Friday, July 2, 2010. The Moncton Times&Transcript. Page C3. "Parents bridge cultural gap." It's a pleasant story of how immigrants from Congo have settled in Moncton and, in the process, enriched our culture. The occasion was a celebration of the creation of the Democratic Republic of Congo in 1960. It mentions the enormous mineral riches in Congo. It mentions political coups by the army. It mentions that some three million were killed in a recent civil war. It's all true.
And it's also one hell of a lie.
If the land is rich, why are the people so poor and uneducated after well over a century of western control and influence?
Why did the army stage coups?
Is the killing of three million unusual in Congo?
Has anybody profited from all this? (hint - include prominent Canadians in your guessing.)
This impression left by this story is that the people of Congo are just ignorant savages who don't know how to run a country. It was written to give that impression. But there's a bigger story.
It was in the 1880s that European leaders agreed to give Congo (which they didn't own) to Belgium. At the time, the attraction was rubber and ivory. The reason given for the handover to Belgium was to bring Christianity and civilization.
The reality has been over a hundred and twenty years of some of the most brutal murdering, torturing, maiming and thieving in human history. The game at first was British, Belgian and French private business forcing the Congolese to work as slaves - torturing and murdering those who refused or tried to run away. Those who stayed were worked, quite literally, to death. There is no possible count of how many died; but it may easily and by far have exdeeded 10 million.
Joseph Conrad visited Congo at the height of the brutality. The result was his novel, Heart of Darkness. It's the story of how British,Belgians and French businessmen took billions out of that country, leaving only death and starvation behind them.
Belgium could no longer hold Congo after World War Two. So it gave Congo independence - leaving behind no schools, no hospitals, nothing. Congolese elected their first prime minister. He wasn't just deposed by the army. He was murdered. Why did the army do it? Well, the British, French and Belgian businessmen were still there, now joined by the US and Canada. Canadian mining companies had already established one of the worst records in the world for pollution and exploitation. (Just check Canada's record in UN reports on the subject.) Lumumba was said to be thinking of taxing the mining companies to build hospitals and schools. Guess who bought the army off to kill him.
Ever since, there has been turmoil and murder and rape on a scale unmatched anywhere in the world. To the several millions killed in the recent civil war, add more than five million dying just in the last ten years for what the UN lists as "war-related causes".
While the Moncton T&T celebrates fifty years of independence for a country that has never been independent, while western mining companies continue to suck billions out of Congo, eighty percent of the Congolese have to live on less than 30 cents a day. Taxes are close to zero for the companies. Wages are low and hours long by any standard. There is virtually no medical care or schooling for the Congolese.
And Canadians are right up front with the butchers. The board of a gold mining company boasted one of Canada's finest sons on its board of directors. Brian Mulroney.
And, when he was leader of the PCs, Joe Clark was an advisor to a Canadian mining company with a particularly evil reputation at the UN.
As in much of our journalism, the Moncton T&T story looked as though it was telling the truth. But by not telling the whole truth, it misled us as to the full horror of the Congo, and whose fault it has been. It wasn't done by ignorant savages. It was and is done by civilized Christians.
A critical review of local and world news. This blog originally commented on the Moncton Times and Transcript but has enlarged its scope.
Friday, July 2, 2010
Thursday, July 1, 2010
Who Is AIMS
Somebody should take up a collection to buy computers for Moncton reporters. Then they could do some easy research,and use a little more sense when reporting on the Atlantic Institute of Marketing Studies.
The could, for example, check out Charles Cirtwell, President and CEO of AIMS, a prominent spokesman on educational issues. His training and experience in education? Zero.
His publishing record consists largely (if the word largely can be used at all) of artcles for extreme right wing American publications such as The American Spectator. His own bio claims he has done extensive research on education. ( Busy man. Extensive research on education, government, free enterprise, etc., all while doing his job as CEO). You have to admire him as a worker who can, in his spare time, demolish most of the ressearch on education that has been published by thousands of educations scholars all over the world in the past century.
He has links with CATO, the very far right wing "think tank" based in Washington.
