Saturday, August 7, 2010

Provincial Elections

New Brunswick has Canada's second most tedious politics. (The leader is PEI.) Only two parties, Liberal and Conservative, have enough money to be able to put on serious campaigns. Both parties get the greater part of their money from Big Business in New Brunswick. Big Business does not donate money to political parties out of any patriotic love for the democratic system. It expects something, plenty, back.

I don't know of another province in Canada in which it is so obvious that big business owns the government. And the opposition.

Both parties,despite having different names, are really the same. Indeed, I doubt very much that any Liberals or Conservatives actually know what the words liberal and conservative mean. Seriously. I challenge any Liberal or Conservative respond to this (if they're not afraid they'll be reported for responding to a blog) to tell us what those two words mean, and how the principles of those words guide their policies.

The NDP and the Green Party don't have enough money to mount a serious campaign. Big business never liked the NDP, and it doesn't give a damn about the environment. Even if the NDP and the Greens did mount an interesting campaign, it would never get reported accurately (or at all) in 90% of the NB news media. Guess why.

The People's Alliance? No way. They don't get corporate money either. In any case, their idea of  MLAs  voting on each issue is a very old idea. It's been put forward in both Canada and the US, and even tried on occasion. In Canada, it was called direct democracy, and was a hot item in 1930s Alberta. It doesn't work.
Quite apart from the logistical problems and costs that would come up with getting a measure of local opinion in every riding for every bill that comes up would be impossible. And there's an even bigger problem.

Many bills are complex matters that require expert opinion. Getting that expert opinion means spending every day studying reports, some of them hundreds of pages long. It would also require every citizen to be an expert in economics, sociology, law and a dozen other subjects. Not many people are going to sit up every night reading reports. And if they did - remember that this is a province in which almost half the population is functionally illiterate.

There is no party that looks at the fundamental problem of politics in New Brunswick (and not just in New Brunswick.) Even the People's Alliance misses it. The problem is not that the government doesn't listen to the people. They problem is that it does listen to big business. We have a legislature of puppets.

What this province needs is to take a hard look at the funding of political parties. It needs to cut down on corporate control of the election system. Now, how one can get that message across, I don't know. To get the message out, you need news coverage. And there is no chance of getting honest and complete coverage from a good 90% of the province's news media.

Friday, August 6, 2010

Language Wars and New Brunswick

There is a crisis in the making in this province. It concerns language. And both sides are acting in a way guaranteed to make it worse. It's important when problems arise to deal with them by action. But action is not the same as reaction. Action means taking a sober look at the realities, at what must be done to ease the tensions, at what must be done to satisfy needs.

Reaction is something quite different. Reaction is attacking the other side who earlier reacted by attacking you, and who will next act by re-attacking you.

Reaction is what we're watching among both French and English. I have been through this before, in Quebec. In fact, I was more pominent in it than I cared to be. For a half dozen years, I was on the provincial executive of the Quebec English rights group, Alliance Quebec. Then I was vice-president for two years, then Chairman of the Board for two more. That was ten years of long hours of meetings every week, travelling the province, getting death threats on the phone, being warned by police to evacuate our building because of danger of mob violence...the whole schmeer.

That's the direction New Brunswick is heading. And it's heading that way because both English and French are reacting instead of acting.

It began with the English majority for two centuries either ignoring the Acadians or treating them like second class citizens if, indeed, they were regarded as citizens at all. At last, action began, and began well, under Robichaud and his successors. Then reaction stepped in. Remember mayor Jones? Nor was he the only one. I was surprised when I first moved here to see how deep was English resentment of Acadians. That was a reaction to their increased prominence in New Brunswick life.

Reaction has bred another reaction - Dieppe's desire for French on all signs of business. I've been there. Done that. You have no idea of the hatreds, fears, and legal and social complexities of going that route. Just discussing it noticeably worsened language relations.

And that reaction bred another reaction - an anglo organization that wants to plant its flag, especially on the anniversary of the Battle of the Plains of Abraham, as the symbol of English domination.  Expect now a counter-reaction which will make things worse.

This is not only foolish. I strongly suspect that both English and French are being used as dupes in a bigger game. And both English and French are being dumb enough to play along with it.

In recent years, the Bloc Quebecois has been extending its influence to French speakers in other provinces. The demand for bilingual signs on private businesses, for example, was effectively used to stir up fears and hatreds in Quebec - to the benefit of the Bloc. That is not, so far as I know, the typical behaviour of Acadians. But I note that a major figure in starting this signs campaign is a local person who studied in Quebec.

I also noticed a recent letter to the editor in The Moncton T&T. It referred to the warning that Quebec would back up the Acadians in their struggle against the English. Would it now?  It might. Stir up enough hatred, and that could pay off in Bloc seats - and it could also be a bargaining chip in separation negotiations with Canada.

