even more - in the form of lower taxes.

Today, it followed up with an attack on the federal Liberals for opposing lower corporation taxes. Unlike the Fraser Institute, it does offer some sources for its argument that low corporation taxes are good for everybody. The sources are Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters, the president of the Canadian Council of Chief Executives, the Canadian Chamber of Commerce - all those impartial and good-hearted people who care only about what is best for us serfs.  Oh, yeah. The writer also quoted Obama. Remember him? He's the guy who's presidential campaign was financed by Wall St.

And those people who want corporation to pay their share on  educating children or maintaining health care? Well, they are just layabouts who envy the corporate class. People who want to be able to heat their houses, feed their families, and get the chance of a good education are really looking for a "nanny" state that will "pillage and plunder" Canada's employers, then come for "our" wallets next. And when he said "our" he didn't mean you and me. He met the better sort like him and the rich people he advises and whom we are robbing so terribly that they don't know where their next billion will come from.

This commentary is so ignorant, so sneering, so arrogant, so condescending and such a professional kiss-up, I ended the reading with a strong urge to put a boot up his otherwise unattractive rear end.

Two things to note.

1. The Moncton Times and Tribune is off on another vicious campaign like the one to denigrate public schools and teachers. This time, they have found a commentator of even lower ethics than their usual editorial writer. Watch for more and worse. Obviously, Big Daddy is as interested in this crusade as he was in the one against p ublic schools.

2.  The commentator is listed as Phil Seely, a business advisor and a Moncton area pastor.
As it happens,  I am a religious person, and I take my faith seriously enough to avoid most of the churches - because I think they accomodate themselves far too much to the powerful and influential. But the tone of this commentary is much worse than a lazy and accomodating Christianity. In fact, in tone and message, it is the most thoroughly anti-Christian statement I have read.

Note to the editor - publish propaganda if you must.But please don't do it in such a contemptible manner.
Note to Moncton clergy - what do you think of a "pastor" who could write such a commentary? What would be your Christian evaluation of that pastor and his choice of friends?

Or are you too busy discussing just how thick the gold paving is on the streets of heaven?

Monday, March 7, 2011

March 7: Cute, really cute...

The Moncton Times and Tribune never met a big business propaganda outfit it didn't like. That's why comments by phony think-tanks so soften appear on the op-ed page. Today, it's The Fraser Institute, the one that makes the Irvings and McCains look like communists. But, oh, the approach is cute.

The heading is "How corporate welfare undermines core essential services". Wow! At last. Something about how handouts, grants, loans, concessions, etc. to big business take attention away for "core essential services".  Gee. Does this mean we're going to do less for business and more for people?

Well, no. Not actually.

It certainly says governments should give less to the corporations who fund their campaign expenses. But that's a safe thing to say since we all know (wink, wink) that isn't going to happen. In fact, the commentary,near its end, doesn't say we should hand out less to big business. It says we should hand out more. It just says it in a way that sounds as though it's getting realistic about business.

It says, near the end, we should give big business even more tax breaks.  But, gee golly whiz, isn't giving big business lower taxes just another way of letting it get more of our money? If we don't give a million in handouts, but do give a million in reduced taxes - gee, I have to close my eyes here, and think real hard but....isn't that really all the same thing? Doesn't big business still end up with more of our money?

And haven't economists long ago learned that cutting business taxes is the worst way to build an economy? (You'll find that in quite respectable books on economics. But "the researchers" at The Fraser Institute never read books like that.)

And what are "core essential services"? Health? Education? Decent housing? Higher minimum wage? No, No, No, and No. What the government should be doing is spending more money on putting more people into prison for longer periods. Let people suffer illness. Let schools collapse for lack of maintenance. Let people live in hovels. Let companies pay poverty-level wages.

The keys to Canada's future are lowering taxes for the rich, and putting more of the poor in jail.

What looks like a left wing stance to get tough on business is actually somewhere to the right of even Harper's platform for the next election.

That's cute.

Sunday, March 6, 2011

March 6: Is Moncton a good place to live?

I like Moncton very much. But it does have elements of the drab and listless about it, too. So, let's start with the bad part.

Moncton ( it's English newspaper  prefers the grander title of Metro Toronto) holds about 160,000 people within a province of less than 800,000.  Both the city and the province are dominated (indeed, saturated) by a handful of very wealthy families. One alone, Irving, is said to employ one person in ten in the province. Their domination - and their love of domination - reaches down to every level of life in the province.

The Irvings and their friends effectively control government at both provincial and local levels. It is a control so pervasive that most New Brunswickers, though they are well aware of the power of these people, are commonly afraid of any serious discussion since serious discussion will almost certainly touch on something that the Irvings and Ganongs and McCain's own or control.

The Irvings own all the English language newspapers in New Brunswick. And those papers are real stinkers by any measure. They are heavily biased on any subject favoured by the boss and the bias shows strongly in what they report and how they report it. They also give prominence to any report issued by the far right wing propaganda agencies for big business that call themselves think tanks - like The Fraser Institute and the Atlantic Institute of Market Studies.

The bias goes beyond bad to reporting that is often unethical, and editorials that are both unethical and loutish. Private radio and TV reporting on this region is not much better. CBC radio is here, but is limited in local  programming by being in a low priority area for English CBC. As well, like everything else down here, it has to remember that corporate interests have influence that extends all the way to Stephen Harper -who needs no urging to get rid of the CBC.

There is no serious discussion of  politics at any level. Nor is there much media information to base it on. Nor would it matter. The only paries with enough money to campaign are the Liberals and the Conservatives; and that money comes largely from corporations and the wealthy. In short, in this respect, New Brunswick politics are much like those of other provinces -but worse. It's just more obvious here.