He is also an expert on health care, and crticizices the Canadian system for wasting money - nicely ignoring the fact that it something like half the cost per person of the US one, and serves ALL the Canadian people. Oh, and he also ignores the difference in health ratings between Americans and Canadians.
He writes approval of Premier Harris of Ontario, who introduced repayment of $3500 to parents to sent their children to private schools. Gee. I wonder who had to make up for that generosity to private schools?
Unusual, iin my eperience of reports, is that there is no listing of exactly who did the research, and who drew the conclusions from it. I mean, that's pretty important. If a small group of researchers got together in Halifax and disproved the research of highly qualified experts all over the world, they must be whoopie-doo experts. Shouldn't AIMS really impress us by saying who they are?
Oh, interesting note. AINS is hiring. They are looking for education researchers who are interested in the free enterprise system, in private schools and, well, anybody who agrees that the answers they already have are right. AIMS is one of the think tanks that starts with answers, then writes propaganda and pseudo-science to prove them.
The AIMS webs site is an interesting read - vague propaganda very skilfully written. But there is no evidence, and no sign of whoever researched this stuff.
Great job, all you Moncton news media. When Jeb Bush ( also a man with no educational training or experience but with a lot of experience in the care and feeding of billionaires) spoke here, Mr. John Irving, founding Chairman of AIMS was here. But you really should have taken the opportunity to ask Mr. Irving how long he has been concerned about education. And why.
And is it really true that most of the professors of education are so ignorant that they disagree with the findings of AIMS. Well, then, why don't we fire them all? We could replace them with distinguished thinkers named Irving.
The could, for example, check out Charles Cirtwell, President and CEO of AIMS, a prominent spokesman on educational issues. His training and experience in education? Zero.
His publishing record consists largely (if the word largely can be used at all) of artcles for extreme right wing American publications such as The American Spectator. His own bio claims he has done extensive research on education. ( Busy man. Extensive research on education, government, free enterprise, etc., all while doing his job as CEO). You have to admire him as a worker who can, in his spare time, demolish most of the ressearch on education that has been published by thousands of educations scholars all over the world in the past century.
He has links with CATO, the very far right wing "think tank" based in Washington.
He is also an expert on health care, and crticizices the Canadian system for wasting money - nicely ignoring the fact that it something like half the cost per person of the US one, and serves ALL the Canadian people. Oh, and he also ignores the difference in health ratings between Americans and Canadians.
He writes approval of Premier Harris of Ontario, who introduced repayment of $3500 to parents to sent their children to private schools. Gee. I wonder who had to make up for that generosity to private schools?
Unusual, iin my eperience of reports, is that there is no listing of exactly who did the research, and who drew the conclusions from it. I mean, that's pretty important. If a small group of researchers got together in Halifax and disproved the research of highly qualified experts all over the world, they must be whoopie-doo experts. Shouldn't AIMS really impress us by saying who they are?
Oh, interesting note. AINS is hiring. They are looking for education researchers who are interested in the free enterprise system, in private schools and, well, anybody who agrees that the answers they already have are right. AIMS is one of the think tanks that starts with answers, then writes propaganda and pseudo-science to prove them.
The AIMS webs site is an interesting read - vague propaganda very skilfully written. But there is no evidence, and no sign of whoever researched this stuff.
Great job, all you Moncton news media. When Jeb Bush ( also a man with no educational training or experience but with a lot of experience in the care and feeding of billionaires) spoke here, Mr. John Irving, founding Chairman of AIMS was here. But you really should have taken the opportunity to ask Mr. Irving how long he has been concerned about education. And why.
And is it really true that most of the professors of education are so ignorant that they disagree with the findings of AIMS. Well, then, why don't we fire them all? We could replace them with distinguished thinkers named Irving.
Tuesday, June 29, 2010
The Beginning of how New Brunswick Got into a mess in Education.
It began eighty years with the great depression and then the war. In the terrible years of the great depression, there was no health care for most people even in the most advanced western countries. There was no employment insurance. In the US, Roosevelt introduced a small pension to ease some of the suffering. Canada maintained what it had - a pension available to those absolutely destitute which was so small as to be incapable of supporting life. There were almost no social services. Almost all government intervention in the economy was there to help business. An example was the protective tariff which gave Canadian manufacturers a captive market; and did so by raising costs for most Canadians.