So here we have English and French fish swimming around and trying to get a worm - and neither side smart enough to notice it's on a hook.

This is not a time for reaction by either side. Dieppe is being suckered into a bylaw that is of almost no practical value, and which stirs up hatreds. The anglo group (whose name I forget and would prefer not to remember) has also been suckered. Sticking up invented flags does nothing useful, and simply stirs up more hatreds.

Grow up, both sides. This is not a time for reaction. This is a time for action.

credit where credit it due

In the Friday, August 6 edition,  there is a superb commentary by Norbert Cunningham in his "ToThe Contrary" column. It deals with the problem of plagiarism by university students (that is, copying the work of others, and submitting it as their own.) It's a constant problem. In my early years of teaching at UPEI, a student submitted a paper that was a word for word copy of an article in a historial journal. I was sure of it because I had read the journal. I also wrote the article in the first place. (Maybe he was just trying to flatter me?)

Cunningham dismisses the assertion of some professors that plagiarism today is not really plagiarism at all. Students are copying, they say, the wealth of material that is available on the internet. So it's not plagiarism. It's the "new creativity". Cunningham is quite right to dismiss tnat nonsense. Plagiarism is copying and claiming it as your own work. Whether it's from books or the web or two big,stone tablets being carried down a mountain by an old man, if you write that down and claim it as your work, that's plagiarism.

Cunningham indicates no great respect for professors who explain away such behaviour. He says they delude themselves. He is being kind. Universities are full of pompous asses who think they live in clouds far above us earthlings, and who say quite silly things.

I would just add a footnote to Cunningjam's excellent piece. In my experience of university teaching, students plagiarize because most professors don't know how to teach them to do research, how to make judgements, and how to write a research paper. And, in my experience as a student, most professors don't even try to do it, That's the major reason why students cheat.

I realized early in my first years at UPEI that I had better learn how to teach these essentials if I expected to serious results. So I worked out a way to do it. The result, with a few years of development, was that plagiarism dropped off to nearly zero.

The Moncton Times&Transcript. August 6. Bottom of the editorial page. It's a keeper.

Saturday, July 17, 2010

an example of bad editing.

Newspaper pages are valuable and limited. So a good editor makes sure any story that appears is worth the space it is given. On Saturday, July 17, p. A7, The Times&Transcript carried a half page story that said close to nothing. It's not the reporter's fault. He could write only the information he had received. It was the editor's fault for assigning a story where there was none.

"Provincial Party Marks Improve" screamed the headline. Then it told anxious readers that The Coalition of New Brunswickers had announced the July grades for New Brunswick's political parties. Good. There's no doubt we need more awareness of how far below any standard New Buunswick's poliitical parties are. (That applies to all of them.)

A useful start might be to tell readers who the coalition is, what qualifications it has to issue a grade sheet, and exactly how it carried out its studies. The story didn't. So I checked in Google. It seems a well intentioned group; and I think I might wish it well.  But I still have no idea of its qualifications, size, or composition.

Then I checked the categories of marking. Public Participation? What does that mean? The number of party members? The frequency of public meetings? Public consultations? Exactly what does Public Participation mean to the coalition. The story never tells us.

Govvernment Ethics? Only one party has been in government this past month. How come they all get marks on government ethics? Does this really mean written statements of Government Ethics? How come the NDP scored highest, going from D to A in just one month? Does the Liberal F mean they have no ethics? Well, possibly. But, spefically, what is meant by government ethics? What were they looking for?

Exactly what does Code of Conduct mean? What characteristics was the coalition looking for? The NDP got a D for Code of Conduct? What? They's bunch of drunken peeping Toms? They're on the take from big business?

Electoral Reform? Same question. Is the coalition looking for any sort of reform? Or does it have a specific one in mind?

And how did the coalition get its data? It seems they just asked the politicians. Phoof!

All this article tells us is that The Coalition of New Brunswickers (and I don't question its good intentions) has to clear up its thinking about exactly what it's doing, and the way it's doing it - and the way it releases information to the news media.

So why did the editor decide to run a non-story and give it half a page? Because no newspaper editor in New Brunswick would dare to print any real investigation of the ethics, conduct or anything else of a serious nature about New Brunswick politics. We certainly don't want to hurt anybody's feelings.

Wednesday, July 14, 2010

The Reason Why...

The blog below was written for a church website I belong to. (Wondercafe) The site offers a range of topic categories from politics to religion to social.  I decided to copy it here because it has particular meaning for those who live in New Brunswick.  It's in the religious category. But don't let that scare you. It's also about reality.