The fear of open discussion has become the norm for daily life. And that has led to a society whose outlook is based on trivia. This is enouraged by The Moncton Times & Transcript whose mission appears to be to keep its readers uninformed and trivial. (This showed up in a recent provincial election in which neither party seemed to have anything that could be called a platform. The big difference was that the Conservative leader promised to listen to people. Hell,I used to have a dog who could do that.)

The defenders of families like the Irvings say they have developed New Brunswick with oil refining, paper, chemical plants, etc.  Nonsense.

The people of New Brunswick developed New Brunswick. Families like the Irvings took advantage of the people to get scandalously low rates for electricity for their industries, grants and low interest loans from the provincial and municipal governments, and access to a vast portion of the province's forests for cheap wood for their paper mills. The Irvings and others have certainly taken a great deal out of New Brunswick to enrich themselves; but they have been an obstacle to any real progress. To say we should be grateful to them is like a storekeeper feeling gratitude for the thief who robbed his till - but left a dollar for the cup of coffee he had taken.

Again, New Brunswick is not all that different from other provinces in any of the above. But the power in New Brunswick has a sense of closeness and obviousness in this small society, a sense that discourages both action and thought.

That may well be what explains the intellectual sterility and flabbiness of so many civil organizations, notably Home and School, Parent-Teachers Association and, most notably, the churches.

City services are pretty poor. That is probably because the city is largely concerned with grandiose schemes to "put Moncton on the map", often schemes to lend public money to billionaires so they can build things like an 80 million dollar stadium for their hockey team that nobody outside "metro" has ever heard of. They would also like a subsidized CFL team. There is little sign the public wants either of those. But who cares what the public thinks? Play up and play the game. The game is to soak the public to build facilities that the rich can then rent on special terms to make more money for themselves.

That's the bad part. But there's lots of good.

The first time I saw Moncton, thirty years ago, it was a pretty homely place that looked as if it should have been called Mudville. But it has quite transformed since that time. The city is generally attractive, even charming. (Parts of it could be even better with a little civic action; but that's where you feel the pressure of the billionaires, again.)

Like any city, it has those suburban-style developments where they cut down the trees, and named the streets after them.  But there are many (and not expensive) areas with trees that have escaped the axe for a century and more, lots of very pleasant and reasonably priced areas to live in. The nineteenth century architecture still common is often delightful. (It takes a while for a Montrealer to get used to the wood finish of most houses - but I've at last decided it's better on the eyes than brick.)

The people are the most courteous I have ever encountered. The use of first names is common right from the start, even in phoning offices about a bill. People are always friendly and helpful - though fitting in as an accepted Monctonian seems to be as slow as it is in most cities.

Monctonians all seem convinced they have the worst drivers in the world. I don't see why. I have seen only one common fault - passing on the right. Certainly, the courtesy of drivers down here is unmatched in any other country or city I have seen.

The problem is pedestrians. They can be expected, day or night, to suddenly step off the sidewalk at any point along a block, with looking either way, and stroll into the traffic. In Montreal, you could get points for hitting them. Here,drivers actually stop.

Moncton, though no metropolis, has a very satisfactory range of shopping, all of it within a ten minute drive of anywhere in the city. (In fact, almost anything is within a ten minute drive. I usually bicycle everywhere in summer,) I have no difficulty finding excellent shops for anything, including  exotica like art supplies or old books and 33 rpm records.

They also have a couple of Frenchy's stores. These are an experience that everybody in the world should have. They are part of a maritime chain of stores that sell clothing, often high-end and usually new, at absurdly low prices.

Police services are provided by the RCMP,  and are excellent.

The schools are excellent, too. They are underfunded, and interfered with by private business. This is happening all over North America as corporations attempt to get control of public education, and convert it to education for profit. They movement has been strong in the US (and also a colossal failure in educational terms). Kissing up to what corporate leaders want is why the local papers are always attacking the schools. But that is happening across Canada as corporations try to get control, and then to copy the American system of contracting out, ranking schools (a false science) and pushing for "freedom" of choice. Despite this, NB public schools, like all schools in Canada are still among the best in the world - far superior to the US, Britain, Germany...

The US schools are rated thirtieth in the world, and sliding down fast. But corporations and the media they own are working hard to take our system down the toilet with the American schools. However, NB, like most provinces, is holding out.

There are two, excellent and large parks in Moncton. One is an attractive strip of playing fields and walks along the river that extends for all of the downtown. The other is the well treed Centennial Park which has a large pond, a great water spray area for kids in summer, an outdoor swimming pool, and excellent sliding in winter. It also has enclosed dog runs.

Neighbourhood play parks for children seem to have been neglected.

The countryside is a fiften minute drive; and it's very attractive. Superb salt-water beaches are another five or ten minutes.

The YMCA has first rate facilities for exercise and swimming. Its social and intellectual programmes are not nearly as strong. There are places available, however - and it varies from year to year - for painting, acting, modelling (teaching girls how to dress and to use makeup intelligently), - though you have to search a bit to find the full range.  The Moncton Library is good, and offers groups for children and adults. Like the schools, it is underfunded - but not so badly as to hamper most readers.

The two hospitals, one French and one English, are both good and well-equipped. Both are within ten minutes of any part of the city. Both are so bilingual that I sometimes have to look for a nameplate to remember which one I'm in. More important, the language service you want is delivered as naturally as breathing. Official bilingualism works very well in New Brunswick. There is a certain amount of resentment of it, mostly from anglos. But I have never encountered any hostility speaking English to an Acadian - and only a mild amusement when I try my French.  There is very little here of the stresses and hatreds that have marked Quebec.

Moncton is an attractive city of convenient size. It is publicly friendly in a way that few cities are. It has easy access to a pleasant countryside and excellent beaches. On balance, I enjoy it very much.