The depression made it clear even to the politicians that something more would have to be done. Then came the war. After ten years of depression came six years of war, and more sacrifices and suffering. Governments had to make promises to keep up the willingness and ability of the Canadian people to suffer those years.
As it happened, the war also proved that government intervention in the economy could be extremely efficient and effective. Indeed, Canadian governments did an impressive job of managing the economy, leaving very little room for the free market, thoughtout the war. When the war ended, then, Canadians expected much more from their governments than they ever had before.
The Liberals and Conservatives, though both dominated by big businss, had to make some gestures if only to keep the CCF party at bay. As early as 1942, it was leading both Liberals and Conservatives in popularity. That's what led to Liberal reforms such as child bonus payments, and Conservative ones to increase the pension to an (almost) liveable size. Similar movement was occuring throughout the western world. Though it has largely been forgotten, government management of the economy and social concerns was so great that business leaders actually studied the the civil service's methods to improve their own.
But big business was also alarmed at the trend. The alarm was greatest in the US where business feared greater taxation for corporations and the rich as government assumed a larger role; it feared regulation; it feared government intrusion into profitable fields such as health, pharmaceutics, and insurance.
Their response that emerged in the 1950s was the adoption of the idea of think tanks. These had existed for some time, gatherings of specialists to study various problems, and to issue reports. The new feature was to use think tanks for ideological purposes. The purpose was to broaden the involvement of private business in social matters; to praise the benefits of cutting taxes to corporations and the rich; to get rid of regulations.
Accordingly, the think tank "experts" knew their conclusions before they began their studies They were in favour of private profit, and against any role for government (with the exception of giving contracts to supporters of the think tank - as in the case of health insurance and the defence industry.) So, with the support of wealthy backers, the think tanks, perhaps bolstered by a "rent a prof", would carry out pseudo-scientific reports which really were propaganda.
The news media were cooperative. Of course. They were largely owned by the same people who owned the think tanks. Any report was guaranteed wide and favourable coverage. There was one given prominent space in newspapers about five years ago, and approving comment on TV and radio. It was a report by the grandly titled Montreal Economic Institute. It "proved" that climate change was not happening.
That report, which dismissed years of research by eminent scientists all over the world, was done by one man. He had no scientific training. I checked where he got his information. He got it from two books. Count them. Two. One was a recent book by one of the minority of scientists who say climate change is not happening. The other was a book on economics printed in the middle of the nineteenth century. Go figure. While you're at it, try to think of a single article or editorial in the Moncton T&T which has ever been critical of AIMS or of standardized testing.
So were born the Fraser Institute, The CDHowe Institute, and the Atlantic Institute of Market Studies. The latter, in defiance of hundreds of years of research by thousands of education scholars, has been given effective control of New Brunswick schools.
The general aim of these "think tanks" is to discredit all public instutions, and ease the way to a gradual privatization of everthing - including schools. They play the press like a harp. When Jeb Bush gave a speech on education, attended largely by business people and sponsored by AIMs, none of the media had the wit or the inclination to ask the obvious questions.
Has Jeb Bush ever taught? Is he considered an authority on education? Why? Why was an education conference attended by so many leading business people?
The general tactic against public education is the same one used so effectively against government, against health care. Look for isolated instances of things that go wrong. Get them played up in the news media. In the case of education, debase teachers, highlight minor or isolated problems in education to give the impression the system is falling apart.
And the real capper - give the contract for supervising the testing to the think tank that is advocating it. That means the same people who want standardized testing are the ones who get to report on it and say whether it is working. And you know what? Surprise. AIMS reports that its standardized tests do show an improvement in the system. And that takes a step further to private for profit education.
Educationally, standardized testing is a scam. Economically, it's a waste of millions. Educationally, it's damaging. There's also a moral aspect.
You've heard of neo-conservatism? This is a movement which is heavily pro business and anti government. Its leaders were the ones who wanted to invade Iraq. Their statement of purpose and their programme is on the web. See "Project for the New American Century". One of the people who signed it is Jeb Bush, the "educator." In the process of developing their extreme right wing philosophy, they also modernized the ten cmmandments.