A confession and a complaint

Posted on: 07/14/2010 18:52

The confession is that, with the exception of a few times when I led the service, I have not attended church for a full year. Partly it's because I moved, leaving behind what was both a community and a congregation (and it's my former church that I occasionally returned to as a preacher.) I don't yet feel any such sense of community where I now live. But that's not the whole story.



In 1957, a woman named Ayn Rand published an enormously popular book, "Atlas Shrugged". It's theme was that we should not love our neighbour. Loving your neighbour is bad. Rather, we should each of live only for ourselves, do nothing except in our own interest, and have no morality whatever. Some people called it a bible whose gospel was "greed is good". Some people were right. It is a complete denial of the validity of every major religion in the world.



Not surprisingly, the wealthy and greedy, annoyed by intrusions like government regulation of oil drilling, mediicare, employment insurance, democracy, took up the new gospel with zeal. They even formed temples to attract converts. They called the temples think-tanks. We know them as the Cato Institute, the Simon Fraser Institute, the CD Howe, the Atlantic Institute for Marketing in Canada.



They preach a gospel of complete freedom for each person to do whatever he wishes to do for his own satisfaction - and without the slightest regard for anyone else. They often call themselves conservatives or neo-conservatives or libertarians. In fact, they have no connection with real conservatism or with liberty. They are simjply advocates of complete power for themsellves with no responsibility whatever.



They support the rape and theft of whole nations like Congo, Haiti, Guatemala. In fact, they are the rapists and thieves of many such countries. Everything on earth is simply something to make them richer. This is no exaggeration. That's why I am so much opposed to the standardized testing and ranking of public schools that they advocate.



They want our children. Their "scientific " sudies of education are garbage; and they know it. They don't give a damn about education. And the only damn they care about children is that they can make money out of them. If it hurts them, so what? The gospel of Ayn Rand is self interest. Besides, they send their own children to private schools.



The gospel of Ayn Rand , with major help from the think tanks ,and thanks to the cooperation of our news media (most of it either biased or gutless), has become a major force in American life. And you're going to see a lot of it in both Canada and the US as governments look to cut budgets.



The province of New Brunswick is virtually owned by disciples of Ayn Rand. So is much of Ontario, and pretty much all of Alberta. This is not only a dismissal of basic concepts of every major faith. It is also going to increase the levels of physical, moral and spiritual damage in the very near future.



This isn't atheism. Most atheists understand morality. But this is a direct assault on the whole Judaeo/Christian/Moslem tradition. If there were a devil, this would be the devil's gospel. It is also unworkable.



The current recession is a direct result of the work of admirers of Ayn Rand. You can put Alan Greenspan at the top of the list. American banking collapsed , partly because of rampant corruption, but more because Randist bankers didn't want regulation. Then Americans went deep into debt to give them bailouts plus bonusses for their work. Medicare in the US was defeated because Insurance and health company Randists buried Congress and the media under tons of money. We are on the edge of much worse that is to come, much worse in war, in torture, accumulation of super-wealth, in suffering, in decline of democracy for all of us but the very wealthy.



And while all of this has been growing for over fifty years, and while millions have been killed and tortured to satisfy greed, the churches have stood around with their faces hanging out. Some will huff and puff about homosexuals and other religion groups we have slated for killing. But all will happily welcome the thieves and murderers who now want our children.



I think this is a religious issue. And I don't feel like wasting time in a church which welcomes advocates of thieving and murder while the preacher prattles about abstractions. Nor, for much the same reason, do I often visit this religious section.



I really don't give a damn about threads on whether we will get cable television in Heaven.



graeme

Tuesday, July 13, 2010

Asking the Right Questions of the Right People

We think of a good journalist as being someone who reports the facts. But almost anyone can do that. It's simply a matter of, for example, seeing a car hit a fire hydrant on Main St., and reporting a car hit a fire hydrant on Main St.  But there is something else essential to good reporting - knowing which questions to ask, and who to ask. We don't see much of that in Moncton.

When the decision was announced to build an 84 million dollar hockey arena in Moncton, reporters asked the wrong question of the wrong person. The result was a wasted front page on the Moncton T&T that left nobody any the wiser.

The T&T reporter asked the owner of the Moncton hockey team if this was a good idea for Moncton. Why on earth would he ask the owner? Is he an expert on town planning? If so, shouldn't the report have mentioned his credentials?

The team owner replied it would be good for the city and would revive downtown. Of course he did. He's getting the use of a brand new 84 million dollar stadium, all paid for by the rest of us. But it's a safe bet he has no idea what effect it will have on Moncton, ir whether the benefits will justify the huge cost.

Moncton is being rushed into steep debt, and one that means taking money away from other city needs. It's rather like buying  an expensive car that has no record because its the first one of its make to come off the line - and we plunge ourselves into years of debt for it without even kicking the tires.