As they have often said, publicly enough, greed is not bad. Greed is good. Greed and competition make everybody rich. This comes from Jeb Bush, whose family has made its millions for three generations out of government connections. (George Sr., before becoming head of the CIA, ran a business front for it). Their new gospel is to be found in the writing of their patron saint, Ayn Rand (notably in "Atlas Shrugged")
Not surpringly, they rarely mention countries that have allowed free rein to greed and competition for over a century, countries like Congo and Haiti and Guatemala.
Greed is a moral good. Competition is a moral good. Schools aren't for children. They're something to make money out of. Our children are not there to be taught. They are there to be used for profit - as we use factories and ore and oil. And if we ruin earth in the processes of burning and refining and spilling the oil, who cares? And if we ruin the children. who cares? Greed is good.
AIMs is not only incompetent and untrustworthy to have any influence over our children. It is also bloody immoral about the way it is using them.
The depression made it clear even to the politicians that something more would have to be done. Then came the war. After ten years of depression came six years of war, and more sacrifices and suffering. Governments had to make promises to keep up the willingness and ability of the Canadian people to suffer those years.
As it happened, the war also proved that government intervention in the economy could be extremely efficient and effective. Indeed, Canadian governments did an impressive job of managing the economy, leaving very little room for the free market, thoughtout the war. When the war ended, then, Canadians expected much more from their governments than they ever had before.
The Liberals and Conservatives, though both dominated by big businss, had to make some gestures if only to keep the CCF party at bay. As early as 1942, it was leading both Liberals and Conservatives in popularity. That's what led to Liberal reforms such as child bonus payments, and Conservative ones to increase the pension to an (almost) liveable size. Similar movement was occuring throughout the western world. Though it has largely been forgotten, government management of the economy and social concerns was so great that business leaders actually studied the the civil service's methods to improve their own.
But big business was also alarmed at the trend. The alarm was greatest in the US where business feared greater taxation for corporations and the rich as government assumed a larger role; it feared regulation; it feared government intrusion into profitable fields such as health, pharmaceutics, and insurance.
Their response that emerged in the 1950s was the adoption of the idea of think tanks. These had existed for some time, gatherings of specialists to study various problems, and to issue reports. The new feature was to use think tanks for ideological purposes. The purpose was to broaden the involvement of private business in social matters; to praise the benefits of cutting taxes to corporations and the rich; to get rid of regulations.
Accordingly, the think tank "experts" knew their conclusions before they began their studies They were in favour of private profit, and against any role for government (with the exception of giving contracts to supporters of the think tank - as in the case of health insurance and the defence industry.) So, with the support of wealthy backers, the think tanks, perhaps bolstered by a "rent a prof", would carry out pseudo-scientific reports which really were propaganda.
The news media were cooperative. Of course. They were largely owned by the same people who owned the think tanks. Any report was guaranteed wide and favourable coverage. There was one given prominent space in newspapers about five years ago, and approving comment on TV and radio. It was a report by the grandly titled Montreal Economic Institute. It "proved" that climate change was not happening.
That report, which dismissed years of research by eminent scientists all over the world, was done by one man. He had no scientific training. I checked where he got his information. He got it from two books. Count them. Two. One was a recent book by one of the minority of scientists who say climate change is not happening. The other was a book on economics printed in the middle of the nineteenth century. Go figure. While you're at it, try to think of a single article or editorial in the Moncton T&T which has ever been critical of AIMS or of standardized testing.
So were born the Fraser Institute, The CDHowe Institute, and the Atlantic Institute of Market Studies. The latter, in defiance of hundreds of years of research by thousands of education scholars, has been given effective control of New Brunswick schools.
The general aim of these "think tanks" is to discredit all public instutions, and ease the way to a gradual privatization of everthing - including schools. They play the press like a harp. When Jeb Bush gave a speech on education, attended largely by business people and sponsored by AIMs, none of the media had the wit or the inclination to ask the obvious questions.
Has Jeb Bush ever taught? Is he considered an authority on education? Why? Why was an education conference attended by so many leading business people?
The general tactic against public education is the same one used so effectively against government, against health care. Look for isolated instances of things that go wrong. Get them played up in the news media. In the case of education, debase teachers, highlight minor or isolated problems in education to give the impression the system is falling apart.
And the real capper - give the contract for supervising the testing to the think tank that is advocating it. That means the same people who want standardized testing are the ones who get to report on it and say whether it is working. And you know what? Surprise. AIMS reports that its standardized tests do show an improvement in the system. And that takes a step further to private for profit education.
Educationally, standardized testing is a scam. Economically, it's a waste of millions. Educationally, it's damaging. There's also a moral aspect.
You've heard of neo-conservatism? This is a movement which is heavily pro business and anti government. Its leaders were the ones who wanted to invade Iraq. Their statement of purpose and their programme is on the web. See "Project for the New American Century". One of the people who signed it is Jeb Bush, the "educator." In the process of developing their extreme right wing philosophy, they also modernized the ten cmmandments.
As they have often said, publicly enough, greed is not bad. Greed is good. Greed and competition make everybody rich. This comes from Jeb Bush, whose family has made its millions for three generations out of government connections. (George Sr., before becoming head of the CIA, ran a business front for it). Their new gospel is to be found in the writing of their patron saint, Ayn Rand (notably in "Atlas Shrugged")
Not surpringly, they rarely mention countries that have allowed free rein to greed and competition for over a century, countries like Congo and Haiti and Guatemala.
Greed is a moral good. Competition is a moral good. Schools aren't for children. They're something to make money out of. Our children are not there to be taught. They are there to be used for profit - as we use factories and ore and oil. And if we ruin earth in the processes of burning and refining and spilling the oil, who cares? And if we ruin the children. who cares? Greed is good.
AIMs is not only incompetent and untrustworthy to have any influence over our children. It is also bloody immoral about the way it is using them.
Sunday, June 27, 2010
The Pathetic Side of New Brunswick
I noticed it first when I taught in PEI. I'm dismayed to find it here in New Brunswick.
I've been writinig and broadcasting commentaries across Canada, as well as some in the US and Britain, for some thirty years. I'm now writing for a very professionally organized national blog called The New Mark News, as well as this blog. But there's a difference between all the others and this blog. This one is just for New Brunswick. There's another difference, too. In all the other writing I've done, people who disagreed with me wrote or phoned to say they disagreed, and they said why. That's called serious discussion. It doesn't suggest good or evil or name-calling. It's called serious discussion and it's the way civilized areas develop their thinking and their responses to the world around them.
Serious thinking didn't happen in PEI when I was teaching there. People would tut-tut silently. They might report you to somebody. They might gossip. But there was no serious discussion. Ditto with NB. It acts like a province of serfs who stay trivial so they won't annoy the feudal baron or his soldiers.
I was reported to Mr. Doyle. Somebody reported me to him. I'm glad it was done. It was a pleasure to talk to him, and to exchange serious ideas as people in democracies are supposed to do. I'm sure we don't entirely agree. But we can discuss, and maybe both of us modify our opinions, or one of us change the other's mind.
Lots of people read this blog. I get a record of it - though without names, of course. For the first time in thirty years, I have not had a single person comment. The one who reported me to Mr. Doyle obviously read my column. By all means report me to whoever you like. I'm happy to have the additional readers. But it he disagreed with me - as I presume he did - why didn't he say so? Why the skulking, why the reporting, why the anonymity? Why the whispers?
It reminds of a kid when I taught grade seven. I h ad to go the office for a moment. As I headed to the door, he followed me out to ask, "Can I take down the name of anybody who talks while you're out?
I'm not interested in preaching or trying to convert anybody. I'm interested in serious discussion, which would benefit me as well as the other person.
Obviously, though, New Brunswick is more the sort of place for the kid who wanted to take down the name of anybody who was talking.
I've been writinig and broadcasting commentaries across Canada, as well as some in the US and Britain, for some thirty years. I'm now writing for a very professionally organized national blog called The New Mark News, as well as this blog. But there's a difference between all the others and this blog. This one is just for New Brunswick. There's another difference, too. In all the other writing I've done, people who disagreed with me wrote or phoned to say they disagreed, and they said why. That's called serious discussion. It doesn't suggest good or evil or name-calling. It's called serious discussion and it's the way civilized areas develop their thinking and their responses to the world around them.