So here are some hints for anyone who wants to be a reporter, and needs to know how to ask the right questions of the right people.
1. Ask the mayor what benefits the city will gain from an $84 million dollar stadium.
2. Ask the mayor for the reports by experts in urban planning who recommended this stadium. (And check out exactly who these experts are if, indeed, there are any such repoprts at all.)
3. Ask the mayor for the full list of projects the council considered as needs for the city. Ask for the reports of urban planners on their opinions of the list.
4. Ask the mayor for estimates of the full cost of maintaining the arena.
5. Ask the mayor whether Moncton will bear the full cost of maintenance.
6. Ask the maor who it is that owns the land which will have to be purchased for the site.
7. If a councillor opposed it, ask that councillor why.
8. Then ask the owner of the hockey team something he should know something about such as:
    a) the owner belongs to a family and economic class with close ties to Atlantic Institute for Marketing Studies. This is a "think tank" dedicated to the ideas that taxes and government owndership are bad. Why are taxes and public ownership suddently desirable in this case?
    b) If the arena is going to be such a big money earner, why doesn't the hockey team owner pay for it himself, and keep all those big profits?

Warning - if you follow this advice, don't expect the story ever to appear in most New Brunswick news media.

Saturday, July 10, 2010

Unconventional Wisdom in the T&T

Saturday, July 10, 2010. Moncton Times&Transcript. pageD9 - the op ed page (page opposite the editorial page.)

A columnist begins by noting that he saw very few prostitutes or panhandlers or homeless in downtown Torntol, ditto downtown Montreal. He felt safer in those cities because of that. He also felt safer because of the large numbers of people using the downtown streets. He feels very vulnerable in downtown Moncton.

Then he mentions that Moncton has one of the lowest crime rates in Canada. There must be a logical link between those two statements. Somewhere. Maybe. But it's hard to follow the thinking patterns of a person. who doesn't even see prostitutes and panhandlers in Montreal.

In Montreal, I have, on an overspending evening in a crowded downtown, had to step over the bodies of sleeping homeless to get to an ATM machine. In downtown Toronto, I have walked through downtown streets with a friend who always had his pockets full of change which he handed out constantly as we walked, and without a break in our conversation.

As for hookers, they are all over downtowns. After all, they aren't going to find many customers on woodland trails. The higher priced ones work downtown restaurants and clubs, usually paying a cut to the proprietors who also rent rooms to them. The economy hookers use the alleways of nearby residential districts.

As well,  mobsters are regulars among the downtown crowds in a city. Of course. They're selling drugs through the bartenders, checking the hookers for their cut, and sharing the bar with visiting journalists who can't see any hookers or homeless.

Ask any urban planner, he says. The best and most memorable cities have the best downtowns. Really?  Perhaps we could have the names and writings of some of these urban planners. Obviously, they must have missed much of New York, Detroit, Amsterdam (where whole downtown streets are given over to prostitutes, male and female, standing in floor length windows to display their wares).

Again, we have the T&T view that an $85,000,000 arena to be built (and maintained) with taxpayers' money would revive downtwon. And, again, I would love to see serious studies that show such projects revive a downtown. I have seen no evidence they do any such thing. They do, however, act as a powerful attraction for hookers and panhandlers. Check out Maple Leaf Gardens.

And, inevitably, there is the call for more parking. Right. Malls, precisely because of easy parking, all over the western world have destroyed downtowns. So let's encourage even more cars. Let's make downtown a mall. Very perceptive.

Let's hope there are going to be tourists in the coming years. (We'll just forget about the world's economic state -which is not getting better; and we'll forget about the cost of driving going up quite spectacularly). Very few tourists are going to travel to Moncton to have a beer at a sidewalk bar while looking at a massive arena wall.

You want to see tourists? Go to the American museum, to Broadway and off Broadway in New York, the many museums in Ottawa, the galleries in even the smallest cities of Europe, the theatres. I remember one European city, a small one, which had an alleyway of excellent, simple restaurants. It was well worth the trip; and those restaraunts were opened with a good deal less than 85 million. Of course, Moncton would have to spend a little bit of money to bring in good cooks.

Before we plunge into an 85 million dollar debt to build a white elephant, it might be wise to get some serious advice about what Moncton really needs to draw people to the downtown area. It can't be big stores because the malls are much better than that. It can't be an arena with parking for at least 5,000 cars, an arena which will be closed most of the time. EVen open, the main dining will be hot dogs and fries.

However passionate Monctonians feel about their hockey team, most of the world has never heard of it, and doesn't care. Nor do most people in Moncton. For all the hype in our news media, barely two percent go to a hockey game.

It's time for Moncton to grow up. It's time get a serious handle on what our priorities are. Take a good look at the big kids. They offer something more than hockey, beer and fries.