Serious thinking didn't happen in PEI when I was teaching there. People would tut-tut silently. They might report you to somebody. They might gossip. But there was no serious discussion. Ditto with NB. It acts like a province of serfs who stay trivial so they won't annoy the feudal baron or his soldiers.
I was reported to Mr. Doyle. Somebody reported me to him. I'm glad it was done. It was a pleasure to talk to him, and to exchange serious ideas as people in democracies are supposed to do. I'm sure we don't entirely agree. But we can discuss, and maybe both of us modify our opinions, or one of us change the other's mind.
Lots of people read this blog. I get a record of it - though without names, of course. For the first time in thirty years, I have not had a single person comment. The one who reported me to Mr. Doyle obviously read my column. By all means report me to whoever you like. I'm happy to have the additional readers. But it he disagreed with me - as I presume he did - why didn't he say so? Why the skulking, why the reporting, why the anonymity? Why the whispers?
It reminds of a kid when I taught grade seven. I h ad to go the office for a moment. As I headed to the door, he followed me out to ask, "Can I take down the name of anybody who talks while you're out?
I'm not interested in preaching or trying to convert anybody. I'm interested in serious discussion, which would benefit me as well as the other person.
Obviously, though, New Brunswick is more the sort of place for the kid who wanted to take down the name of anybody who was talking.
Saturday, June 26, 2010
Harry Doyle
Harry Doyle is chairman of the DEC for school distrcit two. A reader of this blog sent a copy of my post about the DEC. That's good. That's what I wanted to happen. (Though I do wonder why New Brunswickers will scurry to report and gossip, but never reply to a blog with their own views.)
Anyone, Harry Doyle called. me. It was a very friendly call on both sides. That was largely because of Harry. He's such a thoroughly likeable guy,.he could charm a moose in heat. That's good. That's exactly what he needs in his work. I wish I had that skill (though I have only limited interest in charming any moose I have ever met socially.)
He invited me to present my case at a DEC meeting in, perhaps, September. I appreciated his gesture, and accepted it gladly. We may still differ after that. But differing is fair ball. That's why we call our system a democratic one.
Thank you, Mr. Doyle. (Oops. I forgot I'm a New Brunswicker now. Thank you, Harry.)
Anyone, Harry Doyle called. me. It was a very friendly call on both sides. That was largely because of Harry. He's such a thoroughly likeable guy,.he could charm a moose in heat. That's good. That's exactly what he needs in his work. I wish I had that skill (though I have only limited interest in charming any moose I have ever met socially.)
He invited me to present my case at a DEC meeting in, perhaps, September. I appreciated his gesture, and accepted it gladly. We may still differ after that. But differing is fair ball. That's why we call our system a democratic one.
Thank you, Mr. Doyle. (Oops. I forgot I'm a New Brunswicker now. Thank you, Harry.)
Thursday, June 24, 2010
the competitive market and the well-being of Canadians
The Fraser Insitute is a think tank that is practically a twin of the Atlantic Institute for Market Studies. That is, it is a propaganda agency for the very wealthy. It's stated objective is,"...the redirection of public attention to the role of competitive markets in providing for the well-being of Canadians." Cutting through the jargon, the very wealthy and their corporations want a share - maybe all - of things like health care and education.
That's why both AIMS and the folks at Fraser Institute churn out a stream of pseudo-scientific reports on why private health care is better than public health care, and why private education is better than public education. The people who back the Fraser are rich enough to own the BC government. That's why BC has introduced standardized testing for the schools, completely ignoring the fact that virtually every scholar in the field of education says its a bad idea. And - guess who got the contract to administer these tests at a cost of many millions of dollars from the education budget. Why, it was the Fraser Institute, of course. That's called "redirection of public attention to the role of competitive markets in providing for the well-being of Canadians". Well, it certainly pays the mortgage for a few billionaires. Your education dollars at work.
AIMS is doing precisely the same thing in New Brunswick. People with names like Irving sit on the board of AIMS to "redirect our attention to the role of public attention to the competitive market..."
The journalists at the Moncton T&T are not fools. They know what's going on. That's why there's never a word of criticism of it in that wretched paper. Any reference to AIMS is sure to be a kiss up one. The papers are lying, and they have to know they're lying. The Minister of Education is harming our children, and throwing our tax dollars away. And he has to know it, too. Nor would the Conservatives be any different.
Damn it. These are our children. Greedy business people, lying journalists, and rented politicians are not going to lay their hands on them, not if New Brunswick parents have a shred of intelligence to see what's going on, and shred of love for their own children and their welfare.
Alas! Living here for three years has not reassured me New Brunswick parents either know or care a damn.
Oh - and in four days of my requests to the provincial government's media centre for information about the cost of standardized tests, and who got the contract, they just can't seem to find the answer anywhere. Really!
Lucky for me I already knew.
That's why both AIMS and the folks at Fraser Institute churn out a stream of pseudo-scientific reports on why private health care is better than public health care, and why private education is better than public education. The people who back the Fraser are rich enough to own the BC government. That's why BC has introduced standardized testing for the schools, completely ignoring the fact that virtually every scholar in the field of education says its a bad idea. And - guess who got the contract to administer these tests at a cost of many millions of dollars from the education budget. Why, it was the Fraser Institute, of course. That's called "redirection of public attention to the role of competitive markets in providing for the well-being of Canadians". Well, it certainly pays the mortgage for a few billionaires. Your education dollars at work.
AIMS is doing precisely the same thing in New Brunswick. People with names like Irving sit on the board of AIMS to "redirect our attention to the role of public attention to the competitive market..."
The journalists at the Moncton T&T are not fools. They know what's going on. That's why there's never a word of criticism of it in that wretched paper. Any reference to AIMS is sure to be a kiss up one. The papers are lying, and they have to know they're lying. The Minister of Education is harming our children, and throwing our tax dollars away. And he has to know it, too. Nor would the Conservatives be any different.
Damn it. These are our children. Greedy business people, lying journalists, and rented politicians are not going to lay their hands on them, not if New Brunswick parents have a shred of intelligence to see what's going on, and shred of love for their own children and their welfare.
Alas! Living here for three years has not reassured me New Brunswick parents either know or care a damn.
Oh - and in four days of my requests to the provincial government's media centre for information about the cost of standardized tests, and who got the contract, they just can't seem to find the answer anywhere. Really!
Lucky for me I already knew.
Monday, June 21, 2010
The deliberate destruction of public schooling in New Brunswick
The item below is by a quite distinguished American educator, W.L. Sanders. It offers brilliant insight into what is being done to New Brunwick schools by the Atlantic Institute of Market Studies. It should be read by every teacher and parent in the province. It should, in particular, be read aloud to the chairman of the district two education council who is, I suspect, playing political games with our taxes and our children.
But now to Mr. Sanders:
Although I’m a career educator, I'm also a skeptical, questioning independent,not a mindless defender of
public schools. I believe our nation’s public education system must bechanged (dramatically so at the secondary level) for the U.S. to retain its economic competitiveness and democratic freedoms.
I worry that many of the changes proposed for schools could be motivated by aims other than economic
or democratic ideals. Simply, a growing number of the changes to the public education system may be motivated by entrepreneurial greed with little or no consideration for the consequences of the changes.
Hypothetically speaking, if I wanted to end public support for schools and privatize the system, Americans
would have to believe privatization was necessary. To justify privatization, the public schools would
have to be discredited.
If I wanted to discredit the public education system,I would:
1. Reluctantly and minimally fund the system and restrict spending flexibility within the system.
2. Mandate punitive accountability standards thatforce school districts to stress the basics at the
disadvantage of elective courses.
3. Legislate burdensome compliance standards thatrequire more administrative personnel to complete.
4. Discredit those who defend the system and those who work to make schools successful.
5. Divide the ranks of school employees by creating suspicion about compensation decisions made by administrators and boards of education.
6. Hype the instances of public school violence,mismanagement, incompetence, and the results
7. Shift blame for violence and poor student behavior to educators.
8. Absorb any discretionary school district funds by creating unfunded or minimally funded
mandates.
9. Blame teacher turnover on the lack of administrative support for effective classroom discipline
instead of on low salaries and the vexing societal maladies that spill over into classrooms.
10. Minimize the benefits of the teacher retirement systems and increase the cost of school district
and individual contributions to those systems.
11. “De-professionalize” the art of teaching by
promoting a recipe-driven method of instruction that minimizes the importance ofpedagogy and great expectations for all children.
12. Devalue teaching certifications by allowing “just about anyone to teach,” but simultaneously
require all school districts to have highly qualified teachers.
13. Develop legislative incentives that encourage competition among public schools and
minimize the compliance and accountability standards for the competition.
14. Implement a comprehensive strategy, accompanied by unlimited private funds, to continually
tout the advantages of home schooling, private schools, charter schools, and virtual schools.
15. Call attention to political differences between wealthy and poor school districts and encourage
feuding over limited resources.
16. Deny that market forces are driving up administrative salaries or be proactive and blame increasing administrative salaries on incompetent school boards.
17. Disguise the aforementioned actions as school improvement efforts.
These strategies aren’t all inclusive. I’m certain that other public school supporters can add ideas from
their own experiences.
I hope my intention here is clear: I want citizens to be savvy about distinguishing between changes that
could bolster our democratic and economic ideals and support public schools and changes that would harm
public education for enigmatic, avaricious reasons.
But now to Mr. Sanders:
Although I’m a career educator, I'm also a skeptical, questioning independent,not a mindless defender of
public schools. I believe our nation’s public education system must bechanged (dramatically so at the secondary level) for the U.S. to retain its economic competitiveness and democratic freedoms.
I worry that many of the changes proposed for schools could be motivated by aims other than economic
or democratic ideals. Simply, a growing number of the changes to the public education system may be motivated by entrepreneurial greed with little or no consideration for the consequences of the changes.
Hypothetically speaking, if I wanted to end public support for schools and privatize the system, Americans
would have to believe privatization was necessary. To justify privatization, the public schools would
have to be discredited.
If I wanted to discredit the public education system,I would:
1. Reluctantly and minimally fund the system and restrict spending flexibility within the system.
2. Mandate punitive accountability standards thatforce school districts to stress the basics at the
disadvantage of elective courses.
3. Legislate burdensome compliance standards thatrequire more administrative personnel to complete.
4. Discredit those who defend the system and those who work to make schools successful.
5. Divide the ranks of school employees by creating suspicion about compensation decisions made by administrators and boards of education.
6. Hype the instances of public school violence,mismanagement, incompetence, and the results
7. Shift blame for violence and poor student behavior to educators.
8. Absorb any discretionary school district funds by creating unfunded or minimally funded
mandates.
9. Blame teacher turnover on the lack of administrative support for effective classroom discipline
instead of on low salaries and the vexing societal maladies that spill over into classrooms.
10. Minimize the benefits of the teacher retirement systems and increase the cost of school district
and individual contributions to those systems.
11. “De-professionalize” the art of teaching by
promoting a recipe-driven method of instruction that minimizes the importance ofpedagogy and great expectations for all children.
12. Devalue teaching certifications by allowing “just about anyone to teach,” but simultaneously
require all school districts to have highly qualified teachers.
13. Develop legislative incentives that encourage competition among public schools and
minimize the compliance and accountability standards for the competition.
14. Implement a comprehensive strategy, accompanied by unlimited private funds, to continually
tout the advantages of home schooling, private schools, charter schools, and virtual schools.
15. Call attention to political differences between wealthy and poor school districts and encourage
feuding over limited resources.
16. Deny that market forces are driving up administrative salaries or be proactive and blame increasing administrative salaries on incompetent school boards.
17. Disguise the aforementioned actions as school improvement efforts.
These strategies aren’t all inclusive. I’m certain that other public school supporters can add ideas from
their own experiences.
I hope my intention here is clear: I want citizens to be savvy about distinguishing between changes that
could bolster our democratic and economic ideals and support public schools and changes that would harm
public education for enigmatic, avaricious reasons.